Investment workstream 19 May 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project (I1) Update The Manual for near term investment procedures for (cross-

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
TITRE 28/03/2012 NWE IG meeting – Amsterdam Schiphol NWE day-ahead price coupling – cost issues.
Advertisements

1 Madrid, 2 nd Nov th IG Meeting South Gas Regional Initiative VI. MIBGAS.
BEB Transport und Speicher Service GmbH, Hannover Capacity Development NW Region Capacity Development in the North-West.
Safeguarding Investments In Gas Infrastructure Informal lecture Agency for the Cooperation of Energy Regulators, ACER - By Tim Boersma.
Access to long-term capacity for electric interconnections: toward a single European set of rules 2 nd common RCC CSE-CWE regions 28 September 2010 Milan.
1 Intraday in the CWE region NWE and Bilateral initiatives Common RCC CSE - CWE 28 September 2010.
Gas Regional Initiative North West Region - Short Term Capacity GRI NW SG Meeting Brussels – 26 November 2010.
Gas Regional Initiative – North West Region Investment workshop The Hague – 4 June 2010 Investment Project Regional Investment Plans Introduction to methodology.
Future role of GRI NW Stakeholder Group Meeting The Hague, 7 may 2010 Peter Plug Chairman of GRI NW.
Workshop on “Requirements of financial institutions on the financing of gas infrastructure projects, Brussels, Regulatory requirements for new.
Madrid, September 23 rd th SG Meeting South Gas Regional Initiative Open Season for future capacity.
 TYNDP assessmentFindings for NW region  ResilienceDenmark/Sweden, Luxembourg  Supply dependencySouth of France  Network adaptabilityno issues  Supply.
Better Regulation workshop on Rate of Return Guidelines
EU Tariff Code Update 23 rd June EU Tariff Code Update – early feedback  Informal ACER feedback:  Draft code not on line with FG and insufficient.
GRI NW Investment - From virtual to measurable support Update on project Common effort on making regional investment happen Hague 4 june 2010.
1 Brussels workshop: 26 and 27 February 2009 Conclusions and minutes Workshop 26 – 27 February 2009 GRI NW Investment I1- Virtual Test/Business Simulation.
Investment workstream 20 January 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project (I1) Advisory Group Meeting Conclusions and minutes, draft Bonn.
1 Cross-border Investment TRIGGERS GRI NW Investment I1- Virtual Test – Stockholm September 24, 2009 By : Johan Allonsius.
Investment workstream 20 October 2008 Investment project (I1)‏ Update on Consultation Presentation at account and by project manager.
1 The Regulatory Approach to Fostering Investment David Halldearn Ofgem 28 September 2006.
Classification: Internal Status: Draft ERGEG GRI NW Investment Workstream Shippers’ contribution Helga FRANSE, Jerome DUROYON,
Paris, 16 th March th SG Meeting South Gas Regional Initiative.
1 Investment workstream, GRI NW Investments and Incentives an economic perspective Machiel Mulder Office of Energy Regulation Netherlands Competition Authority.
NW GRI Investment Project Virtual Test Case Adam Cooper - EFET.
Gas Regional Initiative North-West Transmission System Operators Page 1 Investment work stream GRI North-West Operators‘ Group Investment Work Stream SG.
1 Gas Regional Investment Plan North West Europe GRI Meeting, November 25 th 2011.
EUROPEAN COMMISSION Heinrich Hick, DG TREN C 2 3rd IEM Package and relevance of GRI GRI NW stakeholder Conference, London, 14 November 2008.
Benoît Esnault Commission de Régulation de l’Energie (CRE) - ERGEG 19th Madrid Forum, March 2011 Energy Infrastructure Package ERGEG preliminary.
Investment workstream 19 May 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project GRI NW (I1) Opening of the Day 2 nd Investment workshop GRI NW.
Brussels workshop on Investment: 26 and 27 February 2009 “Simulating a (virtual) gas pipeline investment in the NW region” Coming to common proposal on.
Chryssa Argyriou Directorate B – Security of supply, Energy markets & Networks Unit B2 Electricity and Gas Sofia, Energy Day, 18 June 2010 Energy Infrastructure.
6th Stakeholder Group Meeting Stockholm - 26 November, 2009 Gas Regional Initiative – North West Region Experience with coordinated o pen seasons Dominique.
Benoît Esnault Commission de Régulation de l’Energie (CRE) - ERGEG 19th Madrid Forum, March 2011 Preparatory work for Framework Guideline Tariffs.
1 The regulators’ view on the Central West REM: Emphasis on the completion of existing initiatives Presentation for the Mini-Forum 20 June 2006.
Madrid, 1 st April 2008 Proposal for the commercialisation of existing and committed capacity at the cross border point of Larrau between France and Spain.
GRI NW Investment - Update on project Common effort on making regional investment happen 21 September 2010.
Walter Boltz Chairman, CEER Gas Working Group Enabling Markets Initial assessment of merging market areas & trading regions Gas Target Model.
Gas Regional Initiative North West Region - Short Term Capacity 7th Stakeholder Group Meeting The Hague – 6 and 7 May 2010.
Public presentation of the draft ERGP work programme for 2013 Luc Hindryckx ERGP Chair 2013 Brussels December 13 th 2012.
Bonn Workshops 8 and 9 Feb Balancing workstream.
1 Day Ahead Auctions Making progress, Jour Fixe Day Ahead Auctions pilot 14 th of September 2007 Jour Fixe The Hague Conclusions and homework Chair DTe.
Asta Sihvonen-Punkka Director General of EMA Vice-Chair of ERGEG Baltic Electricity Mini-Forum 1 October, 2010 Jurmala ACER and regulatory empowerment.
Gas Regional Initiative – North West Region London 13 and 14 November 2008 Project manager: Erik Rakhou Investment project – I1 (in co-operation with I2)
The next steps for regional co-operation GRI NW Stakeholder Group 25 November 2011.
The Central Role of the Network Operators 28 March 2007 ERGEG-GTE Meeting.
GRI NW Investment Cross border investment Dublin 19 May Bid Capture Process Adam Cooper & Mike Young.
Madrid 15 th June 2009 OS Agreement to Reserve Capacity 10 th IG meeting.
Gas balancing interactions: Proposal for case studies Cemil Altin (Ofgem)
David Halldearn 6 May Background Programme Board initial discussion last year at Stockholm Since then: Further analysis has been undertaken on.
Union for the co-ordination of transmission of electricity UCTE, 15 Boulevard Saint-Michel, 1040 Brussels, Belgium, UCTE comments on ERGEG.
1 GTE Transparency Platform GIE Annual Conference Madrid, 22/23 November 2007 Paolo Mosa GTE Vice President.
Investment workstream 19 May 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project (I1) Conclusions workshop Dublin.
Investment workstream 22 January 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project (I1) Update to RCC at account of project leader Erik Rakhou Project.
European Ten Year Network Development Statement Volker Schippers GTE+ Senior Adviser GTE+ Workshop on GTE+ Work Programme 24 June 2008.
Madrid, 15th June rd SG Meeting South Gas Regional Initiative TSOs’ report 2013/2015 – Main Findings.
Investment workstream 08 June 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project (I1) Update for Joint GRI NW Meeting Where are we heading since last.
1 Open Seasons between France and Belgium GRTgaz Fluxys Gas Regional Initiative North-West Stakeholders Meeting 7 May 2010.
Gas Regional Initiative W orkstream regulatory co-ordination, subfocus investment Workshops Bonn, 8 February 2007 Draft 2.
The Business Plan. Role of business planning To set the objectives for the business To ensure the business idea can be delivered profitably To raise finance.
1 Dublin 23/24 April CONCLUSIONS Regulatory Co-ordination Responses to Deliverables 3 and 4 due by 8 th May Papers redrafted to take comments into account.
7th Stakeholder Group meeting The Hague – 07 May 2010 Gas Regional Initiative Region North-West Secondary Markets Betsy Annen, CRE Bernhard Schaefer, E.ON.
1 GRI NW Investment project in progress Cross-border gas transmission‏ Update on Investment project I1 GRI NW Focus at Virtual Test (Business Simulation)
Gas Regional Initiative North West Region - Short Term Capacity RCC Meeting Den Haag – 21 September 2010.
Gas Regional Initiative – North West Region Stakeholders Group meeting - London 14 November, 2008 Capacity Workshop Coordinated Open Seasons Marie-Claire.
Strategic rationale According to Roadmap project shall focus on short-tem capacity issues: maximising use of existing capacity including reserve capacity.
2009 TSO Transparency Gas Regional Initiative North-West
Background and Process
In depth analysis of TYNDP issues
In depth analysis of TYNDP issues
In depth analysis of TYNDP issues
Presentation transcript:

Investment workstream 19 May 2009 Cross-border gas transmission‏ Investment project (I1) Update The Manual for near term investment procedures for (cross- border) transmission Kristien van de Laar (NMa/EK)

2 Investment workstream, GRI NW Outline presentation 1. Overview “Manual” topics 2. Illustrative examples on what to expect (eg on risk allocation) 3. Way forward to September 2009 Workshop

3 Investment workstream, GRI NW 1. Overview “Manual” topics 1) Regulatory model 2) Type of investment 3) Investment Planning 4) Determining whether an investment proposal is efficient, required and sufficient 5) Allocation of risks (cross border only) => see examples on next slide. 6) Allocation of costs (tariff based only) 7) Bearing the costs and risks 8) Determining allowed return

4 Investment workstream, GRI NW 2. Illustrative examples on what to expect (a) (eg on risk allocation, answer for German regulatory framework) Question in the Manual: Could you give an example of how the risk is distributed between parties (please take into account the following parties: network users (shippers) end users (consumers), the TSOs and other parties which are in your country of relevance). Answer to question in the Manual: In Germany the risk allocation for example for a single TSO’s extension project can be handled by the approval of an investment budget if the investment project complies with the conditions of section 23 ARegV. The costs of an approved investment budget are treaded as non-controllable costs. Consequently, they are passed on to the network users by adding these costs to the given revenue cap for the respective regulatory period. These investment costs remain uncontrollable costs until the scenario, the investment budget is based on, is put into effect. That is to say, in Germany there is not a fixed percentage of risk allocation between network users and network operator but a changing risk allocation over the years. In the first phase (after the approval of the investment budget and before the scenario is put into effect) the risk for the network operator might be very high. Besides, during this period the probability of a framework changes, which cannot be controlled by the network operator, is of great importance. In order to set incentives to invest, the whole risk is allocated to the network users.

5 Investment workstream, GRI NW 2. Illustrative examples on what to expect (b) (eg on risk allocation, answer for German regulatory framework) Question in the Manual: Could you give an example of how the risk is distributed between parties (please take into account the following parties: network users (shippers) end users (consumers), the TSOs and other parties which are in your country of relevance). Answer to question in the Manual: As soon as the costs become controllable costs there is a risk shifting between network users and network operators. The degree of risk shifting depends on several factors like for example the individual efficiency factor of the network operator. But even in this phase the BNetzA takes care that the risk of changing quantities is taken into regard: The difference between the permitted revenues and the revenues achievable by the network operator taking into account the actual quantity development can be considered in the regulatory account. As a consequence the network operators do not have to bear the risk of a changing quantity. Besides, an important instrument for the risk allocation between network users and network operators is the value for the equity rate and in detail the beta-factor as part of the equity market risk premium. By determining the beta-factor the risks for which a diversification is not possible are already considered. From our point of view, this mixture of different instruments in the incentive regulation allows an efficient risk shifting between network users and network operators and incentives for investment.

6 Investment workstream, GRI NW 2. Illustrative examples on what to expect (c) (eg on risk allocation, answer for French regulatory framework) Question in the Manual: Could you give an example of how the risk is distributed between parties (please take into account the following parties: network users (shippers) end users (consumers), the TSOs and other parties which are in your country of relevance). Answer to question in the Manual: As we concentrate on cross border investments, the shippers are absolutely master of (managing) this risk. As the system relies on long term user commitments, a shipper gets what he asks for and the tariff is upfront set based on the costs of the investment. We assume shippers all have good business strategies to decide to this investment. If afterwards one shipper do not use its capacity, not only he will have to get its money back from his existing clients, the capacity shall be used on the short term by its competitors. Of course, there is always a secondary market as well (to allow for reselling of unused capacity).

7 Investment workstream, GRI NW 2. Way forward to September 2009 Workshop 1. By 8th of June 2009 the manual will be filled in for frameworks of Germany, Netherlands, Belgium and France To allow for background material to the test discussions Focus on “key” elements required for the discussion “key“ shall be driven by discussions on the model 2. By 24 September 2009 (workshop) overview of all nine regulatory frameworks of GRI NW To allow for practical guidance for current and future regional investment processes In order to allow for potential comparison on lessons learned from the test process