UNAUTHORISED BEHAVIOR IN CROSSBORDER HEALTHCARE ELIŠKA DVOŘÁKOVÁ, HEAD OF INTERNATIONAL LAW DEPARTMENT PRAGUE, 4. 6. 2015.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

Directive on patients rights in cross-border healthcare DG SANCO Unit D2 Healthcare systems.

Advertisements

Regional Workshop Warsaw, January 2006 STATE UNION OF SERBIA AND MONTENEGRO Basel Protocol on Liability and Compensation Questionnaire No. 2 Ratification.

Trilateral Conference on Tax and social fraud Parental benefit Monika Toiger Estonian Social Insurance Board.

CLAIMS SETTLING WITHIN AND OUTSIDE THE EUROPEAN UNION.

Customs administration in the Customs Union and the Common Economic Space Prospects for further development Eurasian Economic Commission Department of.

EU Cross-Border Care Directive from the Primary Care perspective Results of a simulation Rita Baeten Gothenburg, 3 September 2012.

Domestic workers – situation in the Czech Republic.

Single Audit Strategy LATVIA. Audit System The Audit Authority functions are carried out by the Internal Audit Department of the Ministry of.

A step onward on the way towards the eEHIC Fostering the acceptance of Health Insurance Smart Cards from the national to the European-wide scale BIOHEALTH.

Customs 2013 Programme Customs 2013 is a programme which gives the national customs administrations of the EU, together with the European Commission, the.

ACTUAL STATE AND PERSPECTIVE OF MTPL INSURANCE MARKET IN BiH The International Insurance Forum Insurance Agency of Bosnia and Herzegovina Samir Omerhodžić.

With the support of the European Commission 1 RECENT LEGISLATION AND FURTHER REFORMS OF THE SERBIAN STATE ADMINISTRATION Jovan Teokarevic Belgrade Centre.

Czech Health System - legislation Helena Hnilicová, Ph.D. 1.Medical Faculty Charles University, Prague Ludwig Dittrich, Ph.D. CULS in Prague.

1 Liene Ramane Social Insurance Department Ministry of Welfare trESS seminar RIGA, 19 April 2012 Latvian experience and problems of coordination of unemployment.

Employment Agency of the Republic of Macedonia (role, state of affairs, reforms, and implementation of active employment programs) Skopje, April 2015.

1 Government of Montenegro Secretariat for European Integration Secretariat for European Integration Ana Vukadinović, Head of SEI Ana Vukadinović, Head.

KOR-EU Leaders for Global Education (KE-LeGE) – ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCES.

Security of Computerized Medical Information: Threats from Authorized Users James G. Anderson, Ph.D. Purdue University.

KOR-EU Leaders for Global Education (KE-LeGE) – ADMINISTRATION AND FINANCES.

Fiscalis workshop 2020/ September 2014 Cooperation tax recovery authorities – social security authorities – authorities dealing with agricultural.

Making the Services Directive Work Dublin 6 March 2014 Services Directive and why it matters.

Coheur Alain : Mutualités Socialistes de Belgique Coheur Alain : Mutualités Socialistes de Belgique Common Challenges for Health and Care A Europe of patients.

Sapienza University of Rome a short presentation ERASMUS STAFF MOBILITY WEEK 2011 Sapienza University of Rome EU Research Programmes and visiting Professors.

© OECD A joint initiative of the OECD and the European Union, principally financed by the EU BUDGETING EU FUNDS IN LITHUANIA Rimantas Veckys Lithuanian.

Foreigner as a healthcare professional in the territory of Slovak Republic in the context of the Directive of the European Parliament and of the Council.

Directive on the application of patients’ rights in cross-border healthcare Recent developments Jooske Vos European Partnership for Supervisory Organisations.

PRESENTATION OF INDIRECT TAXATION AGENCY ORGANISATION.

1 10 th Anniversary Conference Budapest – May 10, 2011 Impact of for the development of the eEHIC – opportunity and value Dr. Christopher Hermann.

THE STATUS OF SECONDMENT  Poland is a country whose workers are mainly sent to other countries of the European Union or European.

István Pálfi Day “Institutionalized co-operations after 2014 – The future of the EGTCs” Nóra Bella Ivády dr. Head of Department Department of Cross-Border.

The Czech Health System – its Presence and Future Pavel Hroboň L.Dittrich.

Coding Compliance Plan July 12, Benefits of a compliance program  To demonstrate our commitment to honest and responsible conduct, decrease the.

Asylum MINISTRY OF INTERIOR POLICE DIRECTORATE BORDER POLICE DIRECTORATE

Management and the state registration of the enterprise.

Meeting with the Romanian Motor Insurers’ Bureau Bucharest 19 th August 2004 Ulf Lemor.

A major step towards a Europe for Health Directive on patients’ rights in cross-border healthcare DG SANCO D2 Healthcare Systems.

VZP CRVZP CR GENERAL HEALTH INSURANCE COMPANY OF CZECH REPUBLIC OPEN HOUSE PRAGUE, PAVEL VYCHODSKY, PH.D. DEPUTY CEO FOR ICT.

Reform of Annex X 2013 The active attempt to make the external service of the European Union unattractive Ferdinand Kopp, SFE

Czech Development Aid Czech-Asian Forum Business, cultural and education exchange Prague / 2 nd March 2009 Eva Anderová International Relations Department.

“An Expert Comes From Another City” Mobility and Reintegration Petr Svoboda Institute of Molecular Genetics Prague, Czech Republic.

Director of the General Department for Analysis and Regulation of Foreign Economic Activity of the Ministry of Economic Development of the Russian Federation.

Anti-Fraud Strategies

Determining the applicable national social security scheme An overview of the main rules in Regulations n° 883/2004 & 987/2009, …but also in Regulations.

Determining the applicable national social security scheme An overview of the main rules in Regulations n° 883/2004 & 987/2009,

The network of the Immigration Liaison Officers – tasks and personal experiences Mr. Gergely Szabó Head of Administrative Department Regional Directorate.

E-Health and Telemedicine development perspectives in Latvia and EU (The Model of Riga Telemedicine centre) RĪGA, IST4Balt RĪGA, IST4Balt 2006.

TrESS Topical questions Monika Toiger Estonian Social Insurance Board.

Structural Funds Managing Authority – Ministry of Finance 1 Technical Assistance Ilze Aleksandroviča Head of Control and Development Division EU Funds.

Our meetings; a „safe place“ for everybody. Health Insurance The European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) A free card that gives you access to medically.

EU Cohesion Policy and its implementation in the Czech Republic Zuzana Kasáková Department of W European Studies Charles University in Prague.

M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 2– Freedom Movement for Workers Bilateral.

M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 3 – Right of establishment and freedom.

Cross-Border Health Care Under Construction?. Landmark decisions of the European Court of Justice  Kohll/Decker, C-158/96, C-120/95 ( )  Vanbraekel,

REPUBLIC OF ALBANIA PUBLIC PROCUREMENT AGENCY Eighth Regional Public Procurement Forum May, 22-25, 2012 Tirana

Week 12. Lecture 2. Health Law & the EU Cross-border healthcare: patients’ rights.

DG Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities Modernised Social Security Coordination Zagreb, June 2010 Coordination in the field of sickness,

CENTRAL FINLAND HEALTH CARE DISTRICT HEALTH THROUGH KNOWLEDGE, EXPERTISE AND CO-OPERATION

1 M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 29 – Customs union Bilateral screening:

M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 2– Freedom Movement for Workers Bilateral.

DG Employment, Social Affairs and Equal Opportunities Modernised Social Security Coordination within the EU International Dimensions of Social Security.

Foreign investments into Russia. Tax consequences.

1 M O N T E N E G R O Negotiating Team for the Accession of Montenegro to the European Union Working Group for Chapter 29 – Customs union Bilateral screening:

Organization and Implementation of a National Regulatory Program for the Control of Radiation Sources Co-ordination and Co-operation.

Jovan Andonovski, PhD, Deputy Ombudsman Republic of Macedonia

PRESENTATION OF MONTENEGRO

The Czech Health System – its Presence and Future

Cross-border healthcare and the EU Directive 24/2011

Public procurement oversight

Review of Motor Insurance Directive

Coordination of the National Statistical System of the Republic of Macedonia Kruševo, 2018.

Presentation transcript:

UNAUTHORISED BEHAVIOR IN CROSSBORDER HEALTHCARE ELIŠKA DVOŘÁKOVÁ, HEAD OF INTERNATIONAL LAW DEPARTMENT PRAGUE,

CONTENTCONTENT 1.Introduction 2.International payments (reimbursement between institutions, refund) 3.Unauthorized behavior of Insurees 4.Unauthorized behavior of Healthcare Providers 5.Unauthorized behavior of Health Insurance Funds 2

INTRODUCTIONINTRODUCTION -Different situation,when healthcare provided in EU (EEA, Switzerland), Contractual countries, „Third“ countries 1.EU: EU legislation – EU Regulations (No. 883/2004 and 987/2009), EU Directives (No. 2011/24/EU, on the application of patient’s rights in cross- border healthcare) 2.Contractual states (Turkey, Serbia, Montenegro, Macedonia) principals of mutual trust, cooperation, information… 3.„Third“ countries – no international reimbursement system between institutions -In general : more players involved, more space for unauthorized behavior/potential fraud and corruption (legislators, healthcare providers, health insurance funds, insurees) 3

4 INTERNATIONAL REIMBURSEMENT – ADMINISTRATIVE PROCEDURE (EU/EEA/SWITZERLAND, CONTRACTUAL STATES State of Insurance (ČR) Foreign Country Liaison Body (CMU) Czech health insurance fund Czech insuree with entitlement document (EHIC) Liaison Body Helping health insurance fund in EU

STATISTICS 1.Czech patients abroad (EU, Contractual states), in 2014, total amount: ,68 CZK = EUR VZP ČR: ,03 CZK = EUR = +/- 65% 2.Foreign patients in CR in 2014 (temporary payments by Czech Health insurance Funds), total amount : ,30 CZK = EUR VZP ČR: ,93 CZK = EUR = +/- 82% 5

6 REFUND OF COSTS State of Insurance (ČR) Foreign country Czech insuree days Czech health insurance fund

UNAUTHORISED BEHAVIOR OF INSUREES (INDIVIDUALS) -Forgery of EHIC (entitlement documents) - unauthorized (illegal) profit of healthcare (obligation of Health Insurance Fund to cover the costs = damage caused by a person = material profit of a person) international/national system of recovery of debts -Refund of costs of healthcare provided abroad – claiming the refund twice (public health insurance fund + private/commercial health insurance fund) VZP ČR asks for original documents -Fictive foundation of business/fictive declaration of employees to be insured within public health insurance scheme necessary controls of individual payers and employers 7

UNAUTHORISED BEHAVIOR OF HEALTHCARE PROVIDERS Healthcare provided abroad - Principal of mutual trust, cooperation, information -Limited possibilities of control (quality of healthcare, relevance of healthcare, technical conditions and personal capacities of healthcare providers) ›Declaration of healthcare which was not performed ›More healthcare provided when patient is a selfpayer (refund of costs by her/ his health insurance fund later, in her/his home state) – Q of relevance/necessity of such healthcare (considering the medical status of patient) ›Patient do not dispose of entitlement document – healthcare provider sometimes uses the „old one“ – even if the patient is not ensured anymore IMPORTANCE OF INFORMATION 8

UNAUTHORISED BEHAVIOR OF FOREIGN HEALTH INSURANCE FUNDS Principal of mutual trust, cooperation, information es = EU standard forms (E125) – lack of -International invoic information -Controls/revisions are (?) made by „helping“ health insurance fund -declared healthcare does not correspond with the entitlement document (more healthcare than necessary, planned healthcare without previous authorization…) VZP ČR controls (economic department) – where suspicion for unauthorized behavior (repeated healthcare, high amounts invoiced…) 9

QUESTIONS and ANSWERS 1010

THANKYOU FOR YOUR ATTENTION