Chapter 6 & 7 Apologetics as Defense: Problem of Evil, part 1&2 Question General Principles Blind alleys Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense:

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
SIN A SPIRITUAL DISEASE. SIN Most persons in the church today have little knowledge of the subject! So we should ask some questions. Is there such a thing.
Advertisements

CHANGING SEASONS, UNCHANGING LORD AND SAVIOR Hebrews 13:5-9.
Answering Biblical Questions Apologetically Without Being Sorry 1 Peter 3:15.
Discovering HOPE in the midst of evil SUFFERING AND THE HIDDENNESS OF GOD.
The Gospel – Fulfills God’s Purpose in Justifying & Glorifying Men
Salvation By Grace and Eternal Security Foundations for Life.
A Simple Matter of Obedience… from the Heart Romans 6:17 Hebrews 5:9.
THEODICY: WHY GOD ALLOWS EVIL Robby Lashua DSCC Oasis Feb. 23 rd, 2014.
Saturday, December 11, 2010 ~ 6:00 pm In the Best Western, Huffman Mill Road.
The Big Picture of the Bible part 2 Assistance from the book written by Kenneth W. Craig.
The Problem of Evil and Suffering
2011 GLCC 15th ANNIVERSARY MESSAGE SERIES 3: THE GOSPEL REVIEWED I. INTRO II. THE GOSPEL III. 7 IMPORTANT TRUTHS OF THE GOSPEL 1) No One Is Declared Righteous.
{ Preparing to write your paper on Biblical Integration Proposal for Biblical Integration.
“…in His Image” (Gen 1:26) In His Image Gen 1: look at the structure 1:3-5; 1: Similar pattern 1:26 - Pattern change! Not “Let there be…”
I BELIEVE IN GOD THE FATHER ALMIGHTY CREATOR OF HEAVEN AND EARTH … (The Apostles’ Creed)
People use “Faith” in a multitude of different ways... that one simply believes something will happen w/o any emphasis on Deity. or a “better felt than.
Good and Evil Unit Revision Notes. The Problem of Evil Anyone who believes in a loving God, a God who is omnipotent (all-powerful), omniscient (all- knowing)
R. Henderson 2/03/08 Lesson # In the Eternal Plan of God a.Foreknowledge – Acts 2:23, 1Pet 1:2&20 b.Predestinated – Rom 8:29 c.Elect of God – 1Thess.
1 The Preaching of the “Compromised” Gospel Galatians 6:6-7, “ to a different gospel, which is not another; but there are some who trouble you and want.
Chapter 12 The Freedom of the Children of God. Christ has set us free No one is perfect. Everyone struggles with sin. Video: By God’s grace
Paul, an apostle of Jesus Christ by the will of God, to the saints who are in Ephesus, and faithful in Christ Jesus: 2 Grace to you and peace from God.
Theology in Personal Evangelism. Theology- from the Greek word that combines theos and the suffix –logy, means the study of God the·ol·o·gy Why study.
Saved and being saved… Upon conversion, one is ushered into the process of sanctification where he is made a partaker of Christ’s holiness and over time.
Genesis 3. The Fall of Man ● Most important chapter of Bible? ● Pivot of the Bible ● Signficant event between Gen 1-2 and Gen 4-11.
Knowing God (VI) The Mystery of God 1 Tim 3:16 By common confession, great is the mystery of godliness: He who was revealed in the flesh, Was vindicated.
Christian Doctrine Semester 1, Week 6: Humanity in the image of God [Week 3: The God Who Is] [Week 4: The Creator God] [Week 5: The Nature of God]
Apologetics Session 2: The problem of suffering. “Apologetics”????  “…but in your hearts sanctify Christ as Lord. Always be ready to make your defence.
1 APOLOGETICS THE PROBLEM OF EVIL. 2 The Problem of Evil, or “Why Do Bad Things Happen to Good People?” The Problem: How can these three statements all.
Responsibility to Study Not in Man that Walks “to direct his own steps,” Jeremiah 10:23. The Thoughts and ways of God “above our thoughts and ways,” Isaiah.
“The Word Became Flesh” John 1:1-14 “In the beginning was the Word, and the Word was with God, and the Word was God. He was with God in the beginning.
Augustine of Hippo ( AD) Catholic priest We know a great deal about his life from his Confessions and Revisions; from a recent biography and from.
The Problem of Evil Part One Philosophy and Ethics, 3B.
A monotheistic system of beliefs and practices based on the Old and New Testaments of the Bible and the teachings of Jesus Christ, as well as the fact.
How Do We Account For Evil? The Alternatives. Review Evil exists, but God does not Which worldview? God exists, but evil does not Which worldview? Evil.
The Problem of Evil The Theistic Problem. Why a Problem? Suffering simply happens; why is this a problem? Any compassionate being (human or otherwise)
APRECIATING GOD’S ABSOLUTE AND INFINITE GREATNESS By the Means of Studying and Learning His Attributes John Stephenson Biblical Worldview Ministries ;
Lesson 7 for the 14 th of August, “Moreover the law entered that the offense might abound. But where sin abounded, grace abounded much more” (Romans,
Grace Fellowship Church Pastor/Teacher Jim Rickard Tuesday, June 5, 2012.
Why Apologetics? Apologetics Introduction. What is Apologetics? The branch of theology that is concerned with defending or proving the truth of Christian.
Suffering John 9:1-5 Introduction Many who refuse to believe in God claim to do so because of “the problem of suffering” –The thought goes something.
Lesson 2. The Attributes of God Omniscient: God knows all God is perfect in knowledge The righteous accept the reality of these truths by faith Some truths.
JESUS’ PRAYER FOR YOU John 17. Prayer of accountability to the Father 1 After Jesus said this, he looked toward heaven and prayed: "Father, the time has.
To get you thinking... Look carefully at the following statements: what issues or problems do you think they highlight? God made the world and it was GOOD.
God is a “great God” (Psa. 95:3) and the “Lord Almighty” (2 Cor. 6:18), yet there are some things he cannot do God cannot do some things because they.
The Freedom Fighter – Part 2 Ch. 4 Galatians 2:
Conversational Apologetics The Problem of Evil – Part 2.
Are you hiding from God? Fellowship with God is the objective of the book. Now, John gives us practical principles to accomplish that.
I Want to be Sure!.
The Doctrine of Man I. How was man created from the hand of God? A. Man was created in the image of God (Gen. 1:26). 1. This image involves man as a three-fold.
Essential Doctrine that serves to inform the Soul Winner.
Paradise Lost – Major Themes Justifying the Ways of God to Man God’s Omnipotence, Omniscience, and Free Will Individual Responsibility The True Nature.
The Just Shall Live By Faith Studying Paul’s Letter To Rome …
Grace Fellowship Church Pastor/Teacher Jim Rickard Sunday, April 14, 2013.
Grace Fellowship Church Pastor/Teacher Jim Rickard Thursday, March 25,
Global Christian Movement Session 4 Theological Foundations.
The Benefits of Assurance of Salvation By Jay Wegter.
Spiritual Sickness (Some signs/ The cure). The format of today’s study  There will be some questions for you to consider.  Try your best to answer these.
Romans Chapter 5. Disagreement over: Where to put this chapter in outline. Historically Ch. 5 has been grouped with Ch. 4 More scholars now place Ch.
My Proposition: The Scriptures teach that the alien sinner is forgiven of his past sins by faith only, before and without water baptism My Proposition:
Ephesians 2 Salvation was and is God’s Plan: Past, Present and Future.
Grace Bible Church Glorifying God by Making Disciples of Jesus Christ
WHY IS THERE EVIL IN THE WORLD?
Grace Bible Church Glorifying God by Making Disciples of Jesus Christ
Grace Bible Church Glorifying God by Making Disciples of Jesus Christ
Augustinian Theodicy Learning Objectives
Follow along at: southsidepca.org/CE/index.html or
Proposal for Biblical Integration
Conversational Evangelism 1
The Providence of God.
Part 2: Reviewing Theodicies, Addressing Suffering, and Application
Presentation transcript:

Chapter 6 & 7 Apologetics as Defense: Problem of Evil, part 1&2 Question General Principles Blind alleys Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil A Biblical Response

Defense The Bible defends itself God calls people to defend His truth (Phil 1:7,16; 1Peter 3:15)Phil 1:7,163:15 Scripture supplies the fundamental standards and criteria which we must employ –But other data is valuable as well … All facts have apologetic significance, because all facts are created and ordered by God. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

Problem? Answer? Premise 1: If God were all-powerful, he would be able to prevent evil. Premise 2: If God were all-good, he would desire to prevent evil. Conclusion: So, if God were both all-powerful and all-good, there would be no evil. Premise 3: But there is evil. Conclusion: Therefore, there is no all-powerful, all-good God. So is there an explanation that will vindicate God’s providence in every instance of evil? … If you want encouragement and help to go on believing and trusting God in the midst of suffering or unexplained evil, Scripture provides that, and provides it abundantly. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

General Principles The Bible brings us as close to an answer as we can get. Keep in mind the following scriptural truths: 1.God is sovereign, omnipotent, omniscient, loving, and compassionate from eternity past. 2.Man was created good – no pain or suffering before the fall 3.There will be no pain or suffering for those who are in Christ in eternity future. 4.Scripture is true. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

Definitions Theodicy –literally means “justification of God.” –It is used to describe proposed solutions to the problem of evil. These defenses will be presented on the following slides, generally listed from worst to better, or from anti-biblical to more biblical. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

Defenses 1.Divine weakness (proponents: process theology & open theism) God doesn’t overcome all evil because he cannot do so – although he does his best. 2.Free-Will Evil came about by the free choice of rational creatures. This was in no way controlled, foreordained or caused by God, so He cannot be held accountable for it. 3.Stable Environment To live happily and productively requires a universe of regular law. This stable environment open up the possibility of evil. 4.Best-Possible-World Certain evils are logically necessary to achieve certain good ends. E.g. There must be suffering if there is to be compassion for sufferers. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

Defenses 5.Unreality-of-evil (proponent: Augustine) Evil can be classified under the category of nonbeing – it is a “privation,” a lack of good being were good ought to be. E.g. 6.Character-Building (proponent: Irenaeus) Man was created in a state of moral immaturity. To come to full maturity, it was necessary for him to undergo pain & suffering. 7.Indirect-Cause God is the indirect rather than the direct cause of evil, so he bears no blame. 8.ex Lex “outside of the law” God is outside of or above the laws he prescribes for man. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

Defenses (continued) Apologetics to the Glory of God 9.Ad Hominem Best defense is a good offense.The unbeliever has no right even to raise the question, for he cannot even distinguish good & evil. e.g. 10.Scriptural 1 Peter 1:6-7 faith proven genuine and results in praise of God 2 Cor 4:8-11,16-18 troubles can’t compare with future glory Job 1:6-12 & Eph 3:10 on display for the heavenly realms Romans 9:17 display of God’s wrath shows his power & character Romans 3:3-8 ad hominem rebuke Job 38:4-5; 42:3 his thoughts are higher than ours (Is 55:9; Rom 11:33-34) Job 42:6 God’s rebuke lead to repentance Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

The following slides examine the positive aspects, the pros (if it has any), and the negative, cons, for each of the previously mentioned theodicies. There are some things going for most of the defenses, but many of them are not scriptural or still live one with too many question. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

1. Divine weakness (proponents: process theology & open theism) All Negative –Scripture not only fails to teach such a solution, but firmly contradicts it. –This denies historic Christian doctrines of Omnipotence Omniscience Sovereignty May get a solution to the problem of evil, but loses any sure hope for the overcoming of evil. Christian doctrines are not subject to revision. Apologetics to the Glory of God God doesn’t overcome all evil because he cannot do so – although he does his best. Evil exists because God cannot prevent it. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

2. Free-will Positive: Scripture agrees that the blame for sin rests upon man, rather than God (Gen 50:20; Acts 2:23; Acts 4:27) Almost all negative Scripture denies free will in the sense that it is used in this defense. God determines our free choice (see above passages and Prov 16:9; Lk 24:45; John 6:44,65; Acts 2:47; 11:18; 13:48; 16:14; Rom 8:28ff; Rom 9; Phil 1:29; and the free choices of humans are included in Rom 11:36; Eph 1:11) Scripture never uses the free-will defense in any passage where the problem of evil is up for discussion. Scripture does teach that man is, or can be, free in certain senses: 1.He does what he wants to do, acting in accord with his desires 2.Adam had the freedom or ability to choose either good or evil. Fall removed freedom, only do evil (Gen 6:4; 8:21; Is 64:5; Rom 3:10ff)… redemption restores 3. John 8:32 Redemption = freedom from sin 4. Not the helpless victims of historical determinism. Apologetics to the Glory of God Evil came about by the free choice of rational creatures. This was in no way controlled, foreordained or caused by God, so He cannot be held accountable for it. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

3. Stable environment Positive: Although some evils may certainly be traced to natural laws in a stable environment, but these are not a sufficient explanation for evil. Negatives: 1.Bible never gives this as the source of evil. This would be to blame creation rather than our own hearts. 2.God created Adam and placed him in a stable environment that was without evil and pain. 3.Heaven will be another stable place without evil. Apologetics to the Glory of God To live happily and productively requires a universe of regular law. This stable environment open up the possibility of evil. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

4. Best-Possible-World Positive: Scripture does teach that God observes the laws of logic. That God is logical is implied by the scriptural teaching that he is wise, just, faithful, and true… It is possible that, taking the whole history, this is the best world that God could have made. Negative: 1.God is perfect, no evil in him. 2.Original creation contained no evil, nor will heaven 3.God has always been compassionate, even when there was no one to show compassion to 4.Adam was created good, but not perfect – alone, untested 5.There is much that is imperfect that will be perfected (or destroyed) Apologetics to the Glory of God Certain evils are logically necessary to achieve certain good ends. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

5. Unreality-of-Evil Positive: Of being, God say, “It is good” (Gen 1:31; 1 Tim 4:4). That would seem to indicate that only nonbeing can be evil. Augustine recognized that evil has no power of its own and is in some sense parasitic on goodness. Negative: In Scripture, evil is treated as something we must deal with, not as an illusion. God is sovereign over all events, good and evil. (Eph 1:11; Gen 50:20; Lk 22:22; Acts 2:23; 4:28; Rom 9:1- 29) Apologetics to the Glory of God Evil can be classified under the category of nonbeing – it is a “privation,” a lack of good being were good ought to be. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

6. Character-Building Positive: Suffering sometime builds character (Hebrews 12) Negative: 1.Adam wasn’t created morally immature 2.Had he obeyed, he would not have suffered. 3.Not all suffering builds character. 4.Not all character improvement comes through suffering. 5.Sanctification perfected in heaven w/out suffering Apologetics to the Glory of God Man was created in a state of moral immaturity. To come to full maturity, it was necessary for him to undergo pain & suffering. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

7. Indirect-Cause Positive: The author is the closest cause to the effect, the “proximate” cause… God did not tempt Eve, the serpent did. James 1:13 say that such is always the case with temptation. Negative: -Indirectness of causality does not mitigate responsibility (on a human level) -God is not some kind of Mafia boss who keeps his hands legally clean. Apologetics to the Glory of God God is the indirect rather than the direct cause of evil, so he bears no blame. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

8. ex Lex Positive: + God has some prerogatives that he forbids to us. E.g. taking human life + Morally, God is on an entirely different level + Scripture forbids human criticism of God’s actions Negative: -The law reflects God’s own character. To obey the law is to imitate God, to be like Him, to image Him. (Ex 20:11; Lev 11;44-45; Mt 5:45; 1Pt 1:15-16) Overall holiness, justice, and goodness of God is something we can and must imitate on the human level. Apologetics to the Glory of God “outside of the law” God is outside of or above the laws he prescribes for man. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

9. ad Hominem Positive: + Scripture does rebuke people who raise the problem of evil in certain ways. (see Job) + Scripture is not entirely averse to some types of ad hominem response. Negative: - It is an ad hominem argument; it is addressed to the person rather than to the issue Apologetics to the Glory of God Best defense is a good offense.The unbeliever has no right even to raise the question, for he cannot even distinguish good & evil. Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

10. Scriptural Romans teaches what we see elsewhere in Scripture: 1.We have no right to complain against God, and when we do, we expose ourselves as disobedient. 2.God is under no obligation to give us an intellectually satisfying answer to the problem of evil. He expects us to trust him in spite of that. 3.God’s sovereignty is not to be questioned in connection with the problem of evil 4.God’s word, his truth, is entirely reliable. 5.God is not unjust. He is holy, just, and good. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

10. Scriptural (continued) God vindicates his justice by helping us see history through his eyes: -mystery of time -God enters in judgment, but each time he preserves the people in grace. -CHRIST IS THE THEODICY (Romans 3:26 “he did it to demonstrate his justice at the present time, so as to be just and the one who justifies those who have faith in Jesus.”; Rom 5:8 “He demonstrate his love..”) -1 John 1:9 faithful and JUST to forgive Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

10. Scriptural – Greater-Good Defense Clarifications/Foundation: 1.Theocentric (not anthropocentric) – God’s ultimate purpose is to glorify himself (man’s chief end “is to glorify God, and enjoy him forever.”) 2.Obedience to God is a way of life and happiness (John 10:10; Dt 5:33; 8:3; 11:13-15…Ps 1; Ps 119:7) Suffering is for a while; glory is for eternity.Dt 5:33 11:13-15 Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

10. Scriptural – Greater-Good Ways God uses evil to bring about greater good: 1.Displaying his grace and justice (Rom 3:26; 5:8,20-21;9:17)9:17 2.Judgment of evil (Mt 23:35; John 5:14), now and in the future. 3.Redemption: Christ’s sufferings are redemptive (1 Pt 3:18) and in a way so may ours (Col 1:24)Col 1:24 Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

10. Scriptural – Greater-Good 4.Shock value to unbelievers, intended to gain their attention and promote a change of heart (Zech 13:7-9; Luke 13:1- 5; John 9 healing the man born blind. Why blind? )Zech 13:7-9Luke 13: Fatherly disciple of believers (Heb 12)Heb 12 6.Vindication of God (Rom 3:26) We know that God has a reason for everything he does. Everything he does reflects wisdom. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil

Conclusion Why can it be called a so-called problem of pain? –It isn’t so much that evil & pain is an illusion –It isn’t a philosophical problem that argues against God’s existence. –Pain testifies to the veracity, the truthfulness, of God and of Scripture. The answer to the problem of pain is that in reality it is a problem of sin. A good, just, omnipotent, sovereign God has to make the sinner (the rebel against God) suffer. Apologetics to the Glory of God Ch6&7 Defense: Problem of Evil