2 - 1 How To Estimate The Insurance Need Introduction Principal planning areas Income replacement and family needs analysis Business insurance needs analysis Estate preservation and liquidity needs analysis Begin and end with the objectives and goals of the client Even if they do not conform to what advisor’s considers proper or appropriate Advisor should “educate” client about uses and abuses of insurance Ethics and prudence require that the insurance plan satisfy the client’s objectives Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 2 How To Estimate The Insurance Need Income replacement and family needs analysis Rule of thumb approach Estimate amount of insurance required as roughly six to eight time annual gross income Another estimate take five rimes gross income, plus mortgage, debts, final expenses, and any other special funding needs Another estimate says that 6% of breadwinner’s gross income, plus 1% for each dependent, should be spent on premiums for life insurance Example – Person with nonworking spouse and three children should spend 10% of gross income on insurance premiums These methods are easy to understand, but limited Individuals needs vary widely Age of insured or dependents not taken into account Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 3 How To Estimate The Insurance Need Income replacement and family needs analysis Multiples of salary method Hybrid method combining rules of thumb approach with elements of income replacement and needs analysis Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 4 How To Estimate The Insurance Need Income replacement and family needs analysis (cont'd) Multiples of salary method (cont'd) Adjusts for spouse’s age Does not take into account age of insured, premium costs or number of dependents Not a suitable method when both spouses work Does not take into account difference in tax rates or investment rates of return that may apply in difference family situations Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 5 How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach Based on human life value concept Present value of earnings potential of that person Basic objective of life insurance is to replace some or all of the earnings lost if an income- producing family member should die Human life value Factors used to determine human life value Current annual after tax earnings (C) Projected growth rate of earnings (g) Future working lifetime (n) An after tax discount rate (r) Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 6 How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Equation Basic assumptions Present value is very sensitive to changes in the underlying earnings growth and discount rate assumptions Earnings rate growth Dependent on inflation rates, tax rates, and career opportunities U.S. compound growth rate of inflation-adjusted disposable after tax income – just over 2% Inflation has averaged just over 4% in the long run Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 7 How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Basic assumptions (cont'd) Earnings rate growth (cont’d) Not necessarily a good estimate for a particular individual Every individual is unique Many advance faster or slower than others within their occupation Earnings growth rates vary among industries and occupations After-tax discount rates Also problematic Depends on the risk one is willing to assume, tax rates, and inflation rates Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
2 - 8 How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) After-tax discount rates Discuss alternative assumptions with client and let client be your guide on selecting the appropriate discount rate Selected return must be adjusted for taxes Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning AVERAGE ANNUAL NOMINAL AND REAL COMPOUND RETURNS ( ) NominalReal Large Stocks (S&P 500)13.75%7.91% Corporate Bonds (Moody’s AAA)10.04%5.23% Government Bonds (10 Years)9.12%5.77% Treasury Bills (3 Month)6.22%1.86% Inflation (Consumer Price Index4.27% Source: Based on data obtained from Global Financial Data, Los Angeles, CA,
2 - 9 How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Family support ratio Portion of after-tax income spent on self-maintenance not available for the family 25% after-tax income spent for self-maintenance, 75% for family support Ratio may vary widely from family to family Once estimate of breadwinner’s human life value is determined, the amount should be multiplied by the family support ratio Example – Present value of future earnings determined to be $1,000,000 Assume 70% of breadwinner’s after-tax income used to support the family Then amount needed to support the breadwinner’s family is $700,000 Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Other adjustments Reduce by other assets currently available to fund survivor’s income needs Marketable securities Pension and profit-sharing balances Tax-deferred annuity plans IRAs Simplified employee pension plans Reduce by other life insurance currently in force Increase by any outstanding debts Mortgages Personal loans Final death expenses Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Adjustments for social security survivor benefits Benefits for surviving spouses with dependant children (% of PIA) Benefits for surviving spouse alone Fig. 2.2 can be used to estimate social security survivor benefits Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need The income replacement approach (cont'd) Income replacement as a multiple of gross pay - Examples Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Needs analysis Estimates the family income need directly Lump sum cash needs Administrative / final expenses Estate settlement costs Debt liquidation Tax liabilities Education fund Emergency fund Other special needs funding needs Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Needs analysis (cont'd) Multi-period income needs Adjustment period income Surviving spouse’s income needs Children’s income needs Spouse’s retirement income needs Mortgage repayment policy Current amount of risk and how long risk needs to be covered Other major debt repayment policies Nonmortgage long-term debt Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Needs analysis (cont'd) Education fund accumulation policy Pays for projected education costs Estate tax liability policy For estates above $2,000,000 (in 2008) or $4,000,000 with a spouse Income needs are met from various sources Social security survivor’s income Spouse’s earnings Annuity payments Employer provided pension survivor benefits Investment income Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Needs analysis (cont'd) Excess of income needs over expected income Covered by income from re-investing insurance proceeds or Taking an annuity settlement from insurance company Lump sum required to generate a monthly income Capital preservation method Interest income from proceeds without consuming principal Conservative method Requires greater insurance principal Capital consumption method Calculate income assuming liquidation of both interest and principal What happens if spouse outlives income? Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Needs analysis (cont'd) Needs analysis worksheet (Figure 2.9) Current cash needs are estimated Capital necessary to fund lifetime income needs estimated Total value of assets subtracted from current cash needs and capital needs Interest rate assumption critical Use an after-tax rate Adjust for inflation Income needs of children based on a capital liquidation approach Needs will end when they graduate college & support themselves Adjustment period One to two years Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Business Insurance Needs Analysis For business insurance applications Key employee Split dollar Nonqualified deferred compensation agreements Executive bonus plans Funding of Buy-Sell agreements Amounts depend on insurance needs particular to each situation Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Business Insurance Needs Analysis (cont'd) Key employee insurance (cont'd) Premature death or disability, or untimely resignation, will severely impact the business’s profitability Managing the risk Non-compete clauses Employment severance agreements Cross training among employees Management philosophy of mentoring subordinates Attractive and properly designed compensation packages Properly designed insurance plan can provide funds during the transition period Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Business Insurance Needs Analysis (cont'd) Basic principles of key employee valuation approaches measure financial loss based in what employee would have contributed to future success of the firm Adjust financial consequences for the timing of those lost contributions Account for trends in employee’s contributions Realize employee’s contributions will terminate (resignation, death, disability, retirement) Key employee’s contributions will be recovered over time Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Business Insurance Needs Analysis (cont'd) Key employee valuation method Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Business Insurance Needs Analysis (cont'd) Key employee valuation method – Required inputs Number of years required to locate, hire, train, and develop replacement Estimated gross revenue each year of transition (line 1) Estimate of percentage of gross revenues attributable to key employee (line 2) Expected total compensation each year over the transition period (Line 4) Direct and indirect costs of locating, recruiting, hiring, installing, compensating, and training a replacement each year during the transition (Line 8) Estimate of contribution of replacement (Line 6) Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Business Insurance Needs Analysis (cont'd) Remaining parts of worksheet Line 3 – Total projected revenues attributable to key employee Line 5 – Key employee’s net contribution Line 7 – Replacement employee’s contribution Line 9 - Replacement employee’s net contribution Line 10 – Difference between contributions of key employee and replacement Line 11 – Discount factor Line 12 – Net present value of each year’s loss Line 13 – Cumulative present value of the loss in net contributions Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning
How To Estimate The Insurance Need Estate preservation and liquidity needs analysis Planning to minimize estate taxes and to assure adequate liquidity Techniques Lifetime gifts Optimal use of the marital deduction Various marital and family trust arrangements Charitable gifts Life Insurance Chapter 2 Tools & Techniques of Life Insurance Planning