The Epilogue to Developmental Theory. Walkerdine’s Stance “It is perhaps the supreme irony that the concern for individual freedom and the hope of a.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
What separates humans from animals? What separates advanced societies from primitive societies? What separates advanced cognition from basic cognition?
Advertisements

Constructivist theories of cognitive development in adolescence
Life-Span Human Development, Fifth Edition, Carol K. Sigelman and Elizabeth A. Rider Chapter 7 Chapter 7 Cognition.
Developmental Psychology and the study of childhood Valerie Walkerdine Introduction Starting point for her critique: developmental psychology produces.
Copyright 2001 by Allyn and Bacon
Developmental Psychology Infancy and Childhood. How do brain and motor skills develop? Good News While in the womb, you produce almost ¼ million brain.
A Constructivistic Approach to Learning William G. Huitt, Ph.D. Valdosta State University Last revised: August 2000.
Cognitive-developmental (Social constructivist)
SOC Lecture 5 Max Weber. Some limits of Marxist historical sociology: -subjective meaning of action -cultural context of meaning Emphasis on structural.
The Synergy of Technology with Basic Learning Theories, Principles and Practices Synergy is compounded words taken from synchronize and energy which can.
Theories of Development. Cognitive Development Early psychologists believed that children were not capable of meaningful thought and that there actions.
Main Branches of Linguistics
Thinking Skills 1 of 23. Why teach thinking skills? Is it really that important? Creative and critical thinking abilities are not inborn as was once believed.
ESP theory & practices Dr. Fengmin Wang Fall 2008.
SOCIALIZING FORCES WORK BEST WHEN THEY ARE IN TUNE WITH INNER MATURATIONAL PRINCIPLES ARNOLD GESELL A CHILD IS THE PRODUCT OF THE ENVIRONMENT... BUT DEVELOPMENT.
Cognitive Development: Piaget’s and Vygotsky’s Theories
His Life His Theory Applications in Education
 Young children view the world very differently from adults.  E.g. no unusual for a child to think the sun follows them.  Field of cognitive psychology.
Cognitive Development
Copyright 2006 Thomson Delmar Learning. All Rights Reserved. Caring for School-Age Children Chapter 5 Development in Middle Childhood: Cognitive.
Lessons Learned What are some bottom lines? 1.There are no absolutes. 2.Cultural influences are complex and dynamic. 3.Free Will is relevant. 4.Attributing.
Lori Decker EDU  Background  Key Ideas  Stages 1-4  Inconsistencies in Stage 4  Metacognition  Universality of Theory  Educational Effects.
Neurological, Physical/Motor Development, and Cognitive Development.
Cognitive Development
Cognitive Reasoning to Respond Affectively to the Student Patrícia A. Jaques Magda Bercht Rosa M. Vicari UNIVERSIDADE FEDERAL DO RIO GRANDE DO SUL BRASIL.
Cognitive Development and Language. Major Questions in Human Development Continuous or discontinuous development? Nature or nurture? Is there one course.
Vygotsky's theory of cognitive development (sociocultural)
Learning, Cognition and Memory EDC 312 Dr. Diane Kern Session 3.
Chapter 7: Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development
Cluster 2 Anita Woolfolk’s Educational Psychology
Chapter 7: Theories of Cognitive Development Module 7.1 Setting the Stage: Piaget’s Theory Module 7.2 Modern Theories of Cognitive Development Module 7.3.
JEAN PIAGET
Cognitive Learning Theories. Jean Piaget The theory of cognitive development, or the development stages theory, as described by Jean Piaget, was first.
Theories of First Language Acquisition
The development of mathematical concepts and language in school Maulfry Worthington.
Sociocultural Theory Week 4, “Sociocultural Approaches to Learning and Development”
Seminar on Theories in Child Development: Overview Dr. K. A. Korb University of Jos.
Is there a link between 'culture' and 'cultured' behaviour? Can 'culture' save the world? Witold Ostafiński PhD.
Lev Vygotsky ( ) Importance of culture and social interaction.
Sociocultural Approach David, Michael, Rachel And Hiu.
Major Theories For Understanding Human Development
 He was born on Friday November 17, 1896 in the city of Orsha, Rusia.  Lev Semenovich Vygotsky ( ) studied at the University of Moscow to become.
Who was Lev S. Vygotsky? Born in the Belarus region of Russia in Family was Jewish. Earned 2 degrees simultaneously from Moscow University: Law and.
Chapter 6: Theories of Cognitive Development. Chapter 6: Theories of Cognitive Development Chapter 6 has three modules: Module 6.1 Setting the Stage:
Jean Piaget, The Man Behind The Moustache - Story of his life - Overview of his theories - Tips for teachers.
Marquita Friend Eled 303 Dr. Kariuki Final Project.
Educational Psychology Ch. 2 Cognitive Development and Language Ashleigh Dunn 03/19/2011.
DEVELOPMENTAL PSYCHOLOGY COGNITIVE DEVELOPMENT KELLY PYZDROWSKI.
Y Letson 2007 (Miell et al 2002) Social Constructivist Approach to Learning.
Vygotsky in the Classroom Cultural-Historical Activity Theory in Teaching. Dr. Natalia Gajdamaschko, October 6, VCC, Vancouver, Canada. Vygotsky 1: Introduction,
Cognitive Development Jen Brace Jean Piaget “Father” of cognitive development Studied his children Jacqueline, Lucienne & Laurent Where does.
HOW CHILDREN LEARN THE SOCIAL CONSTRUCTIVIST LEV VYGOTSKY.
Cognitive Level of Analysis Unit 3. Cognition The mental act or process by which knowledge is acquired.
Get in the Zone Assigned Learning Theorist: Lev Vygotsky Theory: Theory of Social Development ( ) By: Maricela Gonzalez EDTC _Thrs/Prct.
Teaching the Growing Child Assessment 1 Individual Presentation Nicole Cameron.
Piaget’s Psychological Development Piaget ( ) Swiss Psychologist, worked for several decades on understanding children’s cognitive development.
Piaget’s Theory He was a child prodigy who published his first article in a research journal at the age of 11. Jean Piaget ( ) was one of the 20th.
CHAPTER 2 Cognitive development Identify the four factors that, according to Piaget, influence children’s thinking from early childhood to adulthood.
The Importance of Vygotsky on theories of learning in English.
JBCurts/2005 Stages of Cognitive Development Dr. Jaime Curts The University of Texas Pan American Fall 2005.
Piaget’s Cognitive Development Theory. Cognition All the mental activities associated with thinking, knowing, and remembering Children think differently.
Introduction to health psychology
Chapter 7 Cognition.
Education 173 Cognition and Learning in Educational Settings Piaget’s Theory of Cognitive Development Fall Quarter 2007.
What separates humans from animals?
Piaget and Vygotsky.
KNOWLEDGE AND MEANING ARE CONSTRUCTED BY THE INDIVIDUAL
CHAPTER 7 COGNITION.
Sociocultural Theory by Lev Vygotsky
Presentation transcript:

The Epilogue to Developmental Theory

Walkerdine’s Stance “It is perhaps the supreme irony that the concern for individual freedom and the hope of a naturalized rationality that could save mankind should have provided the conditions for the production of a set of apparatuses which would aid in the production of the normalized child… “…It is precisely this and its insertion into a framework of biological capacities which ensures that the child produced as an object of the scientific and pedagogical GAZE by means of the very mechanisms that were intended to produce its liberation. How do we formulate a “liberatory pedagogy” ?

Walkerdine’s Critique Truth claims in developmental psychology not purely objective/ rational Does not adequately account for social domain of development As a theory, it is historically and socially situated: Epistemology does not stand outside such historical conditions (p. 163) Her thesis demonstrates the “inseparability” of scientific truths and conditions of their emergence, development and transformation

Historical Conditions that Produced Developmental Theory & Child Centred Pedagogy Rise of science beginning in 17th century Capitalism supported as alternative to Religion; science promoted as a form of liberation. With Capitalism: Rise of administrative systems - permitted normalization & social regulation Science became tool for normalization: e.g. monitoring behaviour, population statistics, Social Darwinism gains influence Observations become basis for a normative pedagogy Pedagogy normalized to have children learn through observation ( not the pre-conceptions presented in books)

Historical Conditions Continued Assumptions about the “naturalness” of the development of rationality Sought scientific solutions to social problems Child and Mind can also be an “object” of scientific study Regulate development of child to ensure “fitness” as an adult

Outcomes of Piagetian Approach Naturalization of mathematical thinking and scientific concepts as “individual capacities” developing in a “quasi- spontaneous” fashion (given the right environment) Conceptions (e.g. “place value”) treated as properties of mind which “emerge” quasi-spontaneously Monitoring development of learner-concepts rather than teaching facts ‘Medicalization” of developmental differences; Classroom as laboratory, Child as object of the pedagogic GAZE Pedagogic “facts” naturalized and isolated, stripped of context. Pedagogy as normalized and regulated stage-wise progression with understanding as conscripted goal

Questions re: Piaget/Inhelder’s Staged Development Theory Difficulties Piaget (1972) “However, recent research has shown that subjects from other types of schools or different social environments sometimes give results differing more or less from the norms indicated This does not mean that formal structures are exclusively the result of a process of social transmission. “A second interpretation is possible which would take into account the diversification of aptitudes with age, but this would mean excluding certain categories of normal individuals, even in favorable environments, from the possibility of attaining a formal level of thinking.” “In other words, our fourth period can no longer be characterized as a proper stage, but would already seem to be a structural advancement in the direction of specialization. Piaget ( 1972): previous stages of development and order of succession are universal and comparable to embryogenesis although rate of development can vary across individuals pre-operatory: (addition is not reversible) concrete- operations ( e.g classification systems, Montessori Method) What happens after Stage 6: (Formal Operations period between years old )? Mental and psycho-physiological evolution? Difficulties: Piaget (1972) diversification of aptitudes* when generality of cognitive structures already acquired (e.g. some can reason hypothetically)  With language comes formation of symbolic play & internalization of representations

An Alternative… Socio-Cultural Theory :Offers a different explanation for differences. Vygotsky & Mead circa 1930’s REPORT (2005) Developmental Science 8:6 (2005), pp 492–499 One-year-olds comprehend the communicative intentions behind gestures in a hiding game

MEAD & the significance of the “symbolic gesture” To the extent that the animal can take the attitude of the other and utilize that attitude for the control of his own conduct, we have what is termed mind; and that is the only apparatus involved in the appearance of mind. One attains self-consciousness …as he finds himself stimulated to take the attitude of the other. There he is in the position of reacting in himself to that attitude of the other. (p.229) The plant or the lower animal reacts to its environment, but there is no experience of a self "The pre-existence of social processes to the self-conscious individual"

Mead Continued… What is mind? (p.226) "What the human being has succeeded in doing is in [self]-organizing the response to a certain symbol which is a part of a social act so that he takes the attitude of the other person who cooperates with him. It is that which gives him mind” "The relation of the mind and the body is that lying between the organization of the self in its behaviour as a rational member of a rational society and the bodily organism as a physical thing… Gesture as a cooperative, symbolic act: "certain stages in cooperative activities that mediate the whole process... " Different from herd response to signal for danger.....

Joint-Attentional Scenes

SOCIOCULTURAL THEORY IN A NUTSHELL Vera John-Steiner & Holbrook Mahn, 1994 Emphasis on learning as Activity Human activities take place in cultural contexts Emphasize interdependence between social and individual processes Co-construction of knowledge, mediated by language and symbol systems ( semiotic mediation) Activity best understood when understood in historical context