Visualizing Scholarly Discourse in eScience Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute Open University, UK In collaboration with: John Domingue, Enrico.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

© Simon Buckingham Shum 1 Hypermedia Discourse & Human- Agent Knowledge Cartography Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute & Computing Research.

Advertisements

Simon Buckingham Shum David De Roure Marc Eisenstadt Nigel Shadbolt Austin Tate AKT Town Meeting, April 2003.

Town Meeting Aims Introduce the project and partners Present our baseline technologies Outline current and planned work Understand your perspectives on.

Semantics for e-Science Collaboration Jan Update.

Simon Buckingham Shum (Open) David De Roure (Soton) Marc Eisenstadt (Open) Nigel Shadbolt (Soton) Austin Tate (Edin) AKT Review, Sept AKT I ntegrated.

CoAKTing IFD Dave in Hawaii. AKT Workshop January CoAKTing IFD n Objective is to advance the state of the art in collaborative mediated spaces.

CoAKTing IFD Dave in Hawaii. 2 CoAKTing IFD n Objective is to advance the state of the art in collaborative mediated spaces for distributed e- Science.

1 CoAKTinG – I-X Process Panels I-Space: I-Me, I-Room, I-World I-Tools: I-DE, I-Think, I-Plan, I-AM AIAI, University of Edinburgh

CONCEPTUAL WEB-BASED FRAMEWORK IN AN INTERACTIVE VIRTUAL ENVIRONMENT FOR DISTANCE LEARNING Amal Oraifige, Graham Oakes, Anthony Felton, David Heesom, Kevin.

GMD German National Research Center for Information Technology Darmstadt University of Technology Perspectives and Priorities for Digital Libraries Research.

International Technology Alliance In Network & Information Sciences International Technology Alliance In Network & Information Sciences Paul Smart, Ali.

DELOS Highlights COSTANTINO THANOS ITALIAN NATIONAL RESEARCH COUNCIL.

Information Society Technologies Third Call for Proposals Norbert Brinkhoff-Button DG Information Society European Commission Key action III: Multmedia.

Who are the Experts?Simon KampaSlide 1 Who are the Experts? Simon Kampa IAM Group University of Southampton

Relating research to practice Heather King Department of Education King’s College London.

© Simon Buckingham Shum 1 Mobile Agents Project Leads: Maarten Sierhuis & Bill Clancey (Human-Centered Computing, NASA Ames) CoAKTinG: Simon Buckingham.

1 Stephen Potter University of Edinburgh Building Collaborative eResearch Environments Virtual Organisations and Collaborative Environments.

Simon Buckingham Shum David De Roure Marc Eisenstadt Nigel Shadbolt Austin Tate.

Simon Buckingham Shum David De Roure Marc Eisenstadt Nigel Shadbolt Austin Tate.

I-Room : Integrating Intelligent Agents and Virtual Worlds.

1 Towards Web 2.0 Argumentation Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute The Open University Milton Keynes, UK Proc.

Cohere.open.ac.uk Discourse-Centric Learning Analytics LAK2011: 1st International Conference on Learning Analytics and Knowledge February 27-March 1, 2011.

Tools for the ‘e-PhD’ >>> presence, collaboration and critical thinking Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute

Facilitating Remote Science Teams Albert M. Selvin* ** and Simon Buckingham Shum ** ** Knowledge Media Institute Open University Milton Keynes, UK MK7.

Victoria Uren, Simon Buckingham Shum, Gangmin Li, John Domingue, Enrico Motta Knowledge Media Institute The Open University 21 May 2003 Scholarly Publishing.

Low-cost semantics-enhanced web browsing with Magpie Enrico Motta Knowledge Media Institute The Open University, UK.

1 Scholarly Ontologies Project Knowledge Media Institute The Open University Hobby: EPSRC: PI:

Capturing, Mapping and Integrating Argumentation as Project Memory in Participatory Urban Planning DEMO-net Workshop on Argumentation Support Systems for.

Technologies for The Semantic Web and for The Knowledge Web Enrico Motta Knowledge Media Institute The Open University.

ClaiMaker Knowledge Media Institute Open University, UK Illustrative slides showing how knowledge claims can be made between web resources.

Integrating Argumentation, Text and Community: Toward an ontology and services Neil Benn, Simon Buckingham Shum, John Domingue CMNA Workshop, 30 July 2005.

The trouble with codified knowledge... (a) those that belong to the Emperor (b) embalmed ones (c) those that are trained (d) suckling pigs (e) mermaids.

From Open Content Repositories to Open Sensemaking Communities Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute Open University, UK

1 Digital Libraries and Evidence in the Developing World Context Dr. Jon Ferguson Senior Health Database Scientist IMMPACT Project University of Aberdeen.

Semantic Web for E-Science and Education Enrico Motta Knowledge Media Institute The Open University, UK.

Co-OPR Collaborative Operations for Personnel Recovery Collaborative Sensemaking, Planning and Execution via sharing of issues, activity options, constraints.

Domain Modelling the upper levels of the eframework Yvonne Howard Hilary Dexter David Millard Learning Societies LabDistributed Learning, University of.

© Simon Buckingham Shum Click to edit Master subtitle style Compendium: A computerised programme for the tracking and measurement of group process 11 Marion.

Sharing linguistic multi-media resources Jacquelijn Ringersma Paul Trilsbeek Max Planck Institute for Psycholinguistics Nijmegen, The Netherlands.

CoAKTinG Concepts from Edinburgh Austin Tate, AIAI, 21-Mar-2002 First Ideas… Strong issues, activities/processes, state, event, agents, options, argumentation,

Sharad Oberoi and Susan Finger Carnegie Mellon University DesignWebs: Towards the Creation of an Interactive Navigational Tool to assist and support Engineering.

Meeting Capture and Structural Replay Compendium in Meeting Replay Web Interface BuddySpace I-X Process System Mars Exploration Mission

Semantic Web Browsing for the VISWE Learning Community Arthur Stutt (some slides from ISWC 2003 talk) Knowledge Media Institute, The Open University, UK.

Web of Science® Krzysztof Szymanski October 13, 2010.

Leaping the chasm: moving from buzzwords to implementation of learning analytics George Siemens Technology Enhanced Knowledge Research Institute (TEKRI)

Domain Modeling In FREMA David Millard Yvonne Howard Hugh Davis Gary Wills Lester Gilbert Learning Societies Lab University of Southampton, UK.

Towards an ecosystem of data and ontologies Mathieu d’Aquin and Enrico Motta Knowledge Media Institute The Open University.

Simon Buckingham Shum Michelle Bachler CoAKTinG Project Meeting June 2003.

Directions for Hypertext Research: Exploring the Design Space for Interactive Scholarly Communication John J. Leggett & Frank M. Shipman Department of.

Evaluating Semantic Metadata without the Presence of a Gold Standard Yuangui Lei, Andriy Nikolov, Victoria Uren, Enrico Motta Knowledge Media Institute,

Sharad Oberoi Carnegie Mellon University DesignWebs: Learning in Engineering Project Teams.

AnnotatEd: A Social Navigation and Annotation Service for Web-based Educational Resources Rosta Farzan & Peter Brusilovsky Personalized Adaptive Web Systems.

Mining real world data Web data. World Wide Web Hypertext documents –Text –Links Web –billions of documents –authored by millions of diverse people –edited.

1 Towards Scholarly Publishing on the Semantic Web Simon Buckingham Shum Senior Lecturer Open University, Knowledge Media Institute Gary Li, Victoria Uren.

1 Facilitated Hypertext for Collective Sensemaking 15 Years on from gIBIS CogNexus Institute, USA Verizon eBusiness, USA Open University, UK NASA Ames,

Domain Modeling In FREMA Yvonne Howard David Millard Hugh Davis Gary Wills Lester Gilbert Learning Societies Lab University of Southampton, UK.

Topic Maps introduction Peter-Paul Kruijsen CTO, Morpheus software ISOC seminar, april 5 th 2005.

The Collaborative Semantic Grid David De Roure University of Southampton, UK

Sharad Oberoi and Susan Finger Carnegie Mellon University Interactive Design Navigation Tools.

CS Architecture of Web Information Systems Spring 04 April 16 th 2004 Shay David sd256 at cornell.edu Social Networks in Scholarly publishing.

June 25, 2016 Concepts and methods for exploring the future of learning with digital technologies A research network funded by the European Commission,

Semantic Web Technologies Readings discussion Research presentations Projects & Papers discussions.

Conceptualizing the research world

Data Warehousing and Data Mining

Information Science in International Perspective

<I-N-C-A> and the I-Room

Hadley Staite Nadine Finlay

Workshop Organization Support SAR Environment Schematic

Co-OPR – Compendium and I-X

SOCIAL LEARNING analytics

Presentation transcript:

Visualizing Scholarly Discourse in eScience Simon Buckingham Shum Knowledge Media Institute Open University, UK In collaboration with: John Domingue, Enrico Motta, Gary Li, Victoria Uren, Marc Eisenstadt (Open U.), Austin Tate (Edinburgh U.), Nigel Shadbolt, Dave De Roure (Southampton U.), Albert Selvin (Verizon, USA), Maarten Sierhuis (NASA, USA) Visualization for eScience Workshop, National eScience Centre Edinburgh, Jan, 2003

Why focus on discourse? Researchers spend a lot of time talking and arguing, in meetings and documents New opportunities for eScience collaborative technologies - conversations in meetings - arguments in the literature Discourse has rhetorical structure Semantic hypertext tools enable us to construct and map this visually

2 EPSRC projects at the OU are developing tools Compendium …real-time mapping of discussions and domain modelling in meetings ClaiMaker …modelling research literatures as a networks of claims and counter-claims

Example 1: Compendium Visual mapping of discussions and domains Semantic hypertext for connecting ideas and resources Simple but powerful visual language based on IBIS (Issue-Based Information System) Group memory for collaborators –Working memory: shared visual maps of discussions created during meetings –Long term memory: recover discussions/rationale from months back Interoperability with other tools: –Generates documentation and web discussions –An intuitive interface for populating complex models Large, long term case studies documented

Compendium discussion map from a project meeting, capturing open issues, options, decisions, and linking in other resources

Maps built in meetings can be exported to create other formats of document, e.g. analysing Y2K threats to an organisation (Verizon, USA) Compendium for Visual Modelling

Compendiums visual maps can be used to elicit data to populate modelling tools, e.g. simulation of a Mars lander team (NASA Ames) Compendium for Visual Modelling

Compendium for Remote Collaboration The eScience CoAKTinG Project is integrating a suite of technologies to support the following kinds of eScience collaboration: Mapping discussions in virtual meetings (Compendium, Open U.) Multimedia meeting replay/navigation (HyStream, Southampton U.) Coordination and synthesis activities (I-X Process Panels – Edinburgh U.) Peripheral awareness of colleagues presence and availability (BuddySpace, Open U.)

Time-delayed attendee replays precise moment by highlighting relevant node in the Compendium discussion map (interface mockup) CoAKTinG scenario 1

BuddySpace: Enriching presence+messaging with semantics and visualizations

I-X Process Panel: coordinated, active To Do lists

Example 2: ClaiMaker Will prose always be the dominant format to disseminate, critique and debate research? Research literatures are huge networks of claims and debates: ClaiMaker renders this visible and analysable as a semantic web Use to review, model and analyse complex networks of ideas –Who disagrees with this paper? –What evidence is there for this prediction? –What impact did this paper have? –What is the intellectual history of this idea?

A menu-driven web interface to annotate publications with new concepts, and make connections between concepts using a set of link-types derived from discourse and argumentation theory, and commonly used in research. Adding to the Network

Drawing new conceptual structures via a mapping interface (an alternative to the menu/form interface)

What documents challenge this one? 1.Extract concepts for this document 2.Trace concepts on which they build 3.Trace concepts challenging this set 4.Show root documents

Focusing on a concept from previous view

Searching for Patterns Textual listing of results for a search on machine learning with a certain type of connection Interactive applet to see and browse the structure of the search results

Graph-theoretic cluster detection. Borrowing from scientometric techniques for identifying emerging research fields, instead of citations, we use inter-concept links. Visual Knowledge Services

Visualizing Argumentation Springer-Verlag, Argument mapping for scholarly publishing, scientific and public policy debates, education, teamwork, and organisational memory

To know more… EPSRC CoAKTinG Project: kmi.open.ac.uk/projects/buddyspace EPSRC Scholarly Ontologies Project: kmi.open.ac.uk/projects/scholonto claimaker.open.ac.uk Visualizing Argumentation book: