“Who Governs?” Robert Dahl. Who Governs? Open, but Unequal System: Who Governs? In a political system where virtually everyone can vote, yet there is.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Unit 1: Constitutional Underpinnings of the U.S. Government
Advertisements

WILSON, CHAPTER 1 DISTRICT 127 The Study of American Government.
Pluralist Theories Of The State
Elite Theory 1. A “stable” group: The economic elite model posits a unified and wealthy class of individuals possessing a dominant influence during numerous.
Democracy.
Theories of Democratic Government
Pressure groups and pluralist democracy
Chapter 2: Majoritarian or Pluralist Democracy?
“Power and Powerlessness”
Why Do We Have Government?  Thomas Hobbes ( ) and the state of nature (war of all against all)  John Locke ( ) and protection of life,
Direct Democracy History Athens is considered the birth place Solon (Athenian law-maker/Lyric poet) (7 th Century B.C.) Tried to satisfy everyone (rich.
Introducing Comparative Politics
Politics, Power, and Government An Economy of Influence.
The Study of American Government
Majoritarian or Pluralist Democracy?
AP Government Chapter One
Theory of Democratic Government
Question 1 Weber defined power as………. Answers A - the chance of a person or a number of people to realise their own will in a communal action even against.
Chapter 2 MAJORITARIAN OR PLURALIST DEMOCRACY?. Learning Outcomes 2.1 Distinguish between the two theories of democratic government used in political.
Lineberry Chapter 1 Introducing Government in America.
RIDDLE ME THIS... Who should govern?. THEORY OF DEMOCRATIC GOVERNMENT  Governments can be classified based on the number of people who hold power: 
Intro to Government in America Sawyers – AP Government.
Chapter 1 Introducing government in America. August 13 th bellringer  In your opinion, why are so many young people apathetic about politics?
Government and Public Policy
Theories of Democracy Consider: Is democracy the best system of government? Homework: Collaborize and Assignment 2 for tomorrow.
THE STUDY OF AMERICAN GOVERNMENT Wilson Chapter One.
{ Ch. 1 American Government Distribution of Political Power.
+ Global crises, equity and HIA Associate Professor Marilyn Wise Centre for Health Equity Training Research & Evaluation, University of New South Wales,
Chapter 1.3 Foundations of Democracy Today, t here are more democratic forms of government in the world than any other style of government? Why?
AP U.S. GOVERNMENT & POLITICS – Democracy Democracy.
Politics and Government Matter List of ways government has affected your life: Public Schools Drivers license and driving Age you can drink, smoke, vote.
The Study of American Government AP US Government & Politics Dr. Smith.
The 4 Types of Governments.
“Power and Powerlessness” John Gaventa. Power and Participation Explaining Quiescence Why, in circumstances of inequality, do challenges to that inequality.
The Study of American Government Part 2. Democracy Key Concept #2 – Democracy has shades of meaning that must be understood in order to examine American.
Social Stratification. What is social stratification? Creation of layers of people who possess unequal shares of scarce resources –The “haves” and the.
Chapter 2 Culture and Multinational Management. What is Culture? It is the shared beliefs, norms, values, and symbols that guide everyday life. Norms:
Political Power. Power: the ability of one person to get another person to act in accordance with the first person’s intentions. Authority:the right to.
Democracy An Option (for 2 nd hour and Other hours, too)
Intro to Politics: Government & You. The Necessity of Gov’t "If men were angels, no government would be necessary. If angels were to govern men, neither.
Intro to Government in America Sawyers – AP Government.
CHARACTERISTICS OF DEMOCRACY. SOME COUNTRIES CALL THEMSELVES DEMOCRATIC BUT THEY REALLY ARE NOT EX. DEMOCRATIC PEOPLE’S REPUBLIC OF KOREA (OLIGARCHY-COMMUNIST)
Types of Government Options for Canadian Confederation.
Warm Up Would you rather help make an important decision or would you rather have some one in charge of you make the decision? Explain your answer in 3.
Government Study and Foundation Of. Two Questions Who governs? To what ends should they work? From this basis springs the world we know as politics.
Allison Botkin M1L1 BLOG ASSIGNMENT.  Democracy is a type of government where the power is derived from the people based on their preferences  The people.
“Power and Powerlessness” John Gaventa. Power and Participation Explaining Quiescence Why, in circumstances of inequality, do challenges to that inequality.
Chapter Two: Majoritarian or Pluralist Democracy?.
Chapter 1 The Study of the American Government The Study of the American Government.
Introduction to Politics. Learning Objectives Explain why government exists Identify the source of Conflict in American Society Students will be able.
Government in America Who Participates… Theories of Democratic Government…
Do Now: What type of government does the United States have? List as many features of our government as you can.
Chapter One: The Study of American Government.  Who governs?  Personality and beliefs of our leaders effect us in a real way.  To what ends?  How.
AP Government Majoritarian or Pluralist Democracy?
TYPES OF GOVERNMENT * Government by one person * Government by the few
INTRO TO AMERICAN POLITICAL THEORY (Ch
Changing American Values
Intro to Politics: government & you
American democracy as a competition among interests
Chapter 1 Vocabulary Review
Chapter 1 Vocabulary Review
Would a system where everyone gets to vote on everything be better, or a system where one autocrat makes a decision for us all? Explain.
AP Gov Review: Video #6, Theories Of Democratic Government
Political Questions Who Governs? To What Ends? Not always easy to tell
Chapter 1: The Study of American Government
Chapter 1 Government in America.
Three models of government
Chapter 1 The Study of American Government
The Study of American Government
Unit 1 – Foundations of Guv’ment
Presentation transcript:

“Who Governs?” Robert Dahl

Who Governs? Open, but Unequal System: Who Governs? In a political system where virtually everyone can vote, yet there is vast inequalities in knowledge, wealth, social position, access to officials, who actually governs? (95)

New Haven: Who Governs? New Haven: Cumulative to Non-Cumulative Inequality The city experienced a radical change in last two centuries; changing from oligarchy to pluralism. (96) In the process, there was a profound change in “the way political resources are distributed among the citizens of New Haven.”

New Haven: Who Governs? Inequality did not disappear. But there was a shift from cumulative inequality to non-cumulative or dispersed inequality. Cumulative Inequality: Those who are better off in one resource, are more than likely better off in another, such as social standing, legitimacy…knowledge…

New Haven: Who Governs? Though New Haven is still unequal, it is not longer “dominated by one cohesive set of leaders…” That system has given away to one “dominated by many different sets of leaders…each with different resources. (96) It is, in short, a pluralist system.

New Haven: Who Governs? Pluralist New Haven: Still Not Clear Who Governs (96) Neither elites, nor people rule now. Who rules then? It is difficult to tell: it is complicated by the intricate relationships between leaders and citizens. (96) Not Clear Who is in Charge According to some, leaders are in charge. But from another perspective, constituents rule. Leaders are certainly in a reciprocal relationship with citizens.

Different Political Stratums Different Stratums: Political and Apolitical (97) In every political system, there are those who are highly active. They are the political stratum. Comparing Political and Apolitical For one, politics is highly salient, for the other it is remote, for one, political choice is calculated and informed, for the other it is more impulsive (or, more influenced by habit, unexamined loyalties, emotions…) (98)

Different Political Stratums Political Stratum is not a Single, Uniform Group (99) It is not a closed group, no are its members united in their orientation and strategies. There are cleavages… (99)

“A Preface to Democratic Theory” People Can Get Themselves Heard (100) They can get themselves heard by getting officials to respond to them. Nature of Govt Decision in Pluralist Democracy Decision in Pluralist Democracy is “a majestic march of great majorities united upon certain matters of basic policy. It is the steady appeasement of the relatively small groups… It is a decentralized system, and it is not a static system. ( )

The Nature of Power and Roots of Quiescence This type of control may happen in absence of conflict, which has been averted. Theory of Power cannot focus on actually behavior: it must consider also the way in which “potential” conflicts or debates are avoided, or prevented from ever occurring.