Survey of the New York City Watershed for the Presence of Pharmaceuticals 1 Center for Environmental Health, NYS Department of Health, Troy, NY 2 Wadsworth.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Common Data Repository and Water Resource Assessment for the Southern and Northern Piceance Basin Northwest Colorado Oil and Gas Forum June 2008 Jude Thomas,
Advertisements

1 An Evaluation of Unused Medicine Disposal Options On Wastewater Treatment Plant Influents Douglas S. Finan – GlaxoSmithKline Matthew D. Garamone - Pfizer.
1 Midland Community Meeting Michigan Department of Environmental Quality Steven Chester, Director Jim Sygo, Deputy Director.
Summary Report Emerging Contaminants Program.
Estrogenic Compounds in Wastewater Presentation to the Metropolitan Council Environment Committee September 23, 2008 Paige Novak, Deb Swackhamer, Mike.
BoRit Superfund Site Timeline
Floyd County Board of Commissioners Special Town Hall Meeting Topic: Update on status of Georgetown WWTP.
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Reducing Pharmaceuticals in Water: DEC’s Proactive Approach to Household, Institutional, and Manufacturing.
A Tale of Three WWTPs (Frangel, Town of Kent, Kent Manor ) NYC Watershed/Tifft Science and Technical Symposium September 19, 2013 Thayer Hotel, West Point,
Emerging Constituents 1. Regulatory Initiatives CDPH: Draft Groundwater Recharge/Reuse Regulation (applied in NPDES permits & WDRs) SWRCB: Blue Ribbon.
Analysis of contaminants of emerging concerns in wastewater and the Maryland coastal bays Charniece C. Huff 1, Rehab Abass 2, Ali Ishaque 2 1 Department.
The Effects of Caffeine and Triclocarban on Gammarus pseudolimnaeus Jim Fietzer Department of Biological Sciences, University of Wisconsin – Whitewater.
Improving monitoring campaigns : A case study Dissemination Workshop on Evaluating Source Control Options for Reducing Emissions of Priority Pollutants.
Concentrations and Removal of Pharmaceutical Compounds at Four Wastewater Plants in New York State, P. J. Phillips 1, E. T. Furlong 1, B Stinson.
Printed by DEVELOPING A NON-PUBLIC WATER SUPPLY PROGRAM FOR THE STATE OF GEORGIA Scott A. Uhlich, MCP Georgia Department of Human.
The Nevada Department of Agriculture Water Quality Program The Nevada Department of Agriculture has been involved in groundwater protection since 1990.
Advanced Technologies in Real-Time Monitoring and Modeling for Drinking Water Safety and Security June 27-28, 2002 Ron Hunsinger Manager of Water Quality.
Use of Ozone for Disinfection and EDC Removal at CCWRD Doug Drury, Ph.D. Deputy General Manager Clark County Water Reclamation District Shane Snyder, Ph.D.
Monitoring Design, Available Data, and Filling Data Gaps for Determining Whether Shale Gas Development Activities Contaminate Surface Water or Groundwater.
Water Issues In India by Vijay Kumar Eppakayala. India on the globe.
SCOPING MEETING FOR ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORT REQUIRED BY PUBLIC RESOURCES CODE SECTION 3161 (b)(3) AND (4) (SENATE BILL 4) (PAVLEY) C ALIFORNIA D EPARTMENT.
Eighteen Years of Acid Wet Deposition at Mt. Mansfield Goals & Objectives One goal of the VMC is to understand the sources, mechanisms, and effects of.
EPA/Office of Water’s Strategy for Contaminants of Emerging Concern Octavia Conerly Health and Ecological Criteria Division Office of Water U.S. Environmental.
Evaluation of Analytical Methods for Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products Teresa Chow, Monte Wilcoxon Illinois Waste Management Research Center,
Ecosystems Climate and Land-Use Change Water Natural Hazards Core Science Systems Energy and Minerals, and Environmental Health U.S. Geological Survey.
1 Full Scale and Pilot Scale Evaluation of Endocrine Disrupting Compound Removal Through WTP Processes Bob Raczko, P.E. United Water.
Lsfdlkdfj ;la;fkd theklekrj Girly Grass Dana Devin-Clarke. Sally Brown, Michael Muramoto*, and Michael Doubrava* University of Washington and *King County.
Pharmaceutical Project Update PSI Forum, June 2008 Dave Galvin Local Hazardous Waste Management Program in King County (Seattle, WA)
Roger Miller, Arkansas Department of Environmental Quality Barry Jackson, USGS Arkansas Water Science Center ARKANSAS EXCHANGE NETWORK FOR GROUNDWATER-QUALITY.
Ground Water Rule Workshop Department of Environmental Conservation September 22-23, 2009 Dan Weber & Gloria Collins Regulations Team DEC Drinking Water.
LC-MS/MS Analysis of Naphthenic Acids in Environmental Waters Coreen Hamilton, Million B. Woudneh & Guanghui Wang Presented at Workshop on Analytical Strategies.
Water Quality Data, Maps, and Graphs Over the Web · Chemical concentrations in water, sediment, and aquatic organism tissues.
STATUS OF ECOLOGY’S DRAFT FLOW BLENDING POLICY WATER QUALITY PARTNERSHIP MEETING January 20, 2005.
Evaluating the Potential Human-Health Relevance of VOCs in Samples from Domestic & Public Wells in the U.S. Patty Toccalino, Julia Norman, Barbara Rowe.
Changes in Phosphorus Concentrations and Loads in the Assabet River Following Mandated Reductions in Wastewater Treatment Plant Discharges U.S. Geological.
U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey Dr. Robert M. Hirsch Associate Director for Water April 16, 2007 USGS: Water Resources Program.
New York City Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of Water Supply Water Quality New York City Department of Environmental Protection Bureau of.
MRWS GROUND WATER RULE (GWR) PREPARED BY JOHN CAMDEN MRWS GROUND WATER TECH
Community Based Environmental Chemical Analysis Community Based Environmental Chemical Analysis A Partnership Between: +Seneca Babcock Good Neighbor Committee.
Thuan Chau EMERGING CONTAMINANTS PHARMACEUTICALS AND PERSONAL CARE PRODUCTS (PPCPs) “Contaminants of Emerging Concern” (CECs) – EPA University of Utah.
Environmental impact assessment of steroid hormones R. Laenge, LGE 09 June 2006 Assessment of the impact of selected steroid hormones on biodiversity Reinhard.
What Are We Doing Now? To Measure Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products in the Environment. Approaches to Emerging Chemicals Issues Workshop March.
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Reducing Pharmaceuticals in our Waters: A DEC Update and Appeal for your Input Scott Stoner, Chief, Standards.
An Overview of EDC’s, Pharmaceuticals and Personal Care Products in Our Drinking Water Presented By: Roxanne Russell, Yuh-Chi Niou, Kris McArthur, Amelia.
All About Sanitary Surveys David Edmunds Environmental Program Specialist ADEC Drinking Water Program Sustained Compliance: What It Means to Public Water.
1 Analytical Methods for Perchlorate: Current Technology and Possibilities for the Future David J. Munch Daniel P. Hautman Office of Ground Water and Drinking.
NYC DEP Bureau of Water Supply, Water Quality Division of Science and Research Giardia and Cryptosporidium Monitoring in the New York City Watershed A.
Pharmaceuticals, Hormones, and Other Wastewater Contaminants in U.S. Streams Herb Buxton Coordinator, Toxic Substances Hydrology Program.
Advisory Panel on Emerging Contaminants Unregulated Chemical Contaminants APEC Update – September 27, 2013.
Pharmaceutical Session Intro PSI Forum, June 2009 Dave Galvin Local Hazardous Waste Management Program in King County (Seattle, WA)
U.S. Department of the Interior U.S. Geological Survey Integrated Water-Quality Assessment using Conventional, Passive-Sampling, and Metabolic Assay Techniques:
1 TCEQ Drinking Water Sample Collector Training October 2006 Alicia Diehl TCEQ Public Drinking Water Section UCMR Sampling TCEQ Drinking Water Sample Collector.
Biological & Research Programs. Overview Status Future Direction.
Charge Question 3-1 Comment Summary for HHCB Peer Review Panel Meeting January 9, 2014.
Effects of Annual Snowmelt on the New York City Water Supply Adam Czekanski 29 November 2005.
1 Future Strategies to Address PPCPs Octavia Conerly Health and Ecological Criteria Division Office of Water Office of Water October 26, 2005 October 26,
NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Pharmaceutical Contaminants DEC Actions to Reduce Exposure Presentation to the Watershed Science and Technical.
Nutrients and the Next Generation of Conservation Presented by: Tom Porta, P.E. Deputy Administrator Nevada Division of Environmental Protection President,
The Effect of Stormwater on Wastewater Treatability: A study of targeted Emerging Contaminants at a Wastewater Treatment Plant Kenya L. Goodson 1, Dr.
Review of analytical methods available for measuring PPCPs in water Praveen Kumar Reddy Y *, Amlan Rath, Balakrishna K, Sruthi Balakrishnan, Udayashankar.
John D. Vargo 1 ; Michael Schueller 1 ; Mary Skopec 2 1 State Hygienic Laboratory at the University of Iowa, Coralville, IA; 2 Iowa Department of Natural.
SFEnvironment.org SF’s Safe Medicine Disposal Program.
Safe Drinking Water Act , CCL and Perchlorate
Analysis of Pharmaceuticals & Personal Care Products
Results and Discussion
Julie Strømberg1, Helene Thorsen Rønning2, Aasim Musa M
RINGWOOD MINES/LANDFILL SITE PUBLIC MEETING December 6, 2016
Update on Water Quality
Industrial Pollutants in the Haw: Community Impacts and Action
Jiří Kučera Harmonization of national legislation with Directive 91/271/EEC on urban waste water treatment Czech project of development cooperation in.
Presentation transcript:

Survey of the New York City Watershed for the Presence of Pharmaceuticals 1 Center for Environmental Health, NYS Department of Health, Troy, NY 2 Wadsworth Center for Laboratories and Research, NYS Department of Health, Albany, NY Lloyd Wilson 1, Patrick O’Keefe 2, Patrick Palmer 1, Robert Sheridan 2, Robert Briggs 2, and Thomas King 2

Project Goals  Determine if detectable levels of selected pharmaceutical analytes are present in the NYC Watershed Why? To address concerns in recent scientific and popular literature regarding the potential for contamination of surface waters by hormones and human-use pharmaceuticals

Media Headlines  Rx-Drug H 2 WOE New York Post, 8/23/04  Stay calm everyone, there’s Prozac in the drinking water London Observer, 8/8/04  Household supplies appear in water: Drugs, disinfectants worry state panel The Arizona Republic, 7/23/04  Eat, drink and be wary: Chemicals often linger in water after treatment Poughkeepsie Journal (NY), 1/18/04  Fish off Arctic city get drug cocktail from sewers Reuters, 11/24/03  Frogs, fish, and pharmaceuticals a troubling brew… CNN, 11/14/03  Drugs in your drinking water? Take a valium The Globe and Mail (Canada), 2/12/03

Project Goals (continued)  characterize input to watershed from effluent of four WWTPs (day-of-week, seasonality, variability within and between plants)  monitor major inputs and output of key reservoirs  monitor terminal reservoirs to determine if any analytes are detectable prior to distribution

Project Goals (continued) What are we looking for (and why)? Basic compoundsAcid/neutral compounds amoxicillin (antibiotic) 17  -ethinylestradiol (steroid) atenolol (beta-blocker) 17  -estradiol (steroid) caffeine (stimulant) estrone (steroid) cephalexin* (antibiotic) ibuprofen (analgesic) sulfamethoxazole (antibiotic) valproic acid* (antiepileptic) trimethoprim (antibiotic) *to our knowledge, these compounds have not been previously investigated

Methodology  Four-liter grab samples (pharmaceuticals) (406 total samples to be collected, including duplicates) Samples are extracted within 48 hours  Analysis via Agilent 1100 HPLC and ThermoQuest LCQ Ion Trap LC/MS with ESI (electrospray ionization) - SIM for all analytes, except amoxicillin and cephalexin (MS/MS) Methodology developed by Dr. Patrick O’Keefe, NYSDOH WCLR; Method Detection Limit (MDL) study approved by US EPA

Methodology  Detection limits (from MDL study) Basic cmpds ng/L Env. Conc. Acid/neutral cmpds ng/L Env. Conc. amoxicillin 367 n/a  -ethinylestradiol atenolol  -estradiol caffeine estrone cephalexin* 502 n/a ibuprofen sulfamethoxazole valproic acid* 199 n/a trimethoprim *to our knowledge, these compounds have not been previously investigated - Environmental concentrations are those found in surface waters or WWTP effluents in the literature

Project Description  Pilot Study 3 consecutive days samples collected at each site for pharmaceuticals, VOCs, & SVOCs  4 seasonal sampling events 7 consecutive days of pharmaceutical samples; VOCs & SVOCs at the WWTPs for 3 days  EOH (2 WWTPs + 6 surface water locations) WOH (2 WWTPs + 4 surface water locations)

Pilot Study- Results  WWTPs: - atenolol was found in every sample - trimethoprim was found in all samples from Yorktown, Carmel, and Margaretville - caffeine was found in all samples from Yorktown and Carmel, one sample from Margaretville - ibuprofen detected at all sites - estrone and 17  -estradiol detected once, only at Carmel - no detections of amoxicillin, cephalexin, sulfamethoxazole, valproic acid, or 17  -ethinylestradiol

WWTP results - preliminary data

Pilot Study (cont’d)  Reservoir keypoints - caffeine was detected in a sample from CROGH - trimethoprim was detected in a sample from CATLEFF and one from Neversink - ibuprofen was detected in one sample from CATLEFF, CROGH, and WDA Some of these detections were in higher concentrations than a number of the WWTP effluent concentrations. These results were NOT verified in the corresponding duplicates.

EOH results - preliminary data

Conclusions and Findings  variability in concentrations between WWTPs  daily concentrations at individual WWTPs were similar over the three sampling days  very few detections in reservoir samples (and not in dupes)  several detected compounds supported by recent USGS data: - DOH target analytes: caffeine, ibuprofen, trimethoprim - DOH non-target analytes: acetaminophen, carbamazepine, carisoprodol, DEET, valium

Project Status Completed work: June ’03: Preliminary sampling/pilot study (70 samples) Mar 04 Pilot Report finalized May 04 Sampling completed (340 samples total over 4 seasons) June 05Final Data from Laboratory Planned work: November 05 Interagency draft report Final report January 06 ( Follow-up proposal already developed)

Acknowledgements We would like to thank the following people for their assistance in the design and implementation of this project: Ken Markussen, NYS Department of Environmental Conservation Patrick Phillips, US Geological Survey Charles Cutietta-Olson, NYC Department of Environmental Protection Dennis McChesney, US Environmental Protection Agency This work was funded by the US EPA under a New York City Watershed Protection Grant from the Safe Drinking Water Act. This grant was administered by the NYS DEC.

The End.