Analyses on the National Energy Efficiency Action Plans Assessments of the 1st NEAAPs and Challenges for the 2nd Round Dr. Ralf Schüle Wuppertal Institute.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
EU – ACP PROGRAMME FOR SCIENCE AND TECHNOLOGY INNOVATIONS AND CAPACITY BUILDING (PSTICB) 9 ACP RPR 61.
Advertisements

The PV Policy Group Project FIRST THEMATIC WORKING GROUP MEETING Friday 07 October 2005 in Catania, Italy Presentation Markus Kurdziel & Corinna Klessmann.
A 2030 framework for climate and energy policies Energy.
Renewable Energy Action Plan Martin Finucane DCENR.
EMAS III: A mature instrument for new challenges Soledad BLANCO Director, Directorate Industry DG Environment.
Dynamics with Responsibility Road Safety Priorities in Austria Dr. Eva M. Eichinger Federal Ministry for Transport, Innovation and Technology Road Directorate.
1 Energy Info Day FP7-ENERGY th December 2007 NOT LEGALLY BINDING Bruno Schmitz, DG RTD European Commission Introduction to 2008 RTD Energy Calls.
National Energy Study for the Slovak Republic ISTVAN DOBOZI LEAD ENERGY ECONOMIST/PROGRAM LEADER ENERGY DEPARTMENT EUROPE AND CENTRAL ASIA REGION THE WORLD.
REMODECE Project: WP6: Strategies for Market Transformation and Recommendations to Policy Makers Aggelidis Konstantinos Centre for Renewable Energy Sources.
Capacity building for public authorities – EE7 Veronika Czako Project Adviser, EASME.
REMODECE Project: WP6: Strategies for Market Transformation and Recommendations to Policy Makers Markogiannakis Georgios Centre for Renewable Energy Sources.
Dr. techn. Bedri Dragusha CEO of KEEA The Role of Energy Efficiency in Sustainable Development.
Workshop on the preparation of the fourth national communications by Parties included in Annex I to the Convention 30 September - 1 October 2004, Dublin,
Seppo Silvonen Seppo Silvonen, Motiva Oy Finland Energy auditing as an essential part of the investment process Finnish national and EU energy.
Common recommendations and next steps for improving local delivery of climate finance Bangkok, October 31, 2012.
Page 1 „Development of energy saving obligations for utilities – Energy Efficiency Resource Standards – in Thailand“ Dr Milou Beerepoot Director GIZ Energy.
EU POLICIES ON ENERGY PERFORMANCE OF BUILDINGS: the role of air tightness and ventilation Users & Stakeholders TightVent Meeting, Brussels 24 MARCH 2011.
Ján Magyar Department of International Relations in Energy Energy Section Ministry of Economy of the Slovak Republic , SK-NO Cooperation, Bratislava.
REGIONAL POLICY EUROPEAN COMMISSION The EU Recovery Plan and the proposal amending the European Regional Development Fund Regulation.
Contract number: EIE/06/128/SI Project duration: November 06 - April 2009 National Workshops Bottom up example – Energy labelling for white appliances.
| 1 Guido de Wilt DG TREN D4 EUROPEAN POLICY REGARDING MICRO-CHP EUROPEAN COMMISSION.
Energy-Efficiency-Watch (EEW) - Basics on the project – Dr. Jan Geiss Secretary General EUFORES Coordinator of the EEW SpanishWorkshop In cooperation with.
1 Noise and rail What about Belgium ? Martine Serbruyns Federal Public Service Mobility and Transport Brussels - 28 april 2014.
© OECD/IEA 2010 Energy Policies of the Czech Republic 2010 In-depth Review Energy Policies of the Czech Republic 2010 In-depth Review Prague, 7 October.
The 27 National Energy Efficiency Action Plans – Results of the In Depth Analysis Brussels, 5 Oct 2010 Daniel Becker.
Contract number: EIE/06/128/SI Project duration: November 06 - April 2009 National Workshops Didier bosseboeuf (ADEME) 22 janvier 2008.
2 nd National Energy Efficiency Strategy Review EELN Consultation Workshop 24 April
A worked example for Denmark using the proposed EU Directive rules Senior Adviser Peter Bach Danish Energy Authority EU and eceee expert seminar on measurement.
Energy Efficiency in EU buildings CPI WORKSHOP, BERLIN 18 FEBRUARY 2011 Dr Marina Economidou Expert in Energy Efficiency Buildings Performance Institute.
EU 2030 climate and energy update. Climate Action Network Europe over 120 member organisations in more than 25 European countries.
Anni Podimata MEP Member, Committee on Industry, Research and Energy 8th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency Budapest,
© OECD/IEA INTERNATIONAL ENERGY AGENCY Worldwide Trends in Energy Use and Efficiency Key Insights from IEA Indicator Analysis ENERGY INDICATORS.
Result Orientation in Interreg CENTRAL EUROPE Annual Meeting, Luxemburg, 15 September 2015 Monika Schönerklee-Grasser, Joint Secretariat.
Twinning Project Project Number BG2004/IB/EY/01 “Institutional Building at the Energy Efficiency Agency (EEA)” 28 September 2007, Varna Project Leader.
Ukraine In-Depth Energy Efficiency Review VI International Specialized Trade Fair “ENERGY EFFICIENCY RENEWABLE ENERGY – 2013”, Kiev, 8 November 2013 Steivan.
Promoting Renewable Energies – in Germany and worldwide Dr. Karsten Sach at Eco Cities of the Mediterranean Forum 2008 October 20, 2008.
1 Twinning Project Project Number BG2004/IB/EY/01 “Institutional Building at the Energy Efficiency Agency (EEA)” Financial Incentives Seminar 28 th September.
A new impetus for Europe's energy efficiency policy Paul Hodson Head of Unit DG Energy, European Commission 09/10/2012.
24/11/2015 The templates for National Renewable Energy Action Plans EUFORES – 9 th Interparliamentary meeting Brussels, 18 November 2009 EUROPEAN COMMISSION.
IFIEC Europe International Federation of Industrial Energy Consumers 1 Promotion of Renewable Energies in the EU Member States Consequences on the Price.
The industrial relations in the Commerce sector EU Social dialogue: education, training and skill needs Ilaria Savoini Riga, 9 May 2012.
Energy Efficiency Industrial Forum Andrew Warren Senior Advisor, EuroACE.
Climate Action Meeting the EU’s Kyoto commitments & Avoiding a gap after 2012 Doha, 27 November 2012 Paolo CARIDI Policy Coordinator DG Climate Action.
The European Union Climate Policy and Related Data Needs Velina Pendolovska European Commission, DG Climate Action Meeting on Climate Change Related Statistics.
European Environment Agency ‘Trends and projections in Europe’ – Tracking progress towards Europe’s climate and energy targets for 2020 François Dejean.
Commission proposal for a new LIFE Regulation ( ) Presentation to Directors Meeting DK 22 May 2012.
Renewable Energy Statistics Keep-on-Track! 1 st Policy Workshop 23 January
The renewables Directive 1.Sets mandatory national targets for renewable energy shares, including 10% biofuels share, in 2020 (Articles 3 and 5) 2.Requires.
The EU energy efficiency action plan - one year after Mariangiola Fabbri WWF European Policy Office Brussels 29/01/2008.
Research Activities in Response to IPCC TAR John Christensen UNEP.
Introducing Regulatory Impact Analysis into the Turkish Legal Framework “Training the Trainers” November 2008 Assessing Alternatives to Traditional.
The Regulatory Assistance Project 48 Rue de Stassart Building C, BE-1050 Brussels, Belgium Phone: web: 20 Years of Energy.
Turin Final Conference 25 September 2014 Work Group 1 Cordelia Koenig Ministry of Urban Development and Environment Hamburg Turin Final Conference 25 September.
12/06/2016 Implementation of the European Experience in Buildings Energy Efficiency in Flanders/Belgium Ils Moorkens, Wouter Cyx, Kristien Aernouts.
The 12L Regulations in Relation to the National Energy Efficiency Strategy 25 June 2015 Eskom Tower, Kimberley Presented by Daniel Modise 1.
SIMONA MURRONI Bruxelles - June 27th 2013 Bridging lessons learned from the past with new planning and delivery approaches in the energy sector.
EUROPEAN REGIONAL DEVELOPMENT FUND CLUE final conference, 24 September 2014, Turin EU Interregional Cooperation State of play and perspectives Johanna.
SETTING THE STANDARD: ENERGY MANAGEMENT for SUSTAINABLE ACTION PLANS
European Topic Centre on Sustainable Consumption and Production (ETC/SCP) Lars Fogh Mortensen, Head of Group Sustainable Consumption and Production.
1st China - Belgium Innovation Dialogue R&I landscape and policy in Belgium by Ms Zuhal Demir, State Secretary for Science Policy 30 March,
CLIMATE CHANGE POLICY SCENARIOS - BULGARIA
Overview Rationale Context and Linkages Objectives Commitments
Dan Tofan | Expert in NIS 21st Art. 13a WG| LISBON |
EU-RUSSIA Cooperation in Energy Efficiency
SOCIAL DIALOGUE WITHIN EUPAN
Overview Rationale Context and Linkages Objectives Commitments
EU plan: Supporting directives • The EU Renewable Energy Directive was adopted at the end of 2008 • EU Renewable Energy Directive.
Energy efficiency in buildings
What's new on energy efficiency at DG ENERGY in 2016
Presentation transcript:

Analyses on the National Energy Efficiency Action Plans Assessments of the 1st NEAAPs and Challenges for the 2nd Round Dr. Ralf Schüle Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy 9th Inter-Parliamentary Meeting on Renewable Energy and Energy Efficiency 18 th November 2009 Parliament of Belgium

1 Overview Energy Efficiency Watch Project Context Energy Consumption in the EU and Policy Framework Belgian National Energy Efficiency Action Plan(s) as Exercise and Indicator Policy Conclusions November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

2 Energy Efficiency Watch - Project Context  Project initiated and supported by more than 30 Parliamentarians from the European Parliament and National Parliaments  Co-ordinated by EUFORES - European Forum for Renewable Energy Sources  Core group:  Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy  ECOFYS  Upper-Austria Energy Agency  ECEEE  In co-operation with the energy efficiency related industry and NGOs (as supporting partners) November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

3 Final Energy Consumption and Baseline Projections (in ktoe) Source: PRIMES (2006) November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels Final Energy Consumption in the EU (in ktoe) Final Energy Consumption in Belgium (in ktoe)

4 Implementation Lag: Energy Efficiency Policy in the EU and the Role of the ESD Climate change mitigation policy: Absolute and mandatory cap (minus 20 %, maybe more) Revision of EU ETS until 2020 passed Effort Sharing Dec. until 2020 passed Renewable energy policy: Mandatory target (20% share) Breakdown for each MS until 2020 passed Energy efficiency policy: Indicative targets of 20% primary energy savings compared to projections by 2020 plus 9 % final energy savings by 2016 (ESD) EuP, EPBD, Labelling, ESD – all still in implementation process New energy efficiency action plan drafted 18 November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

5 12 May 2009PRASEG and EUFORES Seminar on NEEAPs Formal Requirements of the ESD  Energy Efficiency and Energy Service Directive (ESD) requires MS  to adopt target to achieve an overall national indicative reduction target in end-energy use of 9%... for the 9th year of application... ( )  to submit three Energy Efficiency Action Plans: 2007, 2011, 2014  Only a few formal requirements are given in the ESD:  Calculation of national indicative annual energy savings target adopted for 2016 and national intermediate indicative annual energy savings target adopted for 2010  Displaying energy efficiency improvement programmes, energy services, and other measures planned for achieving the target  Measures and strategies complying with the provisions on the exemplary role of the public sector, and the provision of information and advice on end energy efficiency on end users.  Space for interpretation:  Additionality (ESD vs. Action plan)?  Early Energy Savings prior to 2008?

6 Assessment of Belgian National Energy Efficiency Action Plan(s)  Sources:  EC Assessment and EEW Evaluation of 27 Plans  Submission and target: Belgium submitted 4 plans (Federal Plan and 3 Regional Plan: Wallonian, Flemish, Brussels-Capital) Federal plan does not contain a 9% national energy savings target November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

7 Assessment of Belgian National Energy Efficiency Action Plan(s)  Additional information provided in 4 EEAPs  Involvement of energy companies, retailers etc. only in Brussels and Flemish plan explicitly mentioned  Information on role of energy services and financing of measures is provided in all plans  Brussels and Wallonian plan remain intransparent about implementing additional measures  Federal and Flemish plan claim for early energy savings achieved prior to November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

8 Assessment of Belgian National Energy Efficiency Action Plan(s)  Assessment (EC and EEW) (1): Diversity of Plans  Large heterogenity of four plans in terms of content and presentation  Scarcity of detailed information on measures displayed especially in the Federal and Wallonian plan  Relation between technical energy saving potentials, energy saving targets and measures implemented is not transparent  Incompatibility and incomparability of plans:  2016 target of Wallonian plan expressed in PE, Flemish target in FE  EEAP of Flanders and Wallonia apply conversion factor 1 for electricity, while EEAP of Brussels-Capital uses 2.5 for electricity  With the exception of the Flemish EEAP no plan does contain any estimates of expected energy savings.  However: Belgian plans draws attention on the relationship between, and integration of regional and federal acivities November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

9 Assessment of Belgian National Energy Efficiency Action Plan(s)  Assessment (EC and EEW) (2): Packages of measures  Four EEAPs have good sectoral coverage with exception of agricultural sector  Example 1: Residential Building sector November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels Wallonian plan provides a „full“ package of measures: information campaigns, information centres and facilitators, trainings, labelling, thermal regulation, energetic standards up to subsidies Flemish plan contains REG (Rationeel Energie Gebruik)

10 Assessment of Belgian National Energy Efficiency Action Plan(s)  Example 2: Transport sector  Federal plan contains 11 measures (10 in place since 2007)  main target: modal shift  Focus of measures on information and tax incentives for companies and private commuters  however: transport sector main driver of expected increase of energy consumption,  Sector not adequately addressed  expected energy saving of improving transport infrastructures is ambivalent (example from Wallonia: new railway station at Gosselines airport)  Innovative elements (Flanders):  REG obligation  Audit covenant November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

11 Conclusions: Measuring Energy Savings  New Action Plan:  Mandatory efficiency targets  White Certificates Schemes (already in operation in UK-CERT, Italy, France, Denmark and !Flanders)  Energy Efficiency Fonds  Conclusions:  Harmonisation of NEEAPs (template) for 2011-process and Harmonisation of evaluation methods  Member States need support from the EC and partners in other MS to establishish capacities  Crucial issue: additionality/early energy savings  Recommendation (after EEW and EMEEES): twin targets for MS: 1. mandatory targets for energy consumption (to guarantee result) PLUS 2. indicative energy savings targets (to enable MS to demonstrate success of their efforts) November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brussels

Thank you for your attention! Dr. Ralf Schüle Wuppertal Institute for Climate, Environment and Energy ++49/(0)202/ Please see for details: (brochure for download)

13 Final Energy Consumption in selected MS in Mio t OE Source: EUROSTAT 18 November 20099th Interparliamentary Meeting, Brusels