Problem with the DSM: It highlights or exaggerates differences between the diagnosed and the undiagnosed A possible alternative to the DSM would be a system.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Obtained from the Michigan Mental Health Ambassador Handbook
Advertisements

As services become more truly focused on service users needs and accept the value of lived experience, so there are obvious implications for the composition.
Good Mental Health Makes Good Sense A public education program presented by the South Carolina Department of Mental Health and developed by the Elimination.
Factors influencing mental illness stigma in Iran: Qualitative study Alireza Momeni, Soroor Parvizy, Nargess Shafaroodi Iran University of Medical Sciences.
What Is This Thing Called “Recovery”?
Psychological Disorders: An Introduction
Introduction to Consumer Operated Service Programs
Copyright © 2012 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Chapter 35Seriously and Persistently Mentally Ill, Homeless, or Incarcerated Clients.
Wellness & Recovery Presented by Sharon Kuehn, Wellness Recovery Educators Debra Brasher, CPRP, Inspired at Work.
The Mental Health of Adolescents in Hong Kong: A Shifting of Paradigm in Intervention, Service and Policy Professor Kam-shing YIP Professor Department.
Culturally Competent Care from the Perspective of the Consumer: What Matters Most October, 2007.
Chapter 1 Mental Health and Mental Illness Copyright © 2014, 2010, 2006 by Saunders, an imprint of Elsevier Inc.
1 An Introduction to the Consumer Movement Self-Help.
Community Supports for People with Serious Mental Illness Psychiatric Recovery: The Role of Peer Support Sheree Neese-Todd Center for Health Care Strategies.
New York Association of School Psychologists & New York Office of Mental Health Present “Is It Just the Blues? Adolescent Depression and Suicide Prevention:”
Person-Centred Care Planning. Outline  Review current care planning practices in the different branches of nursing  Examples from practice  Consider.
Introduction to Mental Disorders. Myth or Reality  Are the following statements myths or realities regarding mental disorders?  1. Mental disorders.
Asperger's Syndrome BY: LAUREN HUMMEL AND MIKAELLA METCALF.
By Motorcyclin and Happenin
What is Stigma? The negative reaction of people to an individual or group because of some assumed inferiority or source of difference that is degraded.
Welcoming and Appreciating Diverse Mental Health Perspectives.
Severe and Persistent Mental Illness and Mothers A Mothers’ Mental Health Toolkit Project Learning Video with Dr. Joanne MacDonald Reproductive Mental.
Section 4.3 Depression and Suicide Slide 1 of 20.
IT IS ALL ABOUT THE JOURNEY: Supporting the creation of active recovery spaces within service frameworks IT IS ALL ABOUT THE JOURNEY: Supporting the creation.
by Susan Nolen-Hoeksema
Psychological Disorders: An Introduction. Defining Disorder.
 Mental and Emotional health helps you function effectively each day.  Good mental and emotional health influences your physical and social health.
Recovery A New Model for Veterans Affairs Mental Health Programs.
Recovery ? What is the Recovery Approach and why do we want it?
Dissociative Identity Disorder (DID) Dissociative identity disorder is a mental illness that involves the sufferer experiencing at least two clear identities.
Mental Disorders Mental Disorder- Is an illness that affects the mind and reduces person’s ability to function, adjust to change, or get along with others.
Mental Health, Mental Illness and Chronic Disease Policy CMHA National Conference August 2008 Barbara Neuwelt, CMHA, Ontario.
Top ten myths about mental illness. Myth #1: Psychiatric disorders are not true medical illnesses Like heart disease and diabetes. People who have a mental.
Cultural Adaptation: The Ambiguity Toward This Notion in Healthcare Marguerite Cognet, Ph.D Sociology Spyridoula Xenocostas, M.Sc. Anthropology METISS.
PRINCIPLES OF DRUG ADDICTION TREATMENT Dr. K. S. NJUGUNA.
PSR Fundamentals: Putting Values into Practice Betty Dahlquist, MSW, CPRP
Engagement, Adherence, Transition to Community & Course Wrap-Up Demian Rose, MD Rachel Loewy, PhD Linda May, PhD, MFT.
Mindtrap.
Depression / Suicide.
Mental Disorders & Resources for Help 7.MEH.3.1. Jacob Jacob is part of the local all-star baseball team. He just finished a long practice and decided.
Mental Health and Employment in TVR Work Building on Our Strengths as Tribal Programs.
100 ways to support recovery A guide for mental health professionals Rethink recovery.
***Clinical Psychologists & Social Workers*** Mary Grun Period 2.
Schizophrenia is a long term mental disorder of a type involving a break down, in a relation between thought, emotion, and behaviour, leading to faulty.
Section 4 & dealing with setbacks Treating mental disorder Robert Burt, Albany Faust, Christopher Schoeck.
Section 4.4 Treating Mental Disorders Slide 1 of 14 Objectives List reasons that might prevent a person from seeking help for a mental disorder. Identify.
7th Grade 7.MEH.3.1. Objective 3.1  Identify resources that would be appropriate for treating common mental disorders.
Breaking down Stigma Speaker’s name Position (if applicable) NAMI Affiliate Date of presentation Speaker’s name Position (if applicable) NAMI Affiliate.
1 Highlights of a Systematic Review of Literature on Peer-Delivered Services Boston University Center for Psychiatric Rehabilitation June 2010.
UNIT 4 SEMINAR HN 220 CULTURAL SENSITIVITY CHAPTER 4 Maria Brown, MS.
Caregivers Re-Discovering Wellness: Reconnecting After Trauma, and the Strength of Community Presented by: Nathalie Cote, Family Peer Support Worker –
Psychosis Psychosis is a serious mental disorder characterized by thinking and emotions that are so impaired, that they indicate that the person experiencing.
Promoting Mental Health Improvement
Depression and Suicide Chapter 4.3. Health Stats What relationship is there between risk of depression and how connected teens feel to their school? What.
SCHIZOPHRENIA LEXI, LEXI, ERIN, & SADIE. WHAT IS SCHIZOPHRENIA? According to Webmd.com schizophrenia is a serious brain disorder that distorts the way.
Care in the Community (Social Approach) A treatment for schizophrenia.
Ch. 19 S. 1 : What is Therapy? Obj: Define psychotherapy, and list the advantages of each method of psychotherapy.
Depression and Suicide
Schizophrenia: an inside view
The Connection Between Sexual Trauma and Mental Health
ACT As A Brief Intervention Model
Esther B. Davis Presenter
Here Is Some More About Drug Addiction Treatment
Recovery to Practice and American Association of
Roles of the Mental Health Team:
What we are Saying Anne Cooke.
Good Morning! HW: Should We Execute article (QCR and focused notes)
Psychological Disorders
Presentation transcript:

Problem with the DSM: It highlights or exaggerates differences between the diagnosed and the undiagnosed A possible alternative to the DSM would be a system that simply defined when normal human problems become severe enough to justify formal treatment. The problems in this case would not be defined as categorically different.

What research says teaching the biological model does to perceived stigma around mental illness: Mental health workers who believe it think less of consumers Consumers feel more helpless The general public sees consumers as more unpredictable and dangerous

More problems with the DSM: It fails to tell us anything unique about cause, or about what will be an effective treatment. It gives people the illusion they know what is causing the problems. (It’s the bipolar disorder, or the intermittent explosive disorder, that caused your troubles!) It makes people imagine that they know the outcome, frequently leading to negative expectations.

Contrasting the Peer Perspective with the Traditional Mental Health Approach

Getting more consumer directed is the “leading edge” in therapy in general: to find out more about “client directed, outcome informed” therapy, check out

Psychiatrist Mark Ragins MD summed up the traditional beliefs about serious mental illness in which he was trained as follows: “People with chronic mental illness are permanently disabled. Medicate them and forget them. They are weak and need to be taken care of. They can’t hold down jobs. They have no significant role to play in society. The possibility of them having a meaningful life is slight. Their prognosis is essentially hopeless.”

Peer Approach: You can recover, just like I did, or am. Traditional Approach: You have a neurobiological disease. We don’t have any model for how you could possibly recover from it.

Peer Approach: Normalizes symptoms, sees “symptoms” as understandable reactions to life events. Traditional Approach: “Abnormalizes” people, frames symptoms as part of brain disease rather than being understandable.

Peer Approach: Is person centered. “Diseases don’t recover, people do.” - Pat Deegan, psychiatric survivor. Traditional Approach: Is disease centered. “We have here a case of schizophrenia.”

Peer Approach: Life story, including experience of trauma, is seen as key to understanding people. Traditional Approach: Trauma, and life story in general, is seen as irrelevant to major mental illness.

If you want to receive two articles on the research and theory about the relationship between trauma and psychosis, please me at

Peer Approach: Interventions should address a person’s needs, usually as defined by that person. Housing & jobs for example may be a priority. Traditional Approach: Interventions should be aimed at the illness.

Peer Approach: People who are being helped by peers can also use those peers as a role model. Traditional Approach: Consumers are expected to learn their role as consumers, rather than to model themselves after the “experts” who help them.

Peer Approach: Self disclosure, of both personal problems and of recovery stories, is considered fundamental. Traditional Approach: Don’t do self disclosure: it is inconsistent with the role as “expert.”

Peer Approach: Focuses on alliance, not compliance. Much more “trauma informed,” better trust, non- hierarchical. Traditional Approach: “Experts know best” so treatment should be forced if people don’t accept it.

Peer Approach: Boundaries only when/as really necessary to prevent exploitation of those being helped (or if needed to prevent exploitation of the helper.) Traditional Approach: Really into “boundaries” even when they get in the way of authentic human connection. More boundaries = more professional!

Peer Approach: Technical language which highlights differences is avoided: common humanity is highlighted instead. Traditional Approach: Lots of medical or technical language so you can tell how expert the “expert” is.

Peer Approach: Formal education is seen as frequently interfering with connecting one on one with another human being. Traditional Approach: Higher education is required, all the better to identify who is hopeless and “non- understandable.”

Peer Approach: Unusual experiences or beliefs are seen as offering some mix of value and trouble. Willing to discuss this with a person. Traditional Approach: Unusual experiences or beliefs are typically seen as purely pathological: increase the medication!

Peer Approach: Peer experiences are expected to be at least somewhat mutual, even when one peer may be doing better and is officially the “helper.” Traditional Approach: Roles are clearly defined: everyone knows who is the “expert” helper & who has nothing to offer and will just be the “patient.”

Peer Approach: Is organized around “how is your life?” Traditional Approach: Is organized around, “how are your symptoms?”

Peer Approach: Peer support for mental health consumers is on a continuum with the natural human support required by all community members. Traditional Approach: Support for Mental health consumers is very different from that provided for community members in general.

As we get better in helping people recover, mental disorders will just be seen as temporary states that we can all help each other through and learn something from, rather than as something that replaces the identity of certain people.