Challenges of Integrating Dispositions into the Curriculum Teresa Freking & Dawn Paulson Eastern Illinois University November 2007 Sixth Annual Symposium on Educator Dispositions

Session Goals This session focuses on the challenges of integrating dispositions into all levels of teacher education. This session focuses on the challenges of integrating dispositions into all levels of teacher education. We invite you to share your own challenges and ideas during the session. We invite you to share your own challenges and ideas during the session.

Introduction Primary focus tends to be on assessing dispositions, yet incorporating dispositions into the curriculum is equally important. Primary focus tends to be on assessing dispositions, yet incorporating dispositions into the curriculum is equally important. Our session focuses on current efforts to integrate dispositions into a fairly large teacher education program (3000+) Our session focuses on current efforts to integrate dispositions into a fairly large teacher education program (3000+)

Current State of Dispositions at EIU Our goal is to have all faculty, students and partners speak the same language of dispositions. Our goal is to have all faculty, students and partners speak the same language of dispositions. Our challenge is how to integrate dispositions into all programs in a sequential manner at all levels. Our challenge is how to integrate dispositions into all programs in a sequential manner at all levels.

Brief History Two years ago there were no clearly articulated dispositions in our programs Two years ago there were no clearly articulated dispositions in our programs Assessments included dispositional items, but were not identified as such Assessments included dispositional items, but were not identified as such A Dispositions Committee was formed in 2005 A Dispositions Committee was formed in 2005 Piloted integration of dispositions into two introductory level courses Piloted integration of dispositions into two introductory level courses Created dispositional framework of College identifying five major dispositional areas Created dispositional framework of College identifying five major dispositional areas

EIU’s Dispositional Areas Interaction with Students (IWS) Professional Ethics and Practices (PEP) Effective Communication (EC) Planning and Teaching for Student Learning (PTSL) Sensitivity to Diversity and Equity (SDE)

Curriculum Considerations Three general certification areas: Three general certification areas: Elementary Special Ed Secondary Ed Four sequential tiers: Four sequential tiers: Introductory Pre-Methods/ Specific Methods Student Teaching Introductory Pre-Methods/ Specific Methods Student Teaching Course Gen Methods Course Gen Methods

Introductory Course Six introductory courses (offered in six different departments in three different colleges) Six introductory courses (offered in six different departments in three different colleges) Dispositions curriculum has been piloted in two of the six courses in the past two years Dispositions curriculum has been piloted in two of the six courses in the past two years

Curriculum Focus of Introductory Course Introduction to dispositions in general Introduction to dispositions in general Introduction to our College dispositions framework Introduction to our College dispositions framework Introduction to dispositional expectations regarding professional practices and interactions with students Introduction to dispositional expectations regarding professional practices and interactions with students Identification of effective teacher dispositions Identification of effective teacher dispositions Identification/analysis of dispositions in others Identification/analysis of dispositions in others Explanation of how dispositions will be assessed in teacher candidates Explanation of how dispositions will be assessed in teacher candidates Self-evaluation of own dispositions Self-evaluation of own dispositions

Assignments in Introductory Course Favorite Teacher Letter Favorite Teacher Letter Human Relations Incident Essay Human Relations Incident Essay Human Relations Incident Analyses Human Relations Incident Analyses Teacher Panel Dispositions Identification Teacher Panel Dispositions Identification Field Experience Performance (PEP & IWS) Field Experience Performance (PEP & IWS) Field Experience Analysis (of effective dispositions) Field Experience Analysis (of effective dispositions) Capstone self-evaluation paper Capstone self-evaluation paper

Pre-Methods/General Methods Courses Includes various courses before the major specialty methods course(s) Includes various courses before the major specialty methods course(s) Curriculum piloted in three courses up to this point Curriculum piloted in three courses up to this point

Curriculum Focus of Pre-Methods/General Methods Courses Review of dispositions Review of dispositions Review of dispositional expectations regarding professional ethics and practices and interactions with students Review of dispositional expectations regarding professional ethics and practices and interactions with students Address dispositions related to effective communication Address dispositions related to effective communication Introduction to dispositions regarding p Introduction to dispositions regarding planning and teaching for student learning and sensitivity to diversity and equity

Assignments in Pre-Methods/General Methods Courses Podcast response: Professional Practices (PEP)* Podcast response: Professional Practices (PEP)* Podcast response: Communicating with Colleagues (EC)* Podcast response: Communicating with Colleagues (EC)* Written Report: Communicating with Families (EC)* Written Report: Communicating with Families (EC)* Letter to Family Members (EC)* Letter to Family Members (EC)* Class Newsletter or Website (EC)* Class Newsletter or Website (EC)* Lesson Plan (using variety of teaching strategies) (PTSL) Lesson Plan (using variety of teaching strategies) (PTSL) Video Response: Learning Disabilities (SDE) Video Response: Learning Disabilities (SDE) Lesson Plan & Assessment Adaptations (SDE) Lesson Plan & Assessment Adaptations (SDE) Portfolio Identification and Reflection on Dispositions (All) Portfolio Identification and Reflection on Dispositions (All) * See handout entitled Effective Communication for a module that addresses these assignments.

Effective Communication Example Created a module designed to teach the knowledge, skills and dispositions of effective communication (see attached handout) Created a module designed to teach the knowledge, skills and dispositions of effective communication (see attached handout) - Assignment 1- Knowledge - Assignments 2 and 3 – Dispositions (Podcast) - Assignments 2 and 3 – Dispositions (Podcast) - Assignments 4 and 5 – Skills - Assignments 4 and 5 – Skills

Report Excerpt #1 The first parent that I interviewed told me about a teacher that would give study guides to her son and she would personally help him complete the study guide. He would know all of the material and was prepared for the tests, but the tests did not coincide with the study guides. When the student came home with a failing grade, his mom called the teacher to ask what the problem was. The first parent that I interviewed told me about a teacher that would give study guides to her son and she would personally help him complete the study guide. He would know all of the material and was prepared for the tests, but the tests did not coincide with the study guides. When the student came home with a failing grade, his mom called the teacher to ask what the problem was.

Continued The teacher said “My classes are like gardens, most of my students are weeds and occasionally I get a flower.” This teacher obviously had the disposition that not all of his students were capable of learning. It is important for teachers to want ALL of their students to learn and not just a select few so called “flowers”.

Report Excerpt #2 The second parent I talked to was Kelly Jones. One of the main teacher dispositions she mentioned was the need for a teacher to believe that students need more than just book work to learn, that they are whole and complex persons. She said, “When a teacher would take the time to actually talk to Mike about what was going on for him outside of class, that’s when I knew that they were concerned about him as a whole person, not just a brain to fill with facts.” The second parent I talked to was Kelly Jones. One of the main teacher dispositions she mentioned was the need for a teacher to believe that students need more than just book work to learn, that they are whole and complex persons. She said, “When a teacher would take the time to actually talk to Mike about what was going on for him outside of class, that’s when I knew that they were concerned about him as a whole person, not just a brain to fill with facts.”

Report Excerpt #3 Guardians and teachers need to work together as a unit, using communication and a plan to put the interests of the student in the forefront. If a teacher has the dispositions that all students should be educated, diversified instruction is the key and love of their career is a must, then putting the student’s interests into the heart of their instruction should be no problem at all. These dispositions are the center of the key relationships between student, guardian and teacher. Guardians and teachers need to work together as a unit, using communication and a plan to put the interests of the student in the forefront. If a teacher has the dispositions that all students should be educated, diversified instruction is the key and love of their career is a must, then putting the student’s interests into the heart of their instruction should be no problem at all. These dispositions are the center of the key relationships between student, guardian and teacher.

Conclusion Integrating dispositions throughout all areas of our College has been one of our biggest challenges to date. Integrating dispositions throughout all areas of our College has been one of our biggest challenges to date. Sequencing dispositions to build on previous learning have been another issue we have faced. Sequencing dispositions to build on previous learning have been another issue we have faced.