UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ UKCGS Conference, Oxford March 31,2015 Sami Kollanus University of Jyväskylä, Finland FROM WEAK MOTIVATION TO GRADUATION - FOUR.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1. Seven things you need to know
Advertisements

PURPOSE OF GRADUATE SCHOOL Ghana Technology University College.
Faculty of Health & Social Work Using Credit for Good Curriculum Design Presentation Revisit original objectives Impact of Credit on the Curriculum Who.
An Introduction to Postgraduate Study at the University of Plymouth Luke Sloan 17 October 2009.
Graduate School in English MA or PhD??. Am I ready for grad school… …or do I need a break?  Do I feel totally burned out? Do I have the stamina to finish.
Managing your supervisor Toby Walsh National ICT Australia Universities of NSW and Uppsala.
INTERNATIONAL COMMUNITIES OF POSTGRADUATE LEARNING: A CASE STUDY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF LIVERPOOL'S ON-LINE PROFESSIONAL DOCTORATE IN EDUCATION' HETL Conference.
UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ 2006 Guidance services in higher education University of Jyväskylä Guidance in Higher Education 8 November 2006 Tuula Maijanen.
The Pennsylvania State University. Topics Purpose Internal Information External Information The Actual Interview Questions.
Exploration of Physiotherapists’ Motivations to Embark upon Taught Master's Level Study Peter Glover MSc BSc (Hons) & Dr Cathy Bulley PhD BSc (Hons)
Why take classes through the Saskatoon Catholic Cyber School?
Preparing for your Interview. What the Employer is Seeking Communication skills Communication skills Focus & attention to detail Focus & attention to.
Agenda Preparation, and the Elevator-Pitch Competency-based Interviews Behavorial Questions STAR response Questions to ask.
Quality Assurance and Doctoral Studies Report of Working Group 4 Urbaan M. Titulaer Johannes Kepler University Linz, Austria.
Development and Promotion of the Faculty Teams in the Schools / Departments of Computer Science of the Universities in China Professor Xu Xiaofei School.
University of Jyväskylä Research Evaluation 2000–2004 General Results – Recommendations Dr. Antoaneta Folea Research Evaluation Coordinator Research and.
Answering open questions to prepare for an exam Teaching Psychology in Germany 6th International Conference on Psychology Education; Flagstaff 2014 Birgit.
Interdisciplinary role of English in the field of medicine: integrating content and context Nataša Milosavljević, Zorica Antić University of Niš, Faculty.
Everglades College Student Orientation by: EC Department of Professional Development.
Estelle M. Phillips and Derek S. Pugh Summarized by Chaky (2012) 1.
Welcome UALR COE Students
Chapter 8 Sport Management
Masaryk University Faculty of Arts Department of Educational Sciences Critical Incidents in Headteachers ۱ Professional Paths ( Examples from the Czech.
Chun-Tsai Wu 1,2, Szu-Ming Chung 1, and Shao-Shiun Chang 2 1 Department of Digital Content Design, Ling Tung University, 2 Department and Graduate Institute.
The Learning Agreement, Intellectual Property Rights and Project Approval Professor Dianne Ford Director of PhD Studies, Faculty of Medical Sciences.
The Systems of Mutual Assistance among the Africans in Moscow EASA 2008, Ljubljana Sergey Serov, Russian Academy of Sciences.
Tom Campbell Empowering students to “articulate” what matters to them during the transition from college to university.
Diversity in Graduate Education: Reflections and Realities UGA Teaching Academy Academic Affairs Faculty Symposium Friday, March 27, 2015 Michelle Cook,
Skills and Life after the PhD Lilian Simones
Career Planning and Development
Telemedicine conference Flexible education of nursing assistants in ”Studieverkstedet”
By Edward Lim 8.7.  What?  Today we started the Cornerstone Piece and we were given a few tasks to complete. The tasks were to watch the Kurt Fearnly.
Career Planning and Development
UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ OPEN UNIVERSITY University of Excellence in Adult Education Satu Helin 2006 Guidance services at the Open University University.
WORKSHOP ON CURRICULUM DEVELOPMENT FOR NEW SCHOOLS OF PUBLIC HEALTH: Review of Kaunas Workshop Linas Šumskas MD, PhD Assoc. Professor, Coordinator for.
Intro to Business, 7e © 2009 South-Western, Cengage Learning SLIDE1 CHAPTER Career Opportunities Planning Your Career Applying for.
NETWORKING AND MULTICULTURAL GUIDANCE SERVICES A challenge for counsellors and their organisations IAEVG Conference Jyväskylä, FINLAND Sauli Puukari.
When you LEARN new skills and/or IMPROVE existing skills.
Different approaches and experiences at the University of Parma (Italy) Embedding information literacy into subject learning Fabrizia Bevilacqua Monica.
EXPANDING YOUR TRANSITION TOOLBOX: Teaching Transition Knowledge and Skills “Building Futures” Transition to Education and Employment Conference Salem,
Confirmation of Candidature Progress Reports
High School Reform: Learning From Rigorous Research Prepared for the U.S. Department of Education High School Initiative Regional High School Summit St.
My Placement Year at Older Adult Mental Health Services,Medway. Katie Snow Supervisor: Reinhard Guss My Expectations I was worried at the start of my placement.
Dr Kirsty Gillespie CASS Research Office Preparing for a Discovery Postdoc 22 August 2008 Dr Kirsty Gillespie CASS Research Office.
ACADEMIC STUDY CULTURE Katja Kurasto International Relations Coordinator School of Engineering
Matters on Postgraduate Studies at FBE From November 2012 to November 2013 Office of PG Studies at FBE.
Information Processing Science Field of Education: Natural Sciences Faculty: Information Technology and Electrical Engineering Field of Education: Natural.
Introduction to Business © Thomson South-Western ChapterChapter Career Planning and Development Career Opportunities Planning Your Career.
How it Works There is a degree of flexibility within projects, so all aspects can be discussed and tailored on an individual basis. This includes: ¤ Project.
GRADUATE PROGRAMS. Chemistry M.S The Chemistry M.S. at the University of Central Florida is aimed at preparing students for careers in the chemical industry.
Time Management and Family Life Bobby CRA Academic Careers Workshop, February, 2016.
UCL CAREERS SUCCEEDING AT INTERVIEWS KAREN BARNARD DIRECTOR, UCL CAREERS.
Nestlé Graduate Programs. Agenda Presentation of Nestlé by Mona Monrad Hald - HR Recruitment specialist Denmark Introducing the Nestlé Graduate programs.
HRM 323 ASSIST The power of possibility/hrm323assistdotcom.
2007. Faculty of Education ► Staff 300 (incl.100 in Teacher training school) ► 20 professorships ► 80 lecturers ► 9 senior assistants ► 12 assistants.
© 2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. Principles of Business, 8e C H A P T E R 9 SLIDE 1 Career Opportunities Planning Your Career Applying for.
Graduate School of Medicine University of Wollongong Educators learning together and modeling interprofessional collaboration Sue Vella, Sal Sanzone, Helen.
University of Stirling STIRLING GRADUATE SCHOOL
MSc Studies in Economics and Finance at York
Starting out on a clinical academic pathway: the experience of a newly- qualified nurse Sarah Lea Faculty of Health and Social Care, London South Bank.
Study Abroad and Employability
Department of Teacher Education, University of Helsinki, Finland
Faculty HR Services Mari Svahn and Helena Knuuttila
The Learning Agreement, Intellectual Property Rights and Project Approval Professor Dianne Ford Director of PhD Studies, Faculty of Medical Sciences.
Pre-Engineering & Computer-Aided Design
Time management and motivation
Advising Doctoral Students
Guide to Strengthening Career Well-Being
By Meredith Forrey & Jessica Martinez
Presentation transcript:

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ UKCGS Conference, Oxford March 31,2015 Sami Kollanus University of Jyväskylä, Finland FROM WEAK MOTIVATION TO GRADUATION - FOUR UNEXPECTED STORIES

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ University of Jyväskylä 1863 Jyväskylä Teacher Seminary Multidisciplinary - 7 faculties 15,000 students staff 2,600 London Paris Madrid Rome Athens Berlin

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ

Case unit Finnish doctoral education –Free, no tuition fees –Unlimited studying time –Flexible study structures Faculty of information Technology –180 doctoral students –30 % women, 25 % international –Relatively young and fast graduates Participants: Full time & Finnish students

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ Research data 30 interviews –26 in different phases in their studies –4 recently graduated doctors Follow-up 3 years after the interviews

No/slow progress Expected progress Weak orientation & progress (n = 5) Weak orientation & progress (n = 5) Semi-orientation & progress (n = 4) Semi-orientation & progress (n = 4) Strong orientation & Progress (n = 6) Strong orientation & Progress (n = 6) Weak orientation & No/slow progress (n = 5) Weak orientation & No/slow progress (n = 5) Semi-orientation & No/slow progress (n = 7) Semi-orientation & No/slow progress (n = 7) Strong orientation & No/slow progress (n = 3) Strong orientation & No/slow progress (n = 3) Orientation & progress

No/slow progress Expected progress Semi-orientation & progress (n = 4) Semi-orientation & progress (n = 4) Strong orientation & Progress (n = 6) Strong orientation & Progress (n = 6) Weak orientation & No/slow progress (n = 5) Weak orientation & No/slow progress (n = 5) Semi-orientation & No/slow progress (n = 7) Semi-orientation & No/slow progress (n = 7) Strong orientation & No/slow progress (n = 3) Strong orientation & No/slow progress (n = 3) Orientation & progress Weak orientation & progress (n = 5) Weak orientation & progress (n = 5)

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ Factors in successful doctoral path Student: –Talented, intelligent, intellectually able –Proper motivation –Instrumental value of PhD for career plans –Physical and emotional stamina –Focused, self-directed –Social relatedness: Integrated with peers and faculty members –Personal issues: family situation, health –Earlier grades? Department –Supervising/advising –Financial support –Faculty attrition –Departmental politics

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ #1 Annie Industry -> employment in a research project No plan for doctoral studies The department expected PhD studies Worked alone - didn’t feel getting support from the supervisor(s) or the project team Didn’t see PhD providing much value for the future career ”I just do my work here”

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ … #1 Annie New supervisor Career change to industry -> one important meeting: –”I didn’t understand how much I had already done” –Motivation to finish the uncompleted degree (individual challenge + uncompleted task) short leaves from the work in industry to finish the doctoral thesis (change for fun) Graduated in ~5 years

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ #2 Jim Long path to M.Sc. Didn’t plan doctoral studies Work as a teaching assistant The department expected doctoral studies Found high intrinsic motivation to research Very little support form the supervisor Jim: ”independent learning process”

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ … #2 Jim A lot of teaching responsibilities PhD needed for an academic position Challenging research topic –A lot of independent learning –Difficulties in the evaluation process Graduated in ~6 years

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ #3 Peter Was asked to work for a research project during master’s studies (pretty technical work) Master’s thesis in the project Wasn’t so much into research –More practically oriented –Writing was challenging –Questioned meaning of the PhD Continued (as a PhD student) in the research group after M.Sc. -> no actual plan for PhD

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ … #3 Peter Wrote several articles with the research group Career change to industry Graduated in ~5 years

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ #4 Dan Master’s thesis in a research project Planned industrial career Random contact to the university through a company -> work in a research project PhD studies for professional development Supervision worked pretty well Got more interested in research during the doctoral path Graduated in 4 years Ei niin itsenäinen, mutta tunnollinen

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ Factor#1 Annie#2 Jim#3 Peter#4 Dan Supervision SemiWeak Strong Initial motivation Weak PhD -> career plans WeakStrongWeakSemi Faculty attrition Weak Peer support Weak StrongWeak Research environment StrongWeakStrongWeak Self-directed Strong Weak

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ Conclusion Key factors in successful doctoral path are individual Even one strength among several weak factors may enable successful graduation So what? –How could we take this into account in doctoral education? –Is there a useful way to identify individual differences in the beginning of the studies (or even in application stage)? –Is this even a relevant question in doctoral education? Do we even want this kind of students or only the students with ambitious aims for an academic career?

UNIVERSITY OF JYVÄSKYLÄ Thanks for your attention! Contact: