CHANGING THE CONSTITUTION Referenda. Constitutional Change There are FIVE ways the Constitution can be altered 1. Referenda 2. Interpretation by the High.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
AoS 2, Unit 3 Legal Studies DP 3, 4: The process of change by referendum under Section 128 of the Commonwealth Constitution and factors affecting its likely.
Advertisements

DP 7: THE CAPACITY OF THE STATES TO REFER LAW MAKING POWER TO THE COMMONWEALTH PARLIAMENT Unit 3 AoS 2 Legal Studies revision.
S 128- Referendums From the Study Design Key Knowledge:
S 128- Referendums From the Study Design Key Knowledge: the process of change by referendum under Section 128 of the Commonwealth Constitution and factors.
The Constitution Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1900 (UK) came into force on the 1st of January A set of Rules or principles guiding.
WHAT DO CONSTITUTIONAL CHANGES LOOK LIKE? Constitutional Recognition of Aboriginal people City of Salisbury Panel discussion Hon. Robyn Layton AO QC 5.
CHANGING THE CONSTITUTION
Georgia’s Constitutions
Recognising Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in the Australian Constitution.
Copyright Guy Harley Australian Legal System Lecture 2 Turner “Australian Commercial Law” Chapter 1 Gibson “Commercial Law in Principle” Chapter.
Holiday Homework.
A COLLABORATIVE ACTIVITY The Australian Constitution.
The process of a change via referendum and the factors affecting its likely success Brittany Goldsmith.
The U.S. Constitution CHAPTER 3 Section 1: Basic Principles
Basic Structure of the Canadian Federal Government.
The Commonwealth of Australia Government. GDP & E.Q. SS6CG7a. Describe the federal parliamentary democracy of Australia, distinguishing form of leadership,
Division of Law-making powers Changing The Constitution
The Australian Constitution
COMPARATIVE CONSTITUTIONAL LAW
Summary of Lecture 1 The Australian Legal System
1.  What does the term ‘division of law- making power’ actually mean?? 2.
Who’s got the Power! Australia Vs. United States of America! What is the difference between Australia’s government to United States of America’s government?
5 Basic principles of the u.s. constitution
Political & Legal Studies TEE Revision Format  Section 1- Short Answer  3 out of 4 to be completed  Section 2- Source Analysis  1 out of 2 to.
Preparing for SAC 2B Monday 27 May Focus your revision on…  Restrictions on the power of the Commonwealth and the State Parliaments  The role.
The Australian Constitution
A FEDERAL NATION- AUSTRALIAN CONSTITUTION. Federation )Occurred on Jan )Created a new nation and new level of government - Commonwealth of Australia.
 Identify and explain ‘task words’  Describe the different stages in the legislative process Learning Objectives 21 February 2012.
Unit 3 Legal Studies Law Making AOS 1 – Parliament and the Citizen.
THE UNITED STATES CONSTITUTION AND FEDERALISM UNIT 3.
Australia’s Government. Australia has a federal parliamentary democracy. There are three key factors that determine Australia’s government: –form of leadership.
The Australian Parliamentary System- Part One- Commonwealth December 7 th 2012.
CONSTITUTION – 10 FACTS YOU SHOULD KNOW Mr. Doolittle November Describe the principles of federalism, dual sovereignty, separation of powers,
The Constitution: A Guide to the Success of the United States of America By: Olivia Corbett Mrs. Hilton 4 th period.
What is a referendum?.
The Australian Parliamentary System. With the passing of the Commonwealth of Australia Constitution Act 1900 (UK) On 1 January 1901, Australia came into.
 House of Representatives  Senate  Legislative Assembly  Legislative Council.
Federalism Legal Studies 3C.
2 The Australian Constitution © Oxford University Press, All rights reserved.
Principles of the Australian Parliamentary system.
Australian Government
Chapter 7/8 Creating the American Republic Vocabulary.
Issues for Canadians Chapter 1 How effectively does Canada’s federal political system govern Canada for all Canadians?
CHANGING THE DIVISION OF LAW-MAKING POWERS UNDER THE CONSTITUTION Constitutional Referendums.
Canada’s Federal Political System
The Federal Parliamentary Democracy Of Australia.
WELCOME TO THE 2016 PLEAWA SUNDOWNER By Mike Filer.
Chapter 24: Governing the States Section 2. Copyright © Pearson Education, Inc. Slide 2 Chapter 24, Section 2 Objectives 1.Describe State legislatures.
AMERICAN GOVERNMENT Chapter 3: The Constitution. Section 1 The Six Basic Principles  Main Idea  The Constitution is a brief, straightforward document.
U3O2: PART A LEGAL STUDIES. ROLE OF THE CONSTITUTION  The Commonwealth of Australia Constitution act 1900, which came in to force on 1 January 1901;
The ways in which one successful referendum changed the division of law-making power 1967 referendum: equal citizenship rights for aborigines, 1910:
Politics and Government
5 Basic principles of the u.s. constitution
Amending the Constitution
Chapter 22 Study Guide Answers
Factors affecting the likely success of referenda
The Commonwealth Constitution of Australia
The Legislative Branch (Congress)
Chapter 3 Section 2 Constitutional Disagreements
Australia’s Government
Changing the Constitution
CHANGING THE CONSTITUTION
The Referendum Process
The Commonwealth Constitution of Australia
Australia’s Government
Haylie Pepper – Perth Using Twitter in P&L Haylie Pepper – Perth
Australia’s Government
Changing the Division of Law-Making Powers Under the Constitution
Of the United States of America TEST DATE: October 25, 2011
Unit 4 United States Government Key Terms
Presentation transcript:

CHANGING THE CONSTITUTION Referenda

Constitutional Change There are FIVE ways the Constitution can be altered 1. Referenda 2. Interpretation by the High Court 3. Cooperation between Commonwealth and states - Referral of powers / Unchallenged legislation 4. Use of financial powers 5. Constitutional conventions and commissions

Referenda All constitutions need to provide for their own alteration The Australian Constitution does this in s 128 – the last section of the document. It provides the only means to formally alter the Constitution’s wording

Referenda Section 128 is a lengthy and legalistic section. In short it stipulates that… ► the proposal be passed by both houses (or the same House twice) of parliament (as a normal bill) ► it be put to the people not less that 2 months and not more that 6 months after the passage of the bill

Referenda ► it be passed by a majority of electors and a majority of electors in a majority of the states (the territories are not counted but their electors count towards the majority of electors)

Referenda Since federation 44 referendum questions have been put to the people Only 8 have been successful – this is a very low success rate

8 Successful Referenda Senate elections - altered s. 13 (timing of Senate elections) State Debts - altered s. 105 (expanded C’th power to take over state debts) State Debts - inserted s. 105A (established loan council – all gov’t borrowing to be conducted through loan council) Social Services - inserted s. 51 (xxiiiA) – gave the C’th power to legislate to create welfare eg maternity allowances etc)

8 Successful Referenda Aborigines - altered s. 51 (xxvi) and deleted s. 127 (highest YES vote – 90.8%) – allowed C’th to make laws about Aborigines and to count them in the census Casual Vacancies - altered s. 15 – the 1975 constitutional crisis was, in part, caused by the filling of casual Senate vacancies, this fixed the problem Territorial Votes - altered s. 128 – included territory electors as part of the majority of electors Retirement of Judges - altered s. 72 – set the age of retirement at 70

Evaluation Why is s 128 so unsuccessful? Several factors explain this… ► Institutional factors ► Political factors ► Attitudinal factors

Institutional Factors ► The “Double Majority” is too high a hurdle, especially when combined with compulsory voting in Australia. This factor has caused the failure of 4 referenda ► The question must be YES or NO. Complex issues are more likely to attract a NO vote

Political Factors To succeed almost all sides of the political divide must support the question. That is… ► Government (likely since they will propose the question) ► Opposition (less likely given our adversarial political system) ► States (depends on the proposal). Many Premiers get “political points” standing up to Canberra so its hard to get all 6 Premiers to agree

Attitudinal Factors ► Distrust of politicians ► Distrust of “power grabs” by Canberra – only 3 referenda have extended Commonwealth power ► Questions and issues are complex – many voters can’t understand or can’t be bothered trying to understand them so vote NO THE THREE “NO” VOTES “DISTRUST NO” - distrust of politicians and Canberra “NO OPINION NO” – I don’t care about the issue but I have to vote so I’ll vote NO “SATISFACTION NO” – Conservative “the Constitution has given us a stable government and shouldn’t be tinkered with”.

Characteristics of Successful Referenda ► Support of both Government and Opposition – Aborigines was supported by both sides ► Limited change is proposed – avoids the “distrust” factor in the voter. Retirement of Judges is an example ► Obviously good – Aborigines was seen as a morally worthy thing to do to “make amends” and reduce racism. Territory voters was logical and just ► Obvious benefits to the states or voters – Social Services was a benefit to all voters