Non-pollutant ecosystem stress impacts on defining a critical load Or why long-term critical loads estimates are likely too high Steven McNulty USDA Forest.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
National Park Service Critical Loads:
Advertisements

WRAP Meeting Nov 11, 2009 Ozone and Nitrogen Concerns in Western National Parks Chris Shaver Air Resources Division National Park Service.
Jeopardy Changing Landscape Using Resources Biodiver- sity Challenges Miscellan- eous Q $100 Q $200 Q $300 Q $400 Q $500 Q $100 Q $200 Q $300 Q $400 Q.
Ecological Perspectives on Critical Loads - Linkages between Biogeochemical Cycles and Ecosystem Change Differences and Similarities in N and S Cycling.
Impacts of Climate Change on Western Forests Dr. Mark Johnston Saskatchewan Research Council and Prairie Adaptation Research Collaborative.
Tonnie Cummings National Park Service, Pacific West Region National Tribal Forum on Air Quality May 14, 2014.
Shenandoah National Park: Critical Load/Target Load Case Study WESTAR November 2005 Tamara Blett- National Park Service Photo credit: University of Virginia.
Locations of Coral Reef Bleaching BLEACHING OF CORAL REEFS BY OCEAN TEMPS > 85deg F (29 deg C)
Estimating c ritical acid loads across the lower 48 US: Opportunities and challenges Steven McNulty USDA Forest Service Southern Research Station Raleigh,
Forest Health Review Committee Prince George, BC January 30, 2008 Canadian Forest Service Forest Health Activities.
Premise Three Basic Forms of Uncertainty - Level of Change - Process Impacts - Time and Space 1.
Critical Load Development for Nitrogen and Sulfur Deposition Elizabeth Waddell Air Resources Specialist Pacific West Region
The Effects of Nitrogen Fertilization on Nutrient Cycling and Forest Productivity By: Eric Sucre.
Acid Deposition—Ch 17.
Global Environmental Issues
Describe how environmental change can impact ecosystem stability.
Ecology.
EFIMOD – a system of models for Forest Management A.S. Komarov, A.V. Mikhailov, S.S. Bykhovets, M.V.Bobrovsky, E.V.Zubkova Institute of Physicochemical.
Tuesday 11:00 – 1:50 Thursday 11:00 – 1:50 Instructor: Nancy Wheat Ecology Bio 47 Spring 2015.
Any harmful substances that can buildup in the air to unhealthy levels
What is Human Impact?.
LBG/LB 1 Working Group on Effects, ICPM&M-Coordination Center for Effects, J.-P.Hettelingh, Gothenburg, October 2004 New developments on air pollution.
Acid Deposition
Acid Rain By: Hessa Boodai. Causes It causes 3 different things 1- Cars 2- Factories 3- Pollution.
Malé Declaration 1 ST emissions inventory workshop AIT, Bangkok, 3rd – 5th July 2006 Part 1 – The air pollution problem and the need for emissions inventories.
Ecological Succession Objectives 1.Explain what succession is 2.Explain the process of ecological succession 3.Explain the role that plants play in maintaining.
Critical Loads and Target Loads: Tools for Assessing, Evaluating and Protecting Natural Resources Ellen Porter Deborah Potter, Ph.D. National Park Service.
Environmental Science: Toward a Sustainable Future Richard T. Wright Atmospheric Pollution PPT by Clark E. Adams Chapter 21.
International and National Abatement Strategies for Transboundary air Pollution New concepts and methods for effect-based strategies on transboundary air.
Ecological Succession.  Ecological succession is the observed process of change in the species structure of an ecological community over time.
Winter Soil Respiration Near Dead and Living Lodgepole Pines at Niwot Ridge, CO Justin D’Atri Winter Ecology Spring 2010 Mountain Research Station – University.
Eric A. Graham UCLA Department of Ecology and Evolutionary Biology Ecological Applications of CENS Technologies at the James Reserve Summer interns: Caitlin.
1 Introduction: What Is Ecology ? Chapter 1. 2 Outline Overview of Ecology Ecology of Forest Birds Ecology of Bumblebees Forest Nutrient Budgets Vegetation.
1. The Study of Excess Nitrogen in the Neuse River Basin “A Landscape Level Analysis of Potential Excess Nitrogen in East-Central North Carolina, USA”
Air Pollution What controls the level? –Amount of pollutants entering the air. –Amount of space into which the pollutants are dispersed. –Mechanisms that.
Lesson 1: Introduction to Ecosystems The Spheres of the Earth.
Scientific Plan Introduction –History of LBA Background –Definition of Amazon –7 Themes with achievements Motivation for Phase II –Unresolved questions.
The role of climate in sugar maple health: Historical relationships and future projections.
Relationships Among Stressors, Forests, and Aquatic Systems *As Number and Severity of Stressors Increase, The Impacts to Forests and Associated Aquatic.
A Practical Approach: The General Physico-Chemical Quality Elements and the Classification of Ecological Status.
Population Ecology Mrs. Gamari. Ecology  The study of the interaction between organisms and their environment (living and non-living).  Biotic – living.
 Human use of ecosystems:  Humans have decreased biodiversity of ecosystems at a very fast rate.
Breakout Group 6 Ocean and Atmosphere Group Terrestrial Group.
2017 EEA report “Climate change adaptation and disaster risk reduction in Europe - Synergies for the knowledge base and policies” Rob Swart, Koen Kramer,
Global Issues Biology CH 6.
Acid Deposition What is Acid Deposition? Primary pollutants such as sulfur dioxide (SO 2 )from factories and nitrogen oxides (NO x ) from.
Materials: LI-COR LAI-2200 Plant Canopy Analyzer FV2200 software Excel Rstudio Methods and Study Site: LAI measurements using an indirect, optical method.
Alejandro Gallego Schmid Department of Chemical Engineering University of Santiago de Compostela (Spain) Boston, 30 th September 2009 Calculation of LCA.
Informed NPS Air Quality Management Decisions in Response to a Changing Climate.
Ecological Terminology Niche = the role of the species in a specific area Niche = the role of the species in a specific area.
FOREST DISEASES AND FOREST HEALTH ESRM 101 Spring 2007 Bob Edmonds 264 Bloedel
Changes Over Time Ecological Succession – natural changes and species replacements in communities of an ecosystem Occurs in stages as different species.
Rose Flores University of Houston – Downtown Biology 1312.
Bell Work Define what you think an indicator is.
AIR POLLUTION AND FOREST HEALTH ESRM 101 Spring 2007 Bob Edmonds
Abiotic and Biotic Factors
Abiotic and Biotic Factors
Biodiversity The variety of life in an area that is affected by abiotic and biotic conditions.
Biodiversity SNC1P1 Findlay.
1. The Study of Excess Nitrogen in the Neuse River Basin
Acid Precipitation.
Define: Community, Ecosystem, Biome
Effects of Ozone on Forests
HUMAN IMPACTS on ECOSYSTEMS
Earth: A Living Planet Ecology
Chapter 4 Population Ecology
CHAPTER 1 INTRODUCTION.
Forest health and global change
Ecosystem Services.
Presentation transcript:

Non-pollutant ecosystem stress impacts on defining a critical load Or why long-term critical loads estimates are likely too high Steven McNulty USDA Forest Service Raleigh, NC

When pollutant loads exceed the critical load it is considered that there is risk of harmful effects. The excess over the critical load has been termed the exceedance. A larger exceedance is often considered to pose a greater risk of damage. UK Centre for Ecology and Hydrology Standard definition of a critical load A critical load can be defined as a quantitative estimate of an exposure to one or more pollutants below which significant harmful effects on specified sensitive elements of the environment do not occur according to present knowledge. Examples of Critical Load Variables Nitrogen dioxide (NO x ) Ammonia (NH 3 ) Sulfur dioxide (SO 2 ) Ozone (O 3 )

Estimates of Critical Loads Based on Direct Ecosystem Impacts N & S Deposition Stream acidification - loss of aquatic biodiversity Soil Acidification - forest mortality - nitrate leaching - reduced biological diversity Episodic Ozone - reduced forest productivity - impaired human health

There are well established relationships between the exceedance of a critical load, and ecosystem degradation. However, what about the ecological interaction between critical load pollutants and other non-pollutant environmental stresses? Could other environmental stresses either increase or decrease an ecosystems sensitivity to other critical loads? The Problem

Non-Critical Load Environmental Stresses - Insects (native and invasive) - Disease - Fire - Drought - Flood - Wind - Extreme Temperature (hot and cold) - Poor Ecosystem Management

How do these environmental stresses impact ecosystem critical load thresholds? A Case Study

The loss of the southern red spruce and white pine forest

Western NC experienced a moderate three year drought from In 2001, white pine and spruce trees began to die in large numbers in and around the Ashville NC area. The initial evidence suggested that the affected trees were killed by the southern pine beetle (SPB). This insect species is not normally successful at colonizing these tree species. Subsequent investigations revealed that only the larger and more vigorously growing trees were killed by the SPB. Background

Southern Pine Beetle Induced White Pine Mortality Near Asheville, NC

Southern Pine Beetle Damage in Southern Appalachian Red Spruce Stand

Questions What conditions allowed the red spruce and white pine trees to be colonized? Why did only the larger, more vigorous trees die?

The ratio between above ground growth (i.e., stem wood, branches and foliage) and below ground growth (i.e. coarse and fine roots) increased Hypothesis for mortality The area in and around Asheville received elevated nitrogen deposition, but these levels are below that considered “critical loads” The increased level of nitrogen inputs likely had a fertilization impact

The lack of oleoresin (especially in large trees) allowed for the colonization of and large scale forest mortality witnessed during that time. Hypothesis for mortality (cont.) The drought conditions reduced available water, carbohydrate reserves for the production of secondary carbon compounds such as oleoresin. The larger more vigorously growing trees had a higher AG/BG ratio than the small trees

Stress interactions Forest Mortality Elevated nitrogen deposition Causing altered tree physiology Drought Reducing carbohydrate reserves Insects Causing tree mortality through colonization and tree girdling by larval feeding

If any one of the three environmental stresses were removed, the mortality would not likely have occurred.

How a different critical nitrogen load could be determined within the same ecosystem N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr N leaching = 0 Mortality = 0% Critical N > 10 kg Load N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr N leaching = 1 Mortality = 10% Critical = 10 kg Load + 3 yr Drought Stress N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr N leaching = 15 Mortality = 75% Critical = 8 kg Load + 3 yr Drought Stress + insects N dep = 10 kg/ha/yr N leaching = 25 Mortality = 100% Critical < 5 kg Load + 3 yr Drought Stress + insects S dep = 10 kg/ha/yr

Revised critical loads model that includes other environmental factors Critical Load Ecosystem structure and function Abiotic StressBiotic Stress

Implications - There should be no single set of environmental criteria determining the critical load - By definition a critical load can change over both space and time - Computer models will be the only viable method of calculating critical load over a wide range of environmental stresses and ecosystems - An a priori approach to field monitoring will be required to develop and test critical load models

Benefits Well validated critical load models would be temporally and spatially dynamic Alternative management and pollutant scenarios could be conducted on at the ecosystem level to determine when or if critical load levels would be exceeded The use of standardized models would lead to more standardized assessments of critical load levels