9 Defense Attorneys.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Chapter Nine: Ethical Issues for Criminal Prosecutors
Advertisements

Courts and the Quest for Justice. In Theory: Courtroom Ideals  Courts have extensive powers in our criminal justice system.  The courts legitimacy is.
© 2005 by Thomson DelmarLearning. All Rights Reserved.1 CALIFORNIA CIVIL LITIGATION ETHICS IN LITIGATION.
Criminal Justice Process: The Trial
BELMONT UNIVERSITY AMERICAN INN OF COURT SEPTEMBER 9, 2014 PRESENTED BY KRISANN HODGES DEPUTY CHIEF DISCIPLINARY COUNSEL - LITIGATION BOARD OF PROFESSIONAL.
Mainstream and Crosscurrents, Second Edition Chapter 9 Working in the Courtroom.
Ethical Justice Chapter Ten: Ethical Issues for Criminal Defense Attorneys.
LAWYERS AND LITIGANTS.  Prosecuting and defense attorneys (criminal)  Plaintiffs’ and defense attorneys (civil)  Groups and individuals represented.
Chapter 1 Crime and Justice in the US. Crime in the United States Crime is a top concern of the American public. Crimes presented by the media are usually.
Q UINCY COLLEGE Paralegal Studies Program Paralegal Studies Program Interviewing & Investigation LAW-123 Introduction to Interviewing and Investigating.
CRIMINAL COURTS AND PROCEEDINGS IN IRAQ Wilson Myers Justice Must Be Won IX" ACDLA Summer Seminar & Annual Meeting June 22,
Chapter 29 Ethics in Accounting
Law & American Society Lawyers. Lawyers/Attorneys There are more than one million lawyers in the United States today 65% are in private practice 15% are.
Professional Ethics “Ethics are statements of moral principles and values that guide the action of auditors”. The independence, powers and responsibilities.
Law and the Courts The Administration of Justice The Courts.
Paralegal and Professional Responsibility Fall 2013.
1 Defense Attorneys Chapter Seven. 2 Sixth Amendment In all criminal prosecutions, the accused shall enjoy the right to a speedy and public trial, by.
The Effective Delivery of Constitutionally Mandated Indigent Defense Services: A National Perspective on Louisiana Shubi Deoras The American Bar Association.
WDNS Week of February 23rd
Law and Justice: Chapter 6 Lawyers. Lawyers What is a Lawyer What is a Lawyer Someone who argues points of law for a client Someone who argues points.
 Trial Courts : listen to testimony, consider evidence, and decide the facts in disputed situations.
The Four Types of Defense Delivery Systems January 2015.
Ethics and Social Responsibility McGraw-Hill/Irwin Contemporary Management, 5/e Copyright © 2008 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved.
An Overview of Religious Non Profit Organizations By Br. Abdul Khadri Mahdi, CPA 1.
Chapter Seven: Defense Attorneys. The RIGHT TO COUNSEL SIXTH AMENDMENT “In all criminal prosecutions the accused shall enjoy the right…..to have the assistance.
The Prosecution and the Defense Chapter 10. District Attorney County Attorney State’s Attorney U.S. Attorney What Titles Do Prosecuting Attorneys Have?
The Courts: Structure and Participants Chapter 9 Frank Schmalleger Criminal Justice Today 13 th Edition.
Criminal Justice Today Twelfth Edition CHAPTER Criminal Justice Today: An Introductory Text for the 21 st Century, 12e Frank Schmalleger Copyright © 2014.
Courts and the Judiciary Chapter 9. Provide for an open and impartial forum for seeking the truth Provide for a fair and equitable hearing using regulated.
LAW for Business and Personal Use © 2012 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved. May not be scanned, copied or duplicated, or posted to a publicly accessible.
Criminal Justice Today Twelfth Edition CHAPTER Criminal Justice Today: An Introductory Text for the 21st Century, 12e Frank Schmalleger Copyright © 2014.
Chapter 7 Courts, Prosecution, and the Defense
Copyright © 2008 Pearson Education Canada1-1 Chapter 1: Managing Your Legal Affairs.
The Legal Team, Law Practices, and Law Firm Governance Practical Law Office Management, 3 rd Edition, Thomson Delmar Learning ©2007 Thomson Delmar Learning.
+ US JUDICIAL EMPLOYEES Professor Delaine R. Swenson.
CRIMINAL JUSTICE TODAY, 10E© 2009 Pearson Education, Inc by Dr. Frank Schmalleger Pearson Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ The Courts: Structure.
Juvenile Justice in America, 5 th Edition ©2008 Pearson Education, Inc. Bartollas/Miller Pearson Prentice Hall Upper Saddle River, NJ Chapter 6:
The Courts: Structure and Participants
CHAPTER 6- LAWYERS Mr. Cimijotti-Intro to Law. Characteristics Breakdown of Lawyers 65% are in private practice. 15% are government lawyers who work for.
Unit 5 Midterm Review. What are some of the components of the ABA?
Dr. Jackson HN450 1 Corey, 8e, ©2011, Brooks/ Cole-Cengage Learning.
WHITE COLLAR CRIME Lecture 13: Policing & Regulating White Collar Crime.
1-1 Chapter 1: Introduction to Law. 1-2 What Is Law?  At a minimum, law consists of enforceable rules governing relationships among persons and between.
Law and Society CJUS/POLS 102 Institutional Roles in the American Legal System.
McGraw-Hill ©2009 The McGraw-Hill Companies, Inc. All rights reserved. Insert cover image so horizontal lines in cover design line up with gold horizontal.
Understanding the Criminal Justice System CJUS 101 Chapter 8-A: Judges, Prosecutors, and Others at the Bar of Justice.
Chapter One The Legal Community and Professional Responsibility.
ETHICS: CONFIDENTIALITY OF IFTA DATA IFTA ATTORNEYS’ SECTION MEETING October 7, :30-10:00 a.m. Jim Clark Motor Carrier Services Attorney Indiana.
Professor El Aouni Zouhair
Criminal Justice: A Brief Introduction Ninth Edition By Frank Schmalleger Pearson Education, Inc.
Social Science.  The main purpose of civil law is to settle disagreements fairly  People file lawsuits, or cases in which a court is asked to settle.
Courts and Criminal Justice in America CHAPTER Courts and Criminal Justice in America, 2nd Edition Siegel | Schmalleger | Worrall Copyright © 2015 by Pearson.
The Paralegal Professional ESSENTIALS, 2/e By Cheeseman and Goldman PRENTICE HALL ©2008 Pearson Education, Inc. Upper Saddle River, NJ PA 101: Unit.
Courts and Criminal Justice in America CHAPTER Courts and Criminal Justice in America, 2nd Edition Siegel | Schmalleger | Worrall Copyright © 2015 by Pearson.
Aim: What is the role of the Defense Attorney?. Vocabulary Defense Attorney: The lawyer who represents an accused offender and a convicted offender. Defense.
CHAPTER 7: DEFENSE ATTORNEYS © 2017 Cengage Learning. All Rights Reserved.
Eliseo Lugo III.  Objectives: By the end of class, students will be able to:  Name at least five situations in which a person might wish to consult.
Criminal Justice: A Brief Introduction Ninth Edition By Frank Schmalleger Pearson Education, Inc.
Criminal Justice Today CHAPTER Criminal Justice Today, 13th Edition Frank Schmalleger Copyright © 2015, © 2013 by Pearson Education, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Chapter 6 Lawyers.
CHAPTER 6: PART 2 Advertisements and Professional Responsibility
LEGAL PROFESSION IN THE USA & UK
The University of Adelaide, School of Computer Science
Violence Against Women Act 2013 Domestic and Family Violence Code
Chapter Nine Defense Attorneys.
The American Court Structure
Chapter 7 Courts, Prosecution, and the Defense
The American Court Structure
Presentation transcript:

9 Defense Attorneys

Introduction The defense attorney is often treated with scorn – why? Portrayal of defense lawyers in the media is often negative The defense lawyer advises, represents and acts for the defendant What makes a good defense attorney?

The History of Criminal Defense The history of criminal defense can be traced back to ancient Rome By the 4th century advocates were essentially lawyers The profession disappeared after the Dark Ages, but the efforts of the church and state led to its resurgence

The History of Criminal Defense Growth of the Criminal Defense Bar Criminal defense attorneys gained prominence around the 1730s Few trained lawyers in American colonies at that time Indigent defense was nonexistent During the 19th century, most attorneys trained in apprenticeships 1771, Blackstone’s Commentaries on the Laws of England provided a source for the study of law and legal principles

The History of Criminal Defense The number of lawyers grew after the American Revolution due to: Increased formalization of law and the legal process created a demand for professionals The rather lax standards for becoming a lawyer Prompted the beginning of law schools

The History of Criminal Defense By the 1960s, concerns with civil rights, poverty and other social problems made a legal career highly desirable High profile Supreme Court cases also fueled growth in the legal profession Law school admission became selective and schools introduced strict entrance requirements

Types of Defense Attorneys Criminal defense attorneys fall into two general categories: Privately-retained attorneys Attorneys who represent indigent defendants Gideon v. Wainwright requires counsel be provided for all criminal defendants

Types of Defense Attorneys Privately Retained Counsel Retaining an attorney for criminal defense is expensive Legal fees in a felony case may exceed $25,000 The result is that many defendants cannot afford to hire their own attorneys

Types of Defense Attorneys Do You Get What You Pay For? Is a privately-retained attorney more effective than a public defender who represents an indigent defendant? Research indicates wealthier offenders end up better off on the whole than poor offenders But for the most part, public counsel and privately-retained attorneys achieve the same results Guilty pleas, trial verdicts and case dismissals

Types of Defense Attorneys Indigent Defense Systems Three main indigent defense systems in operation in the United States: Assigned Counsel Contract Model Public Defender Systems vary state by state One or more of the defense systems may be in operation and can be organized at different levels of government

Types of Defense Attorneys Who qualifies for these services? Most states rely on statutory definitions to determine indigent status Who foots the bill? Most indigent defense services are completely paid by the state Some states fund their programs at the county level The norm is for taxpayers to pay Some authorities lament the state of the system (e.g. the American Bar Association)

Types of Defense Attorneys Assigned Counsel Selected to represent indigent clients in either: Ad hoc assigned counsel systems – judges choose a defense attorney on a case by case basis Coordinated assigned counsel systems – rely on a coordinate to choose the attorney Most often used in rural areas Counsel are paid according to set rates

Types of Defense Attorneys Contract Model The state, county or other jurisdictional authority contracts with private attorneys Two main types of contracts for defense services: In a fixed-price contract the firm agrees to accept an unspecified number of cases for a single, annual flat fee In a fixed-fee contract the defense firm contracts to provide defense representation in a fixed number of cases for a fixed fee per case

Types of Defense Attorneys Public Defender The first public defender program opened in Los Angeles in 1913 The system relies on full-or part-time attorneys who represent indigent defendants When there is a conflict of interest, a contract or assigned counsel is available to assist Sometimes called a “mixed system”

On the Job The Defense Craft Flemming’s study revealed a concern with the “efficiency” to waive preliminary hearings Defense attorneys adopt a “professional” stance Defense attorneys seek to “minimize regrets” A concern with efficiency can run counter to a concern with professionalism and minimizing regrets

On the Job Insider Justice The Myth of the Zealous Advocate Nardulli’s study sought to determine if “regular” defense attorneys were: “manipulators of the process” “cop-out artists” “creators and protectors of routine” The Myth of the Zealous Advocate Blumberg study asserts defense attorneys are “double agents”

On the Job Uphoff describes a defense attorney as a “beleaguered dealer” Struggling against difficulty e.g. the demands of a high caseload, or being confronted with a client who is financially strapped Also found many defendants want to plead guilty Defense attorneys may be doing their best within the institutional constraints they face

Defense Attorneys, Their Clients, and the Public Defense Attorneys’ Perceptions of Their Clients A belief that“public clients” are less trusting than private clients Court-appointed lawyers represent the Criminal Justice system rather than the client’s interest There is a different dynamic between defendants and a privately-retained attorney compared to a public defender

Defense Attorneys, Their Clients, and the Public Defendant’s Perceptions of Their Attorneys What is known can be placed in roughly two categories: The attorney-client relationship is important The client’s ability to assume an active role within the relationship is key

Defense Attorneys, Their Clients, and the Public The trust defendants display toward their attorneys Defendants with limited understanding of the legal process reported less faith in their attorney Public Perceptions of Defense Attorneys Advertising media have portrayed attorneys in a scornful manner

Defense Attorneys, Their Clients, and the Public The ABA survey results indicate the public has both positive and negative perceptions Placed one notch above the media and far below the medical profession Figure 9-2 Public Confidence in Lawyers Relative to Other Professions

Defense Attorneys, Their Clients, and the Public Attorneys’ Satisfaction with Their Work No amount of survey research can capture the satisfaction of a job well done Ethical Dilemmas for the Defense

Defense Attorneys, Their Clients, and the Public A confession in confidence Client perjury Defense receipt of physical evidence Problems with the defendant’s prior record

Defense Ethics Professional Organizations Discuss professional organizations for defense attorneys for two reasons: Professional associations maintain codes of ethics for their members Certain professional associations license attorneys When attorneys fail to follow the rules, they risk losing their authority to practice law

Defense Ethics Bar Associations The ABA’s Model Code of Professional Responsibility was first adopted in 1908 Membership in a state bar association entails adhering by the state’s ethical codes and principles

Defense Ethics NACDL NLADA National Association of Criminal Defense Lawyers Seeks to foster integrity, independence, and expertise in the criminal defense profession NLADA National Legal Aid and Defender Association

Defense Ethics Main focus is on defense attorneys who provide aid to indigent defendants Sets forth important guidelines for the provision of defense services to ensure indigent defendants receive effective representation

Defense Ethics Canons of the Code of Conduct for Federal Public Defender Employee Canon 1. A federal public defender employee should uphold the integrity and independence of the office.

Defense Ethics Canon 2. A federal public defender employee should avoid impropriety and the appearance of impropriety in all activities. Canon 3. A federal public defender employee should adhere to appropriate standards in performing the duties of the office.

Defense Ethics Canon 4. A federal public defender employee may engage in activities to improve the law, the legal system, and the administration of justice. Canon 5. A federal public defender employee should regulate extra-official activities to minimize the risk of conflict with official duties.

Defense Ethics Canon 6. A federal public defender employee should regularly file reports of compensation received for all extra-official activities. Canon 7. A federal public defender employee should refrain from inappropriate political activities.