23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Public Transport in Gauteng Province: Order out of Chaos Prof Nevhutanda Alfred Department of Transport(South.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
ATHENS UNIVERSITY OF ECONOMICS AND BUSINESS TRANSPORTATION SYSTEMS AND LOGISTICS LABORATORY (TRANSLOG) © Prof. K. Zografos STEPs STEPs Scenarios for the.
Advertisements

Smarter Travel Programmes– Financial impacts for Transport for London COLIN BUCHANAN
Mass Transit OSullivan Chapter 11. Outline of the Chapter Analyze some empirical facts about public transit in the United States Analyze the commuters.
Transport for Canberra 07 November2013. Transport for NSW: Regional Transport Plan ACT, whilst not part of the region, is an important destination Transport.
SCATTER workshop, Milan, 24 October 2003 Testing selected solutions to control urban sprawl The Brussels case city.
Mode Choice Lecture 10 Norman W. Garrick. Mode Choice The introduction of congestion charging in London in 2003 is one example of a situation where mode.
Hertfordshire Congestion Topic Group 11 June 2010.
Fundamental Requirements for Sustaining Mobility Prof. Dr. Ahmad Farhan Sadullah School of Civil Engineering Universiti Sains Malaysia 30 April 2013 A.
Transportation leadership you can trust. presented to Regional Transportation Plan Guidelines Work Group Meeting presented by Christopher Wornum Cambridge.
Feb Travel Time and Sustainable Travel Behaviour David Metz Centre for Transport Studies University College London.
Norman W. Garrick Mode Choice The introduction of congestion charging in London in 2003 is one example of a situation where mode choice modeling is needed.
Increasing the Quality of Public Transport in Prague Prague Integrated Transport.
Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative Paris and the Urban Transport Benchmarking Initiative Isabelle Bachmann- RATP- Paris.
Estimating Congestion Costs Using a Transportation Demand Model of Edmonton, Canada C.R. Blaschuk Institute for Advanced Policy Research University of.
Public transport framework plan for Buffalo City July, BUFFALO CITY MUNICIPALITY PUBLIC TRANSPORT FRAMEWORK PLAN PRESENTATION August 2008.
TRIPS, MODE & DISTANCE February MILLION TRIPS EACH DAY Out-of-Home impacts a big audience Source: Total Zenith.
CHAPTER 9 Heavy Rail GUIDELINES FOR PASSENGER TRANSPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA A MULTI MODAL ANALYSIS.
May 2009 Evaluation of Time-of- Day Fare Changes for Washington State Ferries Prepared for: TRB Transportation Planning Applications Conference.
Reforming transit Why smaller public transport subsidy is better Francesco Ramella, Ph.D. June 24-26, 2005 Bloomington, Minnesota.
GUIDELINES FOR PASSENGER TRANSPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA A MULTI MODAL ANALYSIS CHAPTER 1 BACKGROUND TO THIS STUDY GUIDE.
Analysis of the High Speed Rail in California Daniel Montanez 1, Antonio Castro 1 1 Napa Valley College, Napa, CA Abstract: San Francisco and Los Angeles.
City of Johannesburg Department of Development Planning, Transportation and Environment Transportation Planning and Management 08 September 2004 Presented.
CHAPTER 3 URBAN TRANSPORT PROBLEMS GUIDELINES FOR PASSENGER TRANSPORT IN SOUTH AFRICA A MULTI MODAL ANALYSIS [Transportation 3B – CBTL302]
The First International Transport Forum, May , Leipzig INDUCING TRANSPORT MODE CHOICE BEHAVIORIAL CHANGES IN KOREA: A Quantitative Analysis.
Transit Estimation and Mode Split CE 451/551 Source: NHI course on Travel Demand Forecasting (152054A) Session 7.
Competition Reforms in Bus transport sector In Zambia National Advocacy Plan (CREW Project) CREW NRG-IV Meeting, 22 nd April, Lusaka.
Feasibility Study Jonathan CalderwoodJune 14, 2013 West Shore Communities Feasibility of Sustainable Transportation with Passenger Ferry Service.
Sustainable travel for Limerick and Area By Professor Lewis Lesley.
Modelling of Trips using Strategic Park-and-Ride Site at Longbridge Railway Station Seattle, USA, Oct th International EMME/2 Users Conference.
D/TTAS - Transport policy data needs Transport Statistics Liaison Group 19 th September 2013.
Embedding Travel Planning in the Development Process Sarah Cummings Behaviour Change Transport for London.
Presented by Runlin Cai, CAUPD Affiliate. Issue: What determines travel mode choice Transit mode share in LA county was 3% in (Source: SCAG Year.
CREW Project Research Findings of Diagnostic Country Report (DCR), Ghana Bus Transport Sector.
 Scotland’s National Transport Strategy A Consultation.
PUBLIC TRANSPORT IN SKOPJE: NEW APROACH FOR BETTER QUALITY OF SERVICE
Innovative ITS services thanks to Future Internet technologies ITS World Congress Orlando, SS42, 18 October 2011.
Olympic Transportation Planning For London 2012 A Peak Flow And Modal Share Analysis For Rail Usage At The Stratford Regional Station.
Transport for Canberra. 1.Setting the scene 2.Public transport 3.Active travel 4.Roads, Parking, Freight and Fleet 5.Measuring our progress 6.How to have.
GNTP Business Forum – The Big Idea – Gary Smerdon-White 18 th September 2012.
Client Name Here - In Title Master Slide Data Requirements to Support Road Pricing Analyses Johanna Zmud, Ph.D. NuStats Partners, LP Expert Forum on Road.
David B. Roden, Senior Consulting Manager Analysis of Transportation Projects in Northern Virginia TRB Transportation Planning Applications Conference.
Tshwane Growth and Development Strategy Towards Integrating Public Transport and Urban Planning Presented by: Jan Coetzee Pr Eng Part of the Comprehensive.
Cal y Mayor y Asociados, S.C. Atizapan – El Rosario Light Rail Transit Demand Study October th International EMME/2 UGM.
Key problems and priorities in urban transport sector in SEE Regional Meeting on Sustainable Transport Policies in South Eastern Europe Budapest,
Gauteng Strategic Plan Update Public Transport GDS 2055 Summit Hishaam Emeran, General Manager: Strategic Network Planning 7 September 2012.
David Connolly MVA Transport, Travel and SHS Data SHS Topic Report: Modal Shift.
1. Variety of modes (types) of transport (public and private) 2. Density of transport networks more nodes and.
DEMOCRITOS DEveloping the MObility CRedits Integrated platform enabling travellers TO improve urban transport Sustainability Grant agreement no
The Scottish Ferries Review Consultation Document 2010 Arran - 12 July 2010 Graham Laidlaw.
Submission Document went to cabinet … Planning for the Future Core Strategy and Urban Core Plan (the Plan) is a key planning document and sets out the.
Janos MONIGL director of TRANSMAN Ltd 1968 TU Dresden – M.Sc.traffic engineer 1974 TU Budapest – M.Sc.engineer economist 1976 Hungarian Academy of Science.
Impacts of Free Public Transport – An Evaluation Framework Oded Cats Yusak Susilo Jonas Eliasson.
Transportation Planning Asian Institute of Technology
Preconditions for the introduction of free public transport in Tallinn Dago Antov Tallinn University of Technology Professor on transport planning 1 Tasuta.
The Gauteng Economic Indaba Transport and Logistics Mr Piet Sebola Group Executive Strategic Asset Development Date: 09 th June 2016.
Public transport quality elements – What really matters for users? By Dimitrios Papaioannou and Luis Miguel Martinez Presentation for the 20 th ECOMM in.
How may bike-sharing choice be affected by air pollution
T-Share: A Large-Scale Dynamic Taxi Ridesharing Service
Our Bus Service Konrad Pulé – October 2016.
Modelling Sustainable Urban Transport
Traffic Management in Singapore
Long term strategy and structure
36th Southern African Transport Conference
SATC 2017 Influence Factors for Passenger Train Use
SATC 2017 SOUTHERN AFRICAN SOLUTIONS TO PUBLIC TRANSPORT CHALLENGES
NORMS AND STANDARDS FOR PUBLIC TRANSPORT IN GAUTENG PROVINCE
Prepared by: Riyaaz Ebrahim
DISRUPTIVE TRANSPORT TECHNOLOGIES: IS SOUTH AND SOUTHERN AFRICA READY?
38th Southern African Transport Conference 8 July 2019 By Muzi Nkosi
SATC Patronage Time Distribution Ratios for Train (and PT) Services
Presentation transcript:

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Public Transport in Gauteng Province: Order out of Chaos Prof Nevhutanda Alfred Department of Transport(South Africa) Chairperson of South African License Board Forum

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Gauteng Map

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Gauteng Population and Transport Usage The most densely populated of South Africa's nine provinces, however, is Gauteng, with some 9.6- million people (20.2% of the total population) occupying just 1.4% of the country's land area. Where one third of the province's population are public transport users More than 70% of this one third use taxi's as their mode of transport. It is also assumed that the section of the population that has no access at all to mobility, are most likely to walk, cycle or use a taxi.

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 An Example of a Gauteng Commute Now we take a look at the examples below to see a typical example of how congestion is changing the amount of time we spend on the road, as well as our traveling speed. (Speeds are average speeds traveled with and without congestion.)  Pretoria to Sandton – am (55km) Without congestion 35 minutes at 94,2km/h With congestion 90 minutes at 36,6km/h  Sandton to Sunninghill (10km) Without congestion 18 minutes at 33,3km/h With congestion 30 minutes at 20km/h Looking at the two trips when the roads are congested, you can see that driving time would increase by 122 minutes. If you were to drive these routes each working day of the month (21 days), you will be on the road for an additional 42,7 hours, and in the course of the working year (11 months) that’s an additional 468,7 hours! For the same number of kilometres reflected on the vehicle’s odometer, your vehicle is running for an extra 469,7 hours. And in that time, if you were traveling at an average speed of about 40km/h and there was no congestion, you could cover nearly additional kilometres.

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Gauteng Traffic Photos

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Content of Presentation Problem statement Travel needs of communities in Gauteng Corresponding minimum and target LOS Development of strategic model Calibration and sensitivity results of model Shortcomings of the model Policy analysis and results Conclusions and Recommendations

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Problem Statement Public Transport (PT) in SA and Gauteng riddled with problems Characterised by poor performance e.g. late arrivals, over- crowdedness, non-availability Old and unsafe vehicles compromise safety of passengers

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Research Questions  Is there any PT service available and accessible?  How frequently are the services provided?  I s the service affordable?  What level of service can be expected?  What are the demand and cost implications of providing an improved service?

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Travel Needs in Gauteng PT less convenient than private transport, need to be minimised to make service attractive. The most pressing public transport problems in Gauteng relate to: Available and accessibility of service Service capacity (i.e. crowding) Frequency of service Cost of public transport Safety and security issue Forms basis for KPI development, which provide mechanism for performance evaluation

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Status Quo Analysis for Province Walking distances for train services by far the longest (exceed 1000m) All models have average waiting times less than 10 mkins in AM peak period Ave spending estimated at only 1.1% above the standard (although +60% of users spend>10% of income on PT) Low satisfaction ratings regarding personal safety at stations and on vehicles Nearly 64% of minibus-taxis and 50% of buses older than required lifespan of 10 mand 12 years respectively

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Selected KPIs & Corresponding Minimum and Target LOS

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Market Segmentation Municipal Areas in Gauteng Average Household Income > R3 000 Average Household Income < R3 000 Average Car Ownership per household < 0.6 ZONE 1 High Public transport utilization (>50%) ZONE 2 Low Public transport utilization (<50%)

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Description of Model Components Demand Model Predicts shifts in modal splits due to LOS changes Utility functions calculate mode utility from attributes Probability of Selecting mode – LOGIT model Results feed into resource model Resource Model: Determines investment level required Capital and Operating cost Impact prediction based on changes in : Ridership/annum Pass.km/annum Cost /passengers (operating, capital, total) Subsidy levels

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Sensitivity Tests Highlights To establish impact of variables on mode choice and cost Demand most elastic in the following ranges: Fares: R3.50 – R5.50 Peak frequency: 5 – 15 dep/hr Walking time : 0 – 20 mins Resource model Fares highest impact on income and cost (e>1) Least impact on cost from increased service hours and security improvements

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Calibration of Model Desired calibration goals Inclusion of PT and car modes Inclusion of all relevant attributes Utility function for each mode Good Stated Preference data required good prediction of modal split expected Calibration results Car mode disturbed calibration Only walk, waiting time/frequency, fare per trip, % income spent on PT incorporated Underestimation of possible shift in demand One utility function,diff.ASCs (initially dominant) Only Revealed Preference data (lack of variation,no info on alternatives not chosen) Modal spilt predicted with good accuracy (<0.3%)

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Main Conclusions & Recommendations Approach of integration demand / resource (supply) modeling techniques suitable Minimum LOS less resource deficient Measures to be prioritised by cost implications can be off-set against increase in fares Data availability and quality to be improved Inclusion of all variable in demand model Additional research for low-income market with low PT utilisation

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Planning: Ensuring effective and informed planning which prioritised public transport and good land use management. Public Transport: Ensuring a quality public transport system that offers a realistic alternative to individual transport Transport Infrastructure: Increasing provision of transport infrastructure with focus on public transport friendly facilities and transformation of delivery Road Space Management : Ensuring efficiency and effectiveness of the transport system for the movement of people and goods Regulation: Ensuring regulation of the public and private transport system so that it is efficient and safe. Freight and Logistics: Ensuring that goods are moved efficiently and safely around the province and between the province and the sub-regions Recommendations

23e Congrès mondial de la Route - Paris 2007 Finito THANK YOU