ABAF Meeting 24 September 2005 EU 8 th Directive – EU update Martin Manuzi ICAEW, Director, EU Office.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Embedding International Financial Reporting Standards to Promote Private Sector Growth Baku – May 17, 2005 Jody Campbell, Managing Partner, Ernst & Young.
Advertisements

Code of Ethics for Professional Accountants
The Corporate Laws Amendment Bill, B6/2006. © 2006 Deloitte Touche Tohmatsu Corporate Laws Amendment Bill, B6/2006 – 29 May 2006 Introduction Presenting.
Page 1 Non-Assurance Services Caroline Gardner IESBA June 2013 New York, USA.
IAASB CAG Meeting, April 8-9, 2013 Supplement to Agenda B
Standing for trust and integrity Perspectives of the European Accountancy Profession Olivier Boutellis-Taft FEE Chief Executive.
Context In the EU CSR strategy from October 2011 „A renewed EU strategy for Corporate Social Responsibility“, the EU Commission announced to „present.
Office of the Auditor General of Canada CANADA’S ADOPTION OF INTERNATIONAL STANDARDS ON AUDITING 20 FACTS PREPARERS of FINANCIAL STATEMENTS SHOULD KNOW.
Paola Lucantoni Financial Market Law and Regulation.
Breach of a Requirement of the Code Marisa Orbea New York 19 June 2012.
PwC David Devlin 23 April 2002 Auditor Independence in a Global Market Place.
Trinidad & Tobago Corporate Governance Code 2013
The global body for professional accountants COMMON ETHICAL ISSUES.
London, England 7-8 July 2011 International Congress on Professional and Occupational Regulation Workforce Planning and Entry to Practice Presenter: David.
Internal auditing for credit unions Nuala Comerford, Chair IIA Irish Region Committee Pamela McDonald Council Member IIA Credit Union Summer School Thursday,
World Bank SME Financial Reporting José Maria Bové FEE Vice-President, SME/SMP Matters Chairman, FEE SME/SMP Working Party.
EU Accounting and Audit Directives: Overview
REPARIS Project in Macedonia
Reforming the Audit Market European Commission November 30 th 2011.
ADB Project TA 3696-PAK, Regulation for Corporate Governance 1 REGULATION FOR CORPORATE GOVERNANCE IN PAKISTAN CAPITAL MARKETS.
Slide 1 The 8th Company Law Directive on Statutory Audit: Conditions for entry into the profession of auditing, mutual recognition and free movement of.
M. ANGELA JIMENEZ 1 UNIT 5. REGULATION OF EXTERNAL AUDIT IFAC AND E.C.
Nexia International Audit Forum Sharing our strengths to build quality.
Tax Services Provided to Audit Clients: PCAOB view and the report of the IFAC Tax Services Review Group IFAC SMP Permanent Task Force March 8, 2005 Prague.
International Auditing and Assurance Standards Board Communication with Those Charged with Governance ISA Implementation Support Module Prepared by IAASB.
© Securities Commission, Malaysia 1 What the Audit Oversight Board will do ICAA-MICPA Audit Forum 3 August 2010.
1 June 2000 Hong Kong Role of Disclosure in Strengthening Corporate Governance and Accountability Regulation of the Audit Profession Tsuguoki Fujinuma.
Revise Lecture 1 1. Framework of Financial Reporting 1. The regulatory system 2. A conceptual framework 2.
Communication with those charged with Governance
November 29, The Implementation of the 8th Directive Public Oversight in Hungary Katalin Fekete Vice President Hungarian Chamber of Auditors.
Slide 1 ADVANCED PROGRAM IN ACCOUNTING AND AUDITING REGULATION - MODULE 4 Auditing Regulation in the Acquis Communautaire Andrew J. Popham Chairman FEE.
Undertakings for collective investment in transferable securities (UCITS) Worldbank Global Development Learning Network The Advanced Program in Accounting.
Harmonization project CAS project group (Chair, Slovakia, European Court of Auditors) CAS meeting Batumi, Georgia 27th of September 2011.
Nexia International Network versus Association Requirements.
1 SECURITIES REGULATION: TRENDS AND CHALLENGES Washington D.C., April, 15 th 2003 Dr. Doğan CANSIZLAR Chairman of the Capital Markets Board of Turkey Chairman.
March 14, 2006 Vienna1 The Implementation of the 8th Directive in Hungary Katalin Fekete Vice President Hungarian Chamber of Auditors.
Slide 1 Accounting Education Requirements and Implementation of the EU Directive on Statutory Audit Wim Moleveld Education Subgroup of the Liberalization/Qualification.
ASEM IFRS SEMINAR Shanghai, March 2006 IFRS implementation in the EU – experience from a Commission perspective Ulf Linder Deputy Head of Unit Accounting.
Slide 1 ROAD TO EUROPE – PROGRAM OF ACCOUNTING REPORTING AND INSTITUTIONAL STRENGTHENING How can the European Federation of Accountants (FEE) Assist ?
Page 1 | Proprietary and Copyrighted Information The Australian framework Marisa Orbea IESBA Meeting New York April 2015.
Agreed Positions on Audit Policy. Taking audit policy forward  As needs of society, markets & stakeholders evolve, auditors have to reflect on their.
SLOVAKIA - 8th EU Directive Implementation 1 8th EU Company Law Directive - Slovakia case Ivan Bošela National Steering Committee, Vice-Chairman Slovak.
Slide 1 Federation des Experts Comptables Méditerranéens 4 th FCM Conference Capri, 3-4 May 2004 The Globalisation of Small and Medium-sized Enterprises.
International Accounting Standards An older set of standards stating how particular types of transactions and other events should be reflected in financial.
Vienna 14 March 2006 Andrew J. Popham Vice-President of FEE Partner, PricewaterhouseCoopers LLP The New Directive on Statutory Audit in the EU.
Page 1 | Proprietary and Copyrighted Information Structure of the Code Don Thomson, Task Force Chair IESBA Meeting New York, USA September 15-16, 2015.
EU Politics CHAPTER 13: Other Institutions. Outline 1) European Economic and Social Committee (EESC) 2) Committee of the Regions (CoR) 3) European Agencies.
Rahandusministeerium Adopting, Implementing, and Enforcing the Aquis Communautaire Relating to Auditing – Lessons Learned Veiko Tali
Module 16: International Standards on Auditing Implementing ISA Lessons learned in the Czech Republic Petr Kriz 17 January 2006.
Slide 1 World Bank Conference on Proposed Regional Initiative to Strengthen Auditing & Accounting in South East Europe Brussels, 30 June 2004 David Devlin.
ICAJ/PAB - Improving Compliance with International Standards on Auditing Planning an audit of financial statements 19 July 2014.
Corporate Sector Accounting and Auditing within the Acquis Communautaire Mr. Frederic Gielen Senior Financial Management Specialist Europe and Central.
Improving Compliance with ISAs Presenters: Al Johnson & Pat Hayle.
TAIEX-REGIO Workshop on Applying the Partnership Principle in the European Structural and Investment Funds Bratislava, 20/05/2016 Involvement of Partners.
MINISTERIAL CONFERENCE The Road to Europe – Program of Accounting Reform and Institutional Strengthening Vienna 16 March 2005 “Contribution of the Accounting.
Auditing & Investigations I
IIASA Governance Review
Auditing & Investigations II
REPARIS Workshop Vienna
Public Oversight of the Audit Profession David DEVLIN President
Jacek Gdański Accounting Department
International Conference of the Slovak Chamber of Auditors
Alignment of Part 4B with ISAE 3000
IESBA Meeting Athens, Greece June, 2018
Supervision of Financial Reporting
OBJECTIVE AND GENERAL PRINCIPLES GOVERNING AN AUDIT OF FINANCIAL STATEMENTS Lecture 2.
« Eighth » Company Law Directive Statutory Audit
Financial Reporting Policy
IESBA Meeting Nashville June 17-19, 2019
IAASB – IESBA Coordination Fees Proposals by IESBA
Presentation transcript:

ABAF Meeting 24 September 2005 EU 8 th Directive – EU update Martin Manuzi ICAEW, Director, EU Office

Overview of EU issues EU 8 th Directive on Statutory Auditing Independence/Auditor Liability/Network definition/Transparency Professional Qualifications/Services Directives 4 th and 7 th Company Law Directives IFRS implementation in Europe

8 th Directive: introduction Most comprehensive single EU legislative initiative to impact on audit profession 8 th Directive no longer a sufficient title High degree of harmonisation – but not full harmonisation: Member State options Context is perceived need for greater confidence in audit function EU regards this legislation as critical to the success of its regulatory dialogue with US

8 th Directive: Co-decision timetable Council general approach Dec 2004 EP plenary session was due in September but now October If approved on ‘first reading’, final implementation date middle of 2008 No further changes to text now proposed, i.e. we are almost there BUT institutional issue on comitology (not unique to 8 th Directive) has caused delays

8 th Directive: Comitology Essential for implementation of 8 th Directive: endorsement of standards, liaison with third country auditors, independence EP wants“call back” clause giving Parliament 3 months to review implementing measures Problem exacerbated by European Constitution vote UK Presidency high priority Solution appears to have been found for CAD

8 th Directive: specific issues (1) Ownership and management control Qualification, continuous education, mutual recognition Auditing standards/reporting: ISAs (endorsed by EU technical committee) Quality assurance – independent of reviewed auditor, funding of system free of undue auditor influence, subject to public oversight

8 th Directive: Specific issues (2) Public oversight bodies- profession must be in minority. EU coordination of oversight bodies: key feature International aspects (i.e. recognition of third country auditors) Special provisions for public interest entities (PIES) and audit thereof. Definition of PIEs left ultimately to Member States: “… for instance entities that are of significant public relevance because of the nature of their business, their size or the number of their employees.” Audit committees (or comparable bodies) for PIEs

8 th Directive: Issues of particular interest Independence overall and Independence for PIEs - most discussed articles Liability - not included in original EC proposal but now very much on agenda Network definition Transparency report

8 th Directive: Independence (1) Article 22. Includes: “Member States shall ensure that a statutory auditor (…) shall not carry out a statutory audit if there is any direct or indirect financial, business, employment or other relationship between the statutory auditor, audit firm OR THE NETWORK – including the provision of additional non-audit services – and the audited entity from which an objective, reasonable and informed third party would conclude that the statutory auditor’s (..) independence is compromised”

8 th Directive: Independence (2) Significant threats to be documented, safeguards to be applied. If safeguards insufficient: audit must not be carried out. Huge debate over Article 22 whether to include additional paragraph: “Member States may set additional conditions to this Article, such as on the scope of the activities that auditors and audit firms may carry out.” Debate “resolved” through two means

8 th Directive: Independence (3) First solution = Additional requirements for auditors of PIEs. Auditor rotation (internal but external also permitted) Annual written confirmation to audit committee of independence from audited entity Annual disclosure to audit committee of any additional services to audited entity Obligation to discuss with audit committee existing threats and use of safeguards to mitigate them Prohibition of auditor/key partner taking up management role in audited entity for two years

8 th Directive: Independence (4) Second solution= opens way for more radical approach on prohibitions Article 52a: “The Member State requiring the statutory audit can impose more stringent requirements, unless otherwise indicated in the text of the Directive.” ….Independence debate certain to continue. Forum likely to be comitology as this will deal with implementation measures

8 th Directive: auditor liability Specific Article in the Directive requiring an economic study including an objective analysis of limitation of financial liability and a report to EP with, if appropriate, recommendations to member states EC study and Forum: Challenge for profession to contribute as much as possible to the study. (UK commitment to proportionality)

8 th Directive: Network Definition (1) Article 2: "Network" means the larger structure : - which is aimed at cooperation to which a statutory auditor or an audit firm belongs, and; - which is clearly aimed at profit or cost sharing or shares common ownership, control or management, common quality control policies and procedures, common business strategy, the use of a common brand-name, or a significant part of professional resources;

8 th Directive: Network definition (2) Importance in relation to independence requirements: In addition to Article 22, Recital 10: “In order to determine the independence of auditors, the concept of “network” in which auditors operate needs to be clear. In this regard, various circumstances have to be taken into account such as instances where a structure could be defined as a network because it is aimed at profit or cost sharing, which may also be demonstrated if statutory auditors and/or audit firms have common usual [audit] clients. The criteria for demonstrating that there is a network should be judged and weighed on the basis of all factual circumstances known to exist.”

8 th Directive: Transparency (1) In relation to auditors of PIEs: Obligatory requirement of annual transparency report: Among the items to disclose: ownership/legal structure, internal control, financial information, fees by services, independence practices… Member States may add other items…

8 th Directive: Transparency (2) Specific requirement in relation to networks: “where the audit firm belongs to a network, a description of the network and the legal and structural arrangements in the network”. One audit firm auditing one PIE in one Member State would trigger this requirement.

8 th Directive: More on networks The inclusion of the definition would appear to have wider relevance than independence Network definition is also a global issue: IFAC consultation (closes 30 September) FEE study on networks – on reality of networks, not definitions. Trans-national aspects of accounting/auditing firms likely to be re-visited (Single Market policy) Perceptions and disclaimers: can they co-exist?

Professional Qualifications/Services Directive New Recognition of Professional Qualifications Directive adopted -introduces form of cross-border service provisions (modified country of origin concept) Services Directive: proposed amendments. Small impact on accountants. EC Competition work on professions

4 th and 7 th Company Law Directives Another “confidence in reporting” initiative Proposal undergoing co-decision procedure. EP position unclear: divergent views Off-balance transactions: all companies to disclose material arrangements Collective responsibility of boards Corporate governance statement – as part of annual reports Internal control (start of major EU activity?) Rise in thresholds? – to ensure only appropriate companies fall within remit. Audit/assurance debate

IFRS IAS Regulation of 2002 now being implemented Growing interest in IFRS consistency – US influence (SEC/EU Roadmap) Possibility of new Forum (implications for IFRIC?) Re-structuring of DG Internal Market What future for EFRAG?

Conclusion Major implications arising from EU activity for the profession! Further information available from: Tel