Rogelio, Ma. GracielaSalcedo, Von Edward Roque, Marianne Saldana, Emanuel Ruanto, Ma. TheresaSales, Ma. Stephanie Sabalvaro, Dyan KristelSalonga, Cryscel.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
MEDICAL ETHICS TT Wong THE FOUR PRINCIPLES.
Advertisements

Ethical Considerations in Home Visiting
Defining a Moral Problem Samantha Mei-che Pang RN, PhD School of Nursing The Hong Kong Polytechnic University.
Autonomy and Beneficence.  Right to make one’s own choices  Respect for persons- not to interfere with choice of another, though persuasion permitted.
Informed Consent: Requirements Ben Faneye, OP, DHCE West African Bioethics Training Program.
Medical Ethics Lecturer :Noha Alaggad
The principles In Medical Ethics Lecturer :Noha Alaggad
Introduction to basic principles
Ethics and Professionalism Prof MAM Ibnouf. Aims : الأهداف 1- To define medical ethics 2- To provide examples of ethical clinical practice 1- تعريف الأخلاق.
Ethical and Legal Implications of Practice Chapter 5.
The Chaplain as Spiritual Guide in Ethics Consults 2006.
Medical Ethics. Medical Ethics [vs. Professional ethics]  Ethical dilemma is a predicament in which there is no clear course to resolve the problem of.
Principles of medical ethics Lecture (4) Dr. rawhia Dogham.
Medical Decision Making Nuala Kenny SC, OC, MD, FRCP Department of Bioethics (post-rtd) Dalhousie University, Halifax, NS Ethics & Health Policy Advisor.
Autonomy: Respect for Persons, Decision-making Capacity, & Informed Consent Walter Limehouse MD MUSC Ethics Committee Chair.
Legal Term Review. confidential Private or secret.
Proxy Consent. Civil code of the Philippines Competency of minors  Art. 38. Minority, insanity or imbecility, the state of being a deaf-mute, prodigality.
REGULATION OF HEALTH PRACTICE Prof Ames Dhai. Introduction Constitution Statutes (Acts of Parliament) Common Law Criminal.
Medical Law and Ethics Lesson 2: Patient/Physician Relationship.
Dr Mike Ewart Smith Division of Psychiatry, University of Witwatersrand The Ethics of Informed Consent: Revisiting the Doctor Patient Relationship.
Ethics and End-of-Life Care Part 2: Autonomy and Futility Michael Wassenaar, PhD February 9, 2012.
1 Patients without Spokespersons Ethics Champions Program January 6, 2010 John F. Wallenhorst, Ph.D. Vice President, Mission & Ethics Bon Secours Health.
Copyright © 2012 Wolters Kluwer Health | Lippincott Williams & Wilkins Textbook for Nursing Assistants Chapter 4: Legal and Ethical Issues.
ETHICS Basics.
Established in 1996 to enforce standards for electronic health information & enhance the security and privacy of health information.
Dr. Ihab Nada DOE, MSKMC.  The information a patient reveals to a health care provider is private and has limits on how and when it can be disclosed.
Research Profession and Practice ETHICS IN ADVANCED PREHOSPITAL CARE.
Legal and Ethical Issues Counseling Children. Child and Adolescent Clients Counselors who work with children and adolescents under the age of 18 may experience.
In 1987 The Ontario government passed this Bill of Rights to make sure that Long Term Care facilities are truly HOME to the people who live in them.
“What happened to dear PK, he is our idol? Why was a CT done? What was the result of the procedures?” – “Since the people who texted you were your friends,
Confidentiality Toby L. Schonfeld, Ph.D. Department of Preventive and Societal Medicine
1 ETHICS. 2 ETHICS AND PROFESSIONAL BEHAVIOR Ethics: Standards of conduct for a profession Some issues cannot be handled by codes alone Courts may decide.
MEDICAL ETHICS and The End of Life. PRIMA FACIE DUTIES AUTONOMY BENEFICENCE NON - MALEFICENCE JUSTICE UTILITY.
Copyright © 2012 Brooks/Cole, a division of Cengage Learning, Inc. Professional Concerns Chapter Nine.
THOMPSON & HENDERSON (2011): CHAPTER 4 Legal and Ethical Considerations for Counselors.
FIDUCIARY LAW  STATUS RELATIONSHIP  DISPARITY POWER & NEED  DISPARITY OF POWER & NEED  VOLUNTARY UNDERTAKING  TRUST GIVEN BY ONE  CARE PROMISED BY.
Legal Terminology Biomedical Technology Legal implications in health care  Malpractice: harmful, incorrect, or negligent practice or treatment of a.
Ethical AND legal issues in GENETICS. objective 1- introduction. 2-major needs in study of ethics. 3-Ethical Principles in Medicine. 4-The Special Position.
12/24/2015Miss Samah Ishtieh1 Managerial Ethics Patient Rights & Nursing Ethics Prepared by: Miss Samah Ishtieh.
MEDICAL ETHICS and The End of Life. ETHICAL THEORIES DEONTOLOGY CONSEQUENTIALISM VIRTUE ETHICS.
Chapter 24 Ethical Obligations and Accountability Fundamentals of Nursing: Standards & Practices, 2E.
An act is moral if it brings more good consequences than bad ones. What is the action to be evaluated? What would be the good consequences? How certain.
Unit: Ethical and Legal.   Client Autonomy  The right of patients to make decisions about their medical care without their health care provider trying.
By Dr Rukhsana Hussain 2011 Confidentiality GMC guidance.
Universal Principles of Biomedical Ethics
LEGAL AND ETHICAL ISSUES IN HEALTH SCIENCE Andrew Angel and Jody Mr. Peters 8 th period.
Unit 4 Seminar. Key Terms  Confidentiality  Privileged communication  Privacy.
Conflict B Sacha worked as a journalist before she became a social worker. She still writes articles for a human interest magazine. She finds that she.
Sharing Personal Data ‘What you need to know’ Corporate Information Governance Team Strategic Intelligence.
0 Ethics Lecture Essentials of Informed Consent. ACADEMY OF OPHTHALMOLOGY The speaker has no financial interest in the subject matter.
UNITS 4:3-4:4 Patients’ Rights and Legal Directives for Health Care.
Key Knowledge Confidentiality Year 4 Medical Ethics and Law Thread Course The Ethox Centre, University of Oxford.
Medical Ethics  A set of guidelines concerned with questions of right & wrong, of duty & obligation, of moral responsibility.  Ethical dilemma is a.
Principles of medical ethics Lecture (4) Dr. HANA OMER.
Disclaimer This presentation is intended only for use by Tulane University faculty, staff, and students. No copy or use of this presentation should occur.
LEGAL ISSUES COMMON IN NURSING PRACTICE PRESENT BY: DR. AMIRA YAHIA.
Legal Responsibilities. Relationship between HCP & pt is contractual: Relationship between HCP & pt is contractual: Implies everyone agrees to do something.
ETHICAL ISSUES IN HEALTH AND NURSING PRACTICE CODE OF ETHICS, STANDARDS OF CONDUCT, PERFORMANCE AND ETHICS FOR NURSES AND MIDWIVES.
Dr.Amira Yahia, Ph.D (N), M.Sc (N), B.Sc (N).  By the end of this session the student will be able to:  Define some terms related to ethic  Explain.
Patient Care & Ethical Dilemmas
Ethical dimension of nursing and health care
Kids' legal rights in medical care, your obligations and risk minimisation 27 April 2017.
Chapter 2 Ethical and Legal Issues
Informed Consent to Treatment
بنام خداوند جان و خرد كزين برتر انديشه بر نگذرد
Chapter 13: Ethics and Law
Client’s Rights & Choices
MEDICAL ETHICS TT Wong.
Presentation transcript:

Rogelio, Ma. GracielaSalcedo, Von Edward Roque, Marianne Saldana, Emanuel Ruanto, Ma. TheresaSales, Ma. Stephanie Sabalvaro, Dyan KristelSalonga, Cryscel Anne Salac, Carmina NinaSan Diego, Phoebe Salazar, JanelleSan Pedro, Regina Salazar, RiccelSanez, John Ericson 1

Objectives:  To present the case  To enumerate the ethical issues / problems of the case  To enumerate the ethical principles violated  To enumerate the ethical principles upheld  To give recommendations regarding the case 2

Objectives:  To present the case  To enumerate the ethical issues / problems of the case  To enumerate the ethical principles violated  To enumerate the ethical principles upheld  To give recommendations regarding the case 3

CASE 3  PK, a celebrity singer was driving at fast speed at EDSA when he hit a 10 wheeler truck with no tail lights. His car turned turtle several times. He was brought to the hospital emergency room where an x-ray examination revealed multiple rib fractures and a major fracture in the thigh.  He was referred to Radiology for a multiple slice chest CT to rule out fat embolism. You were the radiology resident assigned in the Section who assisted the procedure. 4

CASE 3  Your friends in the hospital texted and called you to ask: “What happened to dear PK, he is our idol?” Why was a CT done? What was the result of the procedures?”  Since the people who texted you were your friends, co-residents and co- healthcare workers in the hospital, you texted back what happened to PK. 5

Objectives:  To present the case  To enumerate the ethical issues / problems of the case  To enumerate the ethical principles violated  To enumerate the ethical principles upheld  To give recommendations regarding the case 6

“What happened to dear PK, he is our idol? Why was a CT done? What was the result of the procedures?” “Since the people who texted you were your friends, co-residents and co-healthcare workers in the hospital, you texted back what happened to PK.” 7

 Medical professionals did not preserve the principle of confidentiality. This was exemplified when: Other medical professionals (co-residents and co- healthcare) who are not part of the attending medical team inquired regarding the status and well-being of a private patient. The attending radiologist disclosed private information by texting back. 8

 Physicians have a prima facie obligation to preserve confidentiality, but such prima facie duties can be overridden for weighty reasons and not just by mere curiosity.  When confidentiality is breached, no matter what the weight of the argument, physicians are blameworthy… Reference: Textbook of Healthcare Ethics 2 nd ed. 9

 Breaching a confidence and violating a trust are not now, nor can they ever be, “good” things. But they can, on the grounds of harm and benefit to others, be a better, and often far better, alternative than passively allowing great harm to occur. Reference: Textbook of Healthcare Ethics 2 nd ed. 10

 Medical profession holds confidentiality of the patient-physician relationship is recognized in the current Code of Medical Ethics of the American Medical Association: In most states, either by statute or case law, disclosure of medical information is prohibited without consent of the patient. One state court, after observing that the privacy right of patients warrants constitutional protection, ruled that patients must be able to secure medical services without fear of betrayal and unwarranted embarrassing and detrimental disclosure of private information. The same court added that the obligation of medical confidentiality relative to patient records and information applies not only to physicians but to hospitals as well. Reference: Smith and Berlin, Malpractice Issues in Radiology; AJR 2001; 176:

 Radiologists should take reasonable care to keep status confidential, with access provided only to those health care professionals involved in the patient's care.  Reasonable care requires, at a minimum, adherence to all applicable laws and institutional guidelines, as well as observance of commonsense precautions such as limiting medical record access in potentially sensitive cases. Reference: Smith and Berlin, Malpractice Issues in Radiology; AJR 2001; 176:

 The nature of confidentiality obligation is to ensure that the information is seen only by those who need to see it in the patient’s interest.  If others wish to have access to this information for other purposes, for instance for research, they may access and use it with patient’s consent, or at least receive it only in an anonymous form. Reference: R E Ashcroft, MA, PhD & P R Goddard, MD, FRCR; Ethical Issues in Teleradiology; The British Journal of Radiology, 73 (2000),

 As physicians, radiologists have both a legal and an ethical responsibility to respect patient confidentiality.  The radiologist’s relationship with a patient ranges from interpreting a radiograph, in which case there is usually no direct contact, to performing a diagnostic or interventional study, where one does have some degree of direct contact with the patient. The patient’s right to confidentiality is the same, no matter what the depth of the doctor-patient relationship.  Unauthorized disclosure to third parties and discussion of a patient’s disease in public areas of the hospital are breaches of confidentiality against which all physicians must constantly be on guard. Reference: Douglas L. Brown, MD. Patient Confidentiality in Radiology. Department of Radiology, Brigham and Women’s Hospital, Harvard Medical School 75 Francis Street, Boston, MA

Section 6. The physician should hold as sacred and highly confidential whatever may be discovered or learned pertinent to the patient even after death, except when required in the promotion of justice, safety and public health. Reference: CODE OF ETHICS OF THE PHILIPPINE MEDICAL ASSOCIATION 15

Objectives:  To present the case  To enumerate the ethical issues / problems of the case  To enumerate the ethical principles violated  To enumerate the ethical principles upheld  To give recommendations regarding the case 16

CONFIDENTIALITY  Shows a respect for an individual's autonomy and their right to control the information relating to their own health. In keeping information about the patient’s secret the doctor is acting beneficently. Disclosing information without the patient's consent can damage the patient. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 17

CONFIDENTIALITY  Confidentiality is not an ethical principle in itself. It can be characterized as a duty by some health professionals.  It involves a respect for autonomy and also beneficence towards the patient and a desire to act non-maleficently.  Breaking confidentiality to protect the safety of a third party is seen as reasonable. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 18

DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION 1) Where serious harm may occur to a third party, whether or not a criminal offence, e.g. threat of serious harm to a named person. 2) Where a doctor believes a patient to be the victim of abuse and the patient is unable to give or withhold consent to disclose. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 19

DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION 3) Where, without disclosure a doctor would not be acting in the overall best interests of a child or young person who is his/her patient and incapable of consenting to disclosure. 4) When, without disclosure the task of preventing or detecting a serious crime by the police would be prejudiced or delayed. 5) When, without disclosure the task of prosecuting a serious crime would be prejudiced or delayed (e.g. a patient tells you that he killed someone several years ago). Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 20

DISCLOSURE OF INFORMATION 6) Where a doctor has a patient who is a health professional and has concerns over that person’s fitness to practice and posing a serious danger to patients in his or her care. 7) Where a doctor has concerns over a patient’s fitness to drive. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 21

CONFIDENTIALITY For instance if a doctor were to reveal privileged information about a celebrity patient to the newspapers then this would be the very reverse of beneficent i.e. maleficent. Maintaining confidentiality can therefore also be seen as non-maleficent. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 22

BENEFICENCE  “First principle" of morality, the dictum "do good and avoid evil“  Is a "middle principle" insofar as it is partially dependent for its content on how one defines the concepts of the good and goodness. As a middle principle, beneficence is not a specific moral rule and cannot by itself tell us what concrete actions constitute doing good and avoiding evil. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 23

BENEFICENCE  Principle of beneficence in the Catholic tradition are: 1) Never deliberately kill innocent human life (which, in the medical context, must be distinguished from foregoing disproportionate means). 2) Never deliberately (directly intend) harm. 3) Seek the patient’s good. 4) Act out of charity and justice. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 24

BENEFICENCE 5) Respect the patient’s religious beliefs and value system in accord with the principle of religious freedom. 6) Always seek the higher good, that is, never neglect one good except to pursue a proportionately greater or more important good. 7) Never knowingly commit or approve an objectively evil action. 8) Do not treat others paternalistically but help them to pursue their goals. 9) Use wisdom and prudence in all things, that is, appreciate the complexity of life and make sound judgments for the good of oneself, others, and the common good. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 25

NON-MALEFICENCE  Primum non nocere, commonly translated as "first, do no harm," is often considered to be a corollary to the principle of beneficence.  In this respect, it shares the same characteristics of beneficence considered as a middle principle.  It is sometimes interpreted to imply that if one cannot do good without also causing harm, then one should not act at all. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 26

Objectives:  To present the case  To enumerate the ethical issues / problems of the case  To enumerate the ethical principles violated  To enumerate the ethical principles upheld  To give recommendations regarding the case 27

INFORMED CONSENT  It is the right and responsibility of every competent individual to advance his or her own welfare.  This right and responsibility is exercised by freely and voluntarily consenting or refusing consent to recommended medical procedures, based on a sufficient knowledge of the benefits, burdens, and risks involved. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 28

INFORMED CONSENT  The ability to give informed consent depends on: 1) Adequate disclosure of information 2) Patient freedom of choice 3) Patient comprehension of information 4) Patient capacity for decision-making Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 29

INFORMED CONSENT  By meeting these four requirements, three necessary conditions are satisfied: 1) That the individual’s decision is voluntary 2) That this decision is made with an appropriate understanding of the circumstances 3) That the patient’s choice is deliberate insofar as the patient has carefully considered all of the expected benefits, burdens, risks and reasonable alternatives. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 30

INFORMED CONSENT  Legally, adequate disclosure includes information concerning the following: 1) Diagnosis 2) Nature and purpose of treatment 3) Risks of treatment 4) Treatment alternatives Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 31

INFORMED CONSENT  Depending on the circumstances, consent may take on two other forms. 1. In cases where individuals are brought to the hospital in an unconscious state or with no decision-making capacity, consent can be presumed, provided that the procedures performed are necessary and cannot be postponed until the person has regained consciousness or decision- making capacity. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 32

INFORMED CONSENT 2. It also may happen that a surgeon sees the critical need of more extensive surgery in the course of an operation. In these circumstances, there may be no time to contact the spouse, parents or surrogate of the unconscious patient. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 33

INFORMED CONSENT VICARIOUS CONSENT For incompetent or incapacitated individuals, this right and duty of the patient to give consent is to be exercised on his or her behalf by a surrogate. It is regulated by individual state and federal laws, following various standards of surrogate decision-making, including substituted judgment and best interests. Reference: Healthcare Ethics. 34

Objectives:  To present the case  To enumerate the ethical issues / problems of the case  To enumerate the ethical principles violated  To enumerate the ethical principles upheld  To give recommendations regarding the case 35

Breach of the principles of medical ethics would eventually result to bad doctor-patient relationship and possible legal sanctions. 36

BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: ♣ Reprimand and give penalty to the resident for disclosing confidential information. ♣ Assess the damage: gather all the co- residents and healthcare workers who were texted, and determine the extent of news leakage. 37

♣ Make sure that the leaked information is truthful and accurate, with correct interpretation of the imaging results. ♣ The resident should tell the patient the truth regarding the leaked information, and apologize for the breached confidentiality. BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: 38

♣ If the extent of leakage has reached the general public, try to work with the patient to arrange a press conference on how he wants the issue to be dealt with. Remember to always protect the right and dignity of the patient. BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: 39

♣ If the patient wants to sue or take legal actions, try to work out first the best possible arrangements that would still maintain the reputation of the hospital. Due compensation could be given. BIOETHICS COMMITTEE: 40

41