Twenty Years and More: Research into Minority Religions, New Religious Movements and 'the New Spirituality' INFORM and CESNUR in association with ISORECEA.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Postcommuni st Believers in a Postmodern World Christianity and Human Rights Conference Samford University, 2004.
Advertisements

INTERNATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS MECHANISMS
1 Essentials of Migration Management for Policy Makers and Practitioners Section 1.6 International Migration Law.
Proactive Interventions: Incorporating a Children’s Rights Approach
Religion and Human Rights C.A. Nigel Hughes Georgetown. Guyana. October 2013.
Religious Freedom and Its Legal Restrictions in China Qianfan Zhang Constitutional and Administrative Law Center, Peking University.
Slide Show A A Presentation For The People of Utah THE UTAH CONSTITUTION A Critical Examination of ARTICLE 8.
Securing Rights: A Legal Perspective Sophy Miles.
The Constitution Fundamental Rights.  Personal Rights The Family Education Private Property Religion.
Jehovah’s Witnesses in Court in Europe: Trailblazing for Religious Freedom James T. Richardson, J.D., Ph.D. University of Nevada, Reno CESNUR.
Sources Of Human Rights
Human Rights Mechanisms in Serbia Maja Micic Youth Initiative for Human Rights.
Presented by :- Ankur sharma Naman jain (B.Com llb Ist year)
The influence of geo-political and constitutional-legal factors on the specifics of the development of the Kaliningrad region in the context of WTO Gorodilov.
 Fundamental Rights for Pakistanis are aimed at overturning the inequities of past social practices.  Guarantee that all citizens can and will lead.
© 2007 Prentice Hall, Business Law, sixth edition, Henry R. Cheeseman Chapter 4 Constitutional Law for Business and Online Commerce Chapter 4 Constitutional.
The First Amendment and The Supreme Court Lesson Plan developed for the Historic Polegreen Church Foundation May, 2010.
A Trip Around the World Part 1 Do citizens in all countries have the same rights and responsibilities?
What can we do? What should we do? RIGHTS AND RESPONSIBILITIES OF THE UNITED STATES CITIZEN.
Articles of Confederation
HUMAN RIGHTS EDUCATION ORIENTATION AND TOT APRIL 12 TH 2011 RELIGIOUS RIGHTS AND WOMEN’S RIGHTS AS HUMAN RIGHTS.
Steffen Rink | Religious Plurality, Religious Freedom, and Importance of Law. Provo Oct. 6, 2008 Steffen Rink, Marburg Religious Plurality, Religious Freedom,
Unit 5 p. 195 How does the Constitution protect our basic rights?
The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms
1 When hate speech tangles privacy... When hate speech tangles privacy...
Constitutional Law for Business and Online Commerce.
The Universal Declaration of Human Rights
INTERNATIONAL NETWORK OF HUMAN RIGHTS ORGANIZATIONS «AMPARO- SOCIETY AND ARMY» Rights of military personnel in post- soviet countries Comparative Analysis.
JUS5701. Scope of application of human rights treaties Material scope of application Temporal scope of application Territorial scope of application Personal.
HUMR5140, lecture # 10. This lecture 1.Picking up the thread from lecture # 4: Scope of application of human rights treaties 2.The relationship with other.
Citizenship: A Trip Around the World Part Two.
© 2006 Religious Freedoms Federal Ministry for Foreign Affairs of Austria.
JáN KIMÁK LEGAL CONCEPT OF EQUALITY IN INTERNATIONAL & NATIONAL LAW
Battle Over the Meaning of Religious Freedom Professor Robert T. Smith Managing Director, International Center for Law and Religion Studies J. Reuben Clark.
Copyright © 2006 by Pearson Prentice-Hall. All rights reserved Slides developed by Les Wiletzky PowerPoint Slides to Accompany ESSENTIALS OF BUSINESS AND.
Copyright © 2010 Pearson Education, Inc. Publishing as Prentice Hall. 5-1 Chapter 2 Constitutional Law for Business and E-Commerce.
Socio economic participation of minorities in relation to their right to (respect for) identity October 2010 Erasmus School of Law Participation.
Seminar on Migration Legislation Ministry of Foreign Affairs of Guatemala 15 – 16 February 2007.
Fundamental Principles of Democracy
The Canadian Charter of rights and freedoms. THE CANADIAN CONSTITUTION AND THE CHARTER Charter was entrenched in the Constitution with the passage of.
The Charter of Rights and Freedoms What is the Charter? A constitutional document that defines the rights and freedoms of Canadians and establishes the.
 Church and State in Spanish Constitutions. Spanish speaking countries are living in an age of profound transformations. Both spiritually and socially.
Georgia The Second Wave of Democratic Reforms 2009.
International Human Rights Defense Institute of International Legal Studies 1.
Human Rights Universal Declaration of Human Rights Based on the UN General Assembly Resolution 217 A (III) 10 DEC 1948 By: Jim Long For: HUMA 1100.
A QUESTION OF FAITH: RELIGION AND BELIEF IN EUROPE Equinet LWG 2011 Jayne Hardwick Moderator Equinet – Legal Working Group.
 The Charter was significantly inspired by documents such as the 1948 United Nations Universal Declaration of Human Rights  Passed by the United Nations.
Lecturer: Miljen Matijašević G10, room 6/I, Tue 11:30-12:30 Session 9.
Copyright © 2004 by Prentice-Hall. All rights reserved. PowerPoint Slides to Accompany BUSINESS LAW E-Commerce and Digital Law International Law and Ethics.
“ Welcome to Seminar 8: Civil Liberties and Civil Rights.
Osce.org/odihr The OSCE/ODIHR framework and activities in the area of freedom of religion or belief, Kishan Manocha, Senior Adviser on Freedom of Religion.
FUNDAMENTAL RIGHTS ARTICLES Article 12 State :- Govt. & Parliament of India Govt. & State legislature Local Authorities & Other Authorities under.
Child Exploitation Research Project Overview. Question… What do you believe are the 10 most essential rights that children around the world should have?
Article 1:  All human beings are born free and equal in dignity and rights. They should act towards one another in a spirit of brotherhood.
The Paralegal Professional Part II: Introduction to Law Chapter Five American Legal Heritage & Constitutional Law.
HOLT, RINEHART AND WINSTON A MERICAN GOVERNMENT HOLT 1 Fundamental Freedoms Section 1: Freedom and the Bill of Rights Section 2: Freedom of Religion Section.
HUMAN RIGHTS LAW Ahmed T. Ghandour.. CHAPTER 2. THE UN & HUMAN RIGHTS I.
Health and Social Care Mental Health Act 2007 Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (MCA / DoLS) What is Depriving a Person’s Liberty?
HUMAN RIGHTS LAW. Ahmed T. Ghandour.. HUMAN RIGHTS IN EUROPE I.
THE HUMAN RIGHTS. THE RIGHT TO PRIVACY No one shall be subjected to arbitrary interference with his privacy, family, home or correspondence, nor to attacks.
Lecture number 12 Topic: Basic rights, freedoms and duties of man and citizens in the Republic of Uzbekistan.
Freedom of religion The Kokkinakis case.
Chapter 4 Constitutional Law for Business and Online Commerce
Theme number 14 Fundamental rights, freedoms and duties of man and citizens in the Republic of Uzbekistan.
Chapter 2 Constitutional Law for Business and E-Commerce
Constitutional Law for Business and E-Commerce
Chapter 4 Constitutional Law for Business and E-Commerce
Religious Plurality, Religious Freedom, and the Importance of Law
Situation of Sexual Minority People in Nepal:
Litigation on a national level – recognizing birth certificate indicating two mothers in Poland Anna Mazurczak.
Presentation transcript:

Twenty Years and More: Research into Minority Religions, New Religious Movements and 'the New Spirituality' INFORM and CESNUR in association with ISORECEA April 16-20, London School of Economics

Shifting Legal Frameworks for Protection of Non-Traditional Religious Communities in Post-Communist Lands Presiding and Introducing: W. Cole DURHAM, Jr. (Brigham Young University, Provo) The Changing Legal Setting for Religious Groups in Russia - Alexander VERKHOVSKY (Director, SOVA Centre for Information and Analysis, Moscow) The Changing Legal Setting for Religious Groups in Russia - Alexander VERKHOVSKY (Director, SOVA Centre for Information and Analysis, Moscow) Position of Non-traditional Religious Communities Following the Adoption of the Romanian Law on Religious Freedom and the General Regime of Religious Denominations - Romanita IORDACHE (Human Rights Lawyer, Center for Legal Resources, Romania) Position of Non-traditional Religious Communities Following the Adoption of the Romanian Law on Religious Freedom and the General Regime of Religious Denominations - Romanita IORDACHE (Human Rights Lawyer, Center for Legal Resources, Romania) Religious Rights in the Georgian Setting - Archil GIORGADZE (Head of Human Rights Protection Unit, Office of the Prosecutor General of Georgia) Religious Rights in the Georgian Setting - Archil GIORGADZE (Head of Human Rights Protection Unit, Office of the Prosecutor General of Georgia)

Position of Non-traditional Religious Communities Following the Adoption of the Romanian Law on Religious Freedom and the General Regime of Religious Denominations by Romanita IORDACHE Full comment of Romanian Law published in "österreichisches Archiv für recht & religion 2007, pp ". The article is available at

Background of the Romanian 2006 Law Situation of religious minorities prior to 1948 Situation of religious minorities prior to 1948 Religious freedom between – 14 state recognized/ controlled religious denominations Religious freedom between – 14 state recognized/ controlled religious denominations Status of religious minorities between – 18 state recognized religious denominations Status of religious minorities between – 18 state recognized religious denominations

Status of religious minorities between – restrictive process based on Decree 177/1948 State recognized religious denominations State recognized religious denominations Religious denominations not recognized by the state: Religious denominations not recognized by the state: –No legal personality –Registered as religious associations=NGOs –Attempts of being recognized as culte The case of Jehovah Witnesses – Supreme Court cases (4) + ECHR case –friendly settlement The case of Jehovah Witnesses – Supreme Court cases (4) + ECHR case –friendly settlement

Constitutional guarantees – Art.29 (1) Freedom of thought, opinion, and religious beliefs shall not be restricted in any form whatsoever. No one shall be compelled to embrace an opinion or religion contrary to his own convictions. (1) Freedom of thought, opinion, and religious beliefs shall not be restricted in any form whatsoever. No one shall be compelled to embrace an opinion or religion contrary to his own convictions. (2) Freedom of conscience is guaranteed; it must be manifested in a spirit of tolerance and mutual respect. (2) Freedom of conscience is guaranteed; it must be manifested in a spirit of tolerance and mutual respect. (3) All religions shall be free and organized in accordance with their own statutes, under the terms laid down by law. (3) All religions shall be free and organized in accordance with their own statutes, under the terms laid down by law. (4) Any forms, means, acts or actions of religious enmity shall be prohibited in the relationships among the cults. (4) Any forms, means, acts or actions of religious enmity shall be prohibited in the relationships among the cults. (5) Religious cults shall be autonomous from the State and shall enjoy support from it, including the facilitation of religious assistance in the army, in hospitals, prisons, homes and orphanages. (5) Religious cults shall be autonomous from the State and shall enjoy support from it, including the facilitation of religious assistance in the army, in hospitals, prisons, homes and orphanages. (6) Parents or legal tutors have the right to ensure, in accordance with their own convictions, the education of minor children whose responsibility devolves on them. (6) Parents or legal tutors have the right to ensure, in accordance with their own convictions, the education of minor children whose responsibility devolves on them.

Adoption of 2006 law Previous drafts – 4-5 Previous drafts – 4-5 Stakeholders: Stakeholders: –State recognized religious denominations – variety of positions – approval by ROC/dissent of GCC (conditioned), JW (rejected) & Baptists, Adventists – withdrew endorsement –Denominations not recognized –International concerns: OSCE, Venice Commission, US Helsinki Commission –Domestic concerns: anti-religious groups and human rights NGOs Voting process - tacit approval by Senate=no debate on the floor and no voting - Chamber of Deputies – slow process; surprise adoption – one vote against, one abstention and majority pro

Main provisions of the 2006 law No definition of religion No definition of religion Protection of forum internum Protection of forum internum Art. 9 ECHR + legitimate aims for limitations – “public security” Art. 9 ECHR + legitimate aims for limitations – “public security” Three tier system Three tier system Preferential status of dominant ROC Preferential status of dominant ROC Autonomy of state recognized religious denominations  public utility status Autonomy of state recognized religious denominations  public utility status

Main provisions of the 2006 law (2) Art. 9 – quasi – Separation/ Neutrality/Equality Clause Art. 9 – quasi – Separation/ Neutrality/Equality Clause (1) There is no State Religion in Romania; the State is neutral towards any religious persuasion or atheistic ideology. (2) The denominations are equal before the law and public authorities. The State, though its authorities, shall neither promote nor support the granting of privileges or the instatement of discrimination towards any denomination. Art. 13 – prohibition of religious defamation and public offending of religious symbols Art. 13 – prohibition of religious defamation and public offending of religious symbols Sensitive issue – restitution of religious assets seized after 1948 – postponed (Art.30) Sensitive issue – restitution of religious assets seized after 1948 – postponed (Art.30)

Conditions for registration as first tier status – different standards Previously recognized  simplified procedure Previously recognized  simplified procedure Newcomers: Newcomers: –religious associations that, “through their activities and number of worshipers, provide guarantees of sustainability, stability and public interest (?).” –bylaws and canon codes of recognised denominations are to be recognised “insofar as they do not, in their contents, threaten public security, order, health and morality or the fundamental human rights and liberties.” –high numerical threshold of 0.1 per cent of the population Romanian citizens residing in Romania (approximately 22,000 people) to qualify for ‘religious denomination’ status, = highest in OSCE –a strict time-requirement of a 12-year waiting period

Registration as religious associations 300 believers (only Romanian citizens or residents in Romania) = 3 persons establishing a NFP association  impact on management of temporal issues of religious communities (access to public subsidies, tax exemptions, property, labor relations, relation with authorities – education, pastoral support in detention, army, hospitals etc.) 300 believers (only Romanian citizens or residents in Romania) = 3 persons establishing a NFP association  impact on management of temporal issues of religious communities (access to public subsidies, tax exemptions, property, labor relations, relation with authorities – education, pastoral support in detention, army, hospitals etc.) Process- SSRA issues an opinion – 8 so far  judge Process- SSRA issues an opinion – 8 so far  judge

Impact of law on NRMs Duty to transform status for NRMs previously registered as religious associations Duty to transform status for NRMs previously registered as religious associations Restrictive criteria for registration for NRMs currently seeking legal status as first tier or second tier denominations Restrictive criteria for registration for NRMs currently seeking legal status as first tier or second tier denominations Disparate impact of some provisions of the law (prohibition of offense against religious symbols, provisions on access to graveyards, taxation, education, pastoral support etc.) Disparate impact of some provisions of the law (prohibition of offense against religious symbols, provisions on access to graveyards, taxation, education, pastoral support etc.) Encouraging further attacks – see decision of the national equality body following a complaint filed by Bahai in relation with the content of the Manuals of Religious Education approved by the MoE which used offensive language in relation with NRMs Encouraging further attacks – see decision of the national equality body following a complaint filed by Bahai in relation with the content of the Manuals of Religious Education approved by the MoE which used offensive language in relation with NRMs