© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Public Policy for Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital March 6, 2012 Turning Research into.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

1 Doingbusiness in 2006 Creating Jobs Simeon Djankov Manager, Doing Business Project, World Bank September 15, 2005 Belgrade.

Advertisements

Lisbon - Copenhagen - Maastricht Consortium December 2004 Tom Leney VET – Challenges and research agendas.

International Tax Reform Prepared for SIEPR-TPC Tax Reform Conference Rosanne Altshuler January 18, 2013.

OPEN FOR BUSINESS An introduction to New Zealand August 2014.

Doing Business in the Middle East and North Africa – with particular reference to Iraq Baghdad 12 November Presentation to Iraq Private Sector Development.

Policy Implications for Iceland Melissa Johns Investment Policy Specialist, World Bank November 21, 2006 Doing Business 2007: How to reform.

Reversing Offshore Economics and Improving Financial Regulation: Curtailing Illicit Financial Flows Petr Janský Economist and Consultant Charles University.

Chapter 1 The Pay Model.

1 1 Mierta Capaul, World Bank Group December 8, 2007 Semiramis Intercontinental Hotel, Cairo.

INVESTMENT CLIMATE IN LITHUANIA

Dr. Eli Opper – Chief Scientist Ministry of Industry, Trade and Labor Early Stage Financing Strategies for High Tech in Israel January 2005.

Doing Business in Poland Warsaw October 20, 2011 Marcin Piątkowski Senior Economist.

1 “European R&D Benchmarking (2002) “European R&D Benchmarking (2002)” Science, Technology and Innovation Policy Student Presentations Students: Miguel.

Introduction to International Trade

Hunter centre for strathclyde Global Entrepreneurship Monitor Scotland 2002 Jonathan Levie Wendy Brown Laura Galloway.

“Business Angel investing across Europe” Angel Prieto General Manager of GOBAN – B.A.N. of Castilla La Mancha, Spain Member of EBAN EBAN - The European.

Starting a business in Madagascar

Financial & Private Sector Development 1 Doing Business in Poland Warsaw, Poland November 4, 2010 Marcin Piątkowski Senior Economist.

Click to edit Master title style Doing Business in Veneto 2009 Michael Klein Vice President - Financial and Private Sector Development, World Bank-IFC,

DOING BUSINESS IN ITALY 2013 Smarter Regulations for Small and Medium-sized Enterprises Rome, Italy - November 14, 2012 Augusto Lopez-Claros Director,

1 Doing Business 2010: Poland Neil Gregory Advisor and Acting Director Financial & Private Sector Development Krakow, Poland September 9, 2009.

August 18, 2009 International Lessons For Broadband Policy Presentation at the FCC Broadband Policy Workshop Dr. Robert Atkinson President Information.

Doing Business 2007 How to reform Sept 5 th 2006 Caralee McLiesh World Bank.

Sarajevo October 20 th, 2011 Doing Business in Bosnia and Herzegovina Iva Hamel Private Sector Development Specialist, Indicator Based Reform Advisory,

Enabling Environments for Successful Contract Farming Carlos Arthur B. da Silva, Ph.D. Rural Infrastructure and Agro-Industries Division FAO - Rome.

The Global Economic Environment

The Wealth of Nations Predicting Economic Growth.

BellRinger 3/23/ What do you think is the richest country in the world today? 2.How do you think economists should measure a country’s wealth? We.

1 ECONOMICS 3150M Winter 2014 Professor Lazar Office: N205J, Schulich

The Future of the Global Economy Augusto López-Claros, Ph.D. International Environment Forum Brighton, United Kingdom December 18, 2010.

Innovation Processes in Transition; SMEs by Erkki Ormala Professor of Innovation Management Aalto University, Business School.

The business environment in the Czech Republic Viktorie Klímová

OECD Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development Organisation and Content Overview.

Click to edit Master title style Doing Business 2009 in East Asia and the Pacific Presented by Rita Ramalho.

1 ECONOMICS 3150B Fall 2015 Professor Lazar Office: N205J, Schulich

Can we help? the impact on entrepreneurial performance of publicly funded business advisory services. Eileen Fischer Schulich School of Business York University.

Financial & Private Sector Development 1 Doing Business in Tajikistan Dushanbe, Tajikistan November 15, 2010 Andrea Dall’Olio Senior Economist, Finance.

The Global Economic Environment The Coming Boom Wealthy Industrial Countries Developing Countries East Asia South Asia Latin America

The Impact of the Global Crisis on SME and Entrepreneurship Financing Pier Carlo Padoan OECD Deputy-Secretary General Urbino, 21 April

Bygrave & Zacharakis, Entrepreneurship, New York: Wiley. © Chapter 1 The Power of Entrepreneurship.

Doing Business 2008 in CROATIA Presented by Michael U. Klein Vice President, The World Bank & Chief Economist, IFC.

Financial & Private Sector Development …… ……. Arusha, Tanzania August 17, 2011 Doing Business in The East African Community 2011.

Why Are Some Nations Wealthy?

International Comparison of Health Care Gene Chang.

Levels of Economic Development Levels of economic development are measured in goods and services available in a country.

Sofia, March 25, 2003 BULGARIA, BRITAIN AND THE LISBON AGENDA: STRATEGIES FOR RAISING EMPLOYMENT AND PRODUCTIVITY.

Doing Business 2007 How to reform Private Sector Development in Small States Michael Klein Vice President, Financial and Private Sector Development and.

The United States The Economy. What is GDP ? Gross Domestic Product (GDP): The total market (or dollar) value of all final goods and services produced.

Overview of the Singapore Economy 2000 –GDP = US$92 bil (0.9% of US economy) –Per Capita GNP = US$24,700 (ranked 19th in the world)

The Euro Area Crisis: Origins, Prospects and Implications for the World Economy and Global Governance Domenico Lombardi UNLV, April 3, 2013.

J LYONS MARKETING Tech Scout for New Technology. J LYONS MARKETING STARTED AS MANUFACTURERS REPRESENTATIVE DESIGN IN NEW TECHNOLOGY AT SENIOR LEVEL FIRST.

1 1 Environmental Performance Reviews OECD ENVIRONMENTAL PERFORMANCE REVIEWS FOCUS ON THE SECOND CYCLE Christian Avérous World Bank, Washington 18 January.

C E N T R A L B A N K O F C H I L E DECEMBER 2010 Progress status of the Quarterly Institutional Accounts project OECD Working Party on Financial Statistics.

Click to edit Master title style Doing Business 2009.

© Cumming & Johan (2013) Institutional Context and Empirical Methods Institutional Contexts and Empirical Methods Cumming & Johan (2013, Chapter 3) 1.

OPEN FOR BUSINESS An introduction to New Zealand August 2014.

6. Ráðstefnan um rannsóknir á íslensku þjóðfélagi Háskólanum á Akureyri, 20. – 21. apríl 2012 The Nordic Countries in an International Comparison Helga.

Tax Policy Challenges in a Changing World. Unintended Consequences of Tax Rob Marston, “Window Tax”, 1 September 2010 uploaded via Flickr, creative commons.

Lecturer: Jack Wu 吳文傑 Taiwan Economy Lecturer: Jack Wu 吳文傑.

Russia for investors: the key points 2016.

Simeon Djankov, Chief Economist

How Canada Compares Internationally

Doing Business indicators

Glenda Napier Global Venture Capital Markets and the Policy Challenges IKED/INSME International Roundtable, February 26, 2004.

The first year of improvements: Can it become a new trend?

LECTURER: JACK WU 吳文傑 Taiwan Economy LECTURER: JACK WU 吳文傑.

Taiwan Economic Development

Taiwan Economic Development

2006 Rank Adjusted for Purchasing Power

Presentation transcript:

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Public Policy for Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital March 6, 2012 Turning Research into Action: Symposium of Ontario Research Chairs in Public Policy Panelists: Bogdan Buduru Senior Economist, Industry Canada Douglas Cumming Professor and Ontario Research Chair Schulich School of Business, York University Maxx-Phillippe Hollott Manager, Access to Capital Secretariat Ontario Ministry of Economic Development and Innovation Jim Pullen Partner, Concert Partners 1

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Ontario versus Peers: GDP Per Capita Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion GDP / Capita Venture Capital / Capita 2 US $47,482 California $51,914 New York $57,423 Massachusetts $58,108 Canada $47,605 Quebec $40,394 Ontario $46,303 Alberta $70,826

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Ontario versus Peers: Venture Capital / GDP Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion GDP / Capita Venture Capital / Capita Investments for Funds Focused in Seed, Early Stage and Expansion Stages in Canada by Province, 2004 – 2008 This figure summarizes investments per GDP for funds focused at the seed, early and expansion stage investments relative to GDP by all types of investors for all industries in select US states and Canadian provinces, January 2004 – December Data source: Thompson Financial SDC VentureXpert.

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital VC / GDP: Ontario versus Massachusetts Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion GDP / Capita Venture Capital / Capita 12.8 times the amount of new capital commitments to newly established VC funds in Massachusetts on a per GDP basis than Ontario. Required an additional $37.5 billion of new capital committed for Ontario to be at the level of VC per GDP that is comparable to Massachusetts-based VC funds.

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital R&D / GDP – Access to Capital Essential Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion R&D / GDP – Access to Capital Essential Gazelles – Access to Capital Essential Correlation (Access to Venture Capital, R&D/Capita) = 0.39 Correlation (Access to Bank Capital, R&D/Capita) = 0.26 Slovak Republic Poland TurkeyHungary Italy Spain Czech Republic Portugal Ireland Luxembourg Norway Netherlands Canada UK Belgium France Australia Austria USA Iceland

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Canada is Behind in Share of Gazelles - Access of Capital Essential Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion R&D / GDP – Access to Capital Essential Gazelles – Access to Capital Essential Canada ranks 24 th in the World in Access to Capital Behind peers: Australia, New Zealand, US, UK, Ireland, etc

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Types of Policy Responses Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion 1.Legal / Regulatory / Tax 2.Government Venture Capital Funds 3.Innovation Centers 1.Legal / Regulatory / Tax 2.Government Venture Capital Funds 3.Innovation Centers

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital World Bank Doing Business Reports: Country Rankings Economy Ease of Doing Business Rank Starting a Business Dealing with Constructio n Permits Getting Electricity Registering Property Getting Credit Protecting Investors Paying Taxes Trading Across Borders Enforcing Contracts Resolving Insolvency Singapore Hong Kong SAR, China New Zealand United States Denmark Norway United Kingdom Korea, Rep Iceland Ireland Finland Saudi Arabia Canada Legal / Regulatory / Tax 2.Government Venture Capital Funds 3.Innovation Centers Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital 2. Government Venture Capital Funds Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion 1.Legal / Regulatory / Tax 2.Government Venture Capital Funds 3.Innovation Centers LSVCCs became dominant with massive tax breaks, not performance (next slide) Sources: Cumming and MacIntosh, 2006, 2007; Cumming and Johan, 2009.

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital 2. Government Venture Capital Funds Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion 1.Legal / Regulatory / Tax 2.Government Venture Capital Funds 3.Innovation Centers LSVCC tax incentives in Ontario phased out in This figure helped push us in the right direction! Sources: Cumming and MacIntosh, 2006, 2007; Cumming and Johan, 2009.

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital 3. Innovation Centers Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion 1.Legal / Regulatory / Tax 2.Government Venture Capital Funds 3.Innovation Centers Centers like the Investment Network of the Innovation Synergy Center, Markam (now “ventureLab”), facilitate strong entrepreneurial outcomes – $6,545,000 in financing, while the program costs were totaled at $662,360, thereby giving a ratio of financing raised per dollar of cost at only $0.10. Empirical evidence needs to control for endogeneity and selection effects. – Cumming and Fischer (2012 Research Policy) – Causal relation between mentor hours and sales and angel capital – Correlation, not causation, between mentor hours and patents and alliances

© Douglas Cumming (2012)Entrepreneurship and Venture Capital Sampling of Topics for Discussion Ontario and Canada are Behind Sources of Canadian Inefficiency Policy Remedies Topics for Discussion Which polices best stimulate gazelle entrepreneurs and more R&D in Canada so that we can catch up to competing jurisdictions? How successful should will the Ontario Venture Capital Fund (OVCF) be, as well as companion programs such as the OETF and IAF? Should Ontario provide tax breaks to large companies to invest in venture capital funds? – Should Ontario provide tax breaks to top tier venture capital funds? – Lower tax rates overall for everyone? Or capital gains tax rates? How to best design programs like the Investment Network at the Innovation Synergy Center, Markham (now “ventureLab”)? How much funding to allocate to early stage programs relative to others?