Experiences at Illinois State University in the first year of deployment Bruce Stoffel, Head, Liaison and Reference Services EBSCO Discovery Service.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Federated Searching Feedback From Usability Testing & Focus Groups Sarah C. Williams Angela Bonnell Milner Library, Illinois State University.
Advertisements

Re-tailoring Interlibrary Loan Workflows After Being Outfitted with IDS Search Carrie Marten Resource Sharing Librarian Purchase College Library-SUNY
Bridging the Sophomore Gap: A Developmental Model of Information Literacy Shawn Bethke, Head of Library Public Services George Loveland, Library Director.
Library Online Catalog Tutorial Pentagon Library Last Updated March 2008.
NWACC Library Instruction Program Teaching information literacy skills for academic success and lifelong learning.
YOU ONLY THINK YOU’RE LIKE GOOGLE : COMPARATIVE USER EXPERIENCE OF DISCOVERY PLATFORMS Rice Majors Faculty Director of Libraries Information Technology.
WS Locating Information Sources, Spring 2005 Searching for Books Use a library Catalog Use a variety of searches Keyword – flexible, but may not.
CAS Writing Program Faculty Orientation August 30, 2007 Boston University Libraries The library’s scholarly resources the two most prominent features.
Web-scale discovery services: searching the library in the era of Google Katie Dunn Technology & Metadata Librarian Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute Slides:
FOCUS GROUP by Dotan and Acadia. Objectives To collect, analyze, and interpret data about students’ opinions of the AUP library website in a focus group.
Finding Psychology Research Articles for Review. The research article must also come from a “scholarly journal.” Scholarly (or peer-reviewed) journals.
Serial Solutions Your Solution to Finding Journals in the Library’s Electronic Collection.
Finding Information Kevin Klipfel, Information Literacy Coordinator, California State University, Chico.
The LTI Protocol An Opportunity for Deep Integration into the LMS.
Website Redesign: User Testing and Web 2.0 Bennett Claire Ponsford - Digital Services Librarian Christina H. Gola - Coordinator of Undergraduate Instruction.
Discovery & Classic Catalogs: Enhancing or Confusing? Jill Dixon Binghamton University Libraries.
Finding Psychology Research Articles for Review 1.
Annie Downey, University of North Texas Gayla Byerly, University of North Texas Society for Research into Higher Education Annual Conference December 2007.
Support.ebsco.com EBSCO Discovery Service Statistics Explained Tutorial.
LIBRARY. Only 4 Steps Researching in academic business journals.
USING THE LIBRARY PATRON CATALOG. Part 1 Easy Search.
BACK TO THE BASICS: Library Instruction Redux. BRENT HUSHER MELISSA MUTH FU ZHU0 University of Missouri–Kansas.
Discover The Library! Libraries and Learning Innovation, Leeds Metropolitan University Julie Cleverley Journals and Electronic Resources Manager Targeted.
Effective use of OPAC - challenge for teaching and learning Kärt Miil Vilve Seiler
Instructional Community of Practice Discussion Dream Information Literacy Curriculum December 9, 2014.
Deborah Gentry, Instructional Development Center Randi Sutter, Library 14 th Annual Illinois Community College Assessment Fair.
Of Database Searching workshop for Ruby Certificate presented by: Theresa Mastrodonato February 20, 2007.
Instruction & Assessment Plan, Melissa Bowles-Terry April 4, 2011.
The Required Library Component: Assessing First-Year Teaching in the Small Academic Library Susan von Daum Tholl, PhD, Director Diane Zydlewski, Head of.
The Embedded Librarian: Integrating Library Resources into Course Management Systems Emily Daly Instruction & Outreach Librarian Perkins Library, Duke.
Discovery layers and the distance student Online search habits of students Rosie Croft, University Librarian Jessica Mussell, Instruction & Public Services.
Name of presentation Month 2009 Courses and Programs Database Information Session September 2009.
What did our users tell us about how we should improve the library website interface? And what are our actions in response? Neena Weng User Interfaces.
How do I? Request an Interlibrary Loan using the OCLC First Search Database?
Electronic Resources for Teaching and Learning Howard University Libraries Washington, DC.
UBC JumpStart workshop By Eugene Barsky Science & Engineering Librarian Irving K. Barber Learning Centre, UBC Fall 2008.
NCSU Libraries Kristin Antelman NCSU Libraries June 24, 2006.
Leatherby Libraries Douglas R. Dechow, MSLIS, PhD Associate Librarian x7781 New Faculty Orientation Spring 2013.
Usability, the User Experience & Interface Design: The Role of Reference July 30, 2013.
Central Search / “Multi-Search” Federated Searching at Portland State University Adriene Lim, 2007 OLA Annual Conference.
1 Integration of Information Literacy into the Biology Curriculum Department of Physics and Astronomy, and Biophysics Ilo-Katryn Maimets, Science Librarian.
Chris Edwards User Experience & Instruction Librarian
Subject Guides and Subject Librarianship Ndhlovu Phillip Assistant Librarian NUST Library SubjectsPlus ZULC National Workshop December 13, 2011.
Learning Stations: Actively Engaging Students in the E-Classroom Shelly Davis, Information Technology Librarian Judy Steere, Head of Technical Services.
Endeca: a faceted search solution for the library catalog Kristin Antelman & Emily Lynema UNC University Library Advisory Council June 15, 2006.
Sakaibrary: Integrating Licensed Library Resources with Sakai 29 November 2006 Steve Smail Mark Notess.
Displayed with permission
Our Situation as Discovery Tools Were Released 2009/10 UNCG had a federated search product (EHIS), but due to its limitations we didn’t feature it very.
One Shot? Make it Four!: Planning and Assessing a Multi-Session Information Literacy Experiment Maureen Williams Neumann University Aston, Pennsylvania.
A Usability Assessment of EBSCO Discovery Service David Comeaux – Web Development Librarian Emily Frank – Instructional Technologies Librarian Mike Waugh.
The Liaison Librarian Program – Meeting Faculty Needs? Daphne Flanagan, AUS University Librarian, Alanna Ross, AUS Associate University.
Social Services Knowledge Scotland Search Tools Found it!
The Role of Instruction in a Contemporary Research Library Michelle Baildon November 10, 2005 Massachusetts Institute of Technology Libraries.
Discovery Tool Implementation: UGA Bill Clayton Assistant University Librarian for Systems University of Georgia Libraries GUGM, Macon State, May.
THE IMPACT OF EDS ON INFORMATION LITERACY LISA ROSE-WILES, SETON HALL UNIVERSITY 400 SOUTH ORANGE AVENUE SOUTH ORANGE, NJ USA
HUMA 1970: Introduction to Library Research Timothy Bristow Research & Instruction Librarian, Scott Library.
Sunni Nishimura AskAway Coordinator ETUG Learn Together Series May 2009 Funding support for this initiative is provided by BCcampus.
DbWiz Federated Search Tool Demo to Staff Carol MacDonald April 4, 2007.
Go to the link listed below to sign-in to your student portal via the My Campus tab.
WHAT WOULD GOOGLE DO? Tracy Gilmore, Virginia Tech Lesley Moyo, Virginia Tech Elizabeth German, University of Houston Andrew Nagy, Serials Solutions Data.
Faculty and Learning Resources Anthony Valenti Campus Director Learning Resources.
A GAINST I NSTINCT Choosing Discovery & Making it Work Liane Taylor, Continuing Resources Librarian Arlene Salazar, Reference/Instruction Librarian Lisa.
Building the Next Successful Library Discovery Tool Jeremy Hall & Michael Kucsak.
Learning Objectives Made Easy
SLA San Diego Fall Seminar Round Table Discussion
First Year Students UWG1101 and Ingram Library
Summon and Resource Discovery at the NCSU Libraries
DISCOVERY A new way to search for articles and other information
Determining Discovery: How First-Year Students Use Primo
Presentation transcript:

Experiences at Illinois State University in the first year of deployment Bruce Stoffel, Head, Liaison and Reference Services EBSCO Discovery Service

Timeline Deployed WebFeat Integrated Search, Fall 2006 Focus groups, Fall 2006 and Fall 2007 Availability of WebFeat ceased Spring 2010 Selected EBSCO Discovery through RFP, Summer 2010 Deployed EBSCO Discovery, July present

Library homepage, August 2010

Library homepage, January 2011

Search results display

Searches, * This figure is reported in EBSCO Discovery as the number of sessions. Academic YearVendorTypeSearches WebFeatIntegrated86, WebFeatIntegrated151, WebFeatIntegrated122, WebFeatIntegrated115, EBSCODiscovery, Integrated257,865

Website feedback The discovery service is more efficient than native database searching. It is much easier to search now. I don’t understand the discovery search. What does the search anything button mean? What am I searching? This feature makes searching more difficult when it was intended to make it easier. I don’t like searching so broadly. I’m just looking for books or articles. How can I do so without using Search Anything? Catalog and databases should be prominent instead. I don’t find the discovery search as efficient as native database searching. Too many results to review. Prefer advanced search that supports fielded searching. People should be expected to learn how to search catalogs and databases. Are we “dumbing down” research too much?

Working with patrons Many patrons do not immediately recognize the facets and how to use them. Once they do, they often seem pleased with their search results. Few understand the integrated search option. Few use it. Few understand what they are searching against. Few ask. Some facets are particularly confusing, including the multiple subject heading options. Patrons wanting a few good sources are satisfied. Patrons wanting depth... not as much.

Reactions from students Introductory English: Positive feedback Introductory Communication: Many choose Discovery although directed to native databases Sophomore English: 50% favor Discovery, 50% favor native databases Junior/Senior Psychology Research: Use Discovery to supplement native databases

Reactions from faculty Mixed. Concerns about precision. But this seems to vary by discipline. Concerns about the mix of publication types in search results. Concerns about student learning.

Reactions from librarians Mixed to negative. Discovery is considered an improvement over federated. Used in general education courses, but librarians teaching other courses tend to stress native databases. Not yet embedding subject-specific Discovery searches in guides. Changes in the way research concepts are taught, but the concepts remain unchanged. Inclusion in Discovery is considered now when selecting databases and interfaces.

The future Some meta search option is here to stay at our library for awhile. The primary question for us is not if we will have a meta search tool but how it will be configured and incorporated into our suite of resources. Discovery will be incorporated more into our instruction and reference services. Formal assessment is underway. More is needed. We will likely revisit our approach to meta search and native databases regularly as products change.

Thank you! Bruce Stoffel Head, Liaison and Reference Services Milner Library Illinois State University