BRIDGET C. O’BRIEN, PhD UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN FRANCISCO Educating Physicians: A focus on integration, inquiry, innovation and improvement.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
From Flexner to the Future: Recommendations of the Carnegie Reports 1910 and 2010 David M. Irby, PhD NCNMLG/MLGSCA Meeting February 25, 2011.
Advertisements

The Future of Basic Sciences in Undergraduate Medical Education Douglas L. Wood, D.O., Ph.D. President - AACOM.
How People Learn: Brain, Mind, Experience and School John D. Bransford, Ann L. Brown, and Rodney R. Cocking, editors.
SCHOOL LEADERS: THE KEY TO SUCCESSFUL INDUCTION
Objectives Explain the purpose of the RIME feedback method.
Conceptual Frameworks
Bringing it all together!
TeachMed Clinical reasoning learning with simulated patients Guy Bisson M.D., Faculté de médecine Froduald Kabanza Ph.D., Faculté des sciences, département.
Comparison of Teacher-Centered and Learner-Centered Paradigms From Figure 1-2 in Huba and Freed, Learner-Centered Assessment on College Campuses: Shifting.
Strategi dan Metode Pembelajaran dalam Pendidikan Dokter
Experiential Learning
Retooling Health Assessment: It Takes More Than a Hammer Cheryl Wilson MSN, ARNP, ANP-BC.
Designing ePortfolios to Promote & Assess Adaptive Expertise Evelyn Reed, Serra De Arment, Angela Wetzel Virginia Commonwealth University TED Conference.
Interprofessional Healthcare Education, Research & Practice Community Faculty Conference May 10, 2014 Dixiana Room 10:30-11:20.
What Matters? Why do the arts matter?. Why do the arts in education matter, especially?
William B. Cutrer, MD, MEd; Lourdes Estrada, PhD; Bonnie Miller, MD; Lillian Nanney, PhD; Neil Osheroff, PhD; Donald Moore, PhD.
Manchester Medical School Clinical Communication in the Undergrad Programme Dr N Barr Co-Lead for Clincial Communication.
Teaching Science with Case Studies: A National Survey of Faculty Perceptions Mary Lundeberg Professor, Teacher Education Michigan State University Aman.
AN INTEGRATIVE CURRICULUM MODEL: Incorporating CAM Within an Allopathic Curriculum Rita K. Benn, Ph.D., Sara L. Warber, M.D. University of Michigan Complementary.
Family Medicine Program By the end of this session, faculty will 1.Understand what is meant by competence and the competence trajectory expected during.
Contribution of a Professional Development Program for Teachers’ Learning Mónica Baptista; Ana Maria Freire
ENGAGING LEADERS FOR CHANGE AND INNOVATION ADEA CCI 2011 Summer Liaison Meeting San Diego, CA June 27-29, 2011 Janet M. Guthmiller, DDS, PhD University.
Contributions of Contextual Teaching to Improved Student Learning Richard L. Lynch, PI University of Georgia (706)
Undergraduate Core at Doane March 14, Overview of Undergraduate Core at Doane Philosophy of the Undergraduate Core at Doane (aligned with mission)
Education at UCSF School of Medicine Spring 2012 Catherine Lucey MD.
11/07/06John Savery-University of Akron1 Problem-Based Learning:An Overview John Savery The University of Akron.
Problem-Based Learning in Professional Education Doris R. Brodeur Massachusetts Institute of Technology AAHE - April 2004.
INTRODUCTION Drawing on personal experience, an in-depth exploration of one novice PT’s journey through her first year of practice, and current educational.
Thomas College Name Major Expected date of graduation address
Preparing New Doctoral Students for Academic Practice: Cultivating New Students’ Scholarly Identity and Practice through Cognitive Apprenticeship Ann E.
Triple C Competency-based Curriculum A Brief Overview for Residents Copyright © 2013 The College of Family Physicians of Canada.
Judith Brenner, MD Associate Dean for Curricular Integration Samara Ginzburg, MD Associate Dean for Medical Education Keith Metzger, PhD Assistant Professor,
Marion H. Martinez, Ed.D. Associate Commissioner for Teaching, Learning and Instructional Leadership August 25,
Problem based learning (PBL) Amal Al Otaibi CP, MME.
How to Frame an Ed.D. Program The following are a set of examples of how programs can be framed to make them unique and focused around the values of the.
Twilight Training October 1, 2013 OUSD CCSS Transition Teams.
Educating Physicians: A Call for Reform of Medical School and Residency David M. Irby, PhD IAMSE Webinar September 1, 2011.
Small Group Teaching Key Educational Skills Faculty Development Workshop December 9, 2014 Katherine M. Hyland, PhD Marieke Kruidering-Hall, PhD.
Developing learner competency in the clinical environment GRACE Session 3 GRACE Program.
Ch. 3 StudyCast SarahBeth Walker. NETS-T Standard 1  Teachers use their knowledge of subject matter, teaching and learning, and technology to facilitate.
Linda A Headrick, MD, MS, FACP February 26, 2013.
Steps to Design CBC. Educational Strategy and Approaches – Best Evidence Medical Education Learning in context Learning to solve patient problems Patient-Centred,
TEACH ON THE RUN! SESSION 3: HELPING LEARNERS THINK! DIAGNOSTIC REASONING Created by Dr. Leslie Ann Sadownik.
ML evi ne CP ED Co nv en in g Ju ne  The Purpose  The People  The Process.
AN INNOVATIVE & INTEGRATED TESTING FORMAT COMBINING ANATOMY, PRIMARY CARE SKILLS, AND OMM IN A SIMULATED PATIENT ENCOUNTER Gail Dudley, DO, Francine Anderson,
How People Learn – Brain, Mind, Experience, and School (Bransford, Brown, & Cocking, 1999) Three core principles 1: If their (students) initial understanding.
Session Objectives Analyze the key components and process of PBL Evaluate the potential benefits and limitations of using PBL Prepare a draft plan for.
Introduction to STEM Integrating Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math.
Small Group Teaching Key Educational Skills Faculty Development Workshop December 8, 2015 Katherine M. Hyland, PhD Marieke Kruidering-Hall, PhD.
UNDERGRADUATE MEDICAL EDUCATION- UNIVERSITY OF ALBERTA SUMMARY OF CURRICULUM.
An Online Support System to Scaffold Real-World Problem Solving Presenter: Chih-Ming Chen Advisor: Min-Puu Chen Date: 11/10/2008 Ge, X., & Er, N. (2005).
Relationships in the 21 st Century Parent Teachers Students Association (PTSA) Goals, Membership, Participation.
Clinical Reasoning. Clinical Reasoning in Differential Diagnosis Experts use 3 main methods or a combination:  Analytic or Hypothetico-deductive  Non-analytic.
© University of California San Francisco Medical School Finding Clarity : Setting Goals and Expectations David Irby, PhD Amy Garlin, MD Brad Sharp, MD.
Clinical Learning Dr Muhammad Ashraf Assistant Professor Medicine.
“To begin with the end in mind means to start with a clear understanding of your destination. It means to know where you’re going so that you better understand.
Expectations What do you expect from: C&I Faculty? Yourself and other students? The Bachelor of Science in Education Program?
Casimir Middle School TUSD Transition to the Common Core.
+ Priory Curriculum & Instruction Faculty Inservice, August 2014.
Integration of generic competencies and content in the Skills for a Changing World Curriculum Key Issues to Consider.
Learning Assessment Techniques
Reflection Win May.
Problem-Based Learning
Katherine M. Hyland, PhD Marieke Kruidering-Hall, PhD
Problem-Based Learning:An Overview
Innovative Learning & Development Specialists
Selecting & Developing Cases and Clinical Problems
Individual Identity: Typical Student Team Roles
Research in Medical Education
Presentation transcript:

BRIDGET C. O’BRIEN, PhD UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN FRANCISCO Educating Physicians: A focus on integration, inquiry, innovation and improvement.

Overview Focus on 2 recommendations from Educating Physicians  Integration  Inquiry, Innovation and Improvement Discuss the rationale for each using theory and research in the learning sciences & med ed Consider implications and describe practical applications and promising examples from undergraduate and graduate medical education

Integration Connect multiple forms of knowledge  Biomedical  Clinical  Experiential Encourage use of multiple forms of reasoning  Analytical reasoning  Non-analytical reasoning Engage learners in multiple physician roles

45%, 48% 73%, 68% 55%, 60% 73%, 53% 91%, 56% 64%, 20%64%, 8% 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Self- directed learning CultureKnowl & reasoning SkillsRolesLogisticsFrequent Change Areas of Struggle Students Clk Dir Learners struggle with transitions across the continuum, especially the transition to clinical immersion, and lack of continuity Integration: Why? O’Brien et al., 2007 Acad Med Students’ Struggles Transitioning to Clerkships

INTEGRATION: Connecting Multiple forms of Knowledge Biomedical knowledge  Can provide an explanatory model  Facilitates long-term retention, diagnostic accuracy and speed  Requires explicit effort to connect to clinical knowledge Clinical knowledge  Formal and experiential  Cases help novices organize and elaborate clinical knowledge in usable ways

INTEGRATION: Encourage multiple forms of reasoning We know experts rely on a combination of:  Analytical reasoning  signs & symptoms  diagnosis  full range of treatment options  plan  Intuitive or Non-analytical reasoning  Pattern recognition / similarity based reasoning  Seems automatic  Increases with experience Do we train our learners to function like experts? Ark et al. Giving learners the best of both worlds. Acad Med, 2006; 81:

Traditional Approach Blended Approach Analytical Mostly Analytical Mostly Intuitive Analytical Intuitive Analytical Intuitive Analytical Intuitive Analytical Patterns INTEGRATION: Encourage multiple forms of reasoning Pre- Clerkship ClerkshipResidency Pre- Clerkship ClerkshipResidency

Clinically-Driven Cumulative Learning Foundation in Basic Science Application through experience PBL, “Doctoring” courses, Intersessions, CODA Longitudinal Integration of Formal & Experiential Content “The primary objective is to inculcate the habit of using clinical experience to drive learning across all domains that underlie effective clinical practice” -Educating Physicians, 2010

Examples Incorporating real patient encounters into case- based curriculum  In both preparation and reporting phases, groups discussed formal clinical knowledge and biomedical knowledge, most often in relation to signs and symptoms (Diemers et al., 2011 Med Ed) Case-based teaching with coaching (Kassirer, 2010, Acad Med)  Drawing on examples from real experience, with learners articulating each step  Coaches help make thought processes explicit – asking the learner to explain why he/she asked for certain pieces of information and what he/she learned after receiving the information

Examples Complex case simulation  Simulation-based preclinical instruction to teach basic science (Gordon et al., 2010, Acad Med) Faculty Development  Building curriculum partnerships between experts in biomedical sciences and clinicians (Martimianakis et al., 2009, Acad Psych)

INTEGRATION: Engage learners in multiple physician roles Clinical reasoning is just one of the many competencies expected of physicians

Inquiry, Innovation, Improvement “Has anyone talked with the patient’s PCP?” “How can we improve our transitions of care?”

What is Inquiry and Improvement? Habit of mind, Form of expertise, Culture A combination of: Metacognitive skills Cultivation & reinforcement of traits/attitudes Communities of inquiry

Inquiry, Innovation & Improvement Cultivate habits of mind that support inquiry, innovation, and improvement  Metacognitive skills (Reflection, Informed self- assessment)  Adaptive Expertise Develop communities of practice that support inquiry, innovation, and improvement

INQUIRY, INNOVATION, IMPROVEMENT Cultivate habits of mind Metacognitive skills  Critical reflection – analyzing, examining, developing deeper understanding of an experience, and responding accordingly (Mezirow, 1990)  May result in learning and/or improvement in practice  Informed self-assessment

INQUIRY, INNOVATION, IMPROVEMENT Train for Adaptive Expertise Adaptive expertise  Important for problem solving, finding innovative solutions  Compliments routine expertise, which focuses on efficiency and mastery of knowledge and skills  Both are learned over time From: Schwartz, Bransford, & Sears Transfer of Learning from a Modern, Multidisciplinary Perspective; p.38

Creating working and learning environments that build knowledge and strive for improvement  Structural supports  Educational supports  Social / cultural supports INQUIRY, INNOVATION, IMPROVEMENT Communities of practice

Everyday Innovation and Big Improvement Involves :  Collaboration with other health professionals to maximize the efficiency and effectiveness of care processes  Real projects, with training and resources to support them  Project-based assessments  Taking responsibility for excellence Residents have detailed, ground-level knowledge of how systems of care are working, or not. Too often, however, this knowledge is not captured and converted to the benefits of patients. -Educating Physicians, 2010

Summary: Integration & Active Learning Learning is achieved by doing, not just knowing To achieve integration we must pay attention to:  Sequencing of tasks & activities  Social context  Learning environment (rules, norms, “hidden curriculum”)

Questions? Thank you!