CHILD SUPPORT PROGRAMME PAKISTAN. Hypothesis CSP Pilot Hypothesis: linking additional cash support to the FSP families with children would force them.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
AFRICA IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE, AFTRL Africa Program for Education Impact Evaluation Muna Meky Impact Evaluation Cluster, AFTRL Slides by Paul J.
Advertisements

1 The Protocol on Water and Health: making a difference where health, environment and development policies meet The Protocol on Water and Health.
1 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt 10 pt 15 pt 20 pt 25 pt 5 pt Transition.
Conditional Cash Transfer penalties Vs. no penalties.
Rates of Return of Social Protection The case for non-contributory social transfers in Cambodia Franziska Gassmann Arusha, Tanzania – 17 December 2014.
Sequestration How Does it Work. Passed the Congress in August 2011 Established the Joint Select Committee on Deficit Reduction It’s the Law! P.L
United Way of Northern Arizona 2013 Community Impact Forum.
Global Poverty Action Fund Community Partnership Window Funding Seminar January 2014 Global Poverty Action Fund Community Partnership Window Funding Seminar.
Social Protection in Uganda
Conditional Cash Transfers for Improving Utilization of Health Services Health Systems Innovation Workshop Abuja, January 25 th -29 th, 2010.
Overview of Maine Health Insurance Coverage Laws Joint Select Committee on Health Care Reform Opportunities and Implementation May 20, 2010 Prepared by.
Background, achievements and challenges in the external evaluation process of Oportunidades November 19 th, 2013.
Module 9 ILO Game on!. Rules  6 groups  Each group answers 4 questions  And earns budget money to implement social protection in Coresia !  Time limit:
Indicators to Monitor Investment in Social Protection Simone Cecchini Social Development Division Economic Commission for Latin America and the Caribbean.
Promoting Entrepreneurship in Houston through the Microfinance Program Kelli Lewis- Chairman of the Microfinance Initiative Presentation at the 2014 Lend.
Government of Saint Kitts and Nevis Ministry of Community Development, Culture and Gender Affairs (MOCDCGA) M.E.N.D. (Mold, Empower, Nurture and Direct)
MEXICO ’ S PROGRESA PROGRAM: WHO BENEFITS? A Presentation by Deon Filmer Of Material by David Coady.
PUENTE PROGRAM – BETWEEN THE FAMILY AND THEIR RIGHTS October, 2009.
Comparing SPI and SSI Data Formats The case of Sri Lanka Ruwanthi Elwalagedara Joint ADB / ILO / OECD Korea Policy Centre Technical Workshop on Social.
Community-Based Conditional Cash Transfer (CB-CCT) Program, Tanzania.
3 rd session: Accessibility of the project to the target groups 1.CONTEXT 2.NEED BASED ANALYSIS 3.METHODOLOGY 4.IDENTIFYING AND REACHING TARGETED GROUPS.
1 KZN SOCIAL WELFARE AND POPULATION DEVELOPMENT PUBLIC HEARINGS ON CONDITIONAL GRANTS 18 TH JAN 2006.
1 Outcome of Conditional Grants & Capital Expenditure as at 30 November 2005 [Section 40(4) of PFMA] Select Committee on Finance National Council of Provinces.
1 Sources of gender statistics Angela Me UNECE Statistics Division.
MARKETS II M&E FRAMEWORK AND CHALLENGES Joseph Obado.
Ministry of Social Services and Community Development DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES SOCIAL SAFETY NET REFORM September, 2013.
Kosovo Child Poverty Study Influencing Policies Unite for children Lulzim Çela UNICEF Kosovo Office.
Efficiency, equity and feasibility of strategies to identify the poor: an application to premium exemptions under national health insurance in Ghana Caroline.
Global Social Floor: a Universal Social Pension Silvia Stefanoni Deputy Chief Executive and Director of Programmes HelpAge International.
HOUSEHOLD BUDGET SURVEY EVALUATION. PROJECT OVERVIEW PRECURSORS State Program on Poverty Reduction & Sustainable Development ( ) CSOs given the.
Pilot Program: Conditional Cash Transfers (CCT) to Increase Girls’ Participation in Education Kano & Bauchi States, Nigeria Presented by Sadi Yahaya SESP.
Presented by Dr. Esmie Tamanda Kainja.  About the MSCTP  Objectives of the paper  Methodology  Findings  Conclusions  Policy implications  Recommendations.
INTOSAI WORKING GROUP ON KEY NATIONAL INDICATORS Audit on Social Protection of Vulnerable Groups Mrs Ivanka Kesyakova, SAI Bulgaria Sofia, March.
Introduction The following chapter will review: –Overview –Model assumptions –The Cost Proposal & Evaluation –Payments methodology –Financial Incentives/Disincentives.
Child Money Program in Mongolia By Ch. Dagvadorj, PhD, Director of Social Assistance Policy and Coordination Department, MSWL.
SELECT COMMITTEE ON FINANCE – 18 OCTOBER 2005 DEPARTMENT OF SOCIAL SERVICES AND POVERTY ALLEVIATION WESTERN CAPE PROVINCE PRESENTATION BY THE MEC & CFO.
The experience of building a Social Protection System in Chile Conference on Horizontal Cooperation in Social Protection Port of Spain, Trinidad & Tobago.
Overview of targeting in Sub- Saharan Africa - the ongoing debate in the region Cash Transfers Workshop 21 st September 2010.
The Roma Education Fund: Objectives, Structure and Operations Donor Conference, Paris 3 December 2004 Maureen McLaughlin Nicholas Burnett Jim Stevens Please.
HOW CAN SOCIAL SECURITY SCHEMES BE DESIGNED FOR LOW-INCOME COUNTRIES TO EFFECTIVELY PROVIDE FOR THE POOREST? Presentation to the International Conference”
Structural Funds Managing Authority – Ministry of Finance 1 Technical Assistance Ilze Aleksandroviča Head of Control and Development Division EU Funds.
Multi-dimensional poverty in the region: Grenada context Presented by: Honorable Delma Thomas Minister for the Ministry of Social Development and Housing.
Introduction to the Pennsylvania Kindergarten Entry Inventory.
MicroLoan Foundation: Creating balanced staff incentives Daniella Hawkins, Social Performance Manager.
Overview of SB 191 Ensuring Quality Instruction through Educator Effectiveness Colorado Department of Education September 2010.
Roma in Serbia Introduction Roma Population in Serbia: Official statistics (census 2002), Roma population - 108,193 Estimates of Roma population (different.
Child Protection and Social Protection “Social Protection must be regarded as one element in a broad strategy aimed at ensuring protection of children”
Conditional Cash Transfer Pilot Upper Egypt. Background Currently Egypt has a welfare regime that is comprehensive and generous but which has some limitations.
CHILDREN OF PRISONERS PARTNERSHIP What is the Children of Prisoners (CP) Partnership? The CP Partnership is a funding project between PFI and selected.
FEMCIDI Executive Secretariat for Integral Development (SEDI) Organization of American States (OAS)
6/18/2016 DES / AzEIP 2011 Cycle Two Self Report Overview & Training Cycle Two Self Report Overview & Training.
ANNUAL PERFORMANCE PLAN 2016/17 1. PROGRAMME 1: ADMINISTRATION 2 Key Performance Indicator Reporting Period Annual Target 2016/17 Quarterly Targets Q1Q2Q3Q4.
Module 3: Ensuring Sustainability Session 1. Empowerment of the Community 1 CBDRR Framework Training - Myanmar Red Cross Society.
1 TARGETING HEALTH INSURANCE TO THE POOR IN COLOMBIA By Tarsicio Castañeda Reaching the Poor Conference The World Bank, February 18-20, 2004.
CONDITIONAL CASH TRANSFER (PROGRAM KELUARGA HARAPAN – PKH) A LESSON LEARN FROM INDONESIA “International Workshop: Conditional Cash Transfers as a Tool.
World Day against Child Labour
Empowering Women - Pakistan’s Experiences
Ministry of Finance Contribution of the Operational Programmes to the implementation of the NSRF objectives Boriana Pencheva Director Management.
CRE8TIVE KO Meeting, Rome Italy Quality Assurance
New automation concept of Targeted Social Assistance Program to families in Azerbaijan Fuad Huseynov, Ministry of Labor and Social Protection of Population.
Disability and Social Safety Nets in Developing Countries
WFP-UNICEF Emergency Cash Transfers to support Dominicans affected by Hurricane Maria Dominica, December 2017 – February 2018 November 30th, 2017.
The Social Investment Package (SIP) -20 February 2013
WELFARE BENEFIT BOARD, MINISTRY OF SAMURDHI AND MINISTRY OF FINANCE
Forum on National Plans as Poverty Reduction Strategies in East Asia National Strategic Development Plan (NSDP), & Public Investment Program.
DSD Third Quarter Performance and Expenditure Report (1 October 2017 – 31 December 2017) Narratives on targets not achieved and overachievements 30.
World Health Organization
Ministry of National Economy of The Republic of Kazakhstan
Micro Economics January – May 2019
Child Labour in the Syrian refugee situation
Presentation transcript:

CHILD SUPPORT PROGRAMME PAKISTAN

Hypothesis CSP Pilot Hypothesis: linking additional cash support to the FSP families with children would force them to invest in human capital development. By doing this, PBM can further assist ongoing government efforts towards achieving universal primary education. CSP Pilot Hypothesis: linking additional cash support to the FSP families with children would force them to invest in human capital development. By doing this, PBM can further assist ongoing government efforts towards achieving universal primary education.

Rationale Food Support Programme is Pakistan’s largest cash transfer program. It reaches some 1.45 million households. The annual budget is close to US$ 70 million dollars per year Food Support Programme is Pakistan’s largest cash transfer program. It reaches some 1.45 million households. The annual budget is close to US$ 70 million dollars per year Pakistan Bait-Ul-Mal with technical assistance from WB and DFID decided to pilot and evaluate the impact of offering additional cash transfers conditional on families sending their children to school. Pakistan Bait-Ul-Mal with technical assistance from WB and DFID decided to pilot and evaluate the impact of offering additional cash transfers conditional on families sending their children to school. For the pilot, 5 districts were chosen with about 50,000 FSP families. Out of them, about 27,000 families had children of ages 5 to 12. For the pilot, 5 districts were chosen with about 50,000 FSP families. Out of them, about 27,000 families had children of ages 5 to 12.

Percentage of families with children of age 5 to 12 enrolled in school by age in the treatment areas

General Objectives of CSP Increase the number of children in primary education towards the achievement of Universal Increase the number of children in primary education towards the achievement of Universal Primary Education Primary Education Promote the investment in human capital for poverty reduction. Promote the investment in human capital for poverty reduction.

Specific Objectives of CSP Increase primary school registration in the target districts Increase primary school registration in the target districts Reduce dropout rates Reduce dropout rates Increase attendance levels Increase attendance levels Provide additional resources to the FSP beneficiaries having children of school going age. Provide additional resources to the FSP beneficiaries having children of school going age.

Target Population Initially the Programme will cover existing beneficiaries of FSP with at least one child of primary school going age Initially the Programme will cover existing beneficiaries of FSP with at least one child of primary school going age Additional beneficiaries will be added as long as space becomes available within the approved budget. New poor families will be chosen using proxy means test methodology (second part of the presentation) Additional beneficiaries will be added as long as space becomes available within the approved budget. New poor families will be chosen using proxy means test methodology (second part of the presentation)

Benefits Beneficiaries are entitled to receive Rs. 3,000 (US$ 50) a year from the FSP on quarterly basis Beneficiaries are entitled to receive Rs. 3,000 (US$ 50) a year from the FSP on quarterly basis The CSP beneficiary is entitled to receive additional: The CSP beneficiary is entitled to receive additional: * Rs. 200 (US$ 3.3) per month for one child * Rs. 200 (US$ 3.3) per month for one child * Rs. 350 (US$ 5.8) if they have two or more children of school going age * Rs. 350 (US$ 5.8) if they have two or more children of school going age

Conditionalities Beneficiaries: Beneficiaries: * Children of FSP families between the age of 5-12 years. * Children of FSP families between the age of 5-12 years. Conditions: Conditions: * Be registered in the primary school * Must attend at least 80% of classes * Must attend at least 80% of classes * Pass the final examination. * Pass the final examination.

Duration and Exit Policy Households will stay in the Programme as long as their children meet the conditionalities. Households will stay in the Programme as long as their children meet the conditionalities. Benefits are suspended when: Benefits are suspended when: * Children fail to comply with given conditions * Children fail to comply with given conditions * Children have failed in final exam for three consecutive times * Beneficiaries have provided false information.

Evaluation of the Programme Treatment group: Treatment group: Families participating in the Food Support program that have children in the age group in the treatment districts. Control Group: Control Group: 1) Current FSP beneficiaries in the control districts 2) Non beneficiaries to be selected in the treatment districts

Data requirements QUANTITATIVE DATA should be collected three times: Baseline data: 2,500 households and 200 schools in the treatment and control districts before the enrollment of the beneficiaries in the new program. Baseline data: 2,500 households and 200 schools in the treatment and control districts before the enrollment of the beneficiaries in the new program. Assessment of 4 months into the program: get ideas of the impact of the program, the need for improvements in the design and implementation of the program. Assessment of 4 months into the program: get ideas of the impact of the program, the need for improvements in the design and implementation of the program. A second data collection: follow up on the same households to assess the impact of the program after the end of the school year and the enrollment in the following school year. A second data collection: follow up on the same households to assess the impact of the program after the end of the school year and the enrollment in the following school year.

PROJECT CYCLE TARGETING ENROLLMENT PAYMENTS COMPLIANCE M&E -program performance -service provision M&E -program performance -service provision CASE MAGMT

Implementation Design document was approved in June 2006 Design document was approved in June 2006 First version of the operational manual in August 2006 First version of the operational manual in August 2006 Development of the MIS by modules between September 2006 and April 2007 Development of the MIS by modules between September 2006 and April 2007 Enrollment process completed in December 2006 Enrollment process completed in December 2006 First payment for January 2007 First payment for January 2007 First control of conditions for March 2007 First control of conditions for March 2007 Expansion of the programme to 100,000 households for August Expansion of the programme to 100,000 households for August World Bank is preparing an investment loan to support the expansion process. World Bank is preparing an investment loan to support the expansion process.

ANALYSIS OF TARGETING MECHANISMS FOR PAKISTAN AND CCTs IN GENERAL

IMPORTANCE OF TARGETING Maximize : Maximize : reduction in poverty reduction in poverty increase in social welfare increase in social welfare Targeting ensures that limited program resources reach the poorest households Targeting ensures that limited program resources reach the poorest households Targeting allow that the poor population are not excluded. Targeting allow that the poor population are not excluded.

TARGETING METHODOLOGIES Geographic targeting Geographic targeting Proxy means test Proxy means test Community based targeting Community based targeting Some Programmes are using combinations of the above methodologies Some Programmes are using combinations of the above methodologies

WHY COMBINATIONS? CCTs are expensive Programmes, and highly criticized if targeting systems are not good. CCTs are expensive Programmes, and highly criticized if targeting systems are not good. More and more Programmes are implementing combined systems to assure better targeting. More and more Programmes are implementing combined systems to assure better targeting.

TARGETING SYSTEMS IN CCTs Combination of GT and PMT. Examples in Mexico, Pakistan, Colombia Combination of GT and PMT. Examples in Mexico, Pakistan, Colombia Combination of GT and CBT. Examples in Kenya Combination of GT and CBT. Examples in Kenya Combination of PMT and CBT. Example in Sri Lanka Combination of PMT and CBT. Example in Sri Lanka Combination of GT, PMT and CBT. Example to be implemented in Tanzania. Combination of GT, PMT and CBT. Example to be implemented in Tanzania.

GT-PMT-CBT Geographic targeting is applied to eliminate non-poor areas Geographic targeting is applied to eliminate non-poor areas Proxy means test is used to identify individual households within poor areas Proxy means test is used to identify individual households within poor areas Community based targeting is applied to prioritize list of beneficiaries and/or verify extreme inclusion errors Community based targeting is applied to prioritize list of beneficiaries and/or verify extreme inclusion errors Example: Sri Lanka Example: Sri Lanka

GT-CBT-PMT Geographic targeting is used to eliminate non-poor areas Geographic targeting is used to eliminate non-poor areas Community based targeting is applied to identify initial list of potential beneficiaries by local committees Community based targeting is applied to identify initial list of potential beneficiaries by local committees Proxy means test to verify inclusion errors and order the list of potential beneficiaries to produce a “priority list” Proxy means test to verify inclusion errors and order the list of potential beneficiaries to produce a “priority list” Example: Tanzania? Example: Tanzania?

COMBINED SYSTEMS ADVANTAGES Balanced participation of the Programme execution unit and community Balanced participation of the Programme execution unit and community Acceptance by all stakeholders Acceptance by all stakeholders Lower levels of exclusion and inclusion errors Lower levels of exclusion and inclusion errorsLIMITATIONS They tend to be expensive, specially in the initial stages They tend to be expensive, specially in the initial stages Difficult to be accepted by stakeholders in the beginning Difficult to be accepted by stakeholders in the beginning If not well designed, system may end up in chaos. If not well designed, system may end up in chaos.

Thank you!!!