University of Minnesota Medical Technology Evaluation and Market Research Department of Healthcare Management Course: MILI/PUBH 6589 Spring Semester, 2013.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
HEA PTP: M207 Health Economics1 Measurement & Valuation of Health What is health? Why do we need to measure it? How can it be measured? Why do we need.
Advertisements

Measuring outcomes Emma Frew October Measuring outcomes Learning objectives By the end of the session students should be able to – Explain how different.
Standardized Scales.
1 Does it make a difference for the patient? Survival & Quality of life  Jan J. v. Busschbach, Ph.D.  Erasmus MC Institute for Medical Psychology and.
The role of economic modelling – a brief introduction Francis Ruiz NICE International © NICE 2014.
Introduction to decision modelling Andrew Sutton.
A METHODOLOGY FOR MEASURING THE COST- UTILITY OF EARLY CHILDHOOD DEVELOPMENTAL INTERVENTIONS Quality of improved life opportunities (QILO)
Valuing Health Daniel M. Hausman University of Wisconsin-Madison October 19, 2009.
Cross-Cultural Use of Measurements: Development of the Chinese SF-36 Health Survey Xinhua S. Ren, Ph.D. Boston University School of Public Health, Boston,
Estimating utilities from individual preference data Some introductory remarks by Tony O’Hagan.
Schneider Institute for Health Policy Heller Graduate School Brandeis University September by Donald S. Shepard, Ph.D. Schneider Institute for Health.
Epidemiology Assignment 1
QUALITY OF LIFE ASSESSMENT IN PEOPLE LIVING WITH HIV/AIDS Antonieta Medina Lara HIV/AIDS and STI Knowledge Programme Liverpool School of Tropical Medicine.
Self-Report Measures of Functional Status and Quality of Life: Adults Sandra A. Mitchell, CRNP, M.Sc.N., AOCN National Institutes of Health Bethesda, MD.
Quality of Life Assessment in Clinical Trials Adapted from Introduction to Clinical Trials Biostatistics.
Environmental Health Sciences Assignment 1 Review of an Article on Determinants of Quality of Life for People with Asthma.
Social and Behavioral Sciences Assignment 1 Health Behavior Impact on Health- Related Quality of Life (HRQOL): Article Review and Behavioral Science Intervention.
Social and Behavioral Sciences Assignment 2
Health Policy and Management Assignment 1 Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQOL) Surveillance Summary Policy Brief.
Assessing Health and Economic Outcomes William C. Black, M.D. Director ACRIN Outcomes & Economics Core Laboratory Dartmouth-Hitchcock Medical Center.
1 Health-Related Quality of Life Ron D. Hays, Ph.D. - UCLA Department of Medicine: Division of General Internal Medicine.
Measuring and valuing health outcome Montarat Thavorncharoensap, Ph.D. 1: Faculty of Pharmacy, Mahidol University 2. HITAP, Thailand.
1 EQ-5D, HUI and SF-36 Of the shelf instruments…..
Introduction to Effectiveness, Patient Preferences and Utilities Patsi Sinnott, PT, PhD, MPH HERC Economics Course May 6, 2009.
Summary Measures of Population Health Ian McDowell November, Rationale for summary measures 2. Mortality-based measures 3. Combined disability.
ABS approach to collecting disability data and relationship to the ICF.
Summary of measures of population Health Farid Najafi MD PhD School of Population Health Kermanshah University of Medical Sciences.
University of Minnesota Medical Technology Evaluation and Market Research Course: MILI/PUBH 6589 Spring Semester, 2012 Stephen T. Parente, Ph.D. Carlson.
Evidence Evaluation & Methods Workgroup: Developing a Decision Analysis Model Lisa A. Prosser, PhD, MS September 23, 2011.
Economic evaluation of health programmes Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupational Health Class no. 11: Cost-utility analysis – Part 4.
Measuring Health Outcomes
Why use the EQ-5D? What are the alternatives?. What are the alternatives for Direct valuation? Other VAS Time Trade-Off Standard Gamble Willingness to.
GENERAL INTRODUCTION TO HEALTH MEASUREMENT (Note: I have added explanatory notes to many of the slides; to see these you will need to save the file and.
MAST Safety (Domain 2) Clinical Effectiveness (Domain 3) Reinhard Prior, HIM, Berlin May 5, 2010.
Quality of Life in People with and at Risk for Type 2 Diabetes: Findings from the Study to Help Improve Early Evaluation and Management of Risk Factors.
Introduction Patients with tumors affecting the spine have significant impairments in Quality of Life domains that include physical function, neural function,
1 The Patient Perspective: Satisfaction Survey Presented at: Disease Management Colloquium June 22, 2005 Shulamit Bernard, RN, PhD.
#1 STATISTICS 542 Intro to Clinical Trials Quality of Life Assessment.
1 The valuation of disease-specific health states to facilitate economic evaluation E. Kok, E. Stolk, Jan J. v. Busschbach Address: –Jan v. Busschbach.
Basic Economic Analysis David Epstein, Centre for Health Economics, York.
Another Perspective on PRO Content in Clinical Practice Ron D. Hays, Ph.D. University of California, Los Angeles June 25, 2007.
Evidence and Information for Policy Health as a multi-dimensional construct and cross-population comparability Colin Mathers (WHO) on behalf of Taskforce.
1 EQ-5D, HUI and SF-36 Of the shelf instruments…..
Patsi Sinnott, PT, PhD, MPH HERC Economics Course April 7, 2010 Introduction to Effectiveness, Patient Preferences and Utilities.
Overview of Health-Related Quality of Life Measures May 22, 2014 (1:00 – 2:00 PDT) Kaiser Methods Webinar Series 1 Ron D.Hays, Ph.D.
1 Session 6 Minimally Important Differences Dave Cella Dennis Revicki Jeff Sloan David Feeny Ron Hays.
Measuring Family HRQOL Spillover Effects Using QALYs Lisa A. Prosser, PhD University of Michigan CANS Special Topics Conference October 14, 2015.
1 Lecture 6: Descriptive follow-up studies Natural history of disease and prognosis Survival analysis: Kaplan-Meier survival curves Cox proportional hazards.
Hermann P. G. Schneider, Alastair H. MacLennan and David Feeny
EQ-5D and SF-36 Quality of Life Measures in Systemic Lupus Erythematosus: Comparisons with RA, Non-Inflammatory Disorders (NIRD), and Fibromyalgia (FM)
“Introduction to Patient Preference Methods used for QALYs” Presented by: Jan Busschbach, PhD, Chair Section Medical Psychology and Psychotherapy, Department.
Scaling Session Measurement implies assigning numbers to objects or events. In our case, the numbers “weight” responses to questions, so that saying “Yes”
Conceptual Foundations for Health Measurements
Overlap between Subjective Well-being and Health-related Quality of Life. 3 Ron D. Hays, Ph.D. (Alina Palimaru) November 18, 2015 (11:30-12:00 noon) Geriatric.
Quality of Life (QOL) & Patient Reported Outcomes (PRO) Lori Minasian, MD Chief, Community Oncology and Prevention Trials Research Group, DCP, NCI, NIH,
EBM --- Journal Reading Presenter :葉麗雯 Date : 2005/10/27.
Principles of Assessment and Outcome Measurement for Physical Therapists ksu. edu. sa Dr. taher _ yahoo. com Mohammed TA, Omar,
Department of Health Service Research Head: Prof. Dr. Ansgar Gerhardus Interactive session: Presentation of the INTEGRATE-HTA Model and short discussion.
Epidemiology Assignment 2
Biostatistics Assignment 1 Analysis of Metropolitan Statistical Area (MSA) data from the Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS), 2007.
Measures of Health-Related Quality-of-Life Background presentation for IOM Committee on Women’s Health Research May 7, 2009 Dennis.
Health-Related Quality of Life (HRQOL) Assessment in Outcome Studies Ron D. Hays, Ph.D. UCLA/RAND GCRC Summer Course “The.
PHARMAECONOMICS Pulmonary Arterial Hypertension Nelli ÄIJÖ & Feyza Nur POLAT Nika Marđetko.
Health Related Quality of Life after serious occupational injuries and long term disability Presenter: Ibishi Nazmie MD,PhD University Clinical Center.
Table 1. Characteristics of generic HRQOL assessments in adult physical activity research Peter D. Hart et al. Systematic Review of Health-Related Quality.
Global burden of diseases
Quality of Life Assessment
Patient Baseline Assessment
Measurement Wu Gong, MS, MD
Measuring outcomes Emma Frew October 2012.
Presentation transcript:

University of Minnesota Medical Technology Evaluation and Market Research Department of Healthcare Management Course: MILI/PUBH 6589 Spring Semester, 2013 Stephen T. Parente, Ph.D. Carlson School of Management, Department of Finance

Class Overview Measuring Effectiveness  Health state 101  Specifying clinical outcomes  Measuring outcomes  Use of decision trees in effectiveness analysis

Terminology: “Health State” “The health of an individual at any particular point in time.” [Gold et al 1996]

When Considering an Assessment of Health: Two areas of concern Length of life –mortality rates –life expectancy Quality of life –ability/disability –independence –other aspects of health & well-being

1.quality of life 2.combination of quality & length We need measurement scales for What do we mean by “measurement” of outcomes?

Measurement Process of setting up a correspondence between –Some set of things (here health states) –Numbers So that qualitative relations among the things (such as “better than”) are reflected by the quantitative numerical relationships

Some differences in scales matter; some don’t Pain ratings from 6 people: A,B,B,B,C,D Averages on 3 different scales:

Goal of health outcome measurement Assign scales so that when we do arithmetic, the averages work out the way we think they should. Use common vales to permit apples to apples comparison.

How about a single measure that combines morbidity & mortality? Simple idea: Weight each year of life with a measure of degree of good/poor health. Add up the weighted life years.

DeadExcellent OverallHealth Quality additional years of life nowdeath QALYs = area under this curve QALE = average number of QALYs experienced by a cohort of the same starting age and quality of life of the same starting age and quality of life = best estimate of future health-adjusted life years for = best estimate of future health-adjusted life years for random member of the cohort random member of the cohort “Life Path” = the general health outcome

Mathematical Assumption to make QALY tractable: “Q” weighting is separable from duration of the health state it represents and other health states in the life path –simplifies data collection immensely! –Life expectancy obtained from medical data –combined mathematically instead of by judgment

Issues... What aspects of “health” are normally covered in a health-related quality of life (HRQOL) measure? How is a health classification system operationalized? How are numbers (weights) assigned to health states?

Illustrate with several different measures QWB Quality of Well-being scale HUI Health Utility Index YHL measure in Years of Healthy Life EQ-5D EuroQol health status measure SF-36 Questionnaire-based health profile

Dead Excellent Overall HRQOL additional years of life nowdeath Continuum of health state weights

Death Excellent Overall Health Description system covering all health states Numerical scale Function corresponding states to scale values so arithmetic “works” Health Status Measurement System

“The health of an individual at any particular point in time.” Things “health” might include... –Functional abilities? Which ones? –Pain? –Other?  “Dimensions” of Health

Typical Concepts & Domains Health Perceptions Social Function –Soc. relations –role function –intimacy –communication Impairment –sensory function/loss –symptoms Psychological Funct. –Cognitive –emotional –mood/feelings Physical Function –mobility –physical activity –self-care

A Hierarchy of Health Dimensions

Health states are multidimensional Measure as vector –one number for each dimension Create one summary number

State 1 –intermittent moderate pain –no mobility limitations –able to do normal socio-occup. functions State 2 –continuous mild pain –mobility limitation –some occupational restrictions Example

Profile (“vector”) representation 1. Decide what dimensions 2. Develop scales for each dimension 3. Develop process for locating patients on each dimension PF SF P A = (70, 30, 50) B = (55, 60, 90) Physical Function Social Function Pain A B

Single number (“scalar”) representation: 1. Same steps as for a profile +2. Develop process for aggregating the attributes into one summary number. OR Just do direct aggregate scaling State B State A Perfect health dead

Example classification scheme: YHL Functional ability

Example classification scheme: YHL 5 levels of self-rating x 6 levels of function = 30 health states An intermediate health state BestWorst

An intermediate health state BestWorst Scaling the Health States: 1.0 Dead 0.0??

Weights for YHL Functional ability Note: “dead” = 0.00

Definitions ….. HALYs: health-adjusted life years using a health status measure for health weights –QALYs: quality-adjusted life years … a type of HALY computed using a HRQOL measure for health weights.

Disease SpecificGeneral Health non-preference physical measures Many! e.g. joint counts total cholesterol -- rating scales Many! SIP, Rand GHS, COOP, MOS short forms EVGFP preference based indexed? QWB, HUI, EQ-5D, YHL? patient’s own prefs.ad hoc

Disease-specific instruments Very specific to intended effects of treatments Can be sensitive to small changes in disease activity/status Clinicians can link to specific actions

But disease-specific measures may miss things Many treatments have unintended effects (arthritis & hearing) Many people (especially when older) have multiple health conditions (median number is 3)...

Why an interest in measures of General Health? (aka “generic measures”) Allows many comparisons: –across diseases –in people with multiple conditions –across studies Needed for cost-effectiveness studies

Medical Outcomes Study -- “short forms” Derived from Rand General Health Survey Originally 250+ questions Published short forms that are in use: –SF-12 –SF-20 –SF-36

SF-36 8 components, scaled worst=0 to best=100  Physical functioning  Role function (from physical limitation)  Pain  General Health Perception Mental health  Vitality  Social functioning  Role function (from emotional limitation)  Mental health

New Scaling for SF-36 & SF-12 PCS : physical component scale MCS: mental component scale

Two web sites for SF

Decision Tree Overview: Movement Across Health States Over Time

What’s Next? Break Technology Evaluation Roundtable Projects