Evaluation of a Rapid Policy Assessment and Response Intervention: Szczecin, Poland Background: Rapid Policy Assessment and Response (RPAR) is a community-level.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Re:Act Coordinating Virtual Team Matt Scott, MSW Amanda Brown, MSW.
Advertisements

The Role of the IRB An Institutional Review Board (IRB) is a review committee established to help protect the rights and welfare of human research subjects.
Quality assurance Kari Kuulasmaa 1 st EHES Training Seminar, February 2010, Rome.
Brussels, May 2009 Awareness and Public Opinion results from: Evaluation of the means used by national Data Protection Authorities in the promotion.
How To Impact Your Research: An Overview of Research Support Services Quincy J. Byrdsong, Terri Hagan, and Alice Owens-Gatlin Research Services Consultants.
Workshop IV: Provision of Health Care The Impact of International Standards and Guidelines on prisoner health in Eastern and Central Europe Antalya, Turkey.
Advocacy 1. What is Advocacy? ● Organized effort to influence policy change/decision making ● Action directed at changing approach of an individual/institution/group.
Bridging the Gap between Needs and Services Towards Evidence-based Drug Policy In Poland Issue: Matching Needs and Services in Environments of Rapid Change.
Ethical Considerations when Developing Human Research Protocols A discipline “born in scandal and reared in protectionism” Carol Levine, 1988.
Program Evaluation and Measurement Janet Myers. Objectives for today… To define and explain concepts and terms used in program evaluation. To understand.
After the Rapid Policy Assessment (RPAR): Drug Policy Change and Advocacy in Szczecin, Poland Sobeyko J (1), Leszczyszyn-Pynka M (2), Duklas T (7), Parczewski.
SWRK 292 Thesis/Project Seminar. Expectations for Course Apply research concepts from SWRK 291. Write first three chapters of your project or thesis.
Comprehensive M&E Systems
Chapter 3 Preparing and Evaluating a Research Plan Gay and Airasian
ARQ part II data management Training pack 2: Monitoring drug abuse for policy and practice.
-Focus on evidence-based and current best practice -To assist law enforcement and other uniformed services build their capacity and enhance their role.
Community Planning Training 1-1. Community Plan Implementation Training 1- Community Planning Training 1-3.
Drug Law And Practice: Application to Harm Reduction In Ukraine Galina Kitsenko (1), Nataliya Kitsenko (2), Tatiana Ysipenko (2), Zita Lazzarini (3, 5),
How to survive in a non-supportive environment: Experience from Russia Ivan Varentsov (Andrey Rylkov Foundation) AIDS 2014, Melbourne.
Proposed Cross-center Project Survey of Federally Qualified Health Centers Vicky Taylor & Vicki Young.
Internal Auditing and Outsourcing
FUNDING OPPORTUNITIES. BACKGROUND New category of funding in the FY13 Harold Rogers Prescription Drug Monitoring Program Official title is “Category 3:
GSU-NACDD-CDC Chronic Disease and Public Health Workforce Training Training Needs Survey and Public Health Certificate in Chronic Disease Training for.
Drug Law in Practice in a Polish City Sobeyko J (1), Leszczyszyn-Pynka M (2), Duklas T (7), Parczewski M (2), Bejnarowicz P (1), Chintalova-Dallas R (4),
Essential Service # 7:. Why learn about the 10 Essential Services?  Improve quality and performance.  Achieve better outcomes – improved health, less.
Divergent Patterns of Amphetamine Use in the City and Rural Areas in Northwest Poland Sobeyko J (1), Leszczyszyn-Pynka M (2), Parczewski M (2), Burris.
Kazakhstan Gulnara Darbekova (1), Nadezhda Kozachenko (1), Irina Mingazova (1), Alexander Solodov (1), Natalia Kartashova (1), Zita Lazzarini (2,3), Patricia.
Whilst the pharmaceutical industry plays a key role in developing and producing medicines, there is a tension between industry’s need to expand product.
Use of OCAN in Crisis Intervention Webinar October, 2014.
Libyan-UK partnership on Infectious Diseases Control Professor Abdulhafid A. Abudher MBBch,DGO,FRCOG,MD,FABOG Director of National Centre for Infectious.
Legal and Policy Barriers to Effective Health Interventions among IDUs in Kaliningrad, Russia Inna Vyshemirskaya (1), Alexander Koss (2), Victoria Osipenko.
Boltushka: Use of Homemade Amphetamine in Odessa, Ukraine
HIV/AIDS prevention and care among injecting drug users and in prison settings in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania Signe ROTBERGA UNODC, Baltic States 5 November.
The Governance of Care: Mapping Local Influences on IDU Health Interventions in a Polish City Sobeyko J (1)(8), Leszczyszyn-Pynka M (1)(2), Duklas T (7),
DrugEpi 1-4 Counting HS Marijuana Use Module 1 Overview Context Content Area: Descriptive Epidemiology & Surveillance Essential Question (Generic): How.
Copyright 2010, The World Bank Group. All Rights Reserved. International Statistics Part 1 Crime, Justice & Security Statistics Produced in Collaboration.
KENTUCKY YOUTH FIRST Grant Period August July
Toolkit for Mainstreaming HIV and AIDS in the Education Sector Guidelines for Development Cooperation Agencies.
INTERNATIONAL LABOUR ORGANIZATION Conditions of Work and Employment Programme (TRAVAIL) 2012 Module 13: Assessing Maternity Protection in practice Maternity.
Module 4 Evaluating Services to Binational Migrant Students Designing an Implementation and Outcome Evaluation of State and Local Binational Services 1.
XXX_DECRIPT_MON00/1 Quality and impact of Social Science and Operations Research by the Special Programme in Human Reproduction Department of Reproductive.
Essential package of targeted interventions for MARA Romania Experience.
Assessments. Assessment in the Project Cycle DESIGN IMPLEMENTATION MONITORING EVALUATION ASSESSMENT.
Ethical Challenge & Solution in Social Behavioral Research Melody Lin December 2012.
Africa Health Workforce Platform & Observatory Presentation to the 1st conference of the Asia-Pacific Action Alliance on HRH (AAAH): October 2006.
EDPQS in 10 minutes: Overview of European Drug Prevention Quality Standards (EDPQS) With financial support from the Drug Prevention and Information Programme.
SUNY Oswego Human Subjects Committee Last Revised 10/28/2011.
HIV in Europe, Stockholm 2 November 2009 Developing Regional HIV T&C Policy Framework Lali Khotenashvili Communicable Diseases Unit, WHO Regional Office.
Needs Assessment Presented By Ernest D. Pérez Capacity Building Assistance Trainer BORDER HEALTH FOUNDATION Tucson, Arizona CAPACITY BUILDING ASSISTANCE.
Profiling exercise of internally displaced persons’ situations in_______ General presentation of the project Official project launch event Date.
PLACE Method Priorities for Local AIDS Control Efforts 1 1 MEASURE Evaluation, A Manual for implementing the PLACE Method.
Guidance Training CFR §483.75(i) F501 Medical Director.
Implement annual campus climate survey to: Gain further insight into student’s perceptions of campus safety Collect common data points Measure long-term.
Consultant Advance Research Team. Outline UNDERSTANDING M&E DATA NEEDS PEOPLE, PARTNERSHIP AND PLANNING 1.Organizational structures with HIV M&E functions.
Overview of EMCDDA’s 2009 Scientific Work Programme Paul Griffiths, Roland Simon - REITOX Meeting, Lisbon, November 2007.
Observatories for the Health Workforce in Africa VIII REGIONAL MEETING OF THE OBSERVATORIES OF HUMAN RESOURCES FOR HEALTH IN THE AMERICAS LIMA, PERU
Cultural Competence Considerations [and other alliterations] in International Research IRB 2 Continuing Education March 10, 2015.
Unit 8: Implementation, Part II Seminar Wednesday pm ET.
Unit 9: Evaluating a Public Health Surveillance System #1-9-1.
California Department of Public Health / 1 CALIFORNIA DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC HEALTH Standards and Guidelines for Healthcare Surge during Emergencies How.
The Flu…it’s Not Just About You Supported by CDC Grant #1 U01 IP Contents are solely the responsibility of the authors and do not necessarily.
M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 28 – Consumer and Health Protection.
Karen Cheung, MPH, Pamela Luna, DrPH, MST, Sarah Merkle, MPH American Evaluation Association Annual Meeting November 11, 2009 The findings and conclusions.
Moving Beyond Response Multi-Disciplinary Teams and Strategies for Preventing Abuse.
Support National Social Protection Strategy (NSPS) CARD/SPCU 1.
HIV/AIDS prevention and care among injecting drug users and in prison settings in Estonia, Latvia and Lithuania Riga, 29 May 2008 Sintija Šmite, UNODC.
Promoting Evidence-Based Policymaking by Sharing State Administrative Data Dr. Marty Romitti January 25, 2017.
General Situation (Overview)
Roles and Responsibilities of VDH Epidemiologists
World Health Organization
Presentation transcript:

Evaluation of a Rapid Policy Assessment and Response Intervention: Szczecin, Poland Background: Rapid Policy Assessment and Response (RPAR) is a community-level action research intervention process. Using the RPAR “tool kit” a research team, in Szczecin, Poland, collected laws and policies “on the books” that were relevant to IDU health and, through qualitative research, investigated how these laws were actually implemented “on the streets.” Researchers worked with a Community Action Board (CAB) of key stakeholders to conduct research, interpret the findings and develop a plan of action. We conducted a process evaluation of the Polish implementation of the RPAR process to assess The feasibility of the process Effectiveness of the process in identifying policy-related problems and identifying solutions influencing the risk environment for IDUs The production of community-level efforts to promote change. Results Feasibility: The RPAR was designed as a 36 week process. The Polish team was able to complete the research activities of the RPAR process within a 44 week period. Despite unanticipated barriers and a longer time to completion, it was feasible to implement and complete the project. Barriers to implementation included : 1) Resistance on the part of officials to sign consent forms, be taped, or saying anything “on the record” 2) Difficulty obtaining complete “Law on the books” legal data 3) Rules governing NGOs that made it difficult for them to accept donations or initiate programs without “official” support 4) Difficulty recruiting and interviewing IDUs from local minority groups. Completeness: Two members of the US team independently evaluated the completeness of collected data. Data collected for all categories except law on the books was 80 percent complete or better. Percent Complete Law on the books 18 Epidemiological data: disease 80 Epidemiological data: IDUs 88 Criminal justice data 97 Activities: The Polish team completed all the RPAR activities, conducting 3 focus groups with providers, 24 individual interviews with lawyers, a judge, police, physicians, drug treatment providers, prison officials and others, and 14 individual interviews with injection drug users. The team conducted legal and epidemiological analysis of available data and led the CAB in seven meetings, coordinating analytic exercises such as power mapping in the effort to identify areas where change could result in an improvement in the health of drug users. Effectiveness: The RPAR CAB identified a number of issues related to the health of injectors in Szczecin, including a number of findings not identified previously. These included The failure of the criminal justice system to utilize legally- mandated and available treatment services for drug users; An emerging rural epidemic of injected amphetamine use; Evidence of a poor fit between current drug use-related health services and needs. Efforts to promote community change: The CAB includes members who are lawyers, professors, physicians, defense attorneys, harm reduction workers, and others. Some are continuing to work to change policy in Szczecin. Projects that are continuing include developing a training curricula for judges and prosecutors about provisions in the law for drug treatment of convicted drug users and other legal issues, and work with local officials in rural areas regarding amphetamine use. There is an on-going evaluation to assess the implementation of the action plan and changes in policy and law related to the health of IDUs in Szczecin. Case P (1 ), Chintalova-Dallas R (2), Lazzarini Z (2)(4), Burris S (3)(4) (1) Fenway Community Health, USA (2) University of Connecticut Health Center, USA (3) Temple University Law School, USA (4) Center for Law and the Public’s Health at Georgetown and Johns Hopkins Universities, USA Methods: To conduct a process evaluation we examined all the materials developed by the Polish team including the weekly process notes written by the Polish team, all collected secondary epidemiological, legal and policy data, results of evaluation survey of CAB members and the Final Report and the Action Plan. We conducted 5 individual interviews with members of the team, surveyed 16 CAB members and evaluated the completeness of the legal data collected. This research was supported by NIDA/NIH Grant # 5 R01 DA PI: LAZZARINI, ZITA. The findings and conclusions expressed are those of the authors and not necessarily of NIH, NIDA, or the US Government. The development of RPAR was supported by the International Harm Reduction Development Program of the Open Society Institute in The RPAR Toolkit The RPAR toolkit is a manual of training materials and tools designed to be used by anyone to conduct an RPAR. It is a flexible system designed to be adapted to unique situations to assist in a community process of identifying ways to change policies and practices to improve the health of drug users. The toolkit includes: A detailed training manual Draft agendas, analytic exercises, and other materials to assist the CAB members Tools for collection of existing epidemiological, criminal justice, and legal data. Interview Guides for all types of individual and focus group interviews Data organization forms Research ethics information and guidelines, including data protection protocol, subject recruitment and consent training, and basic concepts necessary for completing the NIH web- based human subjects certification program For more information about the RPAR and to download preliminary RPAR toolkits in English, Russian and Polish versions, please visit our website Summarized sample of action plan recommendations Organize seminars for judges and prosecutors ssociated in the region of Szczecin. Diagnose drug use patterns in small towns and villages in the region. Add funds for drug counteraction to the city budget. Disseminate a paper to defense lawyers outlining legal strategies for the defense of drug users. Conclusions: The Rapid Policy Assessment and Response process can be used to mobilize local capacity to identify policies and implementation practices that improve or aggravate the social health risk environment for drug users. There were barriers to implementation and the process should be adapted to local conditions for maximum efficiency. Suggestions for improvement CAB members felt that the already-diverse CAB would have been improved with the addition of prosecutors, aldermen, other officials and several mentioned that drug users should have been invited to join the CAB. One said, “Should have invited a representative drug dependent [person] who has considerable experience with dependency….in order to understand, how this population responds toward particular methods of treatment.” “Taking part in [CAB] meetings was to me enormous experience. I became familiar with many different aspects of drug addiction and ways to limit its negative effect. Most solutions to this problem, at this time, cannot be implemented in prison institutions. It is necessary to change regulations and mentality of prison staff.” CAB member