Computer modelling of structural and defect properties of stoichiometric lithium niobate Robert A Jackson School of Physical & Geographical Sciences Keele.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Objectives By the end of this section you should: know how the Lennard-Jones [12,6] potential describes the interaction between atoms be able to calculate.
Advertisements

Do we have a problem with freshwater Kd values? B. Howard and E. Tipping CEH, UK Analysis for discussion only – do not quote.
Partition Coefficients Lecture 26. The Partition Coefficient Geochemists find it convenient to define a partition or distribution coefficient of element.
CHE Materials Chemistry & Catalysis : Solid State Chemistry lecture 4
Author: J R Reid Oxidation and Reduction – Introduction LEO goes GER Examples Balancing simple equations Why gain/lose electrons? Electronegativity.
Thermodynamics of Oxygen Defective Magnéli Phases in Rutile: A First Principles Study Leandro Liborio and Nicholas Harrison Department of Chemistry, Imperial.
CHE Inorganic, Physical & Solid State Chemistry Advanced Quantum Chemistry: lecture 4 Rob Jackson LJ1.16,
Lattice defects in oxides.
DIAMOND Decommissioning, Immobilisation and Management of Nuclear Wastes for Disposal Density Functional Theory study of defects in zirconolite Jack Mulroue.
Computational Solid State Chemistry 2 SSI-18 Workshop 2011 Rob Jackson
Computational Solid State Chemistry 1 SSI-18 Workshop 2011 Rob Jackson
Lecture Notes II Defect Chemistry
Lambda DNA ejection measurements and modeling Hernan G. Garcia APh161, Winter 2003 Caltech.
Lecture 6 Activity Scales and Activity Corrections Learn how to make activity corrections Free ion activity coefficients Debye-Huckel Equations Mean Salt.
Chapter 5: Defects in Solids Perfect crystals don’t exist. Many of the important properties of materials are strongly influenced by defects, or even entirely.
A semiclassical, quantitative approach to the Anderson transition Antonio M. García-García Princeton University We study analytically.
CHAPTER 5: CRYSTAL FIELD THEORY
Defects & Impurities BW, Ch. 5 & YC, Ch 4 + my notes & research papers
Compilation and Evaluation of Beta-Delayed Neutron emission probabilities and half-lives of precursors in the Non-Fission Region (A ≤ 72) M. Birch and.
57 Mn Mössbauer collaboration at ISOLDE/CERN Emission Mössbauer spectroscopy of advanced materials for opto- and nano- electronics Spokepersons: Haraldur.
Computer modelling of the concentration dependence of doping in solid state ionic materials Robert A Jackson School of Physical and Geographical Sciences,
A unifying model of cation binding by humic substances Class: Advanced Environmental Chemistry (II) Presented by: Chun-Pao Su (Robert) Date: 2/9/1999.
Magnetic, Transport and Thermal Properties of La 0.67 Pb 0.33 (Mn 1-x Co x )O y M. MIHALIK, V. KAVEČANSKÝ, S. MAŤAŠ, M. ZENTKOVÁ Institute of Experimental.
Computer Modelling of Materials for Optical and Energy Applications Robert A Jackson Lennard-Jones Laboratories, School of Physical & Geographical Sciences,
Modelling Metal Foam Formation in Helium Nanodroplets David McDonagh, The Centre for Interdisciplinary Science Project Supervisor: Professor Andrew Ellis,
Computer Modelling of Materials for Optical and Energy Applications Robert A Jackson Lennard-Jones Laboratories, School of Physical & Geographical Sciences,
Colossal Magnetoresistance of Me x Mn 1-x S (Me = Fe, Cr) Sulfides G. A. Petrakovskii et al., JETP Lett. 72, 70 (2000) Y. Morimoto et al., Nature 380,
Impurities & Defects, Continued More on Shallow Donors & Acceptors Amusing Answers to Exam Questions Given by Public School Students!
Ion Implantation and Ion Beam Analysis of Silicon Carbide Zsolt ZOLNAI MTA MFA Research Institute for Technical Physics and Materials Science Budapest,
CHE Inorganic, Physical & Solid State Chemistry Advanced Quantum Chemistry: lecture 5 Rob Jackson LJ1.16,
Ionic Conductors: Characterisation of Defect Structure Lecture 15 Total scattering analysis Dr. I. Abrahams Queen Mary University of London Lectures co-financed.
Modelling mixed metal fluorides for optical applications Robert A Jackson Lennard-Jones Laboratories School of Physical and Geographical Sciences Keele.
Computer modelling of defects and dopants in LiNbO 3, with a look ahead to LiTaO 3, and Li(Nb, Ta)O 3 solid solutions Robert A Jackson School of Physical.
Li ion diffusion mechanism in the crystalline electrolyte γ- Li 3 PO 4 The structure of thin film battery 3 Solid state electrolyte could be made very.
A review of computer modelling of rare earth doped mixed metal fluoride materials Robert A Jackson Lennard-Jones Laboratories School of Physical and Geographical.
Using computer modelling to help design materials for optical applications Robert A Jackson Chemical & Forensic Sciences School of Physical & Geographical.
AWE Presentation: 29 April 2013
Modelling the concentration dependence of doping in optical materials Robert A Jackson School of Physical and Geographical Sciences, Keele University,
Computer Modelling of Materials for Optical and Energy Applications Robert A Jackson Lennard-Jones Laboratories, School of Physical & Geographical Sciences,
Electronic phase separation in cobaltate perovskites Z. Németh, Z. Klencsár, Z. Homonnay, E. Kuzmann, A. Vértes Institute of Chemistry, Eötvös Loránd University,
CHE Inorganic, Physical & Solid State Chemistry Advanced Quantum Chemistry: lecture 1 Rob Jackson LJ1.16,
Materials Process Design and Control Laboratory ON THE DEVELOPMENT OF WEIGHTED MANY- BODY EXPANSIONS USING AB-INITIO CALCULATIONS FOR PREDICTING STABLE.
Diffusion of radiation damage in Fe and Fe–P systems Stewart Gordon Loughborough University, UK.
DEFECTS IN CRYSTALS Point defects Line defects Surface Imperfections.
The Periodic Table and the Elements. What is the periodic table ? What information is obtained from the table ? How can elemental properties be predicted.
Australian Nuclear Science & Technology Organisation Simulating radiation damage in quaternary oxides Bronwyn Thomas, Nigel Marks, Bruce Begg, René Corrales,
1 4.1 Introduction to CASTEP (1)  CASTEP is a state-of-the-art quantum mechanics-based program designed specifically for solid-state materials science.
Emission Mössbauer spectroscopy of advanced materials for opto- and nano-electronics Spokepersons: Haraldur Páll Gunnlaugsson Sveinn Ólafsson Contact person:
MIT Microstructural Evolution in Materials 7: Ionic Defects Juejun (JJ) Hu
The d Block Element
Transition elements Introduction
Sanghamitra Mukhopadhyay Peter. V. Sushko and Alexander L. Shluger
Impurities & Defects, Continued More on Shallow Donors & Acceptors
Production of an S(α,β) Covariance Matrix with a Monte Carlo-Generated
Half-Metallic Ferromagnetism in Fe-doped Zn3P2 From First-Principles Calculations G. JAI GANESH and S. MATHI JAYA Materials Science Group, Indira Gandhi.
DEFECTS IN CRYSTALS Point defects Line defects Surface Imperfections.
Imperfections in Solids
“Building up” the atoms in the periodic table
Ar 1s2 2s2 2p6 3s2 3p6 Energy 4p 3d 4s 3p 3s 2p 2s 1s
The Periodic Table and the Elements
It’s time to talk about Bonds…
SOLID STATE CHMISTRY By: Dr. Aamarpali
The Periodic Table and the Elements
The Periodic Table and the Elements
The d block: The d block consists of three horizontal series in periods 4, 5 & 6 10 elements in each series Chemistry is “different” from other elements.
Metastability of the boron-vacancy complex (C center) in silicon: A hybrid functional study Cecil Ouma and Walter Meyer Department of Physics, University.
Transition elements Introduction
Defects & Impurities BW, Ch. 5 & YC, Ch 4 + my notes & research papers
Impurities & Defects, Continued More on Shallow Donors & Acceptors
School of Chemical & Physical Sciences
Presentation transcript:

Computer modelling of structural and defect properties of stoichiometric lithium niobate Robert A Jackson School of Physical & Geographical Sciences Keele University Keele, Staffordshire ST5 5BG, UK 1

Acknowledgements Mário Valerio, Romel Araujo (Aracaju, Brazil) László Kovács, Krisztián Lengyel (Budapest, Hungary) Günter Borchardt, Peter Fielitz (Clausthal, Germany) Bud Bridges (Santa Cruz, USA) … and the workshop organisers for the invitation! 2 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

Relevant publications (some hard copies available) [1] R A Jackson, M E G Valerio ‘A new interatomic potential for the ferroelectric and paraelectric phases of LiNbO 3 ’ Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 17, (2005) [2] R M Araujo, K Lengyel, R A Jackson, L Kovács, M E G Valerio ‘A computational study of intrinsic and extrinsic defects in LiNbO 3 ’ Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 19, (2007) [3] R M Araujo, M E G Valerio, R A Jackson ‘Computer modelling of trivalent metal dopants in lithium niobate’ Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 20, (2008) 3 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

Plan of talk Motivation & background Brief introduction to methodology Potential derivation & structural properties Defect properties Ongoing & future work 4 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

Motivation & background The interatomic potential published by Donnerberg and co- workers in was widely used. However: (i) advances in computational software and (ii) the continued interest in the material and the availability of new experimental data prompted us to revisit and re-derive the potential (published in 2005). 5 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

Potential derivation The potential was fitted to simultaneously reproduce the structures of LiNbO 3 a, Li 2 O and Nb 2 O 5 to allow consistency in later defect calculations. The GULP code b was used, employing the free energy option (allowing temperature dependence of the structure to be treated). a S C Abrahams, P Marsh, Acta Cryst., B 42, 61 (1986) b J Gale, see: 6 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

Brief details of the potential* Full ionic charges on Li, Nb and O. Buckingham potentials describe the interactions between Li-O, Nb-O & O-O. A shell model is employed for O. A 3-body bond bending potential describes the O- Nb-O interactions. * R A Jackson, M E G Valerio, J Phys.: Condensed Matter, 17, 837 (2005) 7 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

8 Ferroelectric phase Exp. [1] This workDonnerberg potential 0 K295 K0 K295 K a=b c Paraelectric phase Exp. [2] This workDonnerberg potential 0 K293 K0 K293 K a=b c [1] S C Abrahams, P Marsh, Acta Cryst. B, 42, 61 (1986) [2] H Boysen, F Altorfer, Acta Cryst. B, 50, 405 (1994) Structural agreement International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

9 Lattice parameter as a function of temperature T/Ka exp (Å)a calc (Å)  a (  ) c exp (Å)c calc (Å)  c (  )

International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Modelling defect properties Using the Mott-Littleton method, energies of formation of the intrinsic defects in LiNbO 3 were calculated. These allow predictions to be made about the defect chemistry of the material. (See Araujo et al: Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 19, (2007))

Mott-Littleton approximation Region I Ions are strongly perturbed by the defect and are relaxed explicitly with respect to their Cartesian coordinates. Region II Ions are weakly perturbed and therefore their displacements, with the associated energy of relaxation, can be approximated. © Mark Read 11 International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

Formation energies for basic defects (in stoichiometric LiNbO 3 ) International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Defect0 K293 K *[1] model II V Li ’ V Nb ’’’’’ V O  Li i  ** Nb i  ** O i ’’ ** Nb L i  Li Nb ’’’’ [1] Donnerberg et al, Phys. Rev. B., 40, (1989) * Temperature taken into account via lattice expansion. ** Deduced values since paper does not report these values.

Frenkel, Schottky and pseudo-Schottky energies* (per defect) International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Defect0 K293 K *[1] Li Frenkel Nb Frenkel O Frenkel Schottky LiNbO Pseudo- Schottky Li 2 O Pseudo- Schottky Nb 2 O *Calculated for information only since defects are more complex. Expected trends in values are observed.

Models to explain the observed experimental data The simple Frenkel and Schottky models do not explain the observed behaviour in LiNbO 3. For example, the Nb Li  + 4V Li ’ defect cluster has a formation energy of –63.61 eV. We needed to consider possible reactions that give rise to such defects. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Explaining the observed non- stoichiometry Following the work of Kovács and Polgár*, we considered models based on antisite or interstitial Nb compensated by Li or Nb vacancies. 3 possible reactions were considered (see next slide): * L Kovács and K Polgár, Crystal Research and Technology, 21, K101 (1986)

International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Possible defect reactions that give rise to Li deficiency Antisite Nb compensated by Li vacancies 5Li Li + ½Nb 2 O 5  4V’ Li + Nb Li  + 5/2Li 2 O  E(reaction) = (-2.52*) eV per Li 2 O formula unit Antisite Nb compensated by Nb vacancies 5Li Li + 4Nb Nb + ½Nb 2 O 5  5Nb Li  + 4V Nb ’’’’’ + 5/2Li 2 O  E(reaction) = 29.8 eV per Li 2 O formula unit Interstitial Nb compensated by Li vacancies 5Li Li + ½Nb 2 O 5  5V Li ’ + Nb i  + 5/2Li 2 O  E(reaction) = 0.49 eV per Li 2 O formula unit * ‘Bound’ defect configuration

International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Conclusions from the reactions If the reaction energies are calculated, using the basic defect energies already obtained, we concluded that: – only the antisite Nb/Li vacancy model is energetically favourable. – of the other two mechanisms, the interstitial Nb/Li vacancy model is more favourable than the antisite Nb/Nb vacancy model.

International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September Divalent and trivalent dopants The incorporation of a range of dopant ions in LiNbO 3 was modelled. Divalent and trivalent ion substitution was considered. Charge compensation is needed for substitution at either the Li + or Nb 5+ site.

Dopant ions considered Reference [2]: M 2+ dopants Mg, Mn, Fe, Co, Ni, Zn, Sr, Cd, Ba & Pb, and M 3+ lanthanide dopants Ce-Lu. Reference [3] focused on M 3+ dopants: Sc, Cr, Fe and In. [2] Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 19, (2007) [3] Journal of Physics: Condensed Matter, 20, (2008) International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Summary of modelling procedure The GULP code is used to calculate the substitution energies, e.g. M 2+ at the Li + site, denoted by M Li  in Kroger-Vink notation. The substitution energies are then converted into solution energies, which give the total energy involved in the process: International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Solution energies Assuming M 2+ substitution at the Li + site, a possible scheme could be: MO + 2 Li Li → M Li  + V Li ’ + Li 2 O This assumes charge compensation by Li vacancies, but other possibilities are considered. The same idea is applied to M 3+ dopants. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Predicted doping schemes: M 2+ ions From the calculations, the following predictions are made based on lowest energies: Co-doping at both Li + and Nb 5+ sites, except for Fe 2+ and Cd 2+ for which substitution at the Nb 5+ site with charge compensation by Nb - Li anti- site substitution is preferred. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Predicted doping schemes: M 3+ ions The predicted scheme for all the lanthanide ions and Sc, Cr and Fe is self-compensation: M 2 O 3 + Li Li + Nb Nb → M Li  + M Nb ’’ + LiNbO 3 For In, the preferred scheme involves doping at the Nb 5+ site with charge compensation by Nb-Li anti-sites. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Further calculations – M 4+ & co-doping Calculations have also been performed on Hf 4+ doping, and a range of pairs of co-doped ions. These results will be submitted for publication, possibly in the ‘Lithium Niobate: Properties and Applications’ special journal issue being planned. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Some relevant experimental data Studies of M 2+ & M 3+ dopants in LiNbO 3 have included: Mn 2+ - LiNbO 3 : Darwish et al, NIMB, 141, (1998)  Supports the idea of Mn 2+ self compensation; does not give dopant concentration. Mg 2+ - LiNbO 3 : González-Martínez et al, Opt. Comm., 282, (2009)  Dopant concentration mol%; suggests that self compensation occurs ‘after a certain dopant concentration level’. Er 3+, Cr 3+ - LiNbO 3 : Dierolf & Sandmann, J. Lum., 125, (2007)  Mainly assumes Li site occupancy, but dopant concentration is unclear as several samples have been used. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Comparison with recent experimental data Bud Bridges recently published a paper: ‘EXAFS evidence for a primary Zn Li dopant in LiNbO 3 ’ (F Bridges et al, Phys. Rev. B (2012)) This doesn’t find any Zn at the Nb site, but may not be directly comparable with the calculations (concentration effects, stoichiometry of sample?) EXAFS measurements on In have also been performed. International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

General comments on comparison with experimental data The calculation results reported are at infinite dilution, so no concentration effects are considered. In recent work we are looking at finite dopant concentrations in other materials, and this could be done for dopants in LiNbO 3 (needs persons and €€€). There may be issues with the stoichiometry of the older crystal samples (i.e. are we comparing ‘like with like’?) International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Ongoing and future work Results on tetravalent dopants and co-doping is still to be published. Bud Bridges has detailed EXAFS data on Zn & In doped LiNbO 3, which we are hoping to reproduce. We are in discussions with Peter Fielitz and Günter Borchardt about modelling defects using some different reaction schemes (talk at 12:00 tomorrow). International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September

Thank you! 29International Workshop on Stoichiometric Lithium Niobate, Goslar, Germany, September 2013

30