Pedagogy and Learning in the Doctorate: Situating Supervision Mark Connolly University of Wisconsin - Madison Dan Kaczynski University of West Florida.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
1 Bologna Shaping the Agenda Bologna today and tomorrow Lesley Wilson Secretary-General, European University Association.
Advertisements

ENQA, Bologna, London and beyond
Official BFUG Bologna Seminar ENHANCING EUROPEAN EMPLOYABILITY July 2006 University of Wales Swansea.
Changes in Doctoral Education Worldwide Past Differences, Current Commonalities, and Future Trends Associate Professor Maresi Nerad Associate Graduate.
The Bologna Process: Implementational Issues UNICA Contributions.
«Bologna Structural Reforms: History, Problems and Perspectives» INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE Astana February 13-14, 2014.
Overview of ULLL in Europe Michel Feutrie President of EUCEN EUCEN Conference Tallinn 7/11/2008.
Establishing an EM Program Brenda D. Phillips Oklahoma State University Fire and Emergency Management Program 519 Math Sciences Building Stillwater OK.
Quality and the Bologna Process Andrée Sursock Deputy Secretary General European University Association (EUA) EPC Annual Congress, March 2005, Brighton.
EUA CONVENTION of HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS General Introduction Eric FROMENT President GRAZ 29 MAY 2003.
UKCGE International conference in doctoral development and training Oxford: March 2015 An international perspective on the structured doctorate Gill.
Ahead of 2015 Bologna Ministerial Conference: A new agenda for the EHEA Gayane Harutyunyan Bologna Secretariat Minsk, Belarus, 3-4 March 2015.
Employability in context of the Bologna Process Gayane Harutyunyan Bologna Secretariat Yerevan, May 2014.
Aims: HERODOT II ( ) HERODOT II will: produce guidelines from TUNING and other research, to promote the role of Geography and the employability.
Bologna and the Third Cycle Anthony J Vickers UK Bologna Expert.
COIMBRA GROUP ANNUAL CONFERENCE Anita Lehikoinen.
EUA Convention of European Higher Education Institutions Graz, May 2003 Theme II Revisiting the Links between Teaching and Research.
EUROPEAN NETWORK FOR THE PROMOTION OF LANGUAGE LEARNING AMONG ALL UNDERGRADUATES (ENLU) Project managed by the European Language.
Quality Assurance in the Bologna Process Fiona Crozier QAA
Exchange A7: Linking activity in Europe – UNEP mapping and building sustainability across universities and colleges in Europe Wayne Talbot, WTA Education.
International Trends: the Bologna Process and the European Research Area Ruth Thompson Director of Higher Education Strategy and Implementation Department.
International Aspects of the European Research Agenda Lesley Wilson EUA Secretary General Monash University 15 November 2007.
Assessment of Higher Education Learning Outcomes (AHELO): Update Deborah Roseveare Head, Skills beyond School Division Directorate for Education OECD 31.
The Bologna Process and the European Higher Education Area Ensuring Worldwide Competitiveness of Master’s and PhD Programmes at European Universities of.
MCCWDTA Sharing Blended Learning Strategies Barbara Treacy January 15, 2014 Massachusetts Community Colleges and Workforce Development Transformation Agenda.
Organization, Administration, and Improvement of Graduate Education Daniel Denecke, Ph.D. Program Director, Best Practices and Publications The Council.
Higher Education and Research: Mission and Interaction David Crosier CONFERENCE TO LAUNCH WORK ON A MASTER PLAN FOR HIGHER EDUCATION IN ALBANIA Tirana,
The European Dimension of Quality Assurance Henrik Toft Jensen EUA Conference “Quality Assurance in Higher Education and Vocational Education and Training.
Embracing Math Standards: Our Journey and Beyond 2008.
RECOMMENDATIONS Strand B: Validation of non-formal and informal learning.
Extension Policy Statements on Public Issues Education Strengthening the Role of the University L. Steven Smutko North Carolina State University.
Internationalizing the Undergraduate Psychology Curriculum Anna Laura Comunian University of Padua, Italy.
R & D in Continuing Education ALISE Conference, 2005 Fiona Black and Judy Dunn.
Building Partnerships to Enhance the Colorado Nursing Workforce.
Andrée Sursock, PhD Mexico–EU Policy Dialogue Seminar on transparency tools, internationalisation and excellence in higher education September 2015.
Improving the recognition system Prof. Andrejs Rauhvargers President, Lisbon Convention Committee.
DETERMINE Working document # 4 'Economic arguments for addressing social determinants of health inequalities' December 2009 Owen Metcalfe & Teresa Lavin.
European Higher Education in Flux – challenges for the next decade - Lesley Wilson Secretary General, EUA EAIR, Vilnius, 24 August 2009.
Tuning of Higher Education Programmes on the Basis of Profiles, Competences and Learning Outcomes WHYHOWWHAT.
Bologna self-certification Implications and challenges.
REGIONAL NETWORK ON QUALIFICATIONS FRAMEWORK FOR SOUTH EAST EUROPE Cetinje, 8-9 July 2008 QUALIFICATIONS FRAMEWORKS: ROLE AND IMPORTANCE FROM A REGIONAL.
THE NEED TO TRAIN THE TRAINERS. Who University lecturers /academics Teaching assistants (such as research students who do tutoring etc) Senior academics.
Date: in 12 pts The Second Africa-EU initiative: Harmonisation, Quality and Accreditation supporting PAQAF Deirdre Lennan, European Commission.
1 The Common Core State Standards Implications for Teacher Preparation The Importance and Impact of Effective Practice K-16 Dorothy S. Strickland, Ph.D.
ANNOOR ISLAMIC SCHOOL AdvancEd Survey PURPOSE AND DIRECTION.
The Recognition of Joint Programmes - overcoming the challenges Cardiff 11 th November 2015 Huw Landeg Morris Swansea University Director.
Staff All Surveys Questions 1-27 n=45 surveys Strongly Disagree Disagree Neutral Agree Strongly Agree The relative sizes of the colored bars in the chart.
1 EAN CONFERENCE June 30 – July 2, 2008, Berlin. 2 „Challenges for Europe: European Higher Education in a Global Setting“ Barbara Weitgruber Austrian.
the European Council of Doctoral Candidates and Junior Researchers Renzo Rubele President of Eurodoc From Bologna to Bergen: A mid-term review… Workshop.
ESG 2015: Linking external and internal QA Involving stakeholders Tia Loukkola Director for Institutional Development 22 January 2016.
LISBON RECOGNITION CONVENTION (LRC) POST 2010 Dr. Carita Blomqvist, Head of Unit Recognition and International Comparability of Qualifications Finnish.
Andy Gibbs Yerevan 2009 Winter School “Promoting European Dimension in Higher Education”
Parallel session 3 Quality Assurance and Recognition in a Global Perspective Chair :Andrejs Rauhvargers Speakers: Marie Jose Lemaitre del Campo Nikki Heerens.
Hanne Smidt, Senior Advisor European University Association.
Bologna Process - objectives and achievements Ms. Sirpa Moitus, FINEEC Mr. Kauko Hämäläinen Baku, 29 September 2015.
Mobility challenges for the Future Eric Froment Professor University of Lyon (Lumière-Lyon2) Founding President of the EUA Conference | Lille 6 & 7 October.
 The NEFEC STEM Initiative Nancy Thompson Supervisor of Curriculum and Instruction.
QUALITY ASSURANCE & ENHANCEMENT IN THE UK AEUA Presidents’ Meeting, 4 July 2011, Groningen Professor Ella Ritchie Deputy Vice-Chancellor, Newcastle University.
Internationalisation is Requisite for the Innovative Development of Applied Technology-Oriented Education Ciarán O’Leary Dublin Institute of Technology.
PhD education in a knowledge society An evaluation of PhD education in Norway Taran Thune, Svein Kyvik, Sverker Sörlin, Terje Bruen Olsen, Agnete Vabø.
Project: EaP countries cooperation for promoting quality assurance in higher education Maria Stratan European Institute for Political Studies of Moldova.
The Bologna Process Bergen, May 2005
Overview of Session Review of the 3 Pillar Documents
RCOB Core Review Update
01/14/02 EUA CONVENTION of HIGHER EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS General Introduction Eric FROMENT President Iits our way of implementing ther action plan since.
Doctoral programmes in Europe
Senior project leader at CIEP Former President of ENQA
Diversity & Inclusion at UCONN
Minnesota State University, Mankato
Doctoral Education in Europe: An Introduction
Presentation transcript:

Pedagogy and Learning in the Doctorate: Situating Supervision Mark Connolly University of Wisconsin - Madison Dan Kaczynski University of West Florida Alison Lee University of Technology, Sydney Vijay Kumar Mallan University of Putra Malaysia [authors listed in alphabetical order]

Overview Currents in Doctoral Change Currents in Doctoral Change Guiding Questions Guiding Questions Emergence of Key Inquiry Issues Emergence of Key Inquiry Issues Future Exploration Discussion Future Exploration Discussion

Globalization of Doctoral Education (Maresi Nerad)  Increase in PhD production  women  international students  More than one supervisor  Proliferation of professional doctorates  Concern for diversity of students & faculty  QA time-to-degree, attrition, employment

Bologna Process An agreement among the education ministries and higher education of 45 European countries to create the European Higher Education Area (EHEA) by 2010 and adoption of the three-tiered degree structure An agreement among the education ministries and higher education of 45 European countries to create the European Higher Education Area (EHEA) by 2010 and adoption of the three-tiered degree structure Europe has ~ 1,200 doctorate-granting and research-intensive universities

Banff Principles on Graduate Education Respect differences in programs & modes of delivery Respect differences in programs & modes of delivery Promote the quality of graduate programs Promote the quality of graduate programs Develop global career competencies and awareness in graduates Develop global career competencies and awareness in graduates Encourage innovation in programs and graduates Encourage innovation in programs and graduates Clarify and strengthen the role of the masters degree Clarify and strengthen the role of the masters degree Promote collaborative programs across national boundaries Promote collaborative programs across national boundaries Understand the global flow of graduate students and researchers Understand the global flow of graduate students and researchers Engage stakeholders in global improvement of graduate education Engage stakeholders in global improvement of graduate education Establish a global platform for best practices in graduate education Establish a global platform for best practices in graduate education

Challenging Research Pedagogies International Working Conference, McGill University, Montreal What is the nature of student learning? What is the nature of student learning? Is there a distinction between learning and study? Is there a distinction between learning and study? What do students need to study? What do students need to study? How might students best study? How might students best study? What are the implications to doctoral education? What are the implications to doctoral education?

Focus of Workgroup Inquiry How do we better understand the place of learning as a key element of doctoral education?

Exploring a Transnational Perspective Australia USAMalaysia

Transnational Differences and Similarities in Doctoral Pedagogies Inquiry Issue 1 Postgraduate/doctoral pedagogy is under theorized Postgraduate/doctoral pedagogy is under theorized Lack good models that can account for the formal and informal ways in which doctoral students learn Lack good models that can account for the formal and informal ways in which doctoral students learn

Transnational Differences and Similarities in Doctoral Pedagogies Inquiry Issue 2 Systems of doctoral education are similar and different in important ways Systems of doctoral education are similar and different in important ways Even when underlying structures and procedures are similar, differences in terminology complicate efforts to promote transnational collective and collaborative work Even when underlying structures and procedures are similar, differences in terminology complicate efforts to promote transnational collective and collaborative work

Transnational Differences and Similarities in Doctoral Pedagogies Inquiry Issue 3 Greater understanding is needed of the changing relationship between supervision (advising) and learning (study), and particularly the influence on the supervisory role of these factors: Greater understanding is needed of the changing relationship between supervision (advising) and learning (study), and particularly the influence on the supervisory role of these factors:  national systems of doctoral training  institutional structures and priorities  disciplinary norms and practice

Conceptual Frameworks (Burton Clark; 1994, 1997) teaching ≥≤ research teaching ≥≤ research research-teaching-study (basic unit) nexus research-teaching-study (basic unit) nexus integration overcoming fragmentation integration overcoming fragmentation  Institutional  National  Transnational

Discussion Paths of inquiry not taken Paths of inquiry not taken Other conceptual frameworks Other conceptual frameworks Promising paths of change Promising paths of change …