Today’s Lecture Your Koller Text Beginning Vedic Hinduism.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
A Global View.  Humans have always expressed a need to understand natural phenomenon and to answer questions regarding their way of life and what happens.
Advertisements

Certainty Of Things Believed Among Us Certainty - A Basic Need Of All Men – Before one is willing to make an "investment" in anything that costs Wants.
Today’s Lecture Concluding the Upanishads Beginning the Gita.
Today’s Lecture A clip from The Matrix Concluding the Upanishads.
“Night” from the Rig-Veda
Ancient India Hinduism. India’s Social Hierarchy Quiz 1. T or F – Brahmins, or the priests are at the top of the caste system. 2. T or F – The Sudras,
Today’s Lecture Admin stuff More basic Buddhist philosophy –The three characteristics of samsaric existence, –The three root evils, –Interdependent Arising.
The Rig Veda Asian Religions Berger. The History of Vedic Texts  Theories of “Aryan” Origins  The Orientalist and Nazi “ethnic” theory  The “Russian”
Nature of the Upani  adic Compositions. The principal texts within the Upani  ads are dialogues between teachers and their disciples The subject: the.
HUMAN NATURE IN THE HEBREW BIBLE PHILOSOPHY 224. RELIGIOUS THEORIES OF HUMAN NATURE We are going to focus on the philosophical rather than religious significance.
PHIL/RS 335 Arguments for God’s Existence Pt. 1: The Cosmological Argument.
Learning about World religions: Hinduism
Vedic Religion Male deities associated with the heavens Sacrifice-essential ritual Brahmin priest controlled rituals and prayers –Rig Veda – thousands.
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE Chapter 5
Today’s Lecture In-class quiz Administrative stuff Preliminary comments about the saddarshanas Some preliminary comments about Samkhya-Yoga A very brief.
Today’s Lecture Some (I hope) final administrative comments Concluding the preliminary comments Orientation for Hinduism The Rig Veda and Vedic Hinduism.
Chapter 6 Section 2.
Hinduism Preview Main Idea / Reading Focus Basic Teachings of Hinduism
Chapter 6 Section 2 Origins of Hinduism
Lecture 5: The origins of Hinduism. Facts on Hinduism The word “Hinduism” encompasses a wide range of beliefs and practices Hinduism is monotheistic and.
Oral and literary tradition that evolved over 3500 years.
HUMAN NATURE IN THE HINDU TRADITION THE UPANISHADS PHILOSOPHY 224.
Ascetics and Upanishads Sarah Bingham Ally Philyaw Caitlin Whiten Amy Wood.
What is Hinduism? One of the oldest religions of humanity Developed over centuries The religion of the Indian people Eventually led to Buddhism Tolerance.
Ancient India Ancient History 10.
Title: Hinduism. Three devas- Brahma, Vishnu, Siva -are particularly influential. Some believe in thousands; others worship only one as the true manifestation.
Today’s Lecture DON’T FORGET TO VOTE! Concluding the Upanishads.
Hinduism Philosophical and metaphysical origins
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Preliminary comments about Vedanta Advaita Vedanta Vishishtadvaita Vedanta.
PHIL 224 The Upanishadic Vision of the Human. THN s : Some Common Features As we will see, theories of human nature typically include some common elements.
What is Hinduism? One of the oldest religions of humanity Began in India Focus on tolerance and diversity: "Truth is one, paths are many“ Not one single.
1.According to Radhakrishnan and Moore, what are the four major periods in the development of Indian philosophy? What, according to Zaehner, are the four.
Ancient India and China Section 2 Preview Main Idea / Reading Focus Basic Teachings of Hinduism Sacred Texts and Practices Jainism Hinduism.
Today’s Lecture First in-class quiz Concluding Vedic Hinduism Beginning the Upanishads.
Today’s Lecture Any questions about the assignments? Continuing the Gita.
What is Hinduism? One of the oldest religions of humanity The religion of the Indian people Gave birth to Buddhism Tolerance and diversity: "Truth is one,
LOGIC AND ONTOLOGY Both logic and ontology are important areas of philosophy covering large, diverse, and active research projects. These two areas overlap.
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Really beginning the Upanishads.
Ascetics and Upanishads Sarah Bingham Ally Philyaw Caitlin Whiten Amy Wood.
Ancient India and China Section 2 Three devas- Brahma, Vishnu, Siva -are particularly influential. Some believe in thousands; others worship only one as.
Hinduism and Buddhism A Brief Introduction Visit For 100’s of free powerpoints.
Philosophy 224 Divine Persons: Broad on Personal Belief.
Today’s Lecture Administrative stuff Continuing the Upanishads.
Hinduism. Do Now List any information you know about Hinudism.
Vedas. “Veda” – Sankrit for “wisdom” or “knowledge stem from oral tradition – rishis written down when ??? 2000 BCE?
SACRED TEXTS. No Single Text… -No single creed or doctrine binds Hindus together -Hinduism is a syncretic religion, welcoming and incorporating a variety.
Hinduism. The History of Hinduism Hinduism The term Hindu was traditionally used by outsiders to describe the people of South Asia, now it has come to.
Origins of Hinduism No definite origin
Religion and Philosophy Understanding the connection between religion and philosophy.
Hinduism World Religions Chapter 3. There is only one God But endless are his aspects and endless are his names. Call him by any name and worship him.
Today’s Lecture Preliminary comments on epistemology Epistemology and our knowledge of the external world - some preliminary considerations. René Descartes.
The Nature of Religion. A worldview that contributes to the lives of individuals Religion provides its adherents with a source of meaning that both transcends.
CHAPTER 1 STUDYING THE WORLD’S RELIGIONS Pg
Ad Hominem (Personal Attack) An attempt to discredit the argument by discrediting the character of the person advancing it.
Relativism, Divine Command Theory, and Particularism A closer look at some prominent views of ethical theory.
Hinduism Overview & Sacred Texts Hinduism Overview & Sacred Texts.
Developments in Christian thought…
Primary Eastern Religions
What is Hinduism? One of the oldest religions of humanity
Caste System & Hinduism
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE Chapter 5
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE Chapter 5
Hinduism.
Hinduism and Buddhism.
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE Chapter 5
Origins of Hinduism The Beginnings….
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE Chapter 5
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE Chapter 5
Eurasian Cultural Traditions 500 BCE to 500 CE
Presentation transcript:

Today’s Lecture Your Koller Text Beginning Vedic Hinduism

Your Koller Text Some of you have ran into problems getting your Koller text, primarily because the UWO Bookstore ran out of stock. The Bookstore has assured me that 40 are on order and should arrive tomorrow or Thursday. Re the first in-class quiz (on Thursday by the way [to begin soon after class begins]): Just concentrate on your lectures and handout on philosophical method for this quiz. I won’t start asking questions based on text content until the second quiz.

Some preliminary comments about Indian Philosophy Where we left off: (3) We can see if such claims are predicted by theories or perspectives already reasonably held to be true. This method won’t work if the epistemic value of these theories or perspectives depends on the truth of the claims about the after-life (or after-death) in question. In such a circumstance, an appeal to these theories or perspectives to defend claims about the after-life (or after-death) would be circular (a fallacious form of reasoning known as ‘begging the question’). As an example think of appeals to authority using narratives involving the appearance or ‘testimony’ of those purported to have died but who now exist ‘elsewhere’.

Some preliminary comments about Indian Philosophy It could be the case that, as it stands, we cannot make a reasoned defense of either a denial or affirmation regarding the existence of an after-life (or after-death). This doesn’t have to finish the discussion. We have three possible responses open to us. (1) We can simply adopt a denial that an after-life exists until evidence to the contrary appears. (2) We can remain agnostic on the issue (i.e. we can remain neutral on the matter). (3) We can simply adopt an affirmation that an after-life exists until evidence to the contrary appears. (1) and (3) suffer from two weaknesses. (i) On the face of it, neither is any more or less rational than the other. (ii) Either option may be based on fallacious reasoning.

Some preliminary comments about Indian Philosophy If we remember that a fallacious argument or an example of fallacious reasoning is so because the principle of inference or reasoning used to move from the premises to the conclusion is not a reliable means of obtaining a true statement/claim, then we should avoid arguing that something is true because of a lack of contrary evidence, or that something is false because of a lack of supporting evidence. To do so is to commit a fallacy known as ‘an argument from ignorance’. Put simply, this is because a lack of contrary evidence is not a definitive or even reliable indicator of the truth of, or a lack of supporting evidence is not a definitive or even reliable indicator of the falsity of, a belief or claim in dispute.

Some very preliminary comments on Hinduism Hinduism is NOT one religion. The term ‘Hinduism’ refers to a diversity of religious traditions that hold the Vedas as authoritative in religion and practice (Koller, Asian Philosophers, p.6). Within Hinduism you can find those who believe in the God or Goddess, or in many Gods and Goddesses, and those who shy away from such a theistic emphasis. There is no one way to be a ‘good Hindu’. This fact about Hinduism allows for a sometimes remarkable degree of tolerance within the Tradition taken as a whole. (This does not mean that there is no sectarianism within Hinduism (or religious killings) … but up until recently this differed in ‘flavor’ or spirit from what you might encounter in Christianity or Islam.)

The Vedas and Vedic Hinduism Vedic Hinduism is the early Hinduism that arose out of and informed the content of the Vedic scriptures. The oldest of the Vedic literature is dated to between 1500 and 1200 B.C.E (Koller, Asian Philosophies, pp.3-4). It was not set down in writing for perhaps a thousand years after its creation. (Writing was considered a ‘polluting’ activity … a rather common view in human antiquity.)

The Vedas and Vedic Hinduism The word ‘veda’ means ‘wisdom’ or ‘knowledge’ (see Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.347). As you’ve already seen, Veda is a term used to refer to a certain subset of the Hindu scriptures. There are two ways to refer to the Vedic scriptures. You can talk of the collections of verses (that form the basis of the rest of the Vedic literature) as the Vedas, or talk of the Vedic literature proper (or as a whole) as the Vedas. Vedic literature includes the Samhitas (or collections of verses) and Brahmanas (or commentaries), Aranyakas (or forest treatises), and theUpanishads (the principal Upanishads contain early Hindu philosophy) (see Koller, Asian Philosophies, pp.4-5).

The Vedas When using the term ‘narrowly’ for the Samhitas (literally ‘the collections’), we talk of four Vedas, one of which is the Rig Veda (Koller quotes from some of the Rig Veda in your text [see pages 17-19], he also mentions the other three Vedas on page 4). Each collection of verses has an associated set of Brahmanas, Aranyakas and Upanishads.

The Vedas Brahmanas consist of lectures (representing the perspectives of various schools in which brahmans received their instruction or training) dealing with the myths and commentaries surrounding certain sections of the Vedas. Aranyakas, or forest treatises, consist of reflections on the greater or deeper significance of the ritual elements (broadly construed). Upanishads consist of reflections on that which underlies, or underpins, Vedic religious thought and practice. Often viewed as the end (vedanta) of the Vedas (see Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.5).

The Vedas (broadly construed) An aside: Philosophical schools (or darshanas) who ground their reflections and arguments on the Upanishads are often referred to as Vedantan. The Upanishads are often highlighted in the study of Vedic Hinduism as the beginning of philosophical reflection in Hinduism (e.g. Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.3). I’m nervous about this claim, though it is a common one, largely because it contains an implicit judgment regarding the philosophical value of the reflection which precedes the Upanishads. Yet there are passages in the Rig Veda that qualify as philosophical. Consider the passages quoted on pages of your Koller text.

The Vedas The Vedas, understood narrowly or broadly (Hindus more often than not use the term in its broad sense), are regarded as shruti (literally ‘that which is heard’). This gives them a status analogous to revealed scripture in, say, the Abrahamic Traditions. Shruti are the highest scriptural authority in Hinduism. As shruti they are regarded as both timeless and authorless. They are timeless in that they are eternal. They are authorless in that they were revealed to (heard by) ancient sages (or rishis) and passed down thereafter from teacher to student (see Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.15).

The Rig Veda The Rig Veda, which is the Samhita often read at this level of study of Hinduism, contains 1028 verses divided into 10 books or sections. Though the various hymns of the Rig Veda address the gods in a worshipful manner (and so may hold some salvific import), such hymns typically entreat these gods for particular blessings or benefits in this life for the participants (Koller, Asian Philosophies, pp.15-16). In the evolution of Vedic Hinduism you see the understanding of the significance of religious ritual change.

The Vedas Over time Vedic ritual becomes treated as a microcosm of macrocosmic events (events in the world, the atmospheric or celestial realm, or heaven). Consequently, Vedic rites become understood as the means for manipulating the relevant cosmic powers or natural forces to gain the benefits sought after (Koller, Asian Philosophies, p.16). Under such an interpretation of the rituals/rites, the priests and their skill in the ritual become more important than the particular deities who are addressed. The priests’ skills in manipulating the elements are the sufficient and necessary conditions for bringing about the desired effects in the world.

The Vedas This becomes an important historical event. The priests, or Brahmins, officiating over the public Vedic rites begin to assume the status associated with the top of the social hierarchy and so begin to acquire a great deal of social power. This will coincide with the gradual emergence of a social hierarchy known as the varnadharma (for a sneak peek look at pages of your Asian Philosophies). This is now more widely known as ‘the caste system’ … though what we can now observe as the caste system in Hinduism is the result of almost three millennia of development and change.

The Vedas A note of caution: There is much speculation in the literature about the change that occurs in the Vedic Religion as participants move from petitioning gods or goddesses for blessings or forgiveness to manipulating them to achieve a certain sought after end. Be careful not to too quickly adopt a framework that sees such a move as a mark of ‘maturity’ within the culture.

The Vedas There is little reason to view polytheism as somehow more culturally primitive than monotheism or monism. (i) Certainly some contemporary expressions of polytheism are no older than some contemporary expressions of monotheism or monism. (ii) There is also no qualitative philosophical difference between some expressions of polytheism (like some popular Hindu views of the divine) and some expressions of monotheism or monism (like popular Christian views of the divine).