Design optimization of the protection heaters for the LARP high-field Nb 3 Sn quadrupoles M. Marchevsky, D. W. Cheng, H. Felice, G. Sabbi, Lawrence Berkeley.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
QXF Quench Protection: issues and plans Giorgio Ambrosio Fermilab QXF Video-meeting August 1, 2013 The HiLumi LHC Design Study is included in the High.
Advertisements

2 nd Joint HiLumi LHC – LARP Annual Meeting INFN Frascati – November 14 th to 16 th 2012 LBNL: Helene Felice – Tiina Salmi – Ray Hafalia – Maxim Martchevsky.
Protection study options for HQ01e-3 Tiina Salmi QXF meeting, 27 Nov 2012.
Long HQ coil drawings now available 1 Miao Yu. Dead voltage taps in TQ/LQ/HQ coils Inner layer: 24, outer layer: 12 (33 inner/23 outer per coil for TQ/LQ/HQ)
MQXF Quench Protection Analysis HiLumi workshop – KEK, Tsukuba Vittorio Marinozzi 11/18/2014.
1 QXF heater proposal M. Marchevsky, H. Felice, T. Salmi, D. Cheng, G. Sabbi, LBNL.
Superconducting Large Bore Sextupole for ILC
MQXF state of work and analysis of HQ experimental current decays with the QLASA model used for MQXF Vittorio Marinozzi 10/28/
ASC 2012, 10/10/2012Test results and analysis of LQS03 – G. Ambrosio 1 BNL - FNAL - LBNL - SLAC Test Results and Analysis of LQS03 Third Long Nb 3 Sn Quadrupole.
Overview of main results from first HQ02a test For HQ meeting 7/30/13.
1 QXF heater design: current status and the path forward M. Marchevsky (LBNL) 03/06/2014 D.W. Cheng, H. Felice, G. Sabbi (LBNL), G. Ambrosio (FNAL)
LQ Goals and Design Study Summary – G. Ambrosio 1 LARP Collab Mtg – SLAC, Oct , 2007 BNL - FNAL - LBNL - SLAC LQ Goals & Design Summary Giorgio Ambrosio.
Susana Izquierdo Bermudez. OUTLINE 1. Margin and MIITs overview 2. Quench study based on FNAL 11T tests results 1. Longitudinal quench propagation 2.
1 QXF heater parameters G. Chlachidze, M. Marchevsky March 13, 2014.
Development of the EuCARD Nb 3 Sn Dipole Magnet FRESCA2 P. Ferracin, M. Devaux, M. Durante, P. Fazilleau, P. Fessia, P. Manil, A. Milanese, J. E. Munoz.
LQ status and plans – G. Ambrosio 1 LARP Collaboration Meeting - LBNL, April , 2006 BNL - FNAL - LBNL - SLAC OUTLINE: Goals, Input and Output Sub-tasks.
DOE Review of LARP – February 17-18, 2014 Coil Design and Fabrication Miao Yu February 17,
Brookhaven - fermilab - berkeley US LHC ACCELERATOR PROJECT LHC IR Quad Heaters.
MQXF Quench Protection G. Ambrosio on behalf of the MQXF team With special contribution by: S. Izquierdo Bermudez, V. Marinozzi, E. Ravaioli, T. Salmi,
QXF instrumentation trace development
QXF protection heater design : Overview and status Tiina Salmi QXF quench protection meeting April 30, 2013.
The HiLumi LHC Design Study (a sub-system of HL-LHC) is co-funded by the European Commission within the Framework Programme 7 Capacities Specific Programme,
Triplet status and plans P. Ferracin, G. Ambrosio, M. Anerella, A. Ballarino, B. Bordini, F. Borgnolutti, R. Bossert, D. Cheng, D.R. Dietderich, B. Favrat,
MQXF protection – comparison between 1 or 2 power supplies Vittorio Marinozzi 06/08/
S. Caspi, LBNL HQ Progress and Schedule Shlomo Caspi LBNL LARP Collaboration Meeting – CM13 Port Jefferson November 4-6, 2009.
E. Todesco PROTECTION IN MAGNET DESIGN E. Todesco CERN, Geneva Switzerland With help from B. Auchmann, L. Bottura, H. Felice, J. Fleiter, T. Salmi, M.
Large Hadron Collider Accelerator Research Program Dimensional Changes of Nb 3 Sn Cables during Heat Treatment LBNL: Ian Pong Dan Dietderich.
Test Program and Results Guram Chlachidze for FNAL-CERN Collaboration September 26-27, 2012 Outline Test program Quench Performance Quench Protection Magnetic.
SIS 300 Magnet Design Options. Cos n  magnets; cooling with supercritical Helium GSI 001 existing magnet built at BNG measured in our test facility 6.
QXF quench heater delay simulations Tiina Salmi, T. Salmi.
Conductor Review Oct 16-17, 2013LARP Strand :Specs. Procurement, Measurement- A. Ghosh1 LARP Strand: Specifications, Procurement and Measurement Plans.
1 Quench Protection Workshop - 04/29/2014 QXF heater design M. Marchevsky, D.W. Cheng (LBNL) E. Todesco (CERN) T. Salmi (Tampere UT) G. Chalchidze, G.
Long Quadrupole – G. Ambrosio 1 LARP Collaboration Meeting – FNAL, Oct , 2008 BNL - FNAL - LBNL - SLAC Long Quadrupole Giorgio Ambrosio LARP Collaboration.
ECC Clément Lorin – Maria Durante Acknowledgements: Fresca2 team.
1 QXF / SQXF heater design update M. Marchevsky (12/03/13)
E. Todesco, Milano Bicocca January-February 2016 Appendix C: A digression on costs and applications in superconductivity Ezio Todesco European Organization.
Quench Protection Maximum Voltages G. Ambrosio, V. Marinozzi, M. Sorbi WG Video-Mtg January 14, 2015.
29 th September 2009 EuCARD-WP7 HFM Conductor specification and procurement Luc OBERLI CERN, TE-MSC-SCD.
Long Quad (LQ) & High Gradient (HQ) Series Alexander Zlobin bnl - fnal- lbnl - slac US LHC Accelerator Research Program DOE LARP review Fermilab, June.
DOE Review of LARP – February 17-18, 2014 SQXF Coil Design and Fabrication Winding and Curing Miao Yu February 17,
Tiina Salmi and Antti Stenvall, Tampere University of technology, Finland FCCW2016 Roma, April 13 th, 2016 Quench protection of the 16T dipoles for the.
Protection heater design for MQXF outer layer *Using long Super- Heating Stations for ensuring quenhces at low currents* Tiina Salmi, Tampere.
Dan Cheng, Xiaorong Wang 12/15/2015 MQXFA Connectors Discussion Part II.
Heaters for the QXF magnets: designs and testing and QC M. Marchevsky (LBNL)
HQ02A2 TEST RESULTS November 7, 2013 FERMILAB. HQ02 test at Fermilab 2  First HQ quadrupole with coils (#15-17, #20) of the optimized design o Only coil.
S. Caspi, LBNL HQ Magnet Program Shlomo Caspi LBNL LARP DOE Review FNAL June 1-2, 2011 BNL Jesse Schmalze Mike Anarella Peter Wanderer Arup Gosh FNAL Rodger.
BNL - FNAL - LBNL - SLAC Long Quadrupole Giorgio Ambrosio Fermilab Many people contributed to this work, most of all the Long Quadrupole Task Leaders:
Thermal screen of the cryostat Presented by Evgeny Koshurnikov, GSI, Darmstadt September 8, 2015 Joint Institute for Nuclear Research (Dubna)
MQXFS1 Test Results G. Chlachidze, J. DiMarco, S. Izquierdo-Bermudez, E. Ravaioli, S. Stoynev, T. Strauss et al. Joint LARP CM26/Hi-Lumi Meeting SLAC May.
Answers to the review committee G. Ambrosio, B.Bordini, P. Ferracin MQXF Conductor Review November 5-6, 2014 CERN.
MQXFSM1 results Guram Chlachidze Stoyan Stoynev 10 June 2015LARP meeting.
2 nd LARP / HiLumi Collaboration Mtg, May 9, 2012LHQ Goals and Status – G. Ambrosio 11 Quench Protection of Long Nb 3 Sn Quads Giorgio Ambrosio Fermilab.
2 nd LARP / HiLumi Collaboration Mtg, May 9, 2012LHQ Goals and Status – G. Ambrosio 11 LHQ Goals and Status Giorgio Ambrosio Fermilab 2 nd LARP / HiLumi.
FNAL Workshop, July 19, 2007 ILC Main Linac Superconducting Quadrupole V.Kashikhin 1 ILC Main Linac Superconducting Quadrupole (ILC HGQ1) V. Kashikhin.
MQXFS1 Protection heater delays vs. Simulations 9 May 2016 Tiina Salmi, Tampere university of technology Acknowledgement: Guram Chlachidze (FNAL), Emmanuele.
QXF Coil Fabrication & Tooling Reaction / Impregnation
Quench estimations of the CBM magnet
MQXF Goals & Plans G. Ambrosio MQXF Conductor Review
MQXF Quench Protection and Meeting Goals
Protection of FCC 16 T dipoles
Tiina Salmi, Tampere University of Technology
MBHSP02 test STATUS and first results
Protection Database Tool
Quench Protection Measurements & Analysis
DESIGN OPTIONS IN THE T RANGE
Voltage tap layout and quench antenna options for the long QXF magnet
Design of Nb3Sn IR quadrupoles with apertures larger than 120 mm
Guram Chlachidze Stoyan Stoynev
Design of Nb3Sn IR quadrupoles with apertures larger than 120 mm
MQXFS1e – PH-to-Coil hipot tests
Presentation transcript:

Design optimization of the protection heaters for the LARP high-field Nb 3 Sn quadrupoles M. Marchevsky, D. W. Cheng, H. Felice, G. Sabbi, Lawrence Berkeley National Laboratory, T. Salmi, Tampere Institute of Technology, G. Chlachidze and G. Ambrosio, Fermi National Accelerator Laboratory, V. Marinozzi, University of Milan, E. Todesco, European Organization for Nuclear Research (CERN) Peak power density W/cm 2 HFU voltage up to 450 V HFU current: up to 220 A HFU capacitance: mF Distance between heating stations: up to 120 mm (Could be related to the transposition pitch of 109 mm) Trace parameters: Kapton Insulation thickness: 50 µm Stainless Steel thickness: 25 µm Copper thickness: 10 µm Glue thickness: up to 25 µm Coil surface coverage by trace: < 50 % IL Distance from heater to coil or voltage taps: 4 mm or more Large spacing L between the heating stations -> higher surface power density -> shorter  1, but longer  2 of the quench propagation between the heated areas Small spacing L between the heating stations > smaller heater power -> longer  1, but shorter  2 of the quench propagation between the heated areas Power density > 50 W/cm 2 is desirable Reducing insulation thickness is critical for achieving a shorter heater delay Superconducting accelerator magnet normally require active quench protection: upon detecting the quench, the goal is to create the largest normal zone in the shortest possible time. One well-known way to use a protection heaters that spreads quench propagation within the coil winding As heaters are placed on the coil surface, there is an insulation barrier between heater and the supercondutor, and hence, an associated heat diffusion time. When coils are short, a continuous heating strip of higher-resistivity material (usually stainless steel) can be used. Example shown: protection heater of the “HQ” LARP high-field quadrupole For a long magnet, a continuous heater strip cannot be used due to large resistance, and therefore a concept of “heating stations” is used to induce quench zones with some periodicity along the coil. Example shown: heater of the LARP “LQ: long quadrupole. Heater delay time (interval between firing the heater and the voltage development across the conductor) measured experimentally for the LQ magnet as function of the peak heater power Uniform strip (  1,  2 =0) Strip with heating stations (  1,  2 ) Numerical simulations of heater delay A model has been developed calculate the heater delay; details can be found in: Making heater periodicity commensurate with the twist pitch of the cable may be expected to further improves heater performance. If p = 2nw and l = (2n+/-1) w, then the supercurrent in all strands This approach can potentially improve heater efficiency, as all cable strands will get resistive and start dissipating heat at once. of the cable segment of length L=nl can be “interrupted” simultaneously by the normal zones created with n heating stations. Experimental heater patterns for the existing LARP magnets 1. Heater patter for the HQ03 – new LARP quadrupole. Heating station periodicity is 2x the cable twist pitch. Heater for the QXF - new LARP magnet for LHC luminosity upgrade 2. Heater pattern for the outer layer of the LHQ – a 3m LARP coil. The top portion design is based on the optimization algorithm [1-3] to provide a simultaneous quenching of high and low-field zones. The bottom portion is the old-style “LQ” pattern. The test is to be completed in September LPo2K-03 Introduction SQXF Coil 1 - a modification of the periodic heating station concept  Reduced width of the copper-plated bridges (more space available for holes)  Increased width of the heating station  Cooper-plated terminals of the heating stations to improve current flow uniformity Optimization is done by minimizing the sum of (PH delay + quench propagation time between the HS). Other designs with selective copper plating are currently in development for the QXF coils: The following list of heater parameters have been by the LARP-CERN collaboration for QXF magnet development: Inner layer heater layout: Four heater strips per outer layer and two per inner layer are planned for redundancy Power (W/cm 2 ) LHS (mm) Period (mm) PH delay (ms) Tot. Delay (ms) Power (W/cm 2 ) LHS (mm) Period (mm) PH delay (ms) Tot. Delay (ms) Outer layer heater layout: Alternative inner layer heater layout: *by T. Salmi *by E. Todesco 5 segments (303.5 mm length) will provide simultaneous quenching of all strands. ½ twist pitch base (60.7 mm period) : OL: 18 segments (R heater = 1.6  P/A (straight) = 161 W/cm 2 at 150 V) IL: 16 segments (R heater = 1.73  P/A (straight) = 137 W/cm 2 at 150 V) Selective copper plating is the way to scale up the heater length to long QXF. (Still an option for the upcoming QXF coils) T. Salmi, et al., IEEE, Trans. Appl. Supercond., 24 (3), 2014 T. Salmi, et al., IEEE, Trans. Appl. Supercond., 24 (4), 2014 T. Salmi, et al., Proc. WAMSDO, 2013 More simulations and experimental data: HQ01, 25 µm polyimide HQ02, 75 µm polyimide Experimental results versus simulations for the HQ magnet Simulation result (adjusted for the pitch length of 109 mm): τ RC = 36 ms, R = 5.6 Ω, I = 80 A  HS length = mm  period = 91 mm  P(0) = 130 W/cm 2  PH delay = 13 ms  propagation between HS = 4 ms