Conceptual Grammar for Analysing Policy Movement Work Group 2: Miguel Lim, Chris Muellerleile, Jana Bajevic, Tatyana Bajenova, Sina Westa, Janja Komljenovic.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Discourses and Framings of Climate Change: What Literatures Do We Need to Review? To realize synergies there is a need to indentify common objectives for.

Advertisements

Introducing Foreign Policy Analysis

Globalizing Learning: Implications for Curriculum Design and University Governance Ka Ho Mok Associate Vice President & Dean The Hong Kong Institute of.

Approach, Methods, Techniques

English 472 A Review. Overview  Histories  Theories  Questions and Quandaries.

Innovation systems and technological transitions – towards a common framework Jochen Markard Innovation Research in Utility Sectors (CIRUS) Workshop Zurich,

Understanding the Research Process

POLITICAL CULTURE Fundamental Values, Sentiments, & Knowledge.

Alternative Technologies and Organizational Forms: A Review and Typology of Initiatives in Agriculture Dinesh Abrol Delhi Science Forum and All India Peoples’

Sociology  Sociology is the study of society. It is a social science (a term with which it is sometimes synonymous) which uses various methods of empirical.

From ‘wickedity’ to tameness

WP 3 Session 1.1 Scientific training Policy Travel – Conceptual grammar for analysing policy movement.

1 © Franz J. Kurfess Constrained Access Franz J. Kurfess Cal Poly SLO Computer Science Department.

History, Theory, and Philosophy of Science (In SMAC + RT) 7th smester -Fall 2005 Institute of Media Technology and Engineering Science Aalborg University.

The Role of the Citizens in Policy Making Thomas Tufte, Roskilde University, Denmark IAMCR Pre-conference on ’Promoting Public Knowledge of’ Media Policy.

INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS THEORIES: CONSTRUCTIVISM

Chapter 5, Social Interaction and The Social Construction of Reality The Context of Social Interaction The Congo in Transition The Content of Social Interaction.

AARHUS UNIVERSITY LJUBLJANA 7 JULY POLICY TRAVEL 1 Conceptual Grammar for Analysing Policy Movement WG1: Corina, Freya, Que Anh, Sina, Sintayehu.

M.Hosseinzadeh EDC Translation Art or Skill Session.

Lecture 1: Concepts September 28, Theoretical Framework From Connelly et al:  “A framework is a system of ideas or conceptual structures that help.

Academic freedom Work Group 2 Tatyana Bajenova Janja Komljenovic Miguel Lim Tore Bernt Sorensen Chris Muellerleile Jana Bacevic.

Aim The aim of this research is to assess and improve research impact on policy and practice of climate change governance at the regional and local level.

Susan S. Gunby, RN, PhD Fall Semester 2003

Carlo Ruzza - University of Trento1 European Institutions and The Policy Discourse of Organised Civil Society Comparing Discourses of Civil Society Actors.

Emerging Trends and Evolving Issues in Open Access and Scholarly Communications Daniel Gelaw Alemneh Digital Curation Coordinator University of North Texas.

An Introduction to Practice Development. Magical History Tour of PD 1980s Nursing Development Unit Burford, Oxford 1990s PD Units PD hospital roles Evidence.

Resuming Nimmo & Swanson: political language and communication Beyond “the voter, persuasion and political campaign model” (made of “dramatized rituals.

Critical Thinking Preparing Society’s Decision Makers FEMA 12th Annual All-Hazards Higher Education Conference June 1–4, 2009 ® James M McCarty, Assistant.

SITUATION ANALYSIS. CONTENT Why do we do a situation analysis? What needs to be achieved? Steps in development of the Situation analysis Defining provisional.

Theories of Democratic Government

“Organization Theory: Genealogy and Neglected Themes” STEWART R CLEGG.

Interpretive approaches: key principles 10 March 2009 Dr. Carolyn M. Hendriks The Crawford School of Economics and Government The Australian National University.

Social Science and Public Health Jeannine Coreil, PhD College of Public Health University of South Florida.

Embedding Multilevel Factors in an Organization Field Context W. Richard Scott Stanford University.

Wolfram & Schilling-Estes Chapter 9

1 DISCRIMINATION AGAINST GIRLS IN SCHOOL: THEIR PERCEPTIONS AND RESPONSES -

DISCOURSES: CONVERSATIONS, NARRATIVES AND AUTOBIOGRAPHIES AS TEXTS © LOUIS COHEN, LAWRENCE MANION & KEITH MORRISON.

An Introduction to Chemistry Section 1 – Basic Understanding of Chemistry Section 2 – Scientific Inquiry.

Masters Level Modules Ros Ollin School of Education and Professional Development University of Huddersfield.

Chapter 1 Cybertechnology, Ethical Concepts, and Methodological Frameworks: An Introduction to Cyberethics Introduction Cybertechnology, Ethical Concepts,

Understanding Users Context, Communication & Construction Michael Olsson Lecturer, Information and Knowledge Management University of Technology, Sydney.

The Formation of Public Policy Promoting Civil Society in the 21st Century.

MA “International Relations, Global Economy and Strategic Analysis” COURSE OUTLINE.

TEFL METHODOLOGY I COMMUNICATIVE LANGUAGE TEACHING.

Week 3 Qualitative Approaches to Field Research GEOG 4520B 3.0 Research Design and Field Studies Department of Geography Faculty of Liberal Arts & Professional.

Why is this on the agenda? Our baseline study was highly critiqued Our monitoring method was revised Our mid-term review highlights monitoring and evaluation.

Introduction to the Study of Sociology and Anthropology.

Constructivism: The Social Construction of International Politics POL 3080 Approaches to IR.

Computational Models of Discourse Analysis Carolyn Penstein Rosé Language Technologies Institute/ Human-Computer Interaction Institute.

Winner quote The things we call "technologies" are ways of building order in our world… contain possibilities for many different ways of ordering human.

CONVENTION & DESTINATION MARKETING Prepared by Yooshik Yoon, Kyunghee University

Chapter 4: Applied Linguistics and language learning/teaching.

‘May you live in interesting times’. IRPG841/L1 Introducing IR Theory: Concepts, Methods and Approaches the nature and scope of IR the role of theory.

NG701 Advanced Theoretical Foundations in Nursing

DEFINITION CDA is an analytical research methodology that proposes a study of the relations between discourse, power, dominance and social inequality Accordingly,

The degrowth side of post-development (and vice versa)

Approaches to Discourse Analysis

(De)constructing Europe in the online news media

Approach, Methods, Techniques

Ruban Anna PhD student Department of Environmental Sciences and Policy

DISCOURSES: CONVERSATIONS, NARRATIVES AND AUTOBIOGRAPHIES AS TEXTS

Genre-Based Approach and the Competence-Based Curriculum

EAP in the North Critical Thinking.

How to define ‘ending homelessness’?

How to define ‘ending homelessness’?

Policy Process and Extension Communication Methods:

TEMPLATE ELEMENTS.

Karolina Lendák-Kabók Marc Vanholsbeeck

Introduction to Technological Innovation Systems Research

Building a Bridge from High School Writing to First-Year Writing to Writing in the Major Noreen Lape Associate Provost of academic Affairs/ Director.

Presentation transcript:

Conceptual Grammar for Analysing Policy Movement Work Group 2: Miguel Lim, Chris Muellerleile, Jana Bajevic, Tatyana Bajenova, Sina Westa, Janja Komljenovic

WG 2 - Asssigned Texts Dryzek, J. (2006). Policy Analysis as Critique. Hajer, M. and D. Laws. (2006). Ordering Through Discourse. – In Moran, M., Rein, M. and R. Goodin (eds) The Oxford Handbook of Public Policy.

Asssigned Texts Dryzek, J. (2006). Policy Analysis as Critique – “Critical theory is directed at an audience of sufferers in order to make plain to them the causes of their suffering” (p.192) – Attention to the linguistic turn and review of techniques to deal with ‘text’ – There are ‘tasks’ for the critical policy analyst

Asssigned Texts Hajer, M. and D. Laws. (2006). Ordering Through Discourse – The central role of the concept of ambivalence – ”Governing is in large a part a matter of defining the situation” (p.252) – Analysis’ goal: to ‘illuminate the mechanisms that are used to manage ambivalence’ (p.263) – Analysts’ ordering devices: beliefs, frames and discourses

Speaking to Peck et al. Mobility (Peck 2011) vs. Coining of policy in situ (Dryzek 2008, Hajer and Laws 2008) Both chapters not directly connected to policy travel – evolution of policy analysis as a field and tend to lean on constructivist side – Commonalities include: attention to both structure and agency Attention to ‘social’ reality around policy transfer

Speaking to Peck et al. Rational-instrumental towards embedded- relational A. Dryzek (2008): Technocratic > accommodative > critical analysis > linguistic turn B. Hajer and Laws (2008): Advocacy coalition framework > framing > narrative and discourse C. Peck (2011): focus on the mobility of policy: distinguishing between diffusion models, theories of transition, and neo-diffusionist approaches.

Speaking to Peck et al. Big picture issues: Critical policy analysis and/vs orthodox approaches to policy transfer Commitments of critical analysis (to ‘democracy’, other institutions) Emerging network society and networked problem solving

Speaking to Peck et al. Big picture issues: Peck and Peck and Theodore: rethink the notion of policy altogether in the context of policies, politics, and policy based "knowledge" that are highly mobile. Need for new methodologies to examine hybrid "policies"

Further questions What should we care about? Sufferers? Is critical policy analysis of policy transfer always about identifying a sufferer? If so, then: who what when where why…?

Further questions A consideration on the ontologies of policy and epistemologies/methodologies for understanding policy. – Do we need a new ontology of policy? – Does the conventional definition of policy help or hinder our research?