MEASURABLE OBJECTIVES FOR

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
United We Stand. Evaluating, Cooperating, and other Unlikely Stories of Evaluation Capacity Building in Italy Martina Bolli, Silvia Ciampi, Francesco Giordano.
Advertisements

Scaling up the global initiative on the implementation of the SNA and supporting statistics Meeting on Scaling up the coordination and resources for the.
The link of STI indicators to STI policy South Asian Regional Workshop on Science, Technology and Innovation Statistics Kathmandu, Nepal.
The Africa Action Plan An IEG Evaluation CSO Forum April 15, 2011.
Assessment of administrative and institutional capacity
1 Reflections on the future Cohesion Policy DG Regional Policy European Commission.
Women in the workforce – addressing the challenge of demographic change OPEN DAYS 11/10/2005 Virag Sandor DG REGIO.
EN Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION The new European Regional Development Fund Brussels, 12 October 2006 Committee of the Regions N. De Michelis,
DG REGIO – Unit "Thematic Development" EUROPEAN COMMISSION EN 1 Transport and Regional Policy Transport and Regional Policy Patrick.
Anna Panagopoulou TEN-T Executive Agency Head of Unit, T4
The Managing Authority –Keystone of the Control System
1 The role of macro- regional strategies after 2013 The Commissions view (or rather the view of one official) David Sweet, DG Regional Policy, European.
María Muñoz General Directorate for Community Funds Ministry of Economy and Finance SPAIN María Muñoz General Directorate for Community Funds Ministry.
1 DG Regio Evaluation Network Meeting Albert Borschette, Brussels, 14 October 2010 Ex post evaluation of Interreg III - Presentation of Final Results Pasi.
Joint presentation by respective units in DGs AGRI, EMPL and REGIO IPA Components III, IV and V: Conditions for successful preparation and absorption of.
Added value and efficiency through the use of article 37.6(b) and EGTC Rossella Rusca Brussels, 11 October 2011.
t J OAQUIM B ERNARDO Coordenador Adjunto do Observatório do QREN Deputy Coordinator of the NSRF Observatory.
1 Seminar on urban-rural linkages fostering social cohesion in Europe Brussels, 2 July 2009 EUROPEAN COMMISSION DG Employment, Social Affairs and Equal.
Cities and Green Growth OECD Green Cities Programme
EN Regional Policy EUROPEAN COMMISSION Information and Publicity SFIT, 15 June 2006 Barbara Piotrowska, DG REGIO
EU-Regional Policy and Cohesion Structural Funds and Accession 1 ANNUAL MEETING OF ISPA PARTNERS 2003 FROM ISPA TO COHESION AND STRUCTURAL FUNDS BRUSSELS,
| | Learning from EuroHealthNets Health Inequalities Projects.
Workshop 4: Using the EU Structural Funds to support Independent Living Ines Bulic European Network on Independent Living Strasbourg Freedom Drive, 9 Sept.
Leicestershires Vision for short break transformation Leicestershire is committed to the transformation and expansion of short break services for disabled.
Evaluating administrative and institutional capacity building
1 CREATING AN EFFECTIVE CENTRAL HARMONIZATION UNIT PEM-PAL WORKSHOP FOR INTERNAL AUDIT OFFICIALS Moldova, June 2007 Dr. Darius MATUSEVICIUS Financial.
Universal Coverage – Can we guarantee health for all? 3 – 4 October 2011, Kuala Lumpur Nossal perspective.
Leveraging the impact of climate finance through MDBs Ko Sakamoto Transport Economist Asian Development Bank.
Towards the Romania of PRINCIPLES OF PROGRAMMING The social and macroeconomic policy of Europe is the policy of Romania EU projects represent a.
Strengthening the Performance of Cohesion Policy through Performance Reserve and Ex-Ante Conditionality Sabina De Luca Italian Ministry of Economic Development.
Socialdepartementet Primary care and the care for the elderly.
The Knowledge Resources Guide The SUVOT Project Sustainable and Vocational Tourism Rimini, 20 October 2005.
Simon Scott, OECD International Conference on MDG Statistics, Manila, October 2011 Development aid information management and its impact on aid volume.
EU-Regional Policy and Cohesion Structural Funds and Accession 1 SPP BUILDING IMPLEMENTATION CAPACITY Training seminar on evaluation Prague February.
Critical Role of ICT in Parliament Fulfill legislative, oversight, and representative responsibilities Achieve the goals of transparency, openness, accessibility,
Presentation to Contra Costa County Climate Leaders October 3, 2013.
Slide 1 Final Conference Stratos Papadimitriou Cracow, September 2009 Work Package C A Quality Management Approach for Managing Mobility in Medium and.
Monica Brezzi – Francesca Utili Department for Development Policies Ministry of Economic Development 17 th session of the Territorial Development Policy.
(Dr. Peter Heil, ALTUS – Hungary)
Guidance notes on the Intevention Logic and on Building a priority axis 27 September 2013.
Capacity Development for the CDM (CD4CDM) First National Workshop - SURINAM Sustainable Development Impact Evaluation Miriam Hinostroza.
Regional policy European Commission EN Update on IPA Component III - environment Brussels, 28 November 2008 Erich Unterwurzacher REGIO.I4 – IPA/ISPA.
Result Orientation in Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE Annual Meeting, Luxemburg, 15 September 2015 Monika Schönerklee-Grasser, Joint Secretariat.
Regional Policy Veronica Gaffey Evaluation Unit DG Regional Policy International Monitoring Conference Budapest 11 th November 2011 Budapest 26 th September2013.
WHO EURO In Country Coordination and Strengthening National Interagency Coordinating Committees.
« Performing Efficient Models of Administration Capacity and Regional Reform in the European Union» European Parliament 15 October 2008 Bruxelles Romanian.
Kathy Corbiere Service Delivery and Performance Commission
TEN-T Executive Agency and Project Management Anna LIVIERATOU-TOLL TEN-T Executive Agency Senior Programme and Policy Coordinator European Economic and.
"The challenge for Territorial Cohesion 2014 – 2020: delivering results for EU citizens" Veronica Gaffey Acting Director EUROPEAN COMMISSION, DG for Regional.
ITALY CFS OBJECTIVE Criteria and allocation mechanism of the performance reserve: the Italian proposal Paola De Cesare Ministry of the Treasury,
The EU Water Initiative and the EU ACP Facility New Instruments to promote sustainable development of water resources and affordable access Antonio Garcia-Fragio.
1 Mongolia - Vision Long term vision All residents of the capital city (Ulaanbaatar) of Mongolia will have access to improved water supply and sanitation.
IMPLEMENTATION OF THE Agenda 2030 in the Czech Republic
Writing LIFE Integrated Project
Peer Group Synthesis 24 November 2006
Part 2: How to ensure good project management?
Ex post evaluation of ERDF and Cohesion Fund
Hidefumi Imura Professor, Nagoya University
Implementation of the UN DA 10 project “The African context”
PEMPAL – Facilitating Practical Solutions in PFM across ECA
Institutional Framework, Resources and Management
The role of Territorial Cooperation in IWT and integrated planning
progress of the water reform in bulgaria
European needs for urban statistics Mireille Grubert
DG EMPL studies on the ESF future
General Outline of EAPN Proposals
Ministry of National Economy of The Republic of Kazakhstan
Ðì SA Effective Monitoring and Evaluation of Progress on the SDGs Monitoring SDGs : the perspective of Armstat Learning Conference: Implementing.
CREATING AN EFFECTIVE CENTRAL HARMONIZATION UNIT PEM-PAL WORKSHOP FOR INTERNAL AUDIT OFFICIALS Moldova, June 2007 Dr. Darius MATUSEVICIUS Financial.
Jeannette Monier and Louise Reid
Presentation transcript:

MEASURABLE OBJECTIVES FOR PUBLIC SERVICES: THE EXPERIENCE OF THE 2007-2013 PERFORMANCE RESERVE IN SOUTHERN ITALY IOLANDA ANSELMO – SIMONA DE LUCA Ministry of Economic Development DG REGIO EVALUATION NETWOR MEETING BRUSSELS, 14-15 OCTOBER 2010

Description of the scheme The role of indicators, monitoring and evaluation From a performance reserve to a programming practice?

2007-2013 performance reserve rewarding final policy results: indicators really matter 11 statistical indicators on provision and quality of Education Child and elderly care Water service Waste management Targets are set at minimum standard (the same for all Regions) Indicators and targets drive programs and implementation (action plan, integration of different financial sources and policies) 3 billion Euros assigned to eight Southern Regions if quantified targets are met in 2013 (reward for each target fulfilled) A share of the resources is assigned in 2009 on the basis of the improvements from the baseline (640 million Euros) Resources not assigned in 2013 to Regions that don’t achieve the targets can be assigned directly to well performing municipalities in the same region and after to other better performing Regions

Regional disparities in Italy Centre- North South: 8 regions; Population 21 millions (36%)

Indicators and targets

The picture in 2009 Gap still to be filled Baseline Improvement   Baseline   Improvement   Worsening  

Binding indicators need special attention … when choosing indicators: Official source Comparable data (across time and territories) Regional/sub-regional breakdown Data available timely and frequently … when setting targets challenging but realistic (Lisbon strategy, benchmarking with other regions) … when implementing the system Guarantee timely and sub-regional data (ad hoc agreement with statistic provider) Improve the quality of statistics (moral suasion through regional authorities and at local level to increase the response rate) Make clear and transparent the meaning of indicators (methodological notes and workshops with statistic provider) Regular update and diffusion of data on the website (including innovative tools)

Monitoring: feedback on action and transparency Every year: data indicators updated (most with sub regional breakdown) + Reports from the regional administrations Technical group (central and regional administrations, statistical national institute ISTAT) use data and report to promote corrective actions (other than guaranteeing the correct implementation of rules) All data and reports on the web-site

Evaluation challenges Monitoring statistical indicators and actions is not enough to assess the progress in well being of citizens More in-depth assessment is needed to drive action Main challenges: Issues not covered by indicators (e.g. integration between social and health services to elderly people) Quality of services (e.g. sea water pollution) Cost of services (sustainability)

Lessons for the future 1 Reward device is not sufficient without clear identification of responsibilities and strong engagement of citizens So far... specific commitments at all levels identified (regional action plans, technical assistance project by line Ministries) local incentive scheme introduced relevant investment to guarantee soundness and transparency of rules and indicators However ... still limited commitment at political level difficult integration between policies need to increase engagement of citizens

Lessons for the future 2 From a reward scheme to a result driven programming practice: binding programs to indicators can work Conditioning financing to the achievement of results (stick) is a much stronger incentive than rewards (carrot) Binding programs not only to final results: need to introduce intermediate steps to be monitored together with statistical indicators

THANK YOU! iolanda.anselmo@tesoro.it simona.deluca@tesoro.it http://www.dps.tesoro.it/obiettivi_servizio/eng/ml.asp http://www.dps.tesoro.it\DPSeXplorer