School systems, segregation and civic competence Germ Janmaat LLAKES International Conference, Birkbeck, London 5-6 July 2010.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Early Childhood Education and Care in Europe: Tackling Social and Cultural Inequalities Early Childhood Education and Care in Europe: Tackling Social and.

Advertisements

OECD Thematic Review on Migrant Education: Progress Reporting The OECD Migrant Education Review Team 13 October nd Meeting of the Group of National.

Measuring Civic Competence Across Europe: A Complex Picture Bryony Hoskins European Commission Centre for Research on Lifelong Learning (CRELL)

The enSI international NETWORK Environment and School Initiatives is a decentralised international network set up in 1986 under the umbrella of OECD's.

Planning for Teaching. Planning -Coherence -Curriculum -Schemes of work -Lesson plans -Aims and objectives -Selection and Structuring of Subject Matter.

Biodegradable Municipal Waste Management in Europe Gerry Carty The Parliamentary Sustainable Waste Group and Environmental Services Association 28th January.

24 July 2014 PISA 2012 Financial Literacy results – New Zealand in an international context.

What is the degree of your global awareness?

What is PIAAC?. About PIAAC PIAAC is an international large-scale assessment administered in in 23 countries It assessed 16 - to 65-year-olds,

A PRACTICAL GUIDE to accelerating student achievement across cultures

MIGRANTS’ POLITICAL PARTICIPATION IN COMPARATIVE PERSPECTIVE: THE LOCALMULTIDEM PROJECT Dr. Laura Morales (University of Murcia & University of Manchester)

OECD Programme for International Student Assessment (PISA)

ICCS European Regional Report National Coordinators Meeting Madrid February 2010.

Outline of International Report on ICCS National Research Coordinators Meeting Madrid, February 2010.

WHAT DO WE KNOW ABOUT SOCIAL INCLUSION?. SOCIAL INCLUSION Social inclusion is a process which ensures that those at risk of poverty and social exclusion.

1 Israel and the OECD A Comparison Based on The Herzliya Indices Approach Presented by Dr. Zalman Shiffer The Herzliya Indices Team Herzliya Conference.

Intergenerational contributions to childcare across Europe Alison Smith University of Edinburgh.

The Work of the European Agency and a European Perspective on Inclusive Education Cor Meijer (PhD), director

Poverty & Human Capability 101 Introductory Class.

PIAAC: ORIGINS, INTERNATIONAL DIMENSION, CONCEPTS AND AIMS William Thorn, OECD

Plan Challenge of studying other education systems The strengths of London schools The underlying problems of the English system Some comparative data.

1. Measuring the Impact of Universal Preschool Education and Care on Literacy Performance Scores. Tarek Mostafa Institute of Education – University of.

A Reconsideration of the “New Gender Gap” in Civic Education and the Implications for Classrooms Kerry J Kennedy The Hong Kong Institute of Education “Making.

New Skills for New Jobs: Action Now Professor Mike Campbell OBE Director of Research and Policy ETUC Conference International Trade Union House, Brussels.

Raising the Quality of Educational Outcomes and Improving E-learning: Cross-national Evidence on Challenges and Opportunities Judit Kádár-Fülöp Indicators.

National Contexts Survey Progress Report National Research Coordinators Meeting Windsor, June 2008.

Improving School Leadership 1 st Workshop of Participating Countries Beatriz Pont Education and Training Policy Division Workshop of National Coordinators.

N° EAC/23/2010 Study on educational support for newly arrived migrant children SIRIUS Stakeholder meeting 13 September, Brussels Hanna Siarova, PPMI.

Overview Report 11 Cities: Antwerp, Amsterdam, Berlin, Copenhagen, Hamburg, Leicester, London, Marseille, Paris, Rotterdam, Stockholm 2199 interviews:

Civic and Citizenship Education in Times of Change: Curriculum and its Implementation Some Results of the IEA Studies Civic Education in Iraq: Study Tour.

Housing markets and ethnic segregation in the Nordic countries Hans Skifter Andersen Affiliated professor Danish Building Research Institute at Aalborg.

Key Findings of the OECD Policy Review of Migrant Education and Implications for Language Education Policy for Immigrant Children Miho Taguma Project Manager.

A focus on student outcomes Key influences on enhancing student outcomes System wide lasting and deep change Knowledge and understanding Capacity and.

Summer School on Migration and Integration České Budějovice, September 1-6, 2013 Michal Vašečka Masaryk University, Brno.

Proposed US Graduate Study Program in New Zealand Introduction The focus of New Zealand education development is to ensure school students achieve as.

The IEA Civic Education Study as a Source for Indicators of Civic Life Skills Judith Torney-Purta Carolyn Barber Gary Homana Britt Wilkenfeld University.

Impact of civic & cultural education on social cohesion Bryony Hoskins, LLAKES, Institute of Education, University of London.

Countries of Europe France Spain Italy Germany Which country is this?

Cross-national attitudinal research

OECD Thematic Review on Migrant Education Claire Shewbridge 12 May 2009.

Germ Janmaat, Institute of Education, LLAKES Second International Conference London, October 2012 Educational Differentiation.

Israel Accession Seminar PIAAC: Programme for International assessment of Adult Competencies Skills strategy in OECD Programme for the International Assessment.

Creating Effective Teaching and Learning Environments OECD Teaching and Learning International Study (TALIS) Teacher evaluation Evidence from TALIS OECD.

The socio-economic gradient in teenagers’ reading skills: how does England compare to other countries? John Jerrim, Institute of Education 1.

Just world? The impact of young peoples’ perceptions of social inequalities in education on the learning of active citizenship Bryony Hoskins and John.

School leadership matters in OECD countries Beatriz Pont Education and Training Policy Division OECD Education Directorate International Conference School.

Image: dan / FreeDigitalPhotos.net Deborah Nusche Early Childhood and Schools Division Directorate for Education, OECD Education for Innovative Societies,

Comparing Britain with other nations: problems of measuring if and how we differ Roger Jowell, City University Director, European Social Survey Gresham.

Northern Europe Label the following countries on the next page, using the color each countries is labeled in, then add capitals to each country using a.

NUMERACY “Well hey that’s just knowing numbers right.” NOT EXACTLY.

Comments on: ”Educating Children of Immigrants: Closing the Gap in Norwegian Schools” The Nordic Economic Policy Review Conference 2011 Lena Nekby Department.

1 Researchers : 10 altogether; 3 from Denmark, 2 from Finland, 2 from Norway, and 3 from Sweden. Scientific board: professor Antero Malin, Finland (project.

C2ME Main findings Jeanine Suurmond, AMC, dept of Public Health, Project leader C2ME 18 September 2015 ‘Culturally Competent In Medical Education’ Amsterdam.

Civic-Related and Social Outcomes of Schooling: Insights from Large-Scale International Assessments Prof. dr. Judith Torney-Purta Human Development University.

IEA International Civic and Citizenship Education Study (ICCS) 2009 in European Countries The International Association for the Evaluation of Educational.

Challenge Your Mind…Build Your Faith A Dissertation Presented to The Faculty of the School of Education Liberty University Joseph F. Fontanella February.

International treaties with relevance to education Universal Declaration of Human Rights Free elementary education International Covenant on Economic,

1 Perspectives on the Achievements of Irish 15-Year-Olds in the OECD PISA Assessment

1 Main achievement outcomes continued.... Performance on mathematics and reading (minor domains) in PISA 2006, including performance by gender Performance.

Southern Illinois University Edwardsville,

What is PIAAC?.

TUC Conference The future of our schools 27th November 2010

School segregation and the performance of immigrant and native pupils

Countries and Capitals of Western Europe

SICI working group SICI-SOE SOCIAL OUTCOMES in EDUCATION

Jenny Bradshaw NCETM National CPD Conference 23rd March 2011

Key Findings of the OECD Policy Review of Migrant Education and

EU: First- & Second-Generation Immigrants

The Gini index is a measure of income inequality — the higher the coefficient, the greater the inequality. Among the select OECD countries,1 Canada has.

Civics for common values George Psacharopoulos

Presentation transcript:

School systems, segregation and civic competence Germ Janmaat LLAKES International Conference, Birkbeck, London 5-6 July 2010

Research questions What are the links between ability grouping, segregation and civic competences? Is ability grouping associated with greater disparities of civic competences? Is ability grouping associated with high levels of social and ethnic school segregation? Is ability grouping intensifying the effect of school social and ethnic composition on civic competences?

Why these research questions? Academia has disregarded disparities of civic competences; yet these are likely to be of interest for policy makers; Ability grouping may enhance disparities of civic competences across schools through curriculum differences and different teacher expectations; Ability grouping has been linked with social and ethnic segregation because of the close relation between social and ethnic background and achievement; In countries with the highest level of school social segregation the effect of social composition on achievement is greatest (OECD 2002; Green et al 2006) But does the latter also apply for civic competences?

What are civic competences? A comprehensive, multidimensional collection of qualities consisting of: -Civic knowledge and skills (cognitive component) -Civic attitudes (normative component) -Participation (behavioural component) Are attitudes and participation responding in the same way to school conditions as knowledge and skills?

Data sources Data: Green et al’s (2006) classification of countries regarding grouping by ability in lower secondary (LS): - Nordic states: full comprehensive systems with strict mixed ability classes; - Southern Europe: centralised comprehensive systems with some streaming; - English-speaking states: incomplete comprehensive system with widespread streaming and setting; - the “German”-speaking states: early selection systems with stratified LS schools IEA Civic Education Study (1999) to explore civic competences Analysis on 13 states Methods: Multilevel analysis with cross-level interaction effects

Civic competence outcomes Four outcomes: Cognitive component: -Civic knowledge and skills (scale based on 38 test items) Normative component: -Interpersonal trust (single item tapping trust in compatriots) -Ethnic tolerance(scale based on 5 items on immigrants) Behavioural component: -Civic participation(composite index based on 15 items on participation in various organizations)

Methods Intra Class Correlation coefficient to assess disparities of civic competences and levels of social and ethnic segregation Multilevel analysis using SPSS mixed methods option to assess individual and classroom effects

Results 1: Cross classroom disparities in civic competences (ICCs) Full comprehensive CentralizedIncomplete comprehensive Early selection Civic knowledge and skills Ethnic tolerance Civic participation Interpersonal trust

Results 2: Classroom social and ethnic segregation Social segregation: (ICC) Ethnic segregation: (ICC) Denmark.05 Finland Norway Sweden Full comprehensive Greece.10-* Italy Portugal.20-* Centralized Australia England United States Incomplete comprehensive Belgium (French) Germany Switzerland Early selection.19.11

Results 3: Effects of classroom social and ethnic composition on civic competences (controlling for other individual and classroom level effects) Civic knowledge and skills Ethnic tolerance Trust in compatriots Civic participation Full comprSocial composition -++ Ethnic composition CentralizedSocial composition ++-- Ethnic composition -- IncompleteSocial composition ++-+ Ethnic composition + Early selection Social composition Ethnic composition ++

Conclusions Results are as expected for social segregation and civic knowledge and skills (CKS): the more grouping by ability, the more segregation, the greater the disparities of CKS and the greater the effect of social composition on CKS Results are not in line with expectation for ethnic segregation and the attitudinal and behavioural component of civic competences. Why not? – Ethnic segregation may depend more on residential segregation in combination with strict catchment areas; – Pupils in lower status tracks may be unaware of the disadvantaged position they find themselves in; by contrast pupils in mixed ability classes may be much more aware of inequalities; One thing is certain: civic competences are a diverse set of qualities