Making Change Karin Hohman R.N., MBA Strategic Health Concepts Stick
What is Policy, System, and Environmental change (aka = PSE) What works in cancer control PSE approaches Ways to work together to make PSE changes stick Overview
“It is unreasonable to expect that people will change their behavior easily when so many forces in the social, cultural, and physical environment conspire against such change” The problem… Smedley and Syme, 2000
…forces conspiring against change WorksitesSchoolsMediaHealth Care Restaurants and Shops Communities
Can we change policies, systems, and the environment to support healthy choices? WorksitesSchoolsMediaHealth Care Restaurants and Shops Communities
Policies - rules that encourage or discourage certain behavior System changes – changes in how things are done in an organization or setting Environmental changes – changes in places we work, play, shop, go to school Policies, systems and the environment around us
Effort is ongoing – not episodic with a start and end Supports a population behavior change – not a 1:1 approach Usually lower in cost with a high impact Change is built to last– it sticks Strengths of policy, system and environmental changes
PSE Change Establish a safe community use fishing pond In other words….
PSE simplified PUT UP a BARRIER to make something harder to do REMOVE a BARRIER to make something easier to do OR
Increase the tobacco tax Create a policy that pop or candy is not available for purchase in schools Restrict ages that can utilize tanning beds Create a system where you must record cancer screening test history in an electronic medical record Ways to PUT UP a barrier
Employers offer reduced gym memberships Establish a community farmers market for fresh produce Institute a patient navigation program Set up a physician office reminder system Ways to REMOVE a barrier
How is PSE different? Events Policy, Systems and Environmental Change Display posters during National Nutrition Month Add more / different fruits & vegetables to cafeteria choices Open the school gym during a community fair Develop a shared use agreement with the school Promote “Bike to Work” Day Provide secure bike parking areas and showers Provide a healthy lunch at a work meeting Adopt a healthy food meeting policy Sponsor a screening fair at work Allow time off every year for employees to get screened Adapted from ‘Understanding Policy, Systems, and Environmental Change to Improve Health’. Presentation by Brooke Ahlquist, MA, MPH
The full continuum of cancer…Prevention, Early Detection, Diagnosis and Treatment, Quality of Life, Survivorship to End of Life Pretty much any setting…schools, work, communities, home, businesses, health care clinics, hospitals Where do PSE change approaches work best?
The most effective approach is a comprehensive approach CommunityWorksitesSchoolsMediaHealth Care Restaurants and Shops Government
CommunityWorksitesSchoolsMediaHealth Care Restaurants and Shops Government Reduce tobacco use = a comprehensive approach
Reduce tobacco use initiation and current use Policy Change – Raise the cost of tobacco by 10% and adolescent tobacco use drops by 3.7 %
Reduce exposure to second hand smoke Policy Change Restrict by law where people can smoke and voluntary restrictions in places such as cars and homes
Decrease obesity rates = a comprehensive approach CommunityWorksitesSchoolsMediaHealth Care Restaurants and Shops
Promote and increase access to active transportation Environmental Change Encourage and enable biking/walking to a destination
Increase access and availability of healthy foods and beverages Environmental Change Make it easier at work, school and events to get healthy foods and beverages And harder to get less healthy options
Increase use of food from local farms Environmental Change Support local farmers by promoting fresh, local foods
Increase access to physical activity opportunities Environmental Change Develop, clean up and promote trails, fitness centers, community centers, and playgrounds
Increase cancer screening rates = a comprehensive approach AppropriateAccessibleAvailableAcceptableAffordable
System Change – Change hours of service, offer screening in other settings, offer transportation and child care, simplify paperwork Make screening more convenient
Policy change Reduce costs through a variety of approaches: increase awareness of benefits, issue vouchers, increase employee benefits Reduce costs for screening
System Changes Patient Reminders Provider Reminders Use reminder systems
System Change 1 on 1 support to help navigate the patient through their cancer treatment process Provide patient navigation
Policy Change Advocate for insurance coverage for clinical trials Increase access to treatment
Systems change – Increase the number of physicians and nurses who are board certified in palliative care Assure palliative care services
System and policy changes Increase the number cancer centers that work with patients to develop survivorship care plans Support cancer survivors
Start with what works and build on that Make one change, even if it is small Get the right people at the table Look for “win-win” opportunities Keys to PSE success
PSE approaches in the Iowa Cancer Plan
Examples of PSE approaches in the Iowa Cancer Plan
Illinois- working with FQHC’s and colorectal cancer to assure systematic screening Michigan – policy scan; what services health care systems are providing cancer patients have available to them. Looking for gaps Montana – working with worksites to increase cancer screening – starting with finding the win-win opportunity Examples of CCC PSE efforts
Partnerships are key to success in PSE efforts
Partnerships…finding the ‘Sweet Spot’
The “Sweet Spot”… the Iowa Cancer Consortium No one organization can do this alone Multiple organizations provide credibility and importance to the cancer plan Increases likelihood of success due to widespread support Leverages partner strengths and relationships Brings together a range of expertise and resources If one partner goes away, the effort doesn’t stop
Convener Communicator Guide Educator Planner Supporter Who does what? Partnership Roles
What role do you see your organization (or you) playing in the following scenarios? An effort to increase Iowa’s tobacco tax? Establishing a patient reminder system? A policy to assure survivorship care plans? Ask yourself…
Start with what works and build on that Make one change, even if it is small Get the right people at the table Look for “win-win” opportunities Keys to PSE success
Thank you Karin Hohman Strategic Health Concepts