The Integration of PoA and NAMA; how can one support the other Ingo Puhl South Pole Carbon Asset Management Ltd. Bonn, 8. May 2011 Prepared by South Pole.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Ongoing discussions on the formulation of National Appropriate Mitigation Actions (NAMAs) and their possible inclusion as market mechanisms in a post-2012.
Advertisements

Paulo Manso CDM EB September, 2011 Proceeder for Submission & Approval Standardized Baselines.
· © 2011 Perspectives GmbH Towards practical application of CDM Standardized Baselines – Perspectives experience.
PoA Challenges & Opportunities
BASELINE STANDARD UNFCCC secretariat workshop
Durban Decisions on the Clean Development Mechanism DUAN Maosheng Chair of the CDM Executive Board First SDM Joint Coordination Workshop Bonn,
Regional Distribution
UNFCCC secretariat, Sustainable Development Mechanisms Verónica Colerio, Standard Setting Unit Standardized Baselines in the CDM: Decisions and Way Forward.
JI Governance – review of JI Guidelines
PoA AFTER Cancun - READY TO TAKE OFF NOW
UNFCCC secretariat, Sustainable Development Mechanisms Programme Conor BARRY Improving and demonstrating efficiency in CDM processes 7 th Joint Coordination.
CDM Regional Distribution Ensuring Broader Participation in the CDM Presented by: Albert Altarejos MAGALANG DNA Forum Chairing Committee.
Defining Standardized Baseline: The role of DNAs Malin Ahlberg Co-Chair of the DNA Forum 13 March 2011, Bonn.
CDM baseline standardization – key policy questions Axel Michaelowa Center for Comparative and International Studies (CIS), University of Zurich and ETH.
NATIONAL SYSTEMS UNDER ARTICLE 5 OF THE KYOTO PROTOCOL EC workshop on Quality Control and Quality Assurance of Greenhouse Gas Inventories and the Establishment.
T HE W ORLD B ANK C ARBON F INANCE U NIT Standardised Baselines Framework March 24-25, Bonn.
Development and Prospects for JI UNFCCC Side Event November 30, 2005 Hiroshi YAMAGATA Ministry of Economy, Trade and Industry JAPAN.
Group Integrating CDM and PoA structures into a NAMA: Case-Studies by South Pole Group September 5 th 2014 Christian Dannecker Director Forestry and Land.
Ensuring Effective Monitoring, Certification and Verification of Emissions by Jed Jones Lloyd’s Register.
James Grabert Manager, Joint Implementation, UNFCCC secretariat Joint Implementation Overview & Status Kyoto Protocol and Carbon Market.
Presentation title Session 3: The Concept of Programme of Activities (PoA) PoA Registration and CPA inclusion Training-Workshop to support the “Uganda.
Ideas on NAMA development and implementation Carolyn Neufeld KfW Carbon Fund.
From PoAs to NAMAs a pilot case. 222 Agenda 1. Context of discussions 2. Objective and concept for NAMA Pilot Case 3. Introduction to example PoA – EE.
How to develop a NAMA by scaling-up ongoing programmatic CDM activities On the road from PoA to NAMAs Berlin, April 2011 Prepared for: KfW Bankengruppe.
SDM programme UNFCCC secretariat Session 2: The CDM project cycle Monitoring, Verification and CER issuance Training-Workshop to support the “Uganda Municipal.
The New Market Mechanism Emissions Trading – Developments in China & Europe Workshop 25 th April 2012 Dr Luke Redmond
UNFCCC Secretariat Status of negociations on CDM Perumal Arumugam Regional Workshop on CDM and NAMAs for Latin America and the Caribbean,Bogota, (31 –
Joint Implementation & Gas Flaring Reduction Projects Alexandrina Platonova-Oquab Carbon Finance Unit, World Bank.
Revision of key attributes and transitional measures relating to possible changes in the JI guidelines Wolfgang Seidel, Chair of the Joint Implementation.
1 Georg B ø rsting Chair of the JI Supervisory Committee Joint Implementation 1-3 April 2008 Bangkok, Thailand AWG-KP 5 In-session workshop on means to.
UNFCCC Secretariat SDM programme CDM‘s contribution to global climate action; its sucesses and further contribution Fatima-Zahra Taibi, UNFCCC secretariat.
1 United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change UNFCCC press conference, Bonn, 20 November 2007 Kyoto Protocol “go-live”: data, policies, infrastructures.
Accounting of Emissions and Assigned Amount under the Kyoto Protocol Clare Breidenich UNFCCC Consultant.
1 Andrew Howard Climate Change Secretariat Emissions trading and project-based mechanisms 1-3 April 2008 Bangkok, Thailand AWG-KP 5 In-session workshop.
UNFCCC Information Event
Introduction to Climate Change: - global warming - basis steps in a clean development project - connection of CDM with European Trading Scheme Wim Maaskant.
PDD Preparation Cairo, June 14 th -15 th, 2004 TIMS/EEAA CD4CDM- Third National Workshop (Phase II) UNEP RISO / APEXPDD Preparation Process and Format.
Beyond offsetting: Ambitious SBL as a national contribution to combat climate change Malin Ahlberg „Designated Focal Point/Designated National Authority“
UNFCCC secretariat Session 4 Meeting eligibility requirements First UNFCCC workshop on implementation of Article 6 projects under the Kyoto.
Enhancement of participation of local stakeholders, key to success of CDM projects: Current rules and procedures under the CDM Fatima-Zahra Taibi, UNFCCC.
The African CDM Training Workshop and Preparatory UNFCCC COP9 Meeting Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, October 20 – 21, 2003 INSTITUTIONAL SET-UP FOR CDM Dr Youba.
Cooperative Mechanisms UNFCCC secretariat JI under UNFCCC - An overview -
Practical Experience with Small-scale Projects: Issues and Suggestions Johannes Heister, Lasse Ringius Carbon Finance Unit, World Bank Bonn, 9-10 March.
CDM Project Cycle & Project Design Document Project Design Document First Extended & Regional Workshops CD4CDM Project Siem Reap, Cambodia March.
L/O/G/O ประเสริฐสุข จามรมาน รองผู้อำนวยการองค์การบริหาร จัดการก๊าซเรือนกระจก ยุทธศาสตร์การเติบโต แบบสีเขียว (Green Growth) 1.
Large Industrial Emitters Emissions Trading Natural Resources Canada March 14, 2003.
UNFCCC secretariat Utilizing CDM experiences to develop NAMAs – MRV Perumal Arumugam Regional Workshop on CDM and NAMAs for Latin America and the Caribbean,Bogota,
CDM Project Cycle LGED Bhaban, Dhaka 8 – 9 April 2008 Presented by Khandaker Mainuddin Fellow, BCAS.
Björn Zapfel UNFCCC secretariat JI section JI Track 2 Project Cycle Side event at COP/MOP 2: “JI Track 2 Project.
Structure of the presentation The origins of CDM What is the CDM? Players of CDM.
UNEP Collaborating Centre on Energy and Environment CD for CDM - Phase 1 - First Regional Workshop, Tunis January Cross-cutting issues to.
Markets & Mechanisms Developments inside and outside the UNFCCC negotiations. Building and Urban Methodologies Workshop UNFCCC, Bonn, March 2014.
Standardized national/sectoral baselines UNFCCC Technical Workshop on Joint Implementation Bonn, 16 October 2007 Manfred Stockmayer Managing Director Camco.
Introduction of information note Compilation and analysis of available information on the scope, effectiveness and functioning of the flexibility mechanisms.
1 NATIONAL SYSTEMS UNFCCC Workshop on National Systems under Article 5, paragraph 1, of the Kyoto Protocol 11–12 April 2005 Wissenschaftszentrum, Bonn,
UNFCCC secretariat, Sustainable Development Mechanisms programme Nashib Kafle, Associate Programme Officer Session 3: The Concept of Programme of Activities.
Canada’s CDM & JI Office First UNFCCC Workshop on the Implementation of Article 6 Projects Under the Kyoto Protocol May , 2004 Moscow, Russia Canadian.
UNFCCC secretariat From CDM to NAMAs – Synergies between CDM and NAMAs Perumal Arumugam Latin American Carbon Forum, Bogota (03 – 05 Sep 2014)
Introduction to the Project Cycle Jane Ebinger Senior Energy Specialist Sustainable Development Department The World Bank.
Policy, normative base and experience of Kyoto Protocol implementation in Bulgaria and other Central European Countries Daniela Stoycheva Consultant emissions.
KfW Carbon Fund From PoA to NAMA Barcelona 31th of May 2011.
Determinations / verifications under JI – Experience to date UNFCCC Technical Workshop on Joint Implementation Bonn, February 13 th, 2007 For the benefit.
Update on Methodological Issues Annual Meeting of the Host Country Committee Köln, May 2006.
Francisco Arango UNFCCC secretariat JI section Joint Implementation State of Play UNFCCC Technical Workshop on.
UNFCCC Technical Workshop on Joint Implementation
Eligibility issues and joint implementation
Baseline setting and monitoring under JI compared to the CDM approach
The various tracks of JI…
Small-Scale Projects Under JI
Joint implementation and eligibility requirements
Presentation transcript:

The Integration of PoA and NAMA; how can one support the other Ingo Puhl South Pole Carbon Asset Management Ltd. Bonn, 8. May 2011 Prepared by South Pole on the basis of analysis conducted for: PoA Support Center

The Big Picture: CDM projects and programs will be nested within NAMA frameworks Principal Observations – A NAMA creates a voluntary emissions target in a developing country on sector or sub-sector level. – The environmental integrity of a NAMA target (MRV, enforcement) is managed on the NAMA level by a national authority. – PoA baseline emissions are either a) already coherent with NAMA target trajectory (on aggregate) or b) a share of CER is used for domestic compliance. Implications – A NAMA framework that surrounds a PoA facilitates the simplification of CDM/PoA design because environmental integrity is controlled on NAMA level. – Existing CDM/PoA building blocks can be used on NAMA level for NAMA design 2 NAMA target GHG PoA baseline emissions NAMA MRV, i.e. IPCC 2006 CDM-style MRV PoA CPA emissions

Pre-Conditions for PoA Simplification; Analogy to Joint Implementation track 1 & 2 ParameterJINAMA Country EligibilityParty to KPParty to KP and has submitted NAMA with UNFCCC TargetHas calculated and recorded its assigned amount units. Has determined baseline, target and recorded NAMA. MRV systemHas in place a national system for estimating of GHG emissions in compliance with international rules. Has established NAMA MRV system RegisterHas in place a national register in compliance with international rules Has in place NAMA register in compliance with international rules Annual inventory submission Has submitted annually most recent required inventory in common reporting format Has submitted latest NAMA inventory Supplementary info Has submitted supp. Info on assigned amount units plus/minus issued ERU Has submitted supp/info required to calculate NAMA baseline and target emissions, issued CER from nested activities Minimum requirement for JI track 2Additional requirements for JI track 1

PoA that are located under a cap should benefit from simplification, in analogy to JI procedures Streamlined Registration and Inclusion Process Determination of eligibility, monitoring & verification subject to national rules and procedures (track 1 only) OR streamlined determination & verification process involving an AIE (DOE) and two JISC members advised by experts. Streamlined Process to Determine Baseline and Additionality Choose an appropriate method using traceable and transparent information showing that the project will lead to reductions of GHG emissions below baseline. MRV Appropriate monitoring plan, allowing combinations of CDM methods. Defined materiality thresholds

PoA Building Blocks for Good NAMA Design: H ow can the NAMA concept benefit from PoA experience? 5 PoA Design Element Applicable for NAMA PoA Elements Eligibility CriteriaTechnical criteria that provide an objective basis to assess eligibility of a facility or activity (type of facility, unit sizes, type of intervention..) Baseline SettingStandardized elements that have been developed for CDM methodologies:: large-scale benchmarks (carbon intensity of power grid, national or regional NRB usage rates) deemed savings (Nepal: average per household biomass use) status-quo baselines: modelled baselines can be used to determine NAMA baselines and targets. MRVA number of CDM MRV procedures are directly applicable : deemed savings approach methods that focus on large emission sources with simple MRV requirements that facilitate cost-effective MRV on facility level Implementation and Operation Some CME already operate at NAMA scale and is also an integral part of existing support mechanisms.

Benefits of PoA – NAMA Integration Procedural Simplification in PoA design and registration PoA/CPA additionality is derived from the NAMA and using procedures controlled by the host country with a strong link to its domestic policy. PoA can develop baseline derived from NAMA target (close to benchmark approach) Existing mechanism to implement credited NAMA instead of new mechanism NAMA could be operated mainly through (one or more) policy-driven PoA in conjunction with ODA-style capacity building/support interventions. Surplus ER (outside of PoA) could be transacted through bilateral output-based assistance approach (OBA). Shifting responsibility for the protection of environmental integrity to host country Parties, de-centralize the role of CDM EB The Party in control of NAMA compliance ensures environmental integrity on system level; typical CDM EB concerns over PoA level environmental integrity become less relevant.. I.e. DOE liability for wrongful inclusion can be addressed through NAMA eligibility criteria. 6

Recommendations/Next Steps 7 Explore the feasibility and benefits of this approach for an increasing number of case-studies CDM method usability vary widely depending on the underlying activity. Availability of substantial benefits need to be properly understood by Parties. Integrate the PoA/CDM reform process agenda with NAMA negotiations to facilitate integration Define requirements for the design of NAMA-level estimation methods for GHG emission inventories (based on national GHG inventory guidelines). Define requirements for the formulation of NAMA targets comparable to assigned amount units. Prepare CDM EB guidance on determination of additionality for projects/programs that are nested in eligible NAMA frameworks; in accordance with JI-style procedures on additionality for JI (track 1 and 2). Prepare CDM EB guidance on MRV flexibility on the activity level in accordance with JI-style procedures on MRV procedures (track 1 and 2).