Climate Change and California Forests Malcolm North Sierra Nevada Research Center, Davis, CA

October May June Greatest changes are in nighttime minima Tahoe City 1875 m Courtesy of Hugh Safford

Precipitation (mm) Temperature (C) Year Temp-HAD Temp-PCM Precip-HAD Precip-PCM HAD = Hadley Center 2 model: Very warm-wet future PCM = Parallel Climate Model: Warm-dry future California future climates: alternate scenarios Source: Electrical Power Research Institute % of climate models predict increased ppt for California in general 23% predict decrease 17% predict no change Courtesy of Hugh Safford

Expansion of C4 grassland Warming benefits broad-leaved spp at expense of needle- leaved Loss of habitat as warming drives veg- types higher Loss in shrubland due to increase in fire (= grassland) or higher ppt (= trees) Courtesy of Hugh Safford

Vegetation community responses Historic conditions, and predictions for 2100 based on the Hadley and PCM models Lenihan et al Ecol Appl 12. Courtesy of Hugh Safford

ABCO PIPO QUKE PSME ABMA PIAL Species-specific responses : species will respond based on their own physiological response and their interactions with other species. Future communities will not look like current communities. Chaparral and gray pine Courtesy of Hugh Safford

Centennial-Scale Climate Trends Holocene MULTI-PROXY ANALYSIS Early Holocene10500 to 7500 YBPWarming Mid-Holocene 7500 to 5000 YBPWarmest, Dry Post Mid- Holocene Transition 5000 to 3500 YBP Cooling, Wetter Neoglacial 3500 to 2600 YBP Cool, Wet Post-Neoglacial Drought 2600 to 1600 YBP Intense Drought Post-Drought Transition and Medieval Warm Period 1600 to 650 YBP Dry but Summer Wet Little Ice Age 650 to 150 YBP Cool Wet, Cool Dry Recent< 150 YBP Warm, wet From Tausch et al Courtesy Connie Millar

Giant Sequoia Glacial: Interglacial Dynamics East Lk, 2863m, < 10kyr Kings Cyn, 1000m, 20kyr Central Valley, 54m, 26-22kyr Mono Lk, 1950m, kyr Current range, W Sierra, m Davis 1999a, Davis 1999b, Power 1998, Cole 1983

Past Climate Analogs: Mid Holocene: (3,000 B.C.-1,500 B.C.) Wetter period: Increase in fir and cedar, relative to pine and a decrease in oak Middle Warming Period (approx A.D.): Rise in tree line but no significant vegetation shifts Early 20 th Century (1880’s-1950): Warming (recovery from little Ice Age) and wet period Reconstruction or Pre-European Period ( ) Very unusual period: end of the little Ice Age with cool, dry conditions

Historic Climate Naturally Fluctuated Cyclically Nested Time Scales - Millennial - Centennial - Decadal - Interannual Rapid and Abrupt Transitions Plants track climate at each scale, but respond with unexpected lags and threshold behaviors Millar 2003

CADE PIPO PIJE ABCO Sensitivity to air pollution (N and ozone) Susceptibility to insect/disease CADE PIPO PIJE ABCO PILA Sensitivity to increased temperatures ABCO PILA PIPO CADE Sensitivity to water stress PIPO PIJE CADE ABCO Sensitivity to fire (adult) CADE PIPO PIJE ABCO Southern California forests: interactions of multiple stressors Who wins? PollutionInsects/diseaseTempsH 2 O stressFire Courtesy of Hugh Safford

Before fire suppression (1865 on this graph), tree death and recruitment is pulsed by fire and El Nino events North et al. 2005

Oaks were especially sensitive to temperature; Oak species fluctuated from rare to widespread in W Sierra Anderson & Smith, 1994

20 th Century Responses: Meadow Invasion Central High Sierra Nevada Studies Found increased colonization in diverse meadows with variable environmental, vegetative, & land-use histories

Mortality in the forest is now primarily driven by drought and beetles Tree density, from fire suppression contributes to drought stress The populations of some insects, including many bark beetles, are kept in check by cold over-wintering temperatures * * * Mortality significantly higher than expected in high density and lower in low density

No BurnBurn Snowpack: Nitrogen : NoneAddition Reduction Nitrogen:NoneAdditionReduction NoneControl+S - SNoneBurn only + S - S Addition+ N+ S + N - S+ NAddition+ N+ S+ N - S+ N What may happen to mixed-conifer understory herbs and shrubs with increasing nitrogen from air pollution, an increase or decrease in snowpack, and with and without fire? Herb biomass increased in shrub dominated communities when snow pack was reduced. Nitrogen additions unexpectedly increased herbaceous species richness. Fire was a more important factor in post-treatment species richness and cover than either snow pack addition or reduction. Hurteau and North. In press.

What are the effects of different fuel treatments on forest carbon storage and emissions under modeled wildfire scenarios? Hurteau and North. In review.

Amount of carbon accumulated after 100 years without wildfire

Hurteau and North. In review. Amount of carbon released during prescribed burns over 100 years

Amount of carbon accumulated after 100 years with a wildfire in 2010

Hurteau and North. In review. Amount of carbon accumulated after 100 years with a wildfire in 2050

Treatment2100 Live Tree tC Rx Fire tC Released 2040 Trees/ha 2050 Wildfire tC Released Total Released (tC/ha) 2100 Carbon Budget Control200.5NA Burn Understory Thin 240.6NA Understory Thin + Burn Restoration244.3NA Restoration + Burn NA Burn * The amount of carbon (tC/ha) stored in live trees and the total amount released over the model’s 100 year run for all prescribed burns (Rx) and for the 2050 wildfire. The 2100 carbon budget is the amount of carbon stored in live trees in 2100 minus the total released in all prescribed fires and the 2050 wildfire for each of the eight treatments. The 2040 trees/ha is each treatment’s stand density in the nearest time step before the 2050 wildfire.

Hurteau and North. In review.

Conclusions: A.Forest communities are unlikely to simply move up in elevation or latitude B.Tree species will respond differently, making future forest compositions difficult to predict C.Snow pack reduction may benefit herbs, but fire is still the strongest influence on the understory D.Bark beetles may become a real problem in high density forests, particularly as winter and night time minimum temperatures rise E.A preliminary FVS model suggest fuels treatments producing a low-density stand structure dominated by large fire-resistant pines may best protect carbon sinks in wildfire prone forests