Birthweight & Childhood Leukaemia: Results from pooled analyses Tracy Lightfoot Epidemiology & Cancer Statistics Unit Department of Health Sciences University of York
In utero origins of leukaemia Evidence childhood leukaemia originates in utero. Chromosomal translocations such as t(12;21), t(4;11), or t(8;21) are found at birth in children who later develop leukaemia. Indicative that prenatal exposures may be important in leukaemogenesis
Aetiology of childhood leukaemia Known risk factors –Age –Sex –Trisomy 21
Aetiology of childhood leukaemia Known risk factors –Age –Sex –Trisomy 21 Consistent observations –Genetic variants IKZF1(7p12.2), CDKN2A/CDKN2B(9p21), ARID5B(10q21.2), CEBPE(14q11.2) –Heavy birthweight (> 3500, 4000 or 4500g)
Previous meta-analysis 18 studies conducted between children ALL cases OR 1.26 (95% CI ) (≥4,000 g vs. <4,000 g) 14% increase in risk of ALL per 1000g increase in birthweight
Additional observations Findings similar for B-cell ALL and T-cell ALL and individuals subtypes (Hjalgrim et al., 2004; O’Neil et al., 2012) –Suggest determinants are not risk factors for a specific type of ALL Children with ALL have the same birthweight as their siblings ( Hjalgrim et al., 2004 and Smith et al., 2010 )
Questions still to answer? What’s the relationship between ALL and fetal growth across the gestational age spectrum? What’s the relative importance of a baby’s absolute weight/size at birth versus the rate of fetal growth?
Potential issues….. Rare events: ALL accounts for less than 0.5% of all incident cancers Less than 1% of live births weighing < 1500g, and only 1- 3% weight above 4500g. Most investigations concentrate on high birthweight, either dichotomizing their data (e.g. <4000g versus ≥ 4000g) or using relatively conservative cut-points (e.g. <2500g, g, ≥ 4000g). Self-reported data: Many of the case-control studies on this topic have relied on birth characteristics reported by mothers at interview, (potential for maternal recall bias)
Recent studies Pooled analyses from Germany, UK and USA – started 2001 – published 2013 –4075 cases and controls Pooled analyses from CLIC –Started 2009 – published 2013 –7348 cases and controls (12 studies) 1680 cases and 3139 controls POBW
USA UK Germany ControlsCases ControlsCases ControlsCases N (%) Total Gender Boys Girls Age at diagnosis (years) Maternal age birth (years) < ≥ Birth order ≥
USA UK Germany ControlsCases ControlsCases ControlsCases N (%) Total Type of delivery Vaginal Caesarian Gestational age (weeks) < > Birth weight (kg) < >
Individual countries and pooled birthweight distributions
US, UK and Germany pooled birth weight distribution by gestational age
Birthweight Number (%) Adjusted OR † (95% CI) Adjusted OR ‡ (95% CI) ControlsCases Grams ≤ (0.5) 5 (0.1) 0.3 ( )0.2 ( ) (0.9) 38 (1.0) 1.2 ( )0.8 ( ) (3.6) 111 (2.9) 0.8 ( )0.7 ( ) (14.8) 494 (12.7) 0.9( ) (37.7) 1393 (35.9) } (31.3) 1279 (32.9) (9.3) 460 (11.9) 1.2 ( ) ≥ (1.9) 103 (2.6) 1.2 ( ) P< Birthweight and ALL
Birthweight Number (%) Adjusted OR † (95% CI) Adjusted OR ‡ (95% CI) ControlsCases Gestational age <37 weeks < (9.8) 10 (4.6) 0.5 ( ) (10.2)24 (11.1) 1.0 ( )1.0 ( ) (60.1)131 (60.4) (9.1)22 (10.1) 1.2 ( ) ≥ (10.9)30 (13.8) 1.6 ( )1.6 ( ) Per kg increase 1.4 ( ) weeks < (9.9)184 (7.0) 0.8 ( ) (10.0)234 (8.9) 0.9 ( )0.9 ( ) (59.8)1573 (59.8) (9.9)281 (10.7) 1.0 ( ) ≥ (10.5)358 (13.6) 1.2 ( )1.2 ( ) Per kg increase 1.2 ( )1.2 ( ) >40 weeks < (9.6)88 (8.5) 1.0 ( ) (8.7)90 (8.7) 1.2 ( ) (61.0)580 (56.0) (9.9)120 (11.6) 1.2 ( ) ≥ (10.8)158 (15.3) 1.5 ( )1.5 ( ) Per kg increase 1.3 ( )
Study population Children (≤ 15 years) registered for primary care with a General Practitioner (GP) Cases - ascertained from multiple sources Treating/referring hospitals Cross-checks with cancer registries Controls – 2 per case from primary care population registers, individually matched on:- date of birth sex UKCCS region of residence Linked to primary care and maternity records, registration and census data, birth and death certificates for all cases and controls irrespective of participation in the study
UK BWT interview versus birth certificates
Gestational Age
Gestational age
UK control data Birth weight (grams) E & W,1988 UKCCS Unadjusted ORs (95% CI) Live births ControlsCases UKCCS cases versus UKCCS Controls UKCCS cases Versus E & W Controls N= 693,577 (%) N=6337 (%)N=1366 (%) < (0.9) 29 (0.5)0 } 0.6 ( ) } 0.5 ( ) (1.3) 88 (1.4) 16 (1.2) (4.4) 285 (4.5) 59 (4.3) 1.0 ( ) 1.0 ( ) (17.2) 1049 (16.6) 210 (15.4) 1.0 ( ) 0.9 ( ) (37.7) 2380 (37.6) 497 (36.4) (28.7) 1838 (29.0) 415 (30.4) 1.1 ( ) 1.1 ( ) (8.6) 583 (9.2) 135 (9.9) 1.1( ) 1.2 ( ) ≥ (1.4) 85 (1.3) 34 (2.5) 1.9( ) 1.9 ( )
Summary Children with ALL were, on average, heavier than controls at all gestations Overall, a 1.2 (95% CI ) increase in ALL risk per kg increase in birthweight was observed –driven by a deficit of low-birthweight at all gestations and an excess of high-birthweight at ≥ 40 weeks. Stable relationship within age strata (< 1, 1-4, 5-9 and years) is noteworthy and is in accord with other studies that have presented age-specific data. –Confirms association with size at birth is not restricted to infants, as had originally been suggested
Conclusions Importance of looking across full birthweight spectrum when examining associations with disease risk. For the first time identified marked paucity of very low-birthweight babies (< 1500g) among ALL cases at all gestational ages; –given in-utero origins of ALL presence of disease at birth could act to increase perinatal mortality in this immature and vulnerable group?
Map of Childhood Leukemia Studies participating in CLIC ,10, , Pooled analysis : California State, USA, COG, USA, Canada; Brazil; UK, France (x3), Germany; Greece, Australia, New Zealand.
Fetal growth and childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia: LGA v AGA OR % CI ( )
Total N 1 Cases/Controls Cases N LGA/AGA Controls N LGA/AGA OR95% CI Overall 7,292/12,406988/5,6701,398/9, , 1.32 Birth weight <4,000g 6,394/11,077297/5,463408/9, , 1.48 Sex Males4,106/6,905552/3,192782/5, , 1.33 Females3,186/5,501436/2,478616/4, , 1.43 Age at diagnosis /1,44776/521154/1, , 1.44 >1-54,075/6,087559/3,178712/4, , 1.35 >52,581/4,872353/1,971532/3, , 1.46 Ethnicity White/European/Caucasian6,042/10,858812/4,7471,232/8, , 1.30 Other1,250/ /9231,66/1, , 1.83 Immunophenotype B-lineage cases5,735/12,406771/4,4561,398/9, , 1.33 T-lineage cases705/12,406105/5461,398/9, , 1.64
Proportion of Optimal Birthweight Takes into account mothers height (cm), birthorder, sex, birthweight (g) and gestational age
Fetal growth and childhood acute lymphoblastic leukemia: POBW OR % CI ( )
SubgroupN Cases/controlsPooled OR 2 95% CI Overall1,689/3, , 1.24 Birth weight <4,000g1,467/2, , 1.31 Sex of child 3 Males954/1, , 1.21 Females735/1, , 1.34 Age at diagnosis (years) / , 1.37 >1-5971/1, , 1.27 >5539/1, , 1.31 Ethnic Group 5 White/European/Caucasian1,281/2, , 1.23 Other408/ , 1.39 Immunophenotype B-lineage cases1,400/3, , 1.24 T-lineage cases161/3, , 1.43
Summary Accelerated fetal growth associated with increased risk of ALL irrespective of high birth weight. Effect consistent whether using categorical or continuous measure of growth.
Mechanisms??????? Links with other childhood/adults cancers ↑ IGF1 levels –Drives pre-leukaemic cells towards leukemogenesis –Pre-leukaemic cells have higher IGF-1 levels leading to higher birthweight Not supported by sibling birthweight observations Factors governing IGF levels e.g. PAPP-A In utero levels of estrogens Increased numbers of stem cells ???????????????????
Acknowledgements Eve Roman Alex Smith Michele R Forman Martha S Linet Les Robison Jill Simpson Peter Kaatsch Kathrine Grell Kirsten Frederiksen Joachim Schüz Clinicians/Health Professionals Funders Families… Elizabeth Milne Kathryn R. Greenop Catherine Metayer Eleni Petridou Maria S. Pombo-de-Oliveira Claire Infante-Rivard John D. Dockerty Logan Spector Sérgio Koifman Laurent Orsi Jérémie Rudant Nick Dessypris Margarita Baka Alessandra Faro Bruce K. Armstrong Jacqueline Clavel Patricia A. Buffler