An Update 1 August 4, 2009.  The proposed hydro generating station at Bala Falls remains front and centre as an issue of concern to residents and cottagers.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Working Groups launch. Today What a Working Group is How they will operate What work they need to do Finalise the Working Groups Get you to sign up and.
Advertisements

The Green Arc Vision “Bringing the Big Outdoors closer to everyone – by creating, linking and managing extensive and valued landscapes for people and.
Ontario Jennifer Keyes/Kevin Edwards OMNR GLWC Offshore Wind Workgroup
Gondomar Polis Project - Sustainable Requalification of Gondomar's River Douro Waterfront PORTUGAL Gondomar Municipality 5th European Conference on Sustainable.
THE DIVERSITY OF INTERESTS IN ENVIRONMENTAL GOVERNANCE A CHALLENGE FOR THE RULE OF LAW By Professor D E Fisher.
Site Evaluation Workshop. Introduction to the Northern Development Taskforce The Northern Development Taskforce was established by Cabinet on the 15 June.
TULSA COMPREHENSIVE PLAN UPDATE Kathy Taylor, Mayor “We are not just producing a document, we are finding our shared vision for the future, finding new.
EXPLORING THE POLICY AND GUIDANCE THAT AFFECTS ENERGY RETROFIT PROJECTS Kayla Friedman AIA AFHEA
Freight-Supportive Guidelines ACT Canada – Sustainable Mobility Summit 2012 November 7, 2012 Ontario Ministry of Transportation.
Sustainable Nova Scotia An Overview FMI February 20, 2008.
Proposed CBS Municipal Plan and Development Regulations Amendments for Backlot Development Municipal Plan Amendment No. 9, 2015 Development Regulations.
Presentation and Management of Heritage Assets
Indigenous Culture and Tourism
October 4, 2004 Detrich B. Allen City of Los Angeles Environmental Affairs Department 1 Siting New Development Detrich B. Allen General Manager Environmental.
Alberta Land Uses; History, Current Status, and Future Trends The Development of a Land-use Framework for Alberta Synergy Alberta Conference October 28,
National Planning Policy Framework. 2 Planning reform: main aims Put power in the hands of communities - with policy that is radically streamlined and.
1 Brace Centre for Water Resources Management McGill University, Sept. 25 François Boulanger, Regional Director The New Canadian Environmental Assessment.
3 September UNDERSTANDING THE SEA 20 th May 2013 Presented by: K. Florence.
A division of Holcim (Canada) Inc. Public Information Session Proposed Extension of the Acton Quarry May 5, 2009.
MNR’s Role in Public Safety Around Dams –An Overview
Aberdeenshire Local Development Plan 2016 Identification of issues.
Driving Indiana’s Economic Growth. Management and Preservation of Indiana's Historic Bridges: A Programmatic Approach Thanks to Mead & Hunt & FHWA-IN.
Tourism Planning Lecture 3.
Community Development & Planning Grant Pre-Application Meeting April 17,
Natural England State of the Natural Environment, Strategic Direction refresh, and Manifesto Dr Helen Phillips, Chief Executive, Natural England.
Overview of Land Use Compatibility between Sensitive Land Uses and Nuisance Sources Peter Piersol A&WMA/OPPI Land Use Compatibility.
Santa Monica Sustainable City Plan Purpose The Sustainable City Plan was created to enhance our resources, prevent harm to the natural environment and.
EVALUATION AND APPRAISAL REPORT MAJOR COMMUNITY ISSUES RELATED TO COMPREHENSIVE PLAN Board of County Commissioners/ Local Planning Agency Joint Meeting.
Prepared by: ROBA KANDEEl بسم الله الرحمن الرحيم.
1 Context Sensitive Design CE 453 Highway Design Iowa State University Howard R. Green Company.
Ontario Waterpower Policy Initiatives The importance of being earnest Paul Norris President Ontario Waterpower Association.
Case study: SEA for land-use plan amendments of Krasna Hora municipality.
Planning the Future to enhance and sustain our town PETERSFIELD TOWN DESIGN STATEMENT.
 Introduction by the Chair  Confirmation of public notice  Municipal overview of planning applications  Public comment  Council & public questions.
UNESCO Intangible Cultural Heritage Section Basic Challenges of Sustaining Intangible Cultural Heritage.
Dominguez-Escalante National Conservation Area Dominguez Canyon Wilderness Resource Management Plan Scoping Meetings August 30 and 31, 2010.
The SSMP Process 1. The Servicing and Settlement Master Plan A plan to encompass the community’s visions and ideas, while approaching planning and servicing.
Connecticut Department of Energy and Environmental Protection.
EIA-legislation and practice in Norway history history latest amendments of regulations latest amendments of regulations integrated planning/EIA processes.
Anglophone West School District Education Council Sustainability Study – Bath Elementary and Middle Schools Executive Summary April 23, 2015.
National Historic Districts And Why Taylor Should Be Among Them.
© 2009 Barnes & Thornburg LLP. All Rights Reserved. This page, and all information on it, is the property of Barnes & Thornburg LLP which may not be reproduced,
Varteg Hill – Coal Recovery and Land Reclamation Pre-Application enquiry by Glamorgan Power Ltd. Members Seminar 31/3/14.
Sample Codes of Ethics in Adventure Tourism
Whistler Nordic Center: A systems perspective of the Callaghan Valley EIA Process Dan Kellar Wilfrid Laurier University October 20 th 2007.
Centre City Planning & Design, Land use Planning & Policy, City of Calgary HERITAGE CANADA FOUNDATION
Overview of Proposed Alaska National Wildlife Refuges Regulatory Changes U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service.
Presentation to Association Municipalities of Ontario Implementation of Management of Excess Soil - A Guide for Best Management Practices Ministry of the.
Hydro One Community Liaison Committee Minister’s Conditions Meeting #2 August 19, 2014 Solina Hall.
Valuation and Rating of Conservation Land and properties Policy issues and options 11 June 2003.
A Sustainable Tourism Framework for the Caribbean Mercedes Silva Sustainable Tourism Specialist Caribbean Tourism Organization “Ma Pampo” World Ecotourism.
Nigel Hannam and David Phillips Parish Conference – 11th September 2013 Balancing Development.
TRAP 5 th interregional meeting & Site Visits Limerick & Lough Derg, Ireland 9 th October 2013 CP3 GP6 Regional Planning Guidelines PP3 – Mid-West Regional.
1 First Nations Economic Development Readiness Questionnaire Presented By: Ontario First Nations Economic Developers Association and Ministry Of Economic.
River Design Overlay. The purpose of the River Design Overlay is to: ◦govern form, function, design and use for properties located within the boundaries.
1 Sahtu Land Use Planning Board Public Hearing on the Draft 3 Sahtu Land Use Plan May 2011 INAC Presentation.
Development Permit System. Development Permit System 2 Disclaimer  The information presented is provided as background information to facilitate understanding.
Gloucestershire County Council Devising a Spatial Vision & objectives for the MCS Robin Drake – Principal Planning Officer.
Buena Park General Plan Update Overview Presentation.
Parks and Recreation Commission
John Martin Reservoir Master Plan Revision
Nova Scotia’s Statements of Provincial Interest
Shaping the future of Laverstock and Ford Parish
CP3 GP6 Regional Planning Guidelines PP3 – Mid-West Regional Authority
Integrated Bilateral Agreement (IBA) 2018 to 2028
NHA Mission & Vision Statements
Proposed Zoning By-law Amendment & Future Consent Application
Planning Advisory Committee Orientation
Environmental Impact Statement (EIS)
MINI -HYDROPOWER Climate friendly but not devoid of environmental and social risk.
Presentation transcript:

An Update 1 August 4, 2009

 The proposed hydro generating station at Bala Falls remains front and centre as an issue of concern to residents and cottagers.  A recent survey of Moon River property owners, as summarized on the MRPOA website, indicates that 87% do not support Swift River’s current proposal and 77% do not support any hydro facility  The Environmental Screening Report has still not been released by the proponent Swift River Energy Limited (SREL) Overview 2

 Met with SREL in May and have had considerable dialogue with them in the interim, but no answers  On this issue Swift River have specifically stated:  “ We intend to update the web site when the ESR is released. Not until then.”  Particularly challenging in that we are now at a time when the majority of cottage owners are up for the summer and would very much appreciate a proponent sponsored open house and information update Overview 3

 At this point then, despite countless requests, we still do not know:  What the project will actually look like  Impact on the recreational use of the area  Impact on the spawning beds  Safety considerations  Scenic flow issues No New Information 4

 There has also been ongoing dialogue with Swift River regarding the necessity to post a performance bond, particularly given that: They are a single purpose company with no cross guarantees from any affiliated companies They have no prior operating history The company’s only asset will be the future right to sell electricity The proposed construction will be across the town’s primary access road and flood control corridor and involves land belonging to both the province and the District of Muskoka Fiduciary Responsibility 5

 In response Swift River has been very clear that the EA does not include anything concerning the “…posting of bonds or fiduciary responsibility” and is solely concerned with “with environmental mitigation”.  Given that we will be living with the results we should be concerned that a project started is a project completed to the very high standards on which any approvals were given Fiduciary Responsibility (cont’d) 6

 Still seeking a Balanced Solution for Bala  The original site was released by the MNR for purposes of hydro electricity, a purpose which is specifically at odds with the historical and current use of the site as parkland.  Following an alternate set of site release policies the MNR could have chosen to release the green space for park and conservation purposes in keeping with its historic and current use Optimal Use for the Site 7

 The MNR has confirmed these site release procedures which allow for other environmental issues such as public health and safety, visual and recreational concerns and social and economic factors  This site release process was designed by the government to protect sites such as Bala Falls from development and to prevent the specific conflict that we are now facing which is hydro generation being imposed on existing parkland  The warning words of the OPG are highly relevant: recreational activities do not mix with hydro facilities Optimal Use for the Site 8

 Bala Falls clearly meets the criteria as a cultural asset and park Waterfalls are an accepted cultural asset, recognized as essential to prosperous, livable, and sustainable communities Should remain undeveloped to meet Bala’s social, economic, and recreational requirements Allowed land uses within designated parkland specifically precludes hydro generation Use as a hydro facility conflicts with both historic and existing uses and Bala’s approved and official Streetscape Plan Why is Bala Falls not a Park? 9

Bala’s Streetscape Plan 10

 Going back in time it should certainly be of concern to all of us that the Chief Operating Officer of Swift River was also the Chair of the Ontario Waterpower Association at the time that the Bala site was released  By his own admission the OWA worked closely with the MNR on the site release policy Was the Site Release Conflicted? 11

 According to the Swift River’s COO “the MNR has released approximately 18 sites during the past fifteen years, and these are pretty well the only sites that their policies allow.”  The “MNR announced a large number of new parks, most of which followed rivers. Simultaneously they announced that in future waterpower would not be allowed in parks”.  “Bala is one of these very limited number of potential development sites that the rules allow.” Was the Bala Site “Cherry-Picked”? 12

 Is a blueprint for identifying and considering if a site meets the objectives of a Conservation Reserve  Identifies social and other values of local, regional, and provincial significance  Begins at the MNR local district level due to a request from the minister, the public, or a municipal body such as District Council  Defined by a Terms of Reference document and results in a Management Direction document  Removes onus from District Council for determining if SREL’s proposal is appropriate from a social/recreational perspective MNR’s Land Use Planning Process 13

 As per the Provincial Parks and Conservation Reserves Act, 2006, the specific objectives in establishing and managing conservation reserves is: 1. To permanently protect representative ecosystems, biodiversity and provincially significant elements of Ontario’s natural and cultural heritage and to manage these areas to ensure that ecological integrity is maintained. 2. To provide opportunities for ecologically sustainable land uses, including traditional outdoor heritage activities and associated economic benefits. Next Steps 14

 We believe that the 0.7 hectare site at Bala Falls meets these stated objectives of a Conservation Reserve would ask that the Chair of this Council write a letter to the MNR asking the province to review the site in the context of releasing this site as a Conservation Reserve  Additionally, Donna Cansfield, Minister of Natural Resources has confirmed a visit to Bala on Friday, October 2, 2009 Is there an expression of interest on the part of Council to participate in the events to be organized for this visit? Next Steps 15