The FLS2012 FEL Working Group Summary Kwang-Je Kim and Tor Raubenheimer for the FEL Working Group March 9 th, 2012.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Slide 1 Light Source Research at Jefferson Lab George R. Neil and Gwyn P. Williams Associate Director, Jefferson Laboratory JSA Science Council January.
Advertisements

Soft X-ray Self-Seeding
KEK : Novel Accelerator TYL Workshop M. Yoshida, M. Nozaki, K. Koyama, High energy research organization (KEK) -Collaboration -IZEST (CEA) :
1 Bates XFEL Linac and Bunch Compressor Dynamics 1. Linac Layout and General Beam Parameter 2. Bunch Compressor –System Details (RF, Magnet Chicane) –Linear.
Sub-femtosecond bunch length diagnostic ATF Users Meeting April 26, 2012 Gerard Andonian, A. Murokh, J. Rosenzweig, P. Musumeci, E. Hemsing, D. Xiang,
Hard X-ray FELs (Overview) Zhirong Huang March 6, 2012 FLS2012 Workshop, Jefferson Lab.
1 Enhancements to the Linac Coherent Light Source.
Does the short pulse mode need energy recovery? Rep. rateBeam 5GeV 100MHz 500MWAbsolutely 10MHz 50MW Maybe 1MHz 5MW 100kHz.
The BESSY Soft X-Ray SASE FEL (Free Electron Laser)
UCLA The X-ray Free-electron Laser: Exploring Matter at the angstrom- femtosecond Space and Time Scales C. Pellegrini UCLA/SLAC 2C. Pellegrini, August.
LCLS Transition to Science DOE Status Review of the LUSI MIE Project Near term opportunities for LCLS 'upgrades' J. Hastings for the LCLS Experimental.
Status of LCLS A. Brachmann, SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory.
W.S. Graves, ASAC Review, Sept 18-19, 2003 Accelerator Overview Goals for proposal Description of technical components: injector, linac, compressors, etc.
FEL WG: Summary Kwang-Je Kim (Part I, Mo-Tu) Joe Bisognano (Part II, Th) Future Light Source WS 2010: FEL WG March 1-5, 2010 SLAC National Accelerator.
Kwang-Je Kim ANL & U of C& POSTECH Workshop on Sciences Outlook and R&D Issues of X-ray FEL Oscillator February 14-15, 2013 POSCO International Center.
Dielectric Wakefield Accelerator for an X-ray FEL User Facility
Low Emittance RF Gun Developments for PAL-XFEL
The Future of Photon Science and Free-Electron Lasers Ingolf Lindau Lund University and Stanford University MAX-Lab and Synchrotron Light Research KTH,
W.S. Graves ASAC Review Sept 18-19, 2003 R&D at Bates William S. Graves MIT-Bates Laboratory Presentation to MIT X-ray laser Accelerator Science Advisory.
FLASH II. The results from FLASH II tests Sven Ackermann FEL seminar Hamburg, April 23 th, 2013.
Beam Dynamics and FEL Simulations for FLASH Igor Zagorodnov and Martin Dohlus Beam Dynamics Meeting, DESY.
Optimization of Compact X-ray Free-electron Lasers Sven Reiche May 27 th 2011.
A bunch compressor design and several X-band FELs Yipeng Sun, ARD/SLAC , LCLS-II meeting.
CLARA Gun Cavity Optimisation NVEC 05/06/2014 P. Goudket G. Burt, L. Cowie, J. McKenzie, B. Militsyn.
Brief Introduction to (VUV/)Soft X-ray FELs R. P. Walker Diamond Light Source, UK ICFA Workshop on Future Light Sources March 5 th -9 th, 2012 Thomas Jefferson.
LCLS-II Capabilities & Overview LCLS-II Science Opportunities Workshop Tor Raubenheimer February 10 th, 2015.
Max Cornacchia, SLAC LCLS Project Overview BESAC, Feb , 2001 LCLS Project Overview What is the LCLS ? Transition from 3 rd generation light sources.
External Seeding Approaches: S2E studies for LCLS-II Gregg Penn, LBNL CBP Erik Hemsing, SLAC August 7, 2014.
External Seeding Approaches for Next Generation Free Electron Lasers
Operated by Los Alamos National Security, LLC for NNSA Dynamics of modulated beams Operated by Los Alamos National Security, LLC, for the U.S. Department.
Electron Sources for ERLs – Requirements and First Ideas Andrew Burrill FLS 2012 “The workshop is intended to discuss technologies appropriate for a next.
P. Krejcik LINAC 2004 – Lübeck, August 16-20, 2004 LCLS - Accelerator System Overview Patrick Krejcik on behalf of the LCLS.
LCLS-II Design and FEL R&D
The Next Generation Light Source Test Facility at Daresbury Jim Clarke ASTeC, STFC Daresbury Laboratory Ultra Bright Electron Sources Workshop, Daresbury,
UCLA Claudio Pellegrini UCLA Department of Physics and Astronomy X-ray Free-electron Lasers Ultra-fast Dynamic Imaging of Matter II Ischia, Italy, 4/30-5/3/
Transverse Gradient Undulator and its applications to Plasma-Accelerator Based FELs Zhirong Huang (SLAC) Introduction TGU concept, theory, technology Soft.
Lessons Learned From the First Operation of the LCLS for Users Presented by Josef Frisch For the LCLS March 14, 2010.
김 귀년 CHEP, KNU Accelerator Activities in Korea for ILC.
J. Corlett. June 16, 2006 A Future Light Source for LBNL Facility Vision and R&D plan John Corlett ALS Scientific Advisory Committee Meeting June 16, 2006.
Neil Thompson ASTeC, Daresbury Laboratory STFC and IoP PAB Group Workshop, 16 th February 2016: Towards a UK X-FEL Existing and Future X-FEL Facilities.
X-band Based FEL proposal
E. Schneidmiller and M. Yurkov FEL Seminar, DESY April 26, 2016 Reverse undulator tapering for polarization control at X-ray FELs.
Emittance-exchange-based high harmonic generation scheme for FEL JIANG Bocheng SINAP 2012 July 18~20 Lanzhou China 2012 Deflecting/Crabbing Cavity Applications.
A single-shot method for measuring fs bunches in linac-based FELs Z. Huang, K. Bane, Y. Ding, P. Emma.
Applications of transverse deflecting cavities in x-ray free-electron lasers Yuantao Ding SLAC National Accelerator Laboratory7/18/2012.
B. Marchetti R. Assmann, U. Dorda, J. Grebenyuk, Y. Nie, J. Zhu Acknowledgements: C. Behrens, R. Brinkmann, K. Flöttmann, M. Hüning,
Operated by Los Alamos National Security, LLC for NNSA Dmitry Yu. Shchegolkov, Evgenya I. Simakov Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, NM
X-Ray Free-Electron Laser Amplifiers and Oscillators for Materials and Fundamental Research Kwang-Je Kim ANL and U. of Chicago ICABU Meeting November 12,
Bunch Shaping for Future Dielectric Wakefield Accelerators W. Gai Mini-Workshop on Deflecting/Crabbing RF Cavity Research and application in Accelerators.
Free Electron Laser Studies
Seeding in the presence of microbunching
Eduard Prat / Sven Reiche :: Paul Scherrer Institute
Beam dynamics for an X-band LINAC driving a 1 keV FEL
Robert Bosch, Kevin Kleman and the WiFEL team
LCLS efforts: Self-seeding -- status report
Plans of XFELO in Future ERL Facilities
Planned Oslo work in the XbFEL collaboration
Tunable Electron Bunch Train Generation at Tsinghua University
LCLS-II-HE FEL Facility Overview
Review of Application to SASE-FELs
ERL working modes Georg Hoffstaetter, Professor Cornell University / CLASSE / SRF group & ERL effort High Current mode High Coherence mode High Buch charge.
LCLS-II-HE FEL Facility Overview
VUV/Soft X-ray Oscillators
Emittance Partitioning between x (or y) and z dimensions
WBS 5.0 LCLS Strategic Projects Division
Two-bunch self-seeding for narrow-bandwidth hard x-ray FELs
Jim Clarke ASTeC Daresbury Laboratory March 2006
Brief Introduction to (VUV/)Soft X-ray FELs
Gain Computation Sven Reiche, UCLA April 24, 2002
Introduction to Free Electron Lasers Zhirong Huang
Presentation transcript:

The FLS2012 FEL Working Group Summary Kwang-Je Kim and Tor Raubenheimer for the FEL Working Group March 9 th, 2012

Schedule of Sessions 29 talks by 24 people, divided into 5 sessions: –Soft X-ray FELs –Hard X-ray FELs –X-ray FEL Oscillators –FEL Theory –Test Facilities and Design Concepts

The Working Group (Roughly 35 Participants)

Soft X-ray FELs Discussion of SXR facilities, future facility plans and R&D needed to develop capabilities (Approximate) TitleSpeaker Overview of SXR FELsRichard Walker The LUNEX5 ProjectMarie-Emmanuelle Couprie LBNL Studies for the NGLSJohn Corlett A Soft X-ray Self-Seeding ExperimentPhil Heimann Plans for Echo-75Erik Hemsing

Users’ Requirements high pulse energy transverse coherence fs pulses (or less) polarization control easy tunability multiple, simultaneous users high repetition rate regularly spaced pulses THz radiation in synchronism with FEL two-colour FEL pulses longitudinal coherence / pulse uniformity* high degree of amplitude stability* small linewidth* precise synchronism with lasers for pump-probe expts. Most requirements not specific to soft X-rays … Especially for soft-X-ray FELs (?).. that was the view, but now XFEL users are starting to demand such properties R. Walker

SXR Facilities, Projects and Tests Common themes: –High Rep rate –Longitudinal coherence –Low cost NGLS – 1 MHz, 280 eV – 1.2 keV –Based on 2 GeV, CW SCRF  undulator farm –R&D on electron source, beam separator, undulators, polarization control, and seeding approaches (Self-seeding, EEHG, HHG+HGHG) LUNE5X – 0.4 GeV SCRF & 1 GeV LWFA –New facility to study SXR generation and LWFA source –Study seeding approaches and undulator technologies John Corlett & M-E Couprie

SXR Seeding Concepts SXR Self-Seeding experiment –Design for an experiment on LCLS being developed for ~2014 SXR Seeding LBNL  two paths –Conventional 100 ~ 200 nm & 100 th harmonic 7 th harmonic demonstrated at NLCTA and SSRF and plans for 75 th 10 ~ 40 nm & 10 th or 50 th harmonic R&D on HHG and laser spectral phase measurement and control 2 nd undulator M1M1 M3M3 G  /2  ’/2 M2M2 e-beam Source plane Re-entrant plane 1 st undulator S  /2 Phil Heimann & Erik Hemsing

Hard X-ray Sessions Hard X-ray (Tuesday PM) –Overview (Z. Huang) –Simulations of the self-seeding experiment at LCLS (J. Wu) –Modeling and multi-dim. optimization of a tapered FEL(S. Spampinati) –LCLS-2 Terawatt options (T. Raubenheimer) –The proposed MaRIE X-ray FEL at Los Alamos (B. Carlsten) –Compact hard x-rayFEL design based on an x-band RF linac ( Y. Sun) –Tolerance for seeded FELs (J. Wu)

Hard X-ray FELs: Self-Seeding Works! With further development, the full potential for self seed hard x-ray FEL will be reached –Electron beam profile needs to be improved to remove double horn, chirp, etc. Two bunch scheme may have additional advantages –Difficult to bench mark with fluctuating initial SASE Tapering is effective for seeded FEL  realizing TW goal

Hard X-ray FELs: Terawatts LCLS 2 Use seeding and heavily tapered undulator to increase power from 10’s GW  TW –Extensive study over last year –Focused on single bunch self-seeding option presently

Further activities at LCLS Attosecond regime with ultralow charge Dechirping with wakefield –Corrugated beam pipe Enhanced SASE Improvement of LCLS injector performance –0.3 mm-mr, 150 pC bunches Vigorous FEL physics study –Tolerances for seeding scheme –Understanding the tapering performance including 3D effects –Compact XFEL with x-band RF

Hard x-ray FEL: MaRIE at LANL Matter-Radiation Interactions in Extremes (MaRIE) ~ $2B for full capabilities ( Initially ~$1B) 12-GeV electron linac driving 42-keV (0.3Å) XFEL is cornerstone of MaRIE 1.0 (for SASE photons in BW) Advanced (and ambitious!) concepts for upgrade –Non-Hamiltonian emittance partitioning –Beam modulation employing EEX

X-Ray Oscillator Sessions XFELO ( Wednesday PM I) –Optics for VUV and soft x-ray FEL oscillators (M. Shinn) –XFELO cavity design with asymmetric crystals (G.T. Park) –The effect of mirror surface errors in XFELO cavity (G.T. Park) ERL-FEL joint session on XFELO ( Wednesday PM II) –Status of the ERL-based light source project in KEK and Cornell (S. Sakanaka) –XFELO parameters (R. Lindberg)

Soft X-ray FEL Oscillator A novel “Flat HR” optical cavity configuration was developed at Jlab –Unstable, low-Q cavity consisting of a flat high reflectivity mirror and a curved mirror with hole –Moderately high-gain  optical guiding stabilizes the mode –Mode does not avoid the hole, thus does not suffer from the well-known hole-coupling problem for a stable cavity –Designed for VUV but could be a path toward 1 keV FEL oscillator

Hard X-Ray FEL Oscillator: Optics Asymmetric crystals (surface not parallel to Bragg planes) for XFELO cavity –Advantages: larger angular acceptance, larger x-ray footprint –Issues: pulse length could keep increasing after each turn –Cavity configurations were found in which the pulse dilation does not occur Surface errors of curved focusing mirrors (required to adjust the transverse mode profile for optimum gain) –Simulation based on Fourier optics –Analytic study clarifying the role of figure errors and roughness errors

Hard X-ray FEL Oscillators will add to the capabilities of an ERL facility 6-7 GeV XFELO at KEK ERL in the second stage Harmonic XFELO may be feasible for a 3 GeV ERL 7.8 GeV XFELO possible at Cornell ERL

XFELOs with ultra-low charge (1 pC) and ultra low emittance (0.062 mm-mr) may be attractive: lower intra- cavity power, higher rep rate, or shorter undulator with a factor of 10 smaller photons/pulse “canonical”Low Q 1Low Q 2 Electron E (GeV)777 Bunch Q (pC)2511 Peak I (A)101.6 Norm em (  m)  E (MeV) Lund (m)52 35 Gain Rtot0.85 Photons/pulse1.1    10 8    meV 

FEL Theory Sessions FEL-Sources joint session on Theory (Thursday AM I) –Staged eigen emittance reduction techniques (K. Bishopberger) –Dynamics of modulated beams (N. Yampolsky) Theory (Thursday AM II) –EEX-based beam compression with higher order corrections(K. Bishopberger) –Enhanced harmonic up-conversion using hybrid HGHG-EEHG (Q. Marksteiner) –Quantum noise in high-gain FELs (K.-J. Kim)

Eigen-Emittance Reduction Extend ideas of Flat-Beam Transformer to longitudinal to further reduce emittances –Initial thoughts to do this at cathode with a tilted laser Concern that hard to preserve correllations from cathode Considered two alternate appraoches: –Canted undulator at high energy –Wedged foil Thinking about tests Normalized emittance PITZ photoinjector REDUCTION TECHNIQUES 0.1  m 25 pC250 pC 0.2  m100 pC1 nC Bishofberger

Emittance-Exchange Compression Discussion of using EEX to reduce bunch length and possible shape longitudinal distribution Believed to be less sensitive to CSR De Possible to include high-order correction elements (sextupoles and octupoles) to compensate nonlinearities sigz = 400 umsigz = 4 um Bishofberger

Seeding Approaches Use of a combined (3-stage) harmonic generation to go from 200 nm laser  1 nm FEL Marksteiner Yampolsky Study different bunching approaches in spectral domain Understand impact visually

Quantum Noise Kwang-Je calculated the additional noise in the FEL due to quantum effects –Derived the FEL equation in terms of quantum operators –Found result that it is a small effect but might be observable and possibly increased by mismatching the radiation ellipse to beam

Test facilities and Design Concepts Test Facilities and Design Concepts (Thursday PM) –RF power sources for XFELs and ERLs (A. Nassiri) –Performance comparisons of S-, C-, and X-band based FEL facilities (Y. Kim) –Modeling of the photon transport system of the ALICE FEL using wavefront propagation (M. Roper) –FEL consideration for CLARA: A UK test facility for future light sources (D. Dunning) –Preliminary study on two possible bunch compression schemes at NLCTA (Y. Sun) –Enabled by Echo:EEHG and more at NLCTA (E. Hemsing) –DWA for FEL facility (A. Zholents)

Rf Source Overview LDMOS Transistor ~1000W/unit × 1000 J. Jacob (ESRF) A. Nassiri (ANL) Solid-state sources can compete with tubes at the lower frequencies and power levels. The outlook for higher-frequency, higher-power solid-state rf sources is promising but with many technical challenges. Nassiri

Rf Frequency Comparison Developed and optimized designs for S-band, C-band and X-band FEL’s –Looked at overall size, beam parameters and tolerances –Use SwissFEL as a basis for optimization Noted advantages and disadvantages of different frequencies – –Lots of detail (48 slides in 15 minutes) – see posted slides Y. Kim

Photon Transport Calculations in ALICE ALICE is an ERL/FEL test facility at Daresbury –26 MeV beam with 1625 bunches in Hz Complicated photon transport modeled with FOCUS code 3 mm aperture 1.5 mm aperture Wavefront propagation Mark Roper

DWA and LWFA Use SCRF to generate high power beam  use dielectric wakefield accelerator to accelerate to high energy FEL10 FEL2 FEL1 1 MHz, P=320 kW Zholents PWFA was discussed in plenary and in reference to LUNE5X Both DWA and LWFA tend to leave beams with large chirps

Test Facilities Three facilities described in detail: –LUNEX5 (Soleil – Monday pm) –CLARA (Daresbury) –NLCTA (SLAC) Broad program including undulator technology, acceleration concepts, beam dynamics and seeding Explicit talk describing test of advanced bunch compression concepts: –two tests, one using existing hardware and one with small upgrade

Survey of Facilities David Dunning

CLARA New facility being designed at Daresbury 250 MeV Flexible format to test variety of FEL concepts Open for collaboration

NLC Test Accelerator 4 Chicanes, 3 undulators, 3 lasers, 2 TCAVs, flexible rf, and lots of diagnostics Broad program of FEL beam physics & technology possible Open for collaboration Erik Hemsing

Final Remarks Thanks to everybody