Paraphrasing in Context Innovations in Research and Pedagogy Casey KeckZuzana Tomaš San Francisco State UniversityUniversity of Utah

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Common Core Standards (What this means in computer class)
Advertisements

Prose Analysis Essay for the AP Language and Composition Exam
Critical Reading Strategies: Overview of Research Process
Balanced Literacy How our instructional practices will support the implementation of Common Core.
The Process Pedagogy ENGL The Process Pedagogy The process pedagogy is a pedagogy that believes students should be treated like real writers,
BCTEAL 2014 JENNIFER WALSH MARR Reformulating Paraphrasing.
The Network of Dynamic Learning Communities C 107 F N Increasing Rigor February 5, 2011.
Writing Performance Tasks* for CTE *also known as Writing Tasks.
Shanshan Zhu. L2 Summary Writing “attempted paraphrase” “A writer selects a specific excerpt of a source text and makes at least one attempt to change.
What is “College Writing”? Getting the Most Out of TS English Fall Quarter.
Teaching and Assessing Discipline- Independent and Discipline-Specific Metacognitive Strategies Laura Wenk Assistant Professor of Cognition and Education.
Bridges New ELA: Supporting SIFE with Low Literacy in the Home Language Session 1, March 19, 2015.
WEEK 8: REVISION CALEB HUMPHREYS. FREE WRITE / READING (~10 MINUTES) Read the sample Draft 1.1 of the rhetorical analysis in your textbook. Pages
WRITING A PROCESS ANALYSIS ESSAY Catherine Wishart Senior Adjunct Instructor Burlington County College.
Faculty Senate Writing Skills Committee Scott Lazerus, ChairChristy Jespersen Jessica YoungJoAnn Arai-Brown Nancy GaussAnne Ryter Julie LukengaCourtney.
Key Strategies for Reading and Writing §Prepare by: §Tapping background knowledge for a topic. §Decide the purpose for reading/writing. §Predict how it.
PDI January 6, 2011 Emily Morgan.  Writing and Discussion: Why do we assign writing?  A.D.D.I.E  Assignment Writing Workshop  Writing Resources Please.
FINAL PROJECT: REVIEW ARTICLES From Proposal to Paper.
Created by Lynne Crandall University of Michigan Revised by Clark County Curriculum Staff Writing On Demand Preparing for Assessment.
Revisiting LDC, Day 2 Elementary Bowling Green, Kentucky – Reach Associates November 15,
ELA Common Core Shifts. Shift 1 Balancing Informational & Literary Text.
Summarizing Research 2G from multiple sources. Summarizing research Electronic Text: anything published in computerized (electronic) format instead of.
Writing in the Disciplines Faculty Seminar August 23, 2007Presenters: Alberto Esquinca and Kerrie Kephart, Teacher Education Kate Mangelsdorf and Jonna.
EdTPA Teacher Performance Assessment. Planning Task Selecting lesson objectives Planning 3-5 days of instruction (lessons, assessments, materials) Alignment.
Summary-Response Essay Responding to Reading. Reading Critically Not about finding fault with author Rather engaging author in a discussion by asking.
Got Citizenship? September 12, 2013 Common Core: Close Reading.
Preparing Students for Professional Writing Following Graduation James Coyle University of Windsor
What is AP English Language and Composition? Course Introduction.
LT512 Reading in the Content Areas Professor: Donna Numeroff-Martin, EdD Seminar: Monday 7:00pm EST Week 5: Unit 5 Comprehension Strategies.
AP Language and Composition. Designed to be the equivalent of a first-year college writing course. Requires students to become skilled readers and composers.
Close Reading of Complex Texts in the 3-8 Modules
Close Reading.  Discuss Model for Text Complexity  Discuss Reader and Task  Define Close Reading  Model a Close Reading Lesson  Create a Close Reading.
Academic Reading ENG 115.
NYS Common Core English Language Arts Grades 9 – 12.
Reading like a Detective Deeper Reading with Text- Based Questions.
AP English Language & Composition. STRENGTHEN THE EFFECTIVENESS OF YOUR WRITING THROUGH CLOSE READING AND FREQUENT PRACTICE AT APPLYING RHETORICAL STRATEGIES,
MRS. LIMA AP Literature & Composition. What are AP Courses? Provide the opportunity for academically prepared and motivated students to complete.
Written Assignment NOTES AND TIPS FOR STUDENTS.  MarksLevel descriptor 0The work does not reach a standard described by the descriptors below. 1–2The.
CREATING AN ACTIVE LEARNING ENVIRONMENT Using Inquiry and Primary Sources.
What Community College Students Need to Know About Writing at the University Professor Irene L. Clark California State University, Northridge.
Fariza Khalid LITERATURE REVIEW. A literature review is a select analysis of existing research which is relevant to your topic, showing how it relates.
“A change of heart about animals” By jeremy Rifkin
Negotiations and Second Language Acquisition Margaret Kersten SLaLS, Carleton University Ottawa, Canada Warsaw, June 2015.
On-demand writing. On-Demand Writing Purpose To provide students the opportunity to demonstrate independently the communication skills they have developed.
An Introduction. “An AP course in English Language and Composition engages students in becoming skilled readers of prose written in a variety of rhetorical.
Standards That Count: Reading, Discussion, Writing, and Presentation.
W R I T I N G M A T T E R S A workshop of the Hoosier Writing Project a site of the National Writing Project at IUPUI Herb Budden, Co-director.
ENGLISH The Analytical Research Project. What is the Analytical Research Project? The goal of The Analytical Research Project is to give you the.
 Florida Standards Assessment: Q & A with the State Literacy Department January Zone Meeting.
Integrating HOTS in Literature Instruction Overview of Literature Program ( Adapted from Online course) After reading this presentation, teachers will.
A Training for English Composition Teaching Assistants.
Academic Writing Skills: Paraphrasing and Summarising Activities and strategies to help students.
ENG 121 PAPERS Learn by Doing / eng121papers.com.

English as an Additional Language or Dialect 2014/21125 © 2014 School Curriculum and Standards Authority.
Writing Learning Outcomes Best Practices. Do Now What is your process for writing learning objectives? How do you come up with the information?
Essay Writing Tips for Writing Essays POL No Simple Answers… Unfortunately there is no simple answer to how to write an essay. However, there are.
Common Core.  Find your group assignment.  As a group, read over the descriptors for mastery of this standard. (The writing standards apply to more.
What do these mean? Your time is up Ready for anything (Red E)
Making Connections: guidance on non-exam assessment
Balanced Literacy How our instructional practices will support the implementation of Common Core.
ENG 147 Innovative Education- -snaptutorial.com
Your Inquiry Project
Socratic Conversation
Literacy Content Specialist, CDE
Big Idea 4: Synthesize Ideas — Moving from AP Seminar to AP Research
Writing Learning Outcomes
What you assess makes a statement about what you value
Class Format Review Essay #1, summary grading rubric: 6:45-7:00pm
Florida Standards Assessment:
Presentation transcript:

Paraphrasing in Context Innovations in Research and Pedagogy Casey KeckZuzana Tomaš San Francisco State UniversityUniversity of Utah

Why are new approaches needed? Paraphrasing instruction is typically done in a decontextualized fashion.  Example paraphrases are invented (i.e., they were not actually part of a larger academic text).  Example paraphrases are labeled as “good” or “unacceptable,” though there is no empirical basis for making such judgments.

Why are new approaches needed? Students are rarely shown paraphrases in the context of actual writing assignments. Teachers have a difficult time finding resources that discuss how and why writers paraphrase within specific genres or disciplines (Tomaš, to appear).

New Approaches to Research Text-based descriptions of the strategies students use when completing academic tasks (Campbell, 1990; Keck, 2006; Pecorari, 2003; Shi, 2004).

New Approaches to Research Investigation of factors that help to explain student strategy use (Keck, 2007; Shi, 2006, 2010):  Cultural and educational background  Language proficiency  Nature of the writing task  Disciplinary practices

New Approaches to Research Investigation of the cognitive and linguistic challenges students face when attempting to integrate source texts into their own writing (Tomaš, in preparation).

Important Research Findings Paraphrasing is a major academic writing strategy for university students (Campbell, 1990; Johns & Mayes, 1990; Keck, 2006; Pecorari, 2003; Shi, 2004). L1 and L2 writers Undergraduates and Graduates

Important Research Findings Paraphrasing is a far more frequent strategy than exact copying (Keck, 2006). Students often use 3 or more strategy types within a one-paragraph summary.  Near Copy  Minimal Revision  Moderate Revision  Substantial Revision

Important research findings Cultural background is only one of several factors that help to explain student strategy use (Keck, 2007; Shi, in press). Other important factors include:  Nature of the writing task  Educational experience  Disciplinary practices

Important research findings In sum, much of this work has helped us to rethink how we describe (or define) paraphrasing, as well as how we address this skill in writing courses.

New approaches to pedagogy Addressing paraphrasing in the context of academic writing tasks  Why might we paraphrase when writing a summary? An article response? A research paper?  How can we draw upon our knowledge of the text, the assignment, and our discipline when making strategy choices?

New approaches to pedagogy Complicating, rather than simplifying, the issue of plagiarism  What role does textual borrowing play in academic writing development? Can we identify “good” types of borrowing?  How do we distinguish effective borrowing from plagiarism? What criteria do we use to decide if a paraphrase is “acceptable” or not?

Examples of new approaches Tardy, C. M. (2010). Writing for the world: Wikipedia as an introduction to academic writing. English Teaching FORUM. Tomas, Z. (to appear). Paraphrase integration task: Increasing authenticity of practice in using academic sources. College Writer’s Toolkit. Keck, C. (to appear). How do university students attempt to avoid plagiarism? Writing & Pedagogy, themed issue on Plagiarism and the Academy.

An example unit Focus  Paraphrasing in the context of summary writing Context  Composition for Multilingual Students  Second Year Composition (ENG 310)  San Francisco State University

Summary Unit Components Diagnostic summary task Reading strategy instruction Writing strategy instruction Group composing Paraphrasing Revision of original summary Application to a new summary task

Diagnostic summary task  45-minute summary task  Read 1,000 word text  Write a one-paragraph summary Source texts  Newsweek editorial  “Where Have the Children Gone?”  Identifies problem, causes, and effects

Reading strategies  Re-reading(s) of the text  Group discussions of text structure and main ideas Strategies  Dividing text into sections  Annotation  Graphic organizers

Writing strategies  Guided drafting  Examples of useful summary expressions Strategies  Drafting main idea statements  Distinguishing main ideas from supporting details  Reporting verbs & transitions

Group composing  Putting all of the pieces together (main ideas, examples, reporting verbs, transitions) Strategies  Thinking aloud  Making selection and integration decisions

Paraphrasing  Paraphrase judgment task  Group composing, revisited Strategies  Developing criteria for judging paraphrase acceptability and quality  Reflecting on the function of paraphrases in a summary

Summary Assignment  Revise original summary from diagnostic task  Apply strategies to a new summary task (new source text)

Subsequent Assignments  Summary & Response  Paraphrasing focus: restating a claim made by the author, with appropriate agreement/disagreement language  Synthesis of Multiple Sources  Paraphrasing focus: note-taking, reporting research findings, in-text citation and reference lists

Culminating Assignments  Library research paper  Similar in format to Synthesis Paper, but students choose topic and sources.  In-class argumentative synthesis  Similar to Summary and Response, but students respond to and evaluate multiple texts written on the same topic.

Interested in reading more? Themed Issue of Writing & Pedagogy Plagiarism in the Academy Volume 2(2), 2010 To appear this summer

Thank You!! Casey KeckZuzana Tomaš San Francisco State UniversityUniversity of Utah