Modeling & Simulation What can they offer? March 28, 2012 Ottawa, ON Waiting Time Management Strategies for Scheduled Health Care Services: A Workshop.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Booking & Choice Colin Innes Executive Lead Choose and Book.
Advertisements

Operations Strategy Capacity Strategy.
Chapter 15: Quantitatve Methods in Health Care Management Yasar A. Ozcan 1 Chapter 15. Simulation.
CPSC 422, Lecture 9Slide 1 Intelligent Systems (AI-2) Computer Science cpsc422, Lecture 9 Jan, 23, 2015.
Strategic Decisions (Part II)
ELMBROOK MEMORIAL HOSPITAL PILOT START DATE 7/30/2012 – DAY SHIFT END DATE 8/29/2012- NIGHT SHIFT Fall Safety Huddles.
Taming of the Queue Workshop March Deborah Marshall, PhD Canada Research Chair, Health Systems and Services Research University of Calgary Alberta.
Desktop Business Analytics -- Decision Intelligence l Time Series Forecasting l Risk Analysis l Optimization.
A Markov Decision Model for Determining Optimal Outpatient Scheduling Jonathan Patrick Telfer School of Management University of Ottawa.
Tools for Data Driven Decisions. FOR OFFICIAL USE ONLY 2 Agenda The Toolkit Designing for Outputs Understanding Tool Inputs Data sources Data collection.
Silberschatz, Galvin and Gagne  2002 Modified for CSCI 399, Royden, Operating System Concepts Operating Systems Lecture 19 Scheduling IV.
Healthcare Operations Management © 2008 Health Administration Press. All rights reserved. 1.
Decision Making: An Introduction 1. 2 Decision Making Decision Making is a process of choosing among two or more alternative courses of action for the.
Operations Research Session Objectives:  To describe the need and importance of Operations Research for rationale decision making in health care delivery.
1 Chapter 12: Decision-Support Systems for Supply Chain Management CASE: Supply Chain Management Smooths Production Flow Prepared by Hoon Lee Date on 14.
1212 / t 1 A SHORT TERM CAPACITY ADJUSTMENT POLICY FOR MINIMIZING LATENESS IN JOB SHOP PODUCTION SYSTEMS Henny P.G. van Ooijen J.Will M. Bertrand.
Page 0 Optimization Uncertainty Decision Analysis Systems Economics Masters of Engineering With Concentration in Systems Engineering A 30 hour graduate.
Supply Chain Logistics Management
Demand and Capacity Planning and Management A rational approach to delivering the best possible clinically effective and.
Modelling 2 Aspects of Modelling. Treating certainty, uncertainty and risk – What if analysis – Sensitivity analysis – Scenario analysis Normative vs.
Software Verification and Validation (V&V) By Roger U. Fujii Presented by Donovan Faustino.
Using Simulation in Understanding the Dynamic of Business Processes By Phinsuda Tarmy MBA 731 Fall 2007.
Network and Operational Planning
Discrete Event Simulation in Automotive Final Process System Vishvas Patel John Ma Throughput Analysis & Simulations General Motors 1999 Centerpoint Parkway.
Operations Research Models
Supply Contract Allocation Gyana R. Parija Bala Ramachandran IBM T.J. Watson Research Center INFORMS Miami 2001.
System Dynamics for Strategic Resource Planning at Watford Hospital Esther Moors Goncalo Esteves 13/11/2013.
1 Value Assessment of Development-Stage Assets Pharmaceutical Products, Medical Devices, and Related Intellectual Property Frank S. Castellana, M.D., Eng.Sc.D.
HOW TO DEVELOP QUALITY ASSURANCE PROGRAM IN HEALTH CARE INSTITUTION Ahmad Fuady.
Column Generation Approach for Operating Rooms Planning Mehdi LAMIRI, Xiaolan XIE and ZHANG Shuguang Industrial Engineering and Computer Sciences Division.
1 1 Slide © 2008 Thomson South-Western. All Rights Reserved © 2011 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or.
Developing a Multi- Methodology Operating Theatre Scheduling Support System Marion Penn With: Prof. Chris Potts and Prof. Paul Harper IMA 29 th March 2010.
1 OM2, Supplementary Ch. D Simulation ©2010 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible.
Copyright © 2013 by The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. McGraw-Hill/Irwin CHAPTER 13: Operation Analysis.
Scheduling Strategies Operating Systems Spring 2004 Class #10.
Sponsor: Dr. K.C. Chang Tony Chen Ehsan Esmaeilzadeh Ali Jarvandi Ning Lin Ryan O’Neil Spring 2010.
CPSC 422, Lecture 9Slide 1 Intelligent Systems (AI-2) Computer Science cpsc422, Lecture 9 Sep, 28, 2015.
Tactical Planning in Healthcare with Approximate Dynamic Programming Martijn Mes & Peter Hulshof Department of Industrial Engineering and Business Information.
Scanning Computer Viruses with Reduced Virus Definition File s Daisuke Anzai Supervised by Prof. H Toyoizumi.
MBAA 607- Operations Analysis & Decision Support Systems Spring 2008 Tuesday 4:25-7:05 Dr. Linda Leon.
MBAA 607- Operations Analysis & Decision Support Systems Spring 2011 Monday 4:25-7:05 Dr. Linda Leon
Appointment Systems - a Stochastic and Fluid Approach Michal Penn The William Davidson Faculty of Industrial Engineering and Management Technion - Israel.
July 27, 2006ORAHS 2006: Poland1 A Case Study of a Simulation-Based Decision Support Tool Michael Carter Healthcare Modeling Lab, Mechanical & Industrial.
0 On the day non-clinical cancelled operations (elective) Total non-clinical cancelled operations (elective) On the day non-clinical cancelled operations.
Copyright 2013 John Wiley & Sons, Inc. Chapter 8 Capacity, Scheduling, and Location Planning.
Presented By Dr. Mohsen Alardhi College of Technological Studies, Kuwait April 19 th,2009.
Waiting Time Management Strategies for Scheduled Services Ottawa March 28, 2012 Minimizing the Cost of Waiting Ray Naden, New Zealand.
Operations Research The OR Process. What is OR? It is a Process It assists Decision Makers It has a set of Tools It is applicable in many Situations.
Lufthansa Update on LH´s Path of O&D Control AGIFORS, New York, March 2000 Werner Tauss.
OPERATING SYSTEMS CS 3530 Summer 2014 Systems and Models Chapter 03.
IT Applications for Decision Making. Operations Research Initiated in England during the world war II Make scientifically based decisions regarding the.
Developing Policy: Simulating a Year of Care for People with Long Term Conditions Claire Cordeaux Executive Director, Healthcare.
Simulation in Healthcare Ozcan: Chapter 15 ISE 491 Fall 2009 Dr. Burtner.
Simulation Modeling and Analysis Ernesto Gutierrez-Miravete Rensselaer at Hartford October 14th, 2003.
PROPRIETARY  2003 Data Research Analysis & Consultancy Solutions All Rights Reserved. This is achieved by: Improving availability / reducing stock outs.
Tactical Planning in Healthcare using Approximate Dynamic Programming (tactisch plannen van toegangstijden in de zorg) Peter J.H. Hulshof, Martijn R.K.
Csci 418/618 Simulation Models Dr. Ken Nygard, IACC 262B
Copyright © 2014 by McGraw-Hill Education (Asia). All rights reserved. 13 Aggregate Planning.
Outpatient KPI Management Bernadette Comitti Clinical Service Director Surgery, Perioperative & Outpatient Services Matiu Bush Patient Services Manager.
Analytics and Value Creation
OPERATING SYSTEMS CS 3502 Fall 2017
ENGM 742: Engineering Management and Labor Relations
Saskatchewan Surgical Care Network
GENESYS Redevelopment Strawman Proposal
System Dynamics Dr Jennifer Morgan.
Cancer Optimal Service Design Workshop Defining “what to change” using the NHS Right Care methodology Part of the NEW Devon Way.
BMW Project “Ship-to-Average“ by Matthias Pauli Thomas Drtil
Strategic Management and the Concepts of Marketing
Material Requirements Planning (MRP)
Access and booking Productivity advice
Presentation transcript:

Modeling & Simulation What can they offer? March 28, 2012 Ottawa, ON Waiting Time Management Strategies for Scheduled Health Care Services: A Workshop for Researchers, Managers and Decision-makers

The Operations Research Toolkit Strategic Tactical Operational Long Range Demand Forecasting Long Range Supply Forecasting Capacity Planning & Allocation Patient Scheduling Models HHR Scheduling Resource Scheduling Managing Demand Variability Managing Supply Variability Analysis of Pathways Patients People Resources 10/4/20152

Operations Research Tools 10/4/20153

Urgent Patient Queueing Model Objective: To develop a generalized model to determine how to best allocate capacity to urgent patients Scope: Any fixed capacity intervention with 2 urgency classes and a critical MAWT to meet for the high urgency class (Winnipeg, Edmonton) Modelling methodology: Stochastic Model to create closed-form Queueing formulas, tested against DES (Arena) models 10/4/20154

Rationale Goal: Provide more certainty around surgery dates for all patient classes Patient Scheduling variability depends upon: – OR Schedule stability Cancellations of OR time, frequency of scramble time – Surgeon variability Longer waitlists create more uncertainty of surgeon availability – Patient readiness Prehab and case management has improved this – Arrival of urgent patients that ‘bump’ elective patients when there isn’t adequate time reserved 10/4/20155

Literature Overview Scheduling Policies for managing Urgent/Elective  Patrick & Puterman (2008) “Dynamic Multipriority Patient Scheduling for a Diagnostic Resource CT Scans for 3 outpatient categories, MAWT of 7, 14, 28 days Markov Decision Process (MDP) that recommends that highest priority gets scheduled right away and that lower priorities are scheduled into the latest appointment available to meet MAWT. When demand > capacity, higher priority patients are rejected vs. a bumping of elective. Increased flexibility with high priority scheduling improves system  Zonderland et al. (2010) “Planning and scheduling of semi-urgent surgeries. Stochastic model created for specific location. Difficult to multi-location replicate due to mathematical approach 610/4/2015

Research Question What is the ‘optimal’ number of urgent surgical slots to set aside so as to meet a desired performance metric – specifically % of urgent patients that bump electives Required data: – Patient arrival rate – MAWT for urgent patients Output: – Minimum # of surgeries to reserve of MAWT window 710/4/2015

Simulation Approach 10/4/20158 Average arrival rate of urgent patients = 1 per week. Surgery rate = Number of urgent surgical spots reserved over the next 4 weeks for urgent patients

Stochastic Model Approach ‘Simple’ representation of urgent patient arrival process Ability to calculate, with relative ease & accuracy, the effect of reserving capacity for urgent patients                        =            10/4/20159 A stochastic model may be used rather than a simulation

Analytical Queueing Model Derive appropriate formulae based upon an M/D/1/N queueing model Test accuracy of queuing model against DES Implement formula in Excel front-end The stochastic model may be solved analytically to determine the probability of having 0, 1, …N patients waiting. 10/4/201510

Results Low volume Medium Volume High Volume Extreme Volume Scenario  (arrivals/week)  (surgery/week) Prob(empty) Prob(bumping) /4/201511

Validation – Comparing DES/Queue 10/4/201512

Excel-based “OR Tool” 10/4/201513

Next Steps Phase I - Data gathering and Implementation of logic into Concordia Scheduling Software, early 2012  Phase II - Integrate into Generalized DES Model as part of “best practices” options Phase III - Improve user interface and test at pilot clinics – gather performance feedback 10/4/201514

Operations Research Tools 10/4/201515

Thank you! 1610/4/2015