What is Economic Justice? Presented by Dr. Norman R Cloutier, Director, University of Wisconsin-Parkside Center for Economic Education, at WCSS, March.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Roderick T. Long Auburn Dept. of Philosophy
Advertisements

The National Council on Economic Education/John Templeton Foundation Teaching the Ethical Foundations of Economics Lesson 2: What Is the Difference Between.
Session 2 Economic Systems Disclaimer: The views expressed are those of the presenters and do not necessarily reflect those of the Federal Reserve Bank.
Crossing the Line: “Economic Incentives and Ethical Behavior”
 2004 Proutist Universal Proutist Economic Development Rational Distribution and Maximum Utilization Dada Maheshvarananda.
Class One Economics July.
© 2009 Prentice Hall Business Publishing Essentials of Economics Hubbard/O’Brien, 2e. Fernando & Yvonn Quijano Prepared by: Chapter 1 Economics: Foundations.
1 chapter: >> First Principles Krugman/Wells Economics
1 INTRODUCTION.
1 INTRODUCTION. Copyright © 2004 South-Western/Thomson Learning 1 Ten Principles of Economics.
Copyright © 2004 South-Western/Thomson Learning 1 Ten Principles of Economics.
THE PRINCIPLE OF UTILITY: Bentham
Taxes, Social Insurance, and Income Distribution <Review Slides>
CHAPTER 1 First Principles. 2 What you will learn in this chapter:  Trade  Gains from trade  Specialization  Equilibrium  Efficiency and equity A.
Economics PRINCIPLES OF By N. Gregory Mankiw Principles of Economics
PRINCIPLES OF MACROECONOMICS
Economics Introduction:
McTaggart, Findlay, Parkin: Microeconomics © 2007 Pearson Education Australia Chapter 5: Efficiency and Equity.
Teaching the Ethical Foundations of Economics
The National Council on Economic Education/John Templeton Foundation Teaching the Ethical Foundations of Economics Lesson 10: What Is Economic Justice?
Proposal Selection Form Proposer Identification Code __________________ Circle a proposal: 19/1 18/2 17/3 16/4 15/5 14/6 13/7 12/8 11/9 10/10 9/11 8/12.
Principles of Microeconomics, 3rd Canadian Edition
Redistribution, Efficiency, Fairness 1. Consider a Possibility Frontier Most government action we have thought about is getting you from inside the frontier.
20.0 Epilogue Economics is a single tool in a toolkit for understanding how humankind works A liberal society where markets determine everything.
Basic Economic Concepts Chapters 1-2. What is Economics in General? Economics is the study of _________. Economics is the science of scarcity. Scarcity.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western PowerPoint® Lecture Presentation to accompany Principles of Economics, Fourth Edition N. Gregory Mankiw Prepared by Kathryn.
Principles of Economics, Third Edition
Distributive Justice II: John Rawls Ethics Dr. Jason M. Chang.
Economics Economics is the study of how people choose to allocate scarce resources to produce goods and services and how they choose to distribute those.
Economics for Leaders Lesson 8: Costs & Benefits Of Government Action.
Introduction to Economics What is this course about??
The Economic Way of Thinking Dr. T. D. Mitchell Bonneville High School, Idaho Falls, Idaho.
Part I: Introduction Chapter 1: Ten Principles of Economics Chapter 1: Ten Principles of Economics.
Splash Screen Section 1-1 Guide to Reading Economics is the study of how individuals and societies make choices about ways to use scarce resources to.
Chapter 1: Ten Principles of Economics. What is Economics? Study of how society manages its scarce resources Therefore, basic economic concept is Scarcity.
The Context of Business Ethics: Economies and Organizations.
The Nature and Method of Economics 1 C H A P T E R.
Rawls on justice Michael Lacewing co.uk.
Market Efficiency SPHA511, John Ries. Market Economies and Perfect Competition Prices are determined by supply and demand Demand represents aggregate.
Voluntary National Content Standards For Economics Presented by Joe Lockerd.
PowerPoint® Lecture Presentation to accompany Principles of Economics, Third Edition N. Gregory Mankiw Prepared by Mark P. Karscig, Central Missouri State.
Principles of Economics
Ten Principles of Economics. ... The word economy comes from a Greek word for “one who manages a household.” Economy...
Thinking Economically Ch. 1, pg An Economic Conundrum…  There are 100 hungry people  There are 100 hamburgers  What do we do with the 100 hamburgers?
Egalitarian Liberalism: Justice in the Modern State
 “We hold these truths to be self evident: that all men are created equal; that they are endowed by their Creator with certain inalienable rights: that.
Section 1 Thinking like an economist. 4 Scarcity: limited nature of society’s resources 4 Economics: the study of how society manages its scarce resources.
ESU Debate Workshop : Economics Stefano Imbriano, English Speaking Union, London.
Equity: Ethical Approaches to Social Justice “Excuse me, but its important to get those drinks to those who need them the most.”
Copyright © 2004 South-Western/Thomson Learning Economy The word economy comes from a Greek word for “one who manages a household.”
 Explain the market failure  Explain the government intervention to correct the market failure in terms of efficiency or equity  Use economic models.
Chapter 1: Ten Principles of Economics. Brainstorm What are 5 things that you would like more of?
The American Free Enterprise System Chapter 3 Capitalism A market economy is based on capitalism, a system in which private citizens own the factors.
Enduring Understandings of the Class The Individual (Self) 1.All Individuals have self-worth and natural rights. 2.An Individual’s experiences and perspective.
Types of Taxes. Impact of Taxes How do taxes affect the decisions you make? Resource Allocation- Whenever a tax is placed on a good or service, it raises.
Essential Questions of Unit 2 1.To what extent does the DOI, Constitution, and the Amendments recognize and protect the rights of the individual? 2.Why.
Ten Principles of Economics 1. Economy – “oikonomos” (Greek) –“One who manages a household” Household - many decisions –Allocate scarce resources Ability,
Economics PRINCIPLES OF By N. Gregory Mankiw Principles of Economics
Rawl’s Veil of Ignorance
Ten Principles of Economics
10 Principles of Economics
Economics Defined The social science concerned with the efficient use of limited or scarce resources to achieve maximum satisfaction of human wants.
Moral Sense Theory.
AP Economics “Econ, Econ” Econ.
© 2007 Thomson South-Western
Fundamental of Economics Continued
Ten Principles of Economics
Economics PRINCIPLES OF By N. Gregory Mankiw Principles of Economics
Principles of Economics
Justice distribution “Rats and roaches live by competition under the laws of supply and demand; it is the privilege of human beings to live under.
Presentation transcript:

What is Economic Justice? Presented by Dr. Norman R Cloutier, Director, University of Wisconsin-Parkside Center for Economic Education, at WCSS, March 16, Adapted from Teaching the Ethical Foundations of Economics, National Council on Economic Education, 2007.

Economic Goals Low Unemployment Economic Growth Low Inflation Efficiency Equity

Adam Smith “However selfish a man may be, there are evidently some principles in his nature, which interest him in the fortunes of others, and render their happiness necessary to him, though he derives nothing from it except the pleasure of seeing it. We feel pity or compassion when we see the misery of others, or are made to conceive of it in a lively manner.” - Adam Smith Paraphrased from the opening paragraph of Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759)

Lesson Objectives Students will: 1.Explain why people disagree about what is just. 2.Contrast a just process with a just outcome. 3.Explain how individuals may seek their own interests through public policy. 4.Contrast self-interested economic behavior with behavior behind the “Veil of Ignorance.”

National Economic Content Standards 1. Productive resources are limited. People must choose some things and give up others. 3.Different methods can be used to allocate goods and services. People, acting individually or collectively through government, must choose which methods to use. 4.People respond predictably to positive and negative incentives. 14. Income for most people is determined by the market value of their productive resources. 16. There is an economic role for government in a market economy whenever the benefits of government policy outweigh the costs.

What is Economic Justice? All economic systems must address the fundamental problem of scarcity, because not all wants can be satisfied. All approaches to the problem of scarcity have efficiency and equity implications. Economics has tended to focus on questions of efficiency, or generating maximum economic welfare. Questions of equity, or fairness in economic transactions, have received less attention.

Economic Justice Economic justice is difficult to define, but involves two – possibly contradictory – questions: Is the outcome just? Is the process just? A fair process may generate a highly unequal, perhaps unfair, outcome.

Economic Justice People who emphasize outcomes tend to believe current economic inequality is unjust. People who emphasize process tend to approve of outcomes, even if they are highly unequal, as long as individuals have equal opportunity.

Is it fair? Is competition in a golf tournament, auto race, or TV reality show fair? Is the process fair? Outcomes are very unequal. Winners generally win very large prizes, while everyone else gets little or nothing.

Is it fair? Do you think it is fair that some students are admitted to higher-quality colleges and universities and other students are rejected? The outcome is unequal. Is the process fair? Student performance matters. Wealthy families can hire tutors and academic coaches. Is that fair? Some students may be admitted because their parents are alumni, others may be admitted through affirmative action. Is that fair?

The Veil of Ignorance Game Round 1 Distribute Role Cards defining position in society. Determine policies that benefit them and vote. Present group’s vote and justification for its position. Round 2 Repeat procedure with new Role Cards under the veil of ignorance.

Raising Government Revenue Option A: Progressive Income Tax Annual IncomeTax Rate $ 0 - $ 10,000 0% $ 10,000 - $ 50,000 10% $ 50,001 - $100,000 20% $100,001 - $300,000 30% > $300,000 50% Example: Jody earns $80,000 0% on first $10,000$10,000 x.00 = $ 0 10% on next $40,000$40,000 x.10 = $ 4,000 30% on next $30,000$30,000 x.20 = $ 6,000 Jody’s total taxes= $ 10,000 Option B: Flat Income Tax Everyone pays the same rate (15%) on all income. Jody would pay $80,000 x.15= $12,000 Actual Marginal Rates for an individual: 2008 Taxable IncomeTax Rate $ 0 - $ 8,025 10% $ 8,026 - $ 32,550 15% $ 32,551 - $ 78,850 25% $ 78,851 - $164,550 28% $164,551 - $357,700 33% > $357,700 35%

Vote 1 Role and Income Known Vote 2 Behind a Veil of Ignorance Issue 1: Raising Government Revenue ProgressiveFlatProgressiveFlat Group 1 Group 2 Group 3 Group 4 Group 5 GroupRoleFamily Income Progressive TaxFlat Tax 1Unemployed laborer$8,000$0$1,200 2Teacher$100,000$14,000$15,000 3Student$0 4Executive$450,000$149,000$67,500 5Retiree$50,000$4,000$7,500

Questions In the second round, you didn’t know your role or position in life. How did this affect your views about these economic policy issues? Students are likely to say that in round 1 they first made decisions based on narrow self-interest, but in round 2 that took a wider perspective. Review policy options and how self-interest can frame points of view.

Questions After playing this game, do you think fairness in economic policy should be based on achieving equal outcomes or providing a process for equal opportunity? Why is it not always possible to have both? A balance between a just process and a just outcome may be possible. Social “safety nets” address unacceptably large disparities in outcomes, but at the same time can make a process more fair. For example, education can be viewed as an outcome and as a part of a process.

Questions Since it is not actually possible to live behind a veil of ignorance, what lessons did you learn about resolving economic policy issues? The game helps us to consider a wider perspective than our own. Considering the perspective of another person stretches our moral imagination. Policy making is enriched and cooperation is more likely.

Further Reading Argument for outcomes based justice: John Rawls, Justice and Fairness: A Restatement (Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 2001) Argument for process based justice: Thomas Sowell, The Quest for Cosmic Justice (New York: The Free Press, 1999)