INVESTMENT CLIMATEDEVELOPMENT IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE BANGLADESH INVESTMENT CLIMATE FUND BANGLADESH Impact Evaluation Concept Note INNOVATIONS IN.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
Armenias Millennium Challenge Account: Assessing Impacts Ken Fortson, MPR Ester Hakobyan, MCA Anahit Petrosyan, MCA Anu Rangarajan, MPR Rebecca Tunstall,
Advertisements

Sub-National Monitoring and Impact Evaluation Kai Kaiser PREM Public Sector & Governance DPWG 6 th Annual Meeting Brussels May 2011.
SWEDISH AGENCY FOR ECONOMIC AND REGIONAL GROWTH Indicator pilot project Skåne-Blekinge, Sweden Kristina Sandberg, Swedish Agency for Economic and Regional.
INVESTMENT CLIMATEDEVELOPMENT IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE Piloting the Entreprenant Status: In search of a successful formalization model BENIN Impact.
Sampling Frames for Establishment Surveys International Workshop on Industrial Statistics Beijing, China, 8-10 July 2013.
Operationalizing IE: Case Study example: Textbooks and Teacher Training in Sierra Leone APEIE Workshop, May
Global Workshop on Development Impact Evaluation in Finance and Private Sector Rio de Janeiro, June 6-10, 2011 Gambia Growth & Competitiveness Project.
HIGHLIGHTS OF GHANA’S ENVIRONMENTAL FISCAL REFORM POLICY (WIP) Presented by: Ebenezer Nortey (Ministry of Finance) at UNEP Regional Workshop on Inclusive.
EVULATION OF RESULTS OF WORK OF CIVIL SERVANTS Yuriy Pizhuk, Director of the Department of the Personnel of Government Bodies and Local Self-Government.
EVALUATING TAACCCT Robin Fernkas Director, Division of Strategic Investments U.S. DOL, ETA July 25,
Arthur Bayhan Chief Executive Officer Competitiveness Support Fund (CSF) INITIATIVE TO UPGRADE COMPETITIVENESS OF PAKISTAN’S ECONOMY.
PROJECT CLOSEDOWN WORKSHOP Alex Findlay Programme Manager YH GDT
Global Workshop on Development Impact Evaluation in Finance and Private Sector Rio de Janeiro, June 6-10, 2011 Presented by Obert Pimhidzai - AFTP2, &
Secondary School Bursaries Kenya impact Evaluation Team AFRICA IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE, AFTRL Africa Program for Education Impact Evaluation.
SUPPORTING A BETTER LOCAL BUSINESS & INVESTMENT CLIMATE Case study of Uganda: Streamlining business regulation procedures with local government.
EU regional support to private sector development, investment, trade, and economic issues in Southern Mediterranean NEAR B.2 - Regional Programmes Neighbourhood.
First Discussion of Climate Change Steering Committee Recommendations to COG Board of Directors Agenda Item #6 February 27, 2008.
Aid Management Platform (AMP) Introduction to AMP Tanzania, February 2009.
SEDA IMPACT EVALUATION WESTERN CAPE (SOUTH AFRICA) Varsha Harinath (the dti) Francisco Campos (World Bank) Finance and Private Sector Development IE Workshop.
Statistics Canada OECD Workshop SME Data Collection Statistics Canada’s Experience Presented by: Terry Evers Director, Small Business and Special Surveys.
1 IRS Regulation of Return Preparers NTEU Briefing March 15, 2010.
1 Office of Travel, Transportation & Asset Management Center for Policy Evaluation (CPE) Collaborative Policy Development Agency adopts policy and implements.
THE WORLD BANK World Bank Group Multilateral Investment Guarantee Agency Rapid Response Toolkit Module II Trade Logistics Deep Dive Washington DC, April.
Workshop Development Impact Evaluation in Finance and Private Sector Dakar February 2010 With generous support from Gender Action Plan The Gambia Team.
Global Workshop on Development Impact Evaluation in Finance and Private Sector Rio de Janeiro, June 6-10, 2011 Private Sector Development Capacity-Building.
Impact Evaluation 4 Peace March 2014, Lisbon, Portugal 1 Investment Climate Reforms and Job Creation: Need for More Rigorous Impact Evaluation Aminur.
Workshop Development Impact Evaluation in Finance and Private Sector Dakar February 2010 With generous support from Gender Action Plan South Africa Competitiveness.
FOURTH CABINET RETREAT 20 – 21 DECEMBER 2011 PRESENTATION BY MOTIE.
Evaluating Pay for Performance in Health Provincial Maternal -Child Health Investment Project in Argentina Sebastian Martinez HDNVP Presentation joint.
International Videoconference, sponsored by the Russian Ministry for Economic Development PRESENTATION Development of Competition and Growth: International.
DEPARTMENTAL REFLECTIONS ON PUBLIC SERVICE COMMISSION MONITORING AND EVALUATION REPORT ON THE DEPARTMENT OF HUMAN SETTLEMENTS.
WHAT IS THE COST OF FORMALITY: EXPERIMENTALLY ESTIMATING THE DEMAND FOR FORMALIZATION David McKenzie, World Bank (With Suresh de Mel and Chris Woodruff)
Can Financial Innovation Promote Energy Efficiency? An Impact Analysis for China November 13, 2009 Hiroyuki Hatashima Independent Evaluation Group-IFC.
Analysing the impact of globalisation on entrepreneurship and SMEs Mariarosa Lunati Paris, November st Meeting of the Wiesbaden Group on.
Cameroon Business Forum (CBF) April 14, The Cameroon Business Forum (CBF) is a platform for public private dialogue to enhance business environment.
S Ethiopia Sustainable Land Management Project Impact Evaluation CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN AGRICULTURE AND COMMUNITY DRIVEN DEVELOPMENT.
Presented by: Shubha Chakravarty (Economist, AFTPM) Impact Evaluation team: Mattias Lundberg (Sr. Economist, HDNCY) Markus Goldstein (Sr. Economist, AFTPM.
Africa RISING M&E Expert Meeting Addis Ababa, 5-7 September 2012.
Development Impact Evaluation in Finance and Private Sector 1.
Quality Assurance Project Makerere University Report on Activities of the No Cost Extension Dr Ddembe Williams Project Manager Dr Lillian Tibatemwa-Ekirikubinza.
Government Impact on Adoption and Expansion of eSignatures and eRecords Kevin Hatton Director, E-file Provider Program Management Internal Revenue Service.
Implementation of a Risk Management System by Cameroon Customs Prepared by: Gasper KONNEH NEBA Inspector of Customs 10 July 2012.
African Development Bank Tunis, Tunisia March, 2011 Dr. Anthony NYONG Manager, ORQR.3 SESA Workshop AfDB’s Green Growth Strategy: What Role can SESA.
MONITORING of Administrative Barriers to Small Business Development in Russia Conducted by CEFIR in collaboration with the World Bank and financial support.
Evaluation Plan Steven Clauser, PhD Chief, Outcomes Research Branch Applied Research Program Division of Cancer Control and Population Sciences NCCCP Launch.
Country: Mauritius Manufacturing and Services Development and Competitiveness Project CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN FINANCE AND PRIVATE.
Let’s Work PILLAR 2: Measuring the Impact of Private Sector Investments on Jobs London, September 2015.
MALAWI Business Environment Strengthening Technical Assistance Project (BESTAP) Impact Evaluation CROSS-COUNTRY WORKSHOP FOR IMPACT EVALUATIONS IN FINANCE.
UN Capital Development Fund What, Why and How? PERFORMANCE BASED CLIMATE RESILIENCE GRANTS October 2013.
Promoting Firm Formalization in Minas Gerais, Brazil Gustavo Henrique de Andrade (Governo do Estado de Minas Gerais) Miriam Bruhn (World Bank) David McKenzie.
INVESTMENT CLIMATEDEVELOPMENT IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE Risk-based support and compliance reform for the Kenyan health sector KENYA Impact Evaluation.
EQB Presentation December 18, Radiological Health Proposed Fee Rule David J. Allard, CHP Director, Bureau of Radiation Protection.
INVESTMENT CLIMATEDEVELOPMENT IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE Moldova ECA Multi-Country Food Safety Study Impact Evaluation Concept Note INNOVATIONS IN INVESTMENT.
Sustaining the impact of investment climate reforms Syed Akhtar Mahmood, CIC, WBG November 13, 2012.
Impact of School Grants in Primary Schools In The Gambia Impact Evaluation Team The Gambian Team AFRICA IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE, AFTRL Africa Program.
INVESTMENT CLIMATEDEVELOPMENT IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE Trade Logistics Project South East Europe Impact Evaluation Concept Note INNOVATIONS IN INVESTMENT.
Innovations in investment climate reforms: an impact evaluation workshop November 12-16, 2012, Paris The Speed of Justice Dakar Regional Court, Senegal.
The Impact of Improving SMMEs' Networking Capacity
Title Strengthening and Modernizing the Public Transport Sector to achieve Mitigation and Sustainable Development.
SOUTH AFRICA ISIVANDE TAKE-UP Bongi (the dti) Tania (IPA)
Impact evaluations at IFAD-IOE
Impact Evaluation Terms Of Reference
Texas Military Preparedness Commission
AARTO PRESENTATION MMC: SAFETY & SECURITY ALDERMAN DERRICK KISSOONDUTH
Presentation to the Parliamentary Portfolio Committee on Public Works – Annual Performance Plan 2018/19 24 April 2018.
Project Name: Country:
PAIN OUT network in Mexico
Rate Commission Meeting
Firm Formalization in Bangladesh: Directions for Research and Policy
Dakar, February 1-4, 2010 Country: Mauritius
Presentation transcript:

INVESTMENT CLIMATEDEVELOPMENT IMPACT EVALUATION INITIATIVE BANGLADESH INVESTMENT CLIMATE FUND BANGLADESH Impact Evaluation Concept Note INNOVATIONS IN INVESTMENT CLIMATE REFORMS AN IMPACT EVALUATION WORKSHOP PARIS, NOVEMBER 15,

Process Mapping diagram Assistant Director Prepares file and checks Deputy Director checks Director checks and approves Deputy Director signs file Assistant Director prepares license Deputy Director checks license Director checks file and signs license Deputy Director signs file Assistant Director signs file and issues license to firm 2

Background  IFC worked with the government to  Map the existing licensing processes,  Analyze bottlenecks, and  Implement unified licensing processes that remove bottlenecks  The reform will affect 3 types of firms  Licensed firms renewing annually  Firms operating without a license that register  New firms that register 3

4 Pilot 1 launched in 3 municipalities in July  Cox’s Bazaar  Hobigonj  Gopalgonj

Processes Processing Time (Average Day) Number of Steps (Average) Applicant’s number of Contacts/Visits (Average) BeforeAfterBeforeAfterBeforeAfter Trade License Issuance (Cox’s Bazaar, Hobigonj and Gopalgonj) Trade License Renewal ( Cox’s Bazaar, Hobigonj, and Gopalgonj) Pilot 1 launched in 3 municipalities in July 5

 Identify constraints to firms for trade license application  Identify triggers for formalization  Impact of municipality trade license process reform on small firms Research Questions 6

Target GroupImmediate EffectsMain EffectsLong term Effects 1) Licensed firms renewing annually  Reduced time and cost of renewing  Reduced “Indirect” costs  Compliance cost savings  Job creation  Investment  Increased government revenue 2) Firms operating without a license that register  Time and cost of registering  Reduced “Indirect” costs  Compliance cost savings  Access to credit  Business Growth 3) New firms that register  Time and cost of registering  Compliance cost savings  Access to credit  Business Growth Government agency/ client/ municipality Reduced internal procedures Increased customer satisfaction Increased government revenue (from higher collection of license fees and taxes ) Expected effects & outcomes to evaluate 7

 Evaluation Method: Randomized control trial  Intervention, piloted in 3 municipalities, is to be rolled out in the remaining 312 municipalities Evaluation Design Cluster Size Pilot 2Pilot 3Pilot 4 TrtCntrlTrtCntrlTrtCntrl Plan A15 30 Plan B75 -- Plan C

 Individual firms within each municipality  Matched randomization at the municipality level  Data collection  Baseline Surveys  Follow-up surveys  Customer satisfaction surveys  End consumer/market polls Sampling and Data 9

Indicative Timeline Dec 2012: Use existing +collect municipality data March 2013: Propensity rank for each municipality April 2013: Form pairs at municipality level April 2013: Baseline for Pilot 2 July 2013: Randomly phase in Pilot 2 10

 How do we distinguish between new and formerly unlicensed firms which register?  Phasing in of the pilots considering the political economy?  Have we missed anything with respect to expected effects and outcomes (slide 6)?  Do any possible unintended consequences come to mind? Questions for further discussion 11