Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Why multiple b-values are required for multi-tensor models. Evaluation with a constrained log- Euclidean model. Benoit.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Pattern Recognition and Machine Learning
Advertisements

Neural Networks and Kernel Methods
SHAPE THEORY USING GEOMETRY OF QUOTIENT SPACES: STORY STORY SHAPE THEORY USING GEOMETRY OF QUOTIENT SPACES: STORY STORY ANUJ SRIVASTAVA Dept of Statistics.
Edge Preserving Image Restoration using L1 norm
Developable Surface Fitting to Point Clouds Martin Peternell Computer Aided Geometric Design 21(2004) Reporter: Xingwang Zhang June 19, 2005.
 Nuclear Medicine Effect of Overlapping Projections on Reconstruction Image Quality in Multipinhole SPECT Kathleen Vunckx Johan Nuyts Nuclear Medicine,
FTP Biostatistics II Model parameter estimations: Confronting models with measurements.
Siddharth Choudhary.  Refines a visual reconstruction to produce jointly optimal 3D structure and viewing parameters  ‘bundle’ refers to the bundle.
Computer vision: models, learning and inference
High Angular Diffusion Imaging and its Visualization… Limitations of DTI Why HARDI is better?!? Different HARDI models My ideas and current work.
Data mining and statistical learning - lecture 6
Diffusion Tensor Imaging Tim Hughes & Emilie Muelly 1.
1 Minimum Ratio Contours For Meshes Andrew Clements Hao Zhang gruvi graphics + usability + visualization.
Visual Recognition Tutorial
Geometric Flows over Lie Groups Yaniv Gur and Nir Sochen Department of Applied Mathematics Tel-Aviv University, Israel HASSIP, September 2006, Munich.
DTI-Based White Matter Fiber Analysis and Visualization Jun Zhang, Ph.D. Laboratory for Computational Medical Imaging & Data Analysis Laboratory for High.
Master thesis by H.C Achterberg
Introduction to diffusion MRI
1 Robust Video Stabilization Based on Particle Filter Tracking of Projected Camera Motion (IEEE 2009) Junlan Yang University of Illinois,Chicago.
Iterative closest point algorithms
Epipolar geometry. (i)Correspondence geometry: Given an image point x in the first view, how does this constrain the position of the corresponding point.
Uncalibrated Geometry & Stratification Sastry and Yang
Independent Component Analysis (ICA) and Factor Analysis (FA)
J OHNS H OPKINS U NIVERSITY S CHOOL O F M EDICINE Statistically-Based Reorientation of Diffusion Tensor Field XU, D ONGRONG S USUMU M ORI D INGGANG S HEN.
Real Time Abnormal Motion Detection in Surveillance Video Nahum Kiryati Tammy Riklin Raviv Yan Ivanchenko Shay Rochel Vision and Image Analysis Laboratory.
Rician Noise Removal in Diffusion Tensor MRI
Computer vision: models, learning and inference
Optimization of thermal processes2007/2008 Optimization of thermal processes Maciej Marek Czestochowa University of Technology Institute of Thermal Machinery.
Binary Variables (1) Coin flipping: heads=1, tails=0 Bernoulli Distribution.
Dr. Vasileios Lempessis MATHEMATICAL PHYSICS II COMPLEX ALGEBRA LECTURE - 1 “The imaginary numbers are a wonderful flight of God’s spirit; they are almost.
Gwangju Institute of Science and Technology Intelligent Design and Graphics Laboratory Multi-scale tensor voting for feature extraction from unstructured.
1 Hybrid methods for solving large-scale parameter estimation problems Carlos A. Quintero 1 Miguel Argáez 1 Hector Klie 2 Leticia Velázquez 1 Mary Wheeler.
Fast and Simple Calculus on Tensors in the Log-Euclidean Framework Vincent Arsigny, Pierre Fillard, Xavier Pennec, Nicholas Ayache. Research Project/Team.
Tensor Distribution Function in Multiple Shell High Angular Resolution Diffusion Imaging Tensor Distribution Function in Multiple Shell High Angular Resolution.
Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2011, Chicago Toward an accurate multi-fiber assessment strategy for clinical practice. Benoit Scherrer, Simon K. Warfield.
Instructor Kwan-Jin Jung, Ph.D. (Carnegie Mellon University) Technical Assistant Nidhi Kohli (Carnegie Mellon University) David Schaeffer (University of.
CS 782 – Machine Learning Lecture 4 Linear Models for Classification  Probabilistic generative models  Probabilistic discriminative models.
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Validation of DTI Analysis Guido Gerig, Clement Vachet, Isabelle Corouge, Casey.
DSim: An MR Diffusion Weighted Imaging Simulator Bob Dougherty Shyamsundar Gopalakrishnan Stanford University June 13, 2008.
Luke Bloy1, Ragini Verma2 The Section of Biomedical Image Analysis
Analytic ODF Reconstruction and Validation in Q-Ball Imaging Maxime Descoteaux 1 Work done with E. Angelino 2, S. Fitzgibbons 2, R. Deriche 1 1. Projet.
Non-Euclidean Example: The Unit Sphere. Differential Geometry Formal mathematical theory Work with small ‘patches’ –the ‘patches’ look Euclidean Do calculus.
Fiber Demixing with the Tensor Distribution Function avoids errors in Fractional Anisotropy maps Liang Zhan 1,Alex D. Leow 2,3, Neda Jahanshad 1, Arthur.
A Passive Approach to Sensor Network Localization Rahul Biswas and Sebastian Thrun International Conference on Intelligent Robots and Systems 2004 Presented.
Ch. 3: Geometric Camera Calibration
Sharpening Improves Clinically Feasible Q-Ball Imaging Reconstructions
A Flexible New Technique for Camera Calibration Zhengyou Zhang Sung Huh CSPS 643 Individual Presentation 1 February 25,
Data Modeling Patrice Koehl Department of Biological Sciences National University of Singapore
NA-MIC National Alliance for Medical Image Computing Mathematical and physical foundations of DTI Anastasia Yendiki, Ph.D. Massachusetts.
Chapter 2-OPTIMIZATION G.Anuradha. Contents Derivative-based Optimization –Descent Methods –The Method of Steepest Descent –Classical Newton’s Method.
MultiModality Registration Using Hilbert-Schmidt Estimators By: Srinivas Peddi Computer Integrated Surgery II April 6 th, 2001.
Robust Regularization for the Estimation of Intra-Voxel Axon Fiber Orientations Also presented at MMBIA Anchorage, Jun, 2008 Alonso Ramirez-Manzanares.
Neural Networks The Elements of Statistical Learning, Chapter 12 Presented by Nick Rizzolo.
CSCI 631 – Foundations of Computer Vision March 15, 2016 Ashwini Imran Image Stitching.
Diffusion Tensor MRI From Deterministic to Probabilistic Modelling
11/25/03 3D Model Acquisition by Tracking 2D Wireframes Presenter: Jing Han Shiau M. Brown, T. Drummond and R. Cipolla Department of Engineering University.
Statistics on Diffeomorphisms in a Log-Euclidean Framework Vincent Arsigny ¹,Olivier Commowick ¹ ², Xavier Pennec ¹, Nicholas Ayache ¹. ¹ Research Team.
Super-resolution MRI Using Finite Rate of Innovation Curves Greg Ongie*, Mathews Jacob Computational Biomedical Imaging Group (CBIG) University of Iowa.
CSCI 631 – Foundations of Computer Vision March 15, 2016 Ashwini Imran Image Stitching Link: singhashwini.mesinghashwini.me.
Goal We present a hybrid optimization approach for solving global optimization problems, in particular automated parameter estimation models. The hybrid.
Introduction to diffusion MRI
Introduction to diffusion MRI
Unsupervised Riemannian Clustering of Probability Density Functions
Introduction to diffusion MRI
Parameter estimation class 5
Epipolar geometry.
Human Brain Mapping Conference 2003 # 653
Solving an estimation problem
Stochastic Methods.
Presentation transcript:

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Why multiple b-values are required for multi-tensor models. Evaluation with a constrained log- Euclidean model. Benoit Scherrer, Simon K. Warfield

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Diffusion imaging  Diffusion tensor imaging (DTI) Gaussian assumption for the diffusion PDF of water molecules  Diffusion imaging Provides insight into the 3-D diffusion of water molecules in the human brain. Depends on cell membranes, myelination, …  Central imaging modality to study the neural architecture  Models local diffusion by a 3D tensor  Widely used (short acquisitions)  Reveals major fiber bundles = “highways” in the brain Good approximation for voxels containing a single fiber bundle direction But inappropriate for assessing multiple fibers orientations  But inappropriate for assessing multiple fibers orientations.

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Diffusion imaging - HARDI  High Angular Resolution Diffusion Imaging (HARDI)  Cartesian q-space imaging (DSI), Spherical q-space imaging  Introduce many gradient directions.  One gradient strength (single-shell) or several (multiple-shell)  Non-parametric approaches  Diffusion Spectrum Imaging, Q-Ball Imaging Drawbacks:  Narrow pulse approximation.  Need to truncate the Fourier representation  quantization artifacts [Canales-Rodriguez, 2009]  Broad distributions of individual fibers at moderate b-values  Lots of data need to be acquired  limited use for clinical applications General aim: estimate an approximate of the underlying fiber orientation distribution

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Diffusion imaging – parametric approaches  Parametric approaches Describe a predetermined model of diffusion  Spherical decomposition, Generalized Tensor Imaging, CHARMED…  Two-tensor approaches An individual fiber is well represented by a single tensor  multiple fiber orientation expected to be well represented by a set of tensors. Limited number of parameters: a good candidate for clinical applications  BUT: known to be numerically instable

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Contributions In this work  Show that the multi-tensor models parameters are colinear when using single-shell acquisitions. Demonstrate the need of multiple- shells acquisitions.  Verify these findings with a novel constrained log-euclidean two- tensor model

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Diffusion signal modeling  Homogeneous Gaussian model (DTI) Diffusion weighted signal S k along a gradient g k (||g k ||=1) : D: 3x3 diffusion tensor, S 0 : signal with no diffusion gradients, b k : b-value for the gradient direction k.  Multi-fiber models (multi-tensor models)  Each voxel can be divided into a discrete number of homogeneous subregions  Subregions assumed to be in slow exchange  Molecule displacement within each subregion assumed to be Gaussian f 1, f 2 : Apparent volume fraction of each subregion, f 1 + f 2 =1

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Diffusion signal modeling  Models fitting y k : measured diffusion signal for direction k.  Manipulating the exponential because Least square approach by considering the K gradient directions: For one gradient direction: α>0

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam By choosing and we verify that Why several b-values are required Demonstration For any We consider a single b-value acquisition and Then for any, and is a solution as well Non-degenerate tensor for

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Why several b-values are required  Infinite number of solutions  The fractions and the tensor size (eigen-values) are colinear  With several b-values Then for any, and is a solution as well Non-degenerate tensor for If is a solution,

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Why several b-values are required  Single b-value acquisitions Leads to a colinearity in the parameters  conflates the tensor size and the fractions of each tensor Two-tensor models:  Multiple b-value acquisitions The system is better determined, leading to a unique solution

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel constrained log-euclidean two-tensor approach

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach  Symmetric definite positive (SPD) matrices: elements of a Riemannian manifold…  … with a particular metric: null and negative eigen values at an infinite distance  Elegant but at a extremely high computational cost.  Log-euclidean framework  Efficient and close approximation [Arsigny et al, 2006]  Has been applied to the one-tensor estimation [Fillard et al., 2007] Tensor estimation  Care must be taken to ensure non-degenerate tensors ( Cholesky parameterization, Bayesian prior on the eigen values, …)  Elegant approach: consider an adapted mathematical space

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach  Two-tensor log-euclidean model  We consider  And the predicted signal for a gradient direction k:  Fractions: parameterized through a softmax transformation [Tuch et al, 2002]

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach Constrained two-tensor log-euclidean model  To reduce the number of parameters: Introduction of a geometrical constraint [Peled et al, 2006]  each tensor is constraint to lie in the same plane  defined by the two largest eigenvalues of the one-tensor solution  One tensor solution:   2D minimization problem. Estimate 2D tensors subsequently rotated by V.  Only 4 parameters per tensor  Formulation

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach  Two-Tensor fitting  Differentiation in the log-euclidean framework for the constrained model:  Solving  Conjugate gradient descent algorithm (Fletcher-Reeves-Polak-Ribiere algorithm) (Iterative algorithm)

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach  Two-Tensor fitting  Differentiation in the log-euclidean framework:  Solving  Conjugate gradient descent algorithm (Fletcher-Reeves-Polak-Ribiere algorithm)

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach  Initial position  We consider the one-tensor solution  Initial tensors: rotation of angle in the plane formed by  Initial tensors almost parallel  Initial tensors perpendicular  The final two-tensor are obtained by:  Formulation

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam A novel two-tensor approach  Initial position  We consider the one-tensor solution  Initial tensors: rotation of angle in the plane formed by  Initial tensors almost parallel  Initial tensors perpendicular  The final two-tensor are obtained by:  Formulation

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Evaluation

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Evaluation  Simulations  Phantom representing two fibers crossing at 70°  Simulation of the DW signal, corrupted by a Rician noise  Evaluation of different acquisition schemes 1 shell 90 images. 90 dir. b=1000s/mm 2 2 shells 45 images. 30 dir. b 1 =1000s/mm dir. b 2 =7000s/mm 2 2 shells 90 images. 30 dir. b 1 =1000s/mm dir. b 2 =7000s/mm 2  Qualitative evaluation  45 images with 2 b-values provides better results than 90 images with one b-value

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Evaluation  Quantitative evaluation  Two-shells acquisitions: b 1 =1000s/mm 2, D 1 =30 directions and different values for b 2, D 2 (1034 experiments)  The introduction of high b-values helps in stabilizing the estimation  tAMD: Average Minimum LE distance  Fractions compared in term of Average Absolute Difference (AAD)

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Evaluation  Quantitative evaluation  Even an acquisition with 282 directions provides lower results than (45,45)

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Discussion Conclusion  Analytical demonstration that multi-tensor require at least two b-value acquisitions for their estimations  Verified these findings on simulations with a novel log-euclidean constrained two-tensor model Need of several b-values  Already observed experimentally. But here theoretically demonstrated  A number of two-tensors approaches are evaluated with one b-value acquisition  conflates the tensor size and the fractions  A uniform fiber bundle may appear to grow & shrink due to PVE (But generally, tractography algorithms take into account only the principal direction)  High b-values: provides better results. Possibly numerical reasons (reduce the number of local minima?).  Three tensors : requires three b-value ?

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Discussion Novel log-euclidean two-tensor model  Log-euclidean: elegant and efficient framework to avoid degenerate tensors  Constrained: reduce the number of free parameters (only 8)  Preliminary evaluations: a limited number of acquisitions appears as sufficient  Two-tensor estimation from 5-10min acquisitions? (clinically compatible scan time) In the future  Fully take advantage of the log-euclidean framework Not only to avoid degenerate tensors, also to provide a distance between tensors.  Tensor regularization  Full characterization of such as model  Noise and angle robustness  Evaluation on real data with different b-value strategies.

Benoit Scherrer, ISBI 2010, Rotterdam Thank you for your attention,