Cost for Large Liquid Scintillator Detector Ken Heller University of Minnesota Active Detector – Liquid Scintillator Target Material - Water Read Out –

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Liquid Scintillator for a 50 KTon Off-Axis Neutrino Detector
Advertisements

Bill Miller NOνA-May 04 NOνA Total Active Liquid Scintillator Detector Installation First Pass Estimate Bill Miller U of M.
Prototype of the Daya Bay Neutrino Detector Wang Zhimin IHEP, Daya Bay.
Discussion on cosmogenic taggers With some thinking by : M.Weber, F.Pietropaolo, A.Guglielmi, M.Ne.
How to Build a Neutrino Oscillations Detector - Why MINOS is like it is! Alfons Weber March 2005.
CERN – March 10, 2006TAN Installation Workshop - The LHCf experimentOscar Adriani The LHCf experiment Measurement of Photons and Neutral Pions in the Very.
1 Prototyping Megaton-Scale  Detectors Jason Trevor DOE Review July 25, 2007 Developing a New Lower-Cost Scintillator Design.
The LHCf experiment Measurement of Photons and Neutral Pions in the Very Forward Region of LHC Letter Of Intent: May 2004 Technical report: September 2005.
NO A at Caltech Leon Mualem DOE Review July 25, 2007.
New Hexagonal Design for MINERvA A. Bodek- Sept Now even counters have a 1.2 solid steel picture frame Around the 3 m wide active target. The.
CMS UPGRADE CAPILLARY TUBE PROFILING. CAPILLARY TUBES EVALUATION Radiation damage Transmission Mixing Scintillating Quartz Tube Water/ Air EJ309 Fiber.
The Status of the NOvA Experiment Sarah Phan-Budd Argonne National Laboratory Miami 2011 December 16, 2011.
KR_SLAC_Jan031 Review of R&D carried out for MINOS active detector …………………………….. Keith Ruddick, University of Minnesota With particular emphasis on liquid.
NuMI Schematic View of the MINOS Scintillator System 8 m Scintillator Module WLS Fibers Optical Connector Clear Fiber Ribbon Cable (2-6 m) Multiplex Box.
Douglas Michael California Institute of Technology NuMI Off-Axis Workshop SLAC Jan. 24, 2003 Overview A few details Some cost and production information.
Cost of a Large Solid Scintillator Detector Jeff Nelson Fermilab.
NuMI NuMI Overview NBI 2002 S. Childress (FNAL) 14 March ‘02 NuMI / MINOS Overview.
Liquid scintillator for an off-axis neutrino detector? (The Minnesota group) We are actively investigating a liquid scintillator option for the off-axis.
NO A Experiment Jarek Nowak University of Minnesota For NOvA Collaboration.
Simulation study of RENO-50 Jungsic Park Seoul National University RENO-50 International Workshop June 13-14, 2013 Hoam Faculty House, Korea.
Monte Carlo Comparison of RPCs and Liquid Scintillator R. Ray 5/14/04  RPCs with 1-dimensional readout (generated by RR) and liquid scintillator with.
Sarah Phan-Budd, TIPP Construction of PVC Extrusions for NO A Near and Far Detectors Sarah Phan-Budd Argonne National Lab On Behalf of the NO A.
Status report on MURAY telescope R&D
Extrusion Modules – The Active Detector Ken Heller University of Minnesota Talks by: Tom Chase – Progress on End Seals and Leak Detection QA Alex Smith.
Status of the NO ν A Near Detector Prototype Timothy Kutnink Iowa State University For the NOvA Collaboration.
THE FORWARD PROTON DETECTOR AT DZERO Gilvan Alves Lafex/CBPF 1) MOTIVATION 2) DETECTOR OPTIONS 3) FPD R&D 4) OUTLOOK Lishep 98 Lafex/CBPF Feb 17, 1998.
The Design and Performance of the MINER A Detector Howard Budd, University of Rochester Technology and Instrumentation in Particle Physics 2011.
A detector design for the Daya Bay reactor neutrino experiment Yifang Wang Institute of High Energy Physics, Beijing Jan. 18, 2004.
21-Aug-06DoE Site Review / Harvard(1) Front End Electronics for the NOvA Neutrino Detector John Oliver Long baseline neutrino experiment Fermilab (Chicago)
Electromagnetic Calorimeter for the CLAS12 Forward Detector S. Stepanyan (JLAB) Collaborating institutions: Yerevan Physics Institute (Armenia) James Madison.
The NOvA Experiment Ji Liu On behalf of the NOvA collaboration College of William and Mary APS April Meeting April 1, 2012.
NuMI Off-Axis Experiment Alfons Weber University of Oxford & Rutherford Appleton Laboratory EPS2003, Aachen July 19, 2003.
IoP HEPP Lancaster 31/03 – 02/04/08 Gavin Davies Dr. Athanasios Hatzikoutelis Dr. Laura Kormos Lancaster University T2K UK Collaboration  DS-Ecal Design.
Structure Update Installation & Building Update Revisions Outlined Costs Revisited (since given to Gina) Jeff Nelson Fermilab.
Gary Feldman MINOS in Cambridge 24 March NO A Update MINOS Collaboration Meeting Cambridge, England 24 March 2009 Gary Feldman.
Forward Muon Installation and Commissioning Dmitri Denisov Fermilab Director’s review 7/12/1999 Plan Forward muon detectors Mini-drift tubes installation.
,,,,, The Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment Liangjian Wen On behalf of the Daya Bay Collaboration Institute of High Energy Physics Daya Bay Detectors.
The Daya Bay Reactor Neutrino Experiment R. D. McKeown Caltech On Behalf of the Daya Bay Collaboration CIPANP 2009.
EUROnu WP5 Detector Costing EuroNu Annual General Meeting, Strasbourg 3 June 2010 Paul Soler.
Indiana University Scintillator Optimization Test Setup and Plan Chuck Bower Gebhard,Messier,Mufson,Musser,Rebel,Urheim,Waldron NOνA Collaboration Meeting.
Off-Axis Collaboration Meeting Feb 7, 2004 Richard Talaga, Argonne (Liquid) Scintillator Structure Workshop Report Workshop Purpose –To review the current.
1 draft NO A WBS J. Cooper NO A Working Group Meeting June 29,2005 Work is the effort of Ron, Dave, Bill, Suzanne, Harry, not just me.
UPDATE ON THE FORWARD PROTON DETECTOR Gilvan Alves Lafex/CBPF Introduction Accelerator Roman Pots Detector Future Plans April 1, 1998 (no kidding)
E. W. Grashorn and A. Habig, UMD, for the MINOS Collaboration The Detectors of The Main Injector Neutrino Oscillation Search (MINOS) Experiment The MINOS.
1 Muon Veto System and Expected Backgrounds at Dayabay Hongshan (Kevin) Zhang, BNL DayaBay Collaboration DNP08, Oakland.
Harvard Neutrino Group DoE Review August 21, 2006.
Coordinate Detector: prototype design General idea about the Coordinate Detector (CDET) so far: Three independent vertical planes with 15 cm plastic shield.
MINER A Main INjector ExpeRiment for v-A Active segmented scintillator detector: 5.87 tons Nuclear targets of C, Fe and Pb, Water, Helium.
SiD Muon Detector Progress. Overall concept 2 There are slots in the iron. We will insert modules of orthogonal strips of appropriate size into the slots.
H. Katajisto RE EDR 10/10/02 Enclosures for the RPC Link Boards Outline Introduction Periphery General Services Components, materials Manufacture, Assembly.
NUMI NUMI/MINOS Status J. Musser for the MINOS Collatoration 2002 FNAL Users Meeting.
Power, Cooling, Cables, Simulations of Heat Dissipation Short overview of ongoing work on these points Technical Coordination (Rolf Lindner et al.) Cooling.
Paul Rubinov on behalf of Gene Fisk, Kurt Krempetz 22 Aug 2012.
MINER A at the Triple Point: Three Phases at once Deborah Harris AEM August 31, 2009.
A Brand new neutrino detector 「 SciBar 」 (2) Y. Takubo (Osaka) - Readout Electronics - Introduction Readout electronics Cosmic ray trigger modules Conclusion.
Status of the NOνA Experiment Satish Desai - University of Minnesota For the NOνA Collaboration APS Meeting - April 2013 Denver, Colorado.
Technical Design for the Mu3e Detector Dirk Wiedner on behalf of Mu3e February Dirk Wiedner PSI 2/15.
The NOnA Experiment Survey of the NOvA Far Detector Gary Feldman
Status of the NO A Experiment Kirk Bays (Caltech) on behalf of the NO A collaboration Lake Louise Winter Institute Saturday, Feb 22, 2014.
FGT Magnet C Assembly metric tons (59 US tons) -100mm thick steel plates -6.6m high x 3.1m wide x 1m deep (outer dimensions) -5m high x 2.25m wide.
Concepts Beyond the Neutrino Factory Baseline Design Detector R&D Alan Bross, Malcolm Ellis, Steve Geer, Olga Mena, Silvia Pascoli.
PROJECT X PHYSICS STUDY WORKSHOP (PXPS 2012) Working Group on Time of Flight Conveners: Mike Albrow (FNAL) & Bob Wagner (ANL) New directions in fast timing:
K.Gadow - DESY 1 The HCAL barrel absorber structure Design Status
IFR Detector R&D status
EURONu Collaboration Board,
J. Musser for the MINOS Collatoration 2002 FNAL Users Meeting
Simulation for DayaBay Detectors
Chris Smith California Institute of Technology EPS Conference 2003
The Development of a Segmented Detector using ZnS:Ag/6Li
Presentation transcript:

Cost for Large Liquid Scintillator Detector Ken Heller University of Minnesota Active Detector – Liquid Scintillator Target Material - Water Read Out – Wavelength Shifting Fiber Photodetector – Image Intensifier + ccd camera Structure – PVC Extrusions Detector cost - $1M/kTon

Design for Costing – PVC Structure 312 planes 64 Tons/plane 48 Tons water 16 Tons scintillator 15.6 planes/kTon 20 m 15 cm 16 modules/plane 4 Tons/module 3 Tons water 1 Ton scintillator 20 m 1.2 m 15 cm 4 layers/module 32 cells/layer Single PVC extrusion 3 Layers water 1 Layer scintillator 392 lbs/module (unfilled) 1.2 m 15 cm 20 m 3.8 cm 32 cells/layer 1.5 mm outer wall 1 mm inner wall WLS read out for scintillator 512 cells/plane 8000 cells/kTon

Design for Costing – Wavelength Shifting Fiber 20 m 3.8 cm 22 m WLS fiber/scintillator cell 0.5 mm diameter fiber 6 m attenuation length To photodetector Light trapped as r Fiber cost as r 2 U gives 2 x light of single fiber near photodetector 4 x light of single fiber at far end 0.5 mm U fiber gives 2 x light of a single 1mm fiber (far end) at ½ the cost End sealed in extrusion process Open end

Budget Scintillator – Fluor in mineral oil concentrate mix at site with Mineral oil to dilute to B517L $1.65M/kTon of scintillator 16 Tons scintillator/plane $26.4k/plane = $66/m 2 Scintillator is ¼ of detector mass $412k/kTon detector WLS Fiber 0.5mm – $0.75/m 44 m/fiber 512 fibers/plane $17k/plane = $42.5/m fibers/kTon $264k/kTon detector PVC extrusions – $1.07/lb 392 lbs/module 16 modules/plane $6.7k/plane = $16.8/m planes/kTon $105k/kTon detector + one time die cost $200k Manifolds – $200/module 16 modules/plane $3.2k/plane = $8/m planes/kTon $50k/kTon detector

Other Costs Photodetector IIT (2 cm x 1.5 cm) $2500 each including CCD camera and optics 1 IIT per plane (1024 fiber ends) 2/3 IIT area $2.5k/plane = $6.25/m planes/kTon $39k/kTon Installation Transport and stack light-weight modules (392 lbs) Fill on site 64 man hours/plane - $1.6k/plane = $4/m planes/kTon $25k/kTon Clear Fiber (4 modules on 4 planes to IIT) 4 m clear fiber/wls end x 1024 wls ends = 4096 m $0.75/m $3.1k/plane = $7.68/m planes/kTon $48k/kTon

A Self Supporting Structure Modules at alternating at 45 o Sealed bottoms 1 o slope Front view Side view

Cost Summary Scintillator WLS Fiber PVC extrusions Photodetector + electronics Clear Fiber Installation Total Not included: DAQ, trigger electronics, water, fiber coupling to IIT, QA, cosmic ray shield, calibration, pumps, hoists, site, power, safety, heating, cooling A 20kTon liquid scintillator detector costs $20M + site + outfitting Can build with current technology at reasonable price Manifolds Per m 2 $66 $42.5 $16.8 $ 6.3 $ 7.7 $ 4 $151 $ 8 Per plane $26.4k $17k $ 6.7k $ 2.5k $ 3.1k $ 1.6k $60.4k $ 3.2k Per kTon $412k $264k $105k $ 39k $ 48k $ 25k $943k $ 50k

Liquid vs Solid for 20kt with water absorber ($M)SolidLiquid Scintillator Container/module Small partsAbove1.0 WLS fiber IIT + housing + cable Absorber2.1above Installation $/Area (m^2)154 Total (20 kTons) Added flexibility of liquid scintillator design Change fraction or nature of absorber