The Continuing Evolution of Challenges Robert Frances, President & CEO, PEAK Financial Group June 7, 2012
Compliance and regulation of MGAs/advisors Technology Competition and consolidation Succession Profitability Trends and Issues
Growing demand Many distributors Volume based incentives (bonuses, contests) Little regulation of the distributor Paper based Lack of central processing between suppliers Domination of large suppliers vs smaller distributors Increase in compliance costs Industry snapshot
Mutual Fund Industry Evolution What were the catalysts to change Areas of possible change for the insurance industry Agenda Changes – David Bowie
Suppliers/distributors Competition Regulation Technology Customers Mutual Funds Industry 1992 What a Wonderful World – Louis Armstrong
Rapid growth, doubled since 1992 Dropping interest rates, high returns, ease of sales process Industry attracting regulators Risks and cases of losses Mutual Funds Industry 1995
Catalysts for change: insular competition scandals increase in awareness and demand regulators worried What happenned
Key issues raised: conflict of interest sales practices regulation Risks Stromberg Report Let it Be - Beatles
“It’s the end of the world” “This will never happen” “I don’t care” “The regulators don’t understand this industry” Industry spent time on this rather than building its coalition and response Players
Little impact anticipated Some provinces began to consider changes IFIC – Sales Code Industry reaction You ain’t seen nothing yet - BTO
Industry not taking issues seriously Sweeping changes recommended Stromberg Report Suspicious Minds – Elvis Presley
Within 12 months – MFDA Sales practices Capital requirements and financial reporting Books and records, KYC Regulation – 0 to 60 in 2.4s Dazed and Confused – Led Zeppelin
Tech bubble 9/11 Recession The perfect Storm Under Pressure - Queen
MFDA initial audits Compliance infractions, reports Fines and enforcement With every client loss - Opportunities for regulation The perfect Storm Killing Me Softly – Roberta Flack
Decreasing number of players Decrease in new entrants Increase in regulatory, compliance, technology costs Increase in consolidation activity The Result Crying – Roy Orbison
Dealers - proactive Work with regulators Self regulatory organization Supplier – distributor solution Hindsight
A comparison with the mutual fund industry…
1992Challenges throughout years Continued Increase in Fixed Costs Industry Consolidation Regulatory Changes Independent Fund Dealer Challenges faced by the mutual fund industry
Life Insurance Sales Code Single MGA per advisor Value based growth vs. consolidation Capital requirements and contingency fund Options
Change is inevitable; misery is an option. Yesterday - Beatles Come Together - Beatles Taking Care of Business – BTO I will Survive – Gloria Gaynor I’m Winning - Santana Conclusion
Thank You Robert Frances, President & CEO, PEAK Financial Group June 7, 2012