1 Why Regulate Telecommunications? Dr Rob Albon Senior Economic Adviser (Regulatory Development) Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
12 CHAPTER Monopoly.
Advertisements

12 MONOPOLY CHAPTER.
Gender Perspectives in Introduction to Tariffs Gender Module #5 ITU Workshops on Sustainability in Telecommunication Through Gender & Social Equality.
Copyright©2004 South-Western 15 Monopoly. Copyright © 2004 South-Western What’s Important in Chapter 15 Sources of Monopolies (= Price Makers = Market.
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 10 Monopoly, Cartels, and Price Discrimination.
Monopolistic Competition
The case of free trade, National welfare arguments against free trade
How can Supply-Side Policies be used to achieve Economic Growth? To see more of our products visit our website at Andrew Threadgould.
Understanding Monopoly 10. Natural Barriers to Entry Economies of scale –“Bigger is better” (more cost-efficient) –This is due to the ATC being downward-
Ch. 12: Monopoly Causes of monopoly
Monopoly While a competitive firm is a price taker, a monopoly firm is a price maker. A firm is considered a monopoly if it is the sole seller of.
Ch. 12: Monopoly  Causes of monopoly  Monopoly pricing and output determination  Performance and efficiency of single-price monopoly and competition.
Monopoly CHAPTER 12. After studying this chapter you will be able to Explain how monopoly arises and distinguish between single-price monopoly and price-discriminating.
12 MONOPOLY CHAPTER.
Monopoly Monopoly and perfect competition. Profit maximization by a monopolist. Inefficiency of a monopoly. Why do monopolies occur? Natural Monopolies.
McGraw-Hill/Irwin Copyright © 2010 by the McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
12 MONOPOLY CHAPTER.
Chapter 15-1 The market structure of Monopoly
Imperfect Competition and Market Power: Core Concepts Defining Industry Boundaries Barriers to Entry Price: The Fourth Decision Variable Price and Output.
A.S 3.3 Describe and illustrate resource allocation via the public sector to compensate market failure.
Microeconomics and Corporate Analysis State Intervention, Public choice and Economic Regulation Lecture Slides Rui Baptista.
Supply Side policies AS Economics.
Copyright © 2002 by Harcourt, Inc. All rights reserved. Topic 7 : Competition and Business Lecturer: Zhu Wenzhong.
Markets fail to Allocate resources efficiently Provide goods to benefit society Stop production and consumption of harmful goods.
Competition policy reforms in Australia 18 February 2014 Matt Crooke, Minister-Counsellor (Economic) Australian High Commission, New Delhi.
Introduction to Telecom Reform and Liberalization Policy and Regulatory Tools Stefaan G. Verhulst, Markle Foundation August 2003.
Monopolies & Market Structure. Market Structure Market structure – identifies how a market is made up in terms of: The number of firms in the industry.
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Addison-Wesley. All rights reserved. Chapter 12 Economic Efficiency and Public Policy.
Chapter 15 notes Monopolies.
Finishing Up Monopolies: Natural Monopolies.  natural monopoly ◦ one firm can produce a desired output at a lower cost than two or more firms—cost 
Price Discrimination Price discrimination is the practice of selling different units of a good or service for different prices. To be able to price discriminate,
11 Prepared by: Fernando Quijano and Yvonn Quijano © 2004 Prentice Hall Business PublishingPrinciples of Economics, 7/eKarl Case, Ray Fair General Equilibrium.
International Seminar on ICT Policy Reform and Rural Communication Infrastructure, Keio University, Japan Rethinking telecom reform model: the case of.
Copyright©2004 South-Western Monopoly. Copyright © 2004 South-Western While a competitive firm is a price taker, a monopoly firm is a price maker.
An introduction to infrastructure services. Presentation outline  key characteristic of infrastructure industries economies of scale and/or scope  GATS.
Chapter 7: Market Structures Section 2
Evaluating Monopoly Comparison with Perfect Competition.
Electronic Commerce and Economic Policy. Policy Issues Antitrust Policies –Promotion of competition –Regulation of uncompetitive markets Information Policies.
Review of the previous lecture A monopoly is a firm that is the sole seller in its market. It faces a downward-sloping demand curve for its product. A.
Chapter 6 The Two Extremes: Perfect Competition and Pure Monopoly.
Chapter 22 Microeconomics Unit III: The Theory of the Firm.
10 Monopoly The price of monopoly is upon every occasion the highest which can be got. ADAM SMITH Monopoly The price of monopoly is upon every occasion.
Public Utilities: Privatisation and Regulation by Kevin Hinde.
1 Economic Approaches to Regulation and its Indirect Effects A brief overview Meeting of Productivity & Regulation Group AIM London, Tuesday 4 April 2006,
© 2009 Pearson Education Canada 10/1 Chapter 10 Monopoly.
11 Prepared by: Fernando Quijano and Yvonn Quijano © 2004 Prentice Hall Business PublishingPrinciples of Economics, 7/eKarl Case, Ray Fair General Equilibrium.
AS: Competitive and concentrated markets
Monopoly CHAPTER 12. After studying this chapter you will be able to Explain how monopoly arises and distinguish between single-price monopoly and price-discriminating.
Introduction to Business LECTURE 2: Introduction to Business MGT
Monopolistic Competition Topic 7(a). Contents 1. Characteristics of MC 2. Short run profit maximisation 3. Long run equilibrium 4. Assessment of MC 5.
Monopoly and Public Policy. Welfare Effects of Monopoly ▫By holding output below the level at which marginal cost is equal to the market price, a monopolist.
MONOPOLY 12 CHAPTER. Objectives After studying this chapter, you will able to  Explain how monopoly arises and distinguish between single-price monopoly.
Market Failure. Occurs when free market forces, using the price mechanism, fail to produce the products that people want, in the quantities they desire.
1 Regulation of Mobile Termination Dr Rob Albon Senior Economic Adviser (Regulatory Development) Australian Competition and Consumer Commission.
ECON 201 WEEK 7 Finishing Up Monopolies: Natural Monopolies.
Externalities >> chapter: 17 Krugman/Wells Economics ©2009  Worth Publishers 1 of 32.
Copyright©2004 South-Western 15 Monopoly. Copyright © 2004 South-Western Monopoly While a competitive firm is a price taker, a monopoly firm is a price.
1.4.5 Monopoly and the allocation of resources What is the objective in a game of monopoly? Use your knowledge of economics to explain why a hotel on Old.
Evaluating Monopoly Comparison with Perfect Competition.
Chapter 10: Monopoly, Cartels, and Price Discrimination Copyright © 2014 Pearson Canada Inc.
Pure competition is a theoretical market structure that has a very large numbers of sellers, identical products, and freedom to enter into, conduct, and.
13 MONOPOLY. © 2012 Pearson Education A monopoly is a market:  That produces a good or service for which no close substitute exists  In which there.
Monopoly 15. Monopoly A firm is considered a monopoly if... it is the sole seller of its product. it is the sole seller of its product. its product does.
Monopolies & Market Structure
What were the main problems for Chile?
Chapter 5 Microeconomic Reform
Pure Competition Pure competition is a theoretical market structure that has a very large numbers of sellers, identical products, and freedom to enter.
Chapter 10: Monopoly, Cartels, and Price Discrimination
Ch. 13: Monopoly Causes of monopoly
Game Theory & Natural Monopolies
Presentation transcript:

1 Why Regulate Telecommunications? Dr Rob Albon Senior Economic Adviser (Regulatory Development) Australian Competition and Consumer Commission

2 Telecommunications has never been free of government intervention … Since the beginning of telecommunications in the late nineteenth century, telecommunications markets have never been free of government intervention. Generally, existing postal monopolies were extended to take over monopoly control of the emerging telecommunications industry.

3 Why not uncontrolled competition? There will tend to be three major problems with a free-market approach: Natural monopoly – the tendency towards monopoly will be wasteful of scarce resources as new entrants fail. Externalities unattended – private decisions do not always reflect social values, so some externalities may not be properly attended in a free market. Dynamic efficiencies forgone – properly regulated entry will find new techniques and innovations.

4 Traditional Intervention (1) There has always been intervention but the form has changed. Traditional intervention usually comprised: Government ownership and operation – usually as part of a government department. Statutory (legislated) monopoly Politicised pricing and investment; including uniform geographical pricing.

5 Traditional Intervention (2) This was aimed at pursuing social and political objectives … … not just addressing ‘market failure’. Governments in the past – and present? – have used their influence on telecommunications to bestow political favours.

6 Inadequacy of Traditional Intervention The traditional model is now regarded as having produced inefficient outcomes: Too many resources to produce given outputs (‘productive inefficiency’) Inefficient pricing through ‘cross-subsidies’ (‘allocative inefficiency’) Insufficient incentives for invention and innovation (‘dynamic inefficiencies’)

7 Reforms (1) Reforms in the last 20 or so years addressed these problems and constraints through: Corporatisation – taking the function out of a government department and giving it a more commercial structure. Independent regulation – inappropriate to have the incumbent regulating entry, anti- competitive behaviour, etc!

8 Reforms (2) Controlled introduction of competition – the major focus of these presentations Transparency and independent funding of USOs/CSOs Privatisation

9 Why is Natural Monopoly a Problem? Natural monopoly means that having more than one producer causes higher costs of producing a given level of output (or given bundle of outputs). Economies of scale, economies of scope and network economies are defining characteristics of ‘natural monopoly’.

10 Economies of Scale Economies of scale means that the fragmentation resulting from ‘duplication’ would result in higher overall costs of producing a given level of output. This can be seen in the following diagram:* * LRAC = long-run average cost

11 LRAC Q This area multiplied by two is the excess cost of producing 2Q in two identical firms rather than one. 2Q2QQ

12 Economies of Scope Economies of scope means that a given bundle of outputs can be produced at a lower total cost than if the outputs were divided between one or more producers. This arises from the sharing of common network infrastructure by a multi-product producer. Perhaps the line-sharing service (LSS) is a perfect example?

13 Addressing Natural Monopoly Not all production components are naturally monopolistic. Competition has been introduced by giving new entrants regulated access to those network elements that have ‘natural monopoly characteristics’. These elements are sometimes known as ‘essential facilities’.

14 Essential Facilities An essential facility is both:  prohibitively costly to reproduce (natural monopoly) and  essential for development of competitive downstream markets (like long-distance and international).

15 Sources of ‘Bottleneck’ Market Power (1) The classic example of an essential facility is the public switched telecommunications network (PSTN). Other telecommunications facilities may be natural duopolies, triopolies, quadropolies, etc. Natural monopoly characteristics are not the only source of ‘bottleneck’ market power.

16 Sources of ‘Bottleneck’ Market Power (2) Termination of fixed-to-mobile (FTM) and mobile-to- mobile (MTM) calls by mobile carriers provides a special case of bottleneck market power. Subscribers to a particular network can only be reached by access to that network. The addition of new networks does not directly mitigate this market power. Even small mobile networks have market power because they control access to their subscribers.

17 Why Network Externalities may be a Problem Network externalities arise when new subscribers result in external benefits to existing subscribers, additional to their own private benefits. This means marginal social value (MSV) of a new subscriber exceeds marginal private value (MPV). The free market will produce too little subscription.

18 Marginal social value Marginal private value Potential efficiency gain ‘Cost ’ Free-market subscription Socially-optimal subscription Subsidised price necessary Cost-based price

19 Addressing Network Externalities Some potential subscribers will need to be subsidised before they will join. This may be through uniform pricing (‘cross-subsidy’) or direct subsidies. The potential gain is shown in the diagram.

20 Issues (1): Determining the MSV Getting the subsidy right requires knowing the MSV of an additional subscriber. This is hard to determine because – by definition – the value of an externality is not determined in a market. Carriers can be very ‘creative’ in valuing externalities!

21 Issues (2): Funding the Subsidy All ways of funding the subsidy (usually it is cross-subsidy) result in efficiency costs. The efficiency gains from the subsidy must be weighed against the efficiency loss from the tax. The gain and the loss must be equated at the margin.

22 Issues (3): ‘Second-best’ Considerations There is usually more than one externality. For example, there may be a call-receipt externality enjoyed by the receivers of mobile calls. This may negate any mobile network externality.

23 Why Dynamic Efficiencies May be Lacking To the extent that new entrants are doomed to fail in a free market, an access regime can lead to a dynamic efficiency benefit. Entry in downstream markets could generate dynamic efficiencies. For example, there may be new niche service offerings, not previously available from an incumbent supplier.

24 Promoting Dynamic Efficiencies Even where the entrants offer very similar services to the access provider, it is possible that entrants could offer more innovative arrangements for pricing, billing, etc. The famous economist of the 1940s, Joseph Schumpeter, highlighted the creative and destructive forces of competition.

25 Social and Political Objectives Universal service obligations (USOs) and community service obligations (CSOs) can be better addressed than by cross-subsidy and direct intervention. These require:  Better definition and targeting  Greater transparency  More efficient funding