Department of Social Work and Social Administration UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG Poverty Reduction Strategy – Singapore M Ramesh.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The Dismal Economy Heather Boushey Center for Economic and Policy Research 8 April 2005.
Advertisements

Massachusetts HC Reform November 29, The Context The problem of the “uninsured” and “underinsured” is perennial issue Clinton Health Security Act.
1 Measurement and Analysis of Poverty in Jordan Joint Study by :  Ministry of Social Development  Department of Statistics  Department for Int’l Development.
In Work Poverty. Lesson Objectives I will get the opportunity to develop my understanding of the extend of in work poverty. I will be able to explain.
International Labour Office 1 The ILO Global Campaign to extend Social Security to all A new deal for people in a global crisis - Social security for all:
HEALTH AND WEALTH – PRELIM REVISION Critically examine the success of recent government policies to reduce poverty.
Bank of Israel Annual Report 2006 Presentation to Knesset Finance Committee May 2007.
1 Reducing the Gaps in Society: Policy Challenges in the Era of Globalization Dr. Karnit Flug June 2007 Taub Center Conference.
Unit 1 Economic Concepts
Social Security Includes a number of government programs designed to insure stability in income and standard of living Programs in Social Security: 1.Old.
Social Security Includes a number of government programs designed to insure stability in income and standard of living Programs in Social Security: 1.Old.
Social Security: Its Role in Retirement Planning William J. Arnone Ernst & Young LLP National Academy of Social Insurance September 2007.
Reforms to the Civil Service Pension Scheme Update: February 2012 Your Questions Answered.
Income Inequality and Poverty. Income Mobility Income mobility –The ability to move up and down the economic ladder over time Higher levels of income.
2000/2001 Household Budget Survey (HBS) Conducted by The National Bureau of Statistics.
Distribution of income and wealth Define income Market income= wages/salaries/profit/rent Gross income= market income + transfers Disposable income= gross.
12 th Global Conference on Ageing June 11-13, 2014 The Economic Support System for Senior Citizens in India: Restating the Obvious K S James Institute.
Research and Planning Administration National Insurance Institute National Insurance Institute Research & Planning Administration Herzliya Conference The.
1 Making Universal Health Care Work Jon Forman Alfred P. Murrah Professor of Law University of Oklahoma “The Future of Employer-Provided Benefits” John.
Module 9 ILO Game on!. Rules  6 groups  Each group answers 4 questions  And earns budget money to implement social protection in Coresia !  Time limit:
Free Trade Agreements: Helping U.S. Businesses Export.
Structural Change and Labor Policy Reaction in Asia
Incentives and the Welfare State James Mirrlees University of Melbourne and Chinese University of Hong Kong Trevor Swan Lecture ANU 13 March 2008.
Unemployment and its Natural Rate
Are public sector workers overcompensated? What impact does a higher standard of living for unionized public sector workers have on the economy? Public.
Confidential The Budget Presentation to the JCC By Eddie Teare MHK, Treasury Minister 18 February 2015.
Annual Conference May 19 – 22, 2015 St. Augustine, FL.
1 Chapter 12 Income Distribution, Poverty, and Discrimination Key Concepts Summary Practice Quiz Internet Exercises ©2002 South-Western College Publishing.
Chapter 6 Equity and Income Distribution
2 DATA AND ESTIMATION 3 4 CONCLUSIONS AND WAY FORWARD 1 MALAYSIAN DEMOGRAPHIC PATTERNS FINDINGS AND IMPLICATIONS.
1 Chapter 12 Income Distribution, Poverty, and Discrimination Key Concepts Summary Practice Quiz Internet Exercises ©2002 South-Western College Publishing.
Chapter 13SectionMain Menu Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment? How are unemployment rates determined? What is full employment?
Types of Unemployment Frictional Unemployment
12 October 2010 Livelihoods and Care: Synergies between Social Grants and Employment Programmes National Labour and Economic Development Institute.
 Poverty = when a person’s income and resources to not allow him/her to achieve a minimum standard of living  Minimum standard varies from country to.
The Role of the Fiscal Policy in Poverty Reduction Youngsun Koh Korea Development Institute.
Timebanking and Poverty: Creating Abundance in a Challenged Economy.
Poverty and the Distribution of Income
Chapter 13SectionMain Menu Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment? How are unemployment rates determined? What is full employment?
Poverty Programs. NEW DEAL REFORMS Created during the Depression President Franklin D. Roosevelt.
SOCIAL QUALITY INDICATORS: SINGAPORE M Ramesh LKY School of Public Policy National University of Singapore Paper presented at the Asian Conference on Social.
Fourth Annual Meeting of NTA Project University of California in Berkeley January 2007 CONSTRUCTION OF NATIONAL TRANSFER ACCOUNTS FOR INDIA: METHODS,
HOUSEHOLD BUDGET SURVEY EVALUATION. PROJECT OVERVIEW PRECURSORS State Program on Poverty Reduction & Sustainable Development ( ) CSOs given the.
Providing a Safety Net. Why Households Differ One of the main reasons why household income differs is because the number of household members who work.
Chapter 13: Economic Challenges Section 3. Copyright © Pearson Education, Inc.Slide 2Chapter 13, Section 3 Objectives 1.Define who is poor, according.
Poverty and Income Inequality in Edinburgh September 2015.
Reading Budgets. This presentation Explains how to read the budget tables in the February budget votes Explains how to read the budget tables in the annual.
1.02 ~ ECONOMIC ACTIVITIES AND CONDITIONS CHAPTER 2 MEASURING ECONOMIC ACTIVITY.
Introduction Characteristics of the Israeli labor market –Low participation rate in the labor force compared to OECD countries –High rate of foreign workers.
Reducing vulnerability and enhancing social protection.
Global trends and Social security issues for workers in non-standard forms of employment Study Visit of the delegation of the Social Insurance Fund of.
MINIMUM INCOME AND INCLUSION POLICY Challenges of a precarious inclusion model Brussels 6 April 2016.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western. Income Inequality and Poverty A person’s earnings depend on the supply and demand for that person’s labor, which in turn.
Social Welfare in THAILAND Office of the National Commission on Social Welfare Promotion, Ministry of Social Development and Human Security.
International Programme on the Elimination of Child Labour (IPEC) Fundamental Principles and Rights at Work (FPRW) Branch.
17 th Oct, 2012 ILO. Points 4 right answers! +200 billion dines! 3 right answers! +100 billion dines! 2 right answers! 0 1 right answers! 0 0 right answers!
Thailand’s outlook in 2009 Population : million Population : million Labour Force Labour Force employed : 38.7 million employed : 38.7 million.
Promoting social cohesion in Korea. Social spending is low but increasing rapidly Rising income inequality and relative poverty and the factors behind.
Poverty and Income Inequality in Edinburgh
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
MISSOC NETWORK MEETING,NICOSIA
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Unemployment What are the different types of unemployment?
Presentation transcript:

Department of Social Work and Social Administration UNIVERSITY OF HONG KONG Poverty Reduction Strategy – Singapore M Ramesh

Introduction Singapore’s welfare system has been described as a “full employment” model Chew, 2006) and as a “capital investment state” (Tang, 2000) L Singapore government firmly believes that economic growth is the best (only?) way to address the problem of poverty The strategy has largely worked Singapore has had one of the highest economic growth rates in the world over the last four decades Widespread abject poverty does not exit (though no data available!) GDP Growth, %, Annual Average High income OECD Singapore

Introduction The problems with this strategy are Growth has been low in some years Some people have not benefited from growth, and their numbers is increasing. Wages for low-income earners have declined in real terms in recent years Recent inflation has hit the poor hardest Income inequality is high and rising: gini rose from in 2000 to in 2007 (an under-estimate!) The focus of my discussion is: What is the government of Singapore doing about the problem of poverty? How well is it doing it? The answers are discouraging.

The Thinking underlying social policy in Singapore The government subscribes to an essentially Liberal conception of state’s role in social protection Individuals should fend for themselves Family should look after those who cannot fend for themselves State should be the last resort because public social protection Undermines work incentive incentives Distorts labour markets Weakens public finances Undermines family and community The Minister for Community Development described the government’s strategy as one of “assistance, not welfare; mutual obligation, not entitlement” (Balakrishnan, 2005).

The Thinking underlying social policy in Singapore State to provide assistance only To only those with “good” reason for being poor and no family to turn to And only to a minimal degree: not meant to cover all essential costs Assistance programs in Singapore are therefore stringent, provide small benefits, and of short duration.

Public Assitance Available to Singapore citizens who: “Are unable to work owing to old age, illness or unfavourable family circumstances; and Have no means of subsistence and little or no family support.” To receive benefit, one’s income needs to be below S$400 a month or 9% of per capita GDP PA rate is S$330 a month for elderly individuals, $1,020 for a family of two adults and two children, and $1,100 for family of five or more members. S$330 is equivalent to 7 % of per capita GDP Compared to OECD average of 25% of per capita GDP

ComCare It provides short term-assistance It is funded from a government-established endowment fund of S$1 billion only the earnings are used to pay benefits ComCare programmes include: (1) ComCare Enable, targeted at those who are unable to work and have no other means of support; (2) ComCare Grow, for children from low-income families and (3) ComCare SelfReliance, which is focused on assisting individuals and families in financial difficulty due to unemployment and the like to regain independence Small programs overall: only 2,754 cases in 2007

Workfare Income Supplement (WIS) scheme Benefit for low-wage older workers to incentivise them to remain in the workforce Subject to means test: <S41,500/month earning And employment in previous 6 months To improve empoyability of such workers, contribution to Central Provident Fund (CPF) for both employer and employee is reduced. The maximum payout per year is between S$900 for those aged and S$1200 for above 45 75% of the benefit amount is channeled to CPF Main purpose seems to be to address the shortcomings of CPF rather than supplement wages Total Expenditures: ??

Other programs Poor also have access to Nearly full primary and secondary education for entire population Means tested free health care Subsidized housing Subsidized utilities “Growth dividends” whereby government ‘shares’ budget surplus with population on ad hoc basis Available to everyone (S$100) but poor get more (S$400)

Social Protection Expenditures Many small programs for the poor Makes the total expenditure directed at the poor hard to calculate Social protection expenditure is projected to be S$168 million in 2008 – equivalent to 0.07% of GDP The government estimates that a single elderly can expect to receive S$1000 in cash by the end of the 2008, excluding benefits received from charities (MCYS Media Release, 11 April, 2008) Detailed breakdown not provided

Conclusion Programs for the poor Apply stringent means test Require family to support Aim to maintain labor market incentives or shore up provident fund that does not work for the poor Offer small benefits for short period of time Fragmented Lack transparency What exists now is vast improvement over what existed only a few years ago Government realizes that it cannot count on economic growth alone to address the problem of poverty. But limited by its ideology.

Average Monthly Household Income from Work Among Employed Households by Decile Deciles* Average Monthly Household Income from Work ($) st – 10 th th – 20 th st – 30 th st – 40 th st – 50 th st – 60 th st – 70 th st – 80 th st – 90 th st – 100 th Source: Singapore, Department of Statistics, Key Household Income Trends 2007, February 2007, Table A2