1 Feedback gain scaling quantifies postural abnormality of Patients with Parkinson’s disease Seyoung Kim, Fay B. Horak, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta and Sukyung.

Slides:



Advertisements
Similar presentations
The effect of Enquist footwear on the locomotor system.
Advertisements

KINETIC ANALYSIS OF GAIT INITIATION D. Gordon E. Robertson, PhD, FCSB 1 Richard Smith, PhD 2 Nick ODwyer, PhD 2 1 Biomechanics Laboratory, School of Human.
3-Dimensional Gait Measurement Really expensive and fancy measurement system with lots of cameras and computers Produces graphs of kinematics (joint.
DOES THE LINEAR SYNERGY HYPOTHESIS GENERALIZE BEYOUND THE SHOULDER AND ELBOW IN MULTI-JOINT REACHING MOVEMENTS? James S. Thomas*, Daniel M Corcos†,, and.
Kinetics (continued) Dr. Moran EXS 587 April 12, 2006.
MINIMAL FOOT CLEARANCE IN STAIR DESCENT Tyler Cluff & D. Gordon E. Robertson, PhD, FCSB School of Human Kinetics, University of Ottawa, Ontario, Canada.
TWU Biomechanics Laboratory Lower-limb dynamics in two approaches of stair descent initiation: walk and stand Ketki Rana, Kunal Singhal, Sangwoo Lee, and.
Benjamin Stephens Carnegie Mellon University 9 th IEEE-RAS International Conference on Humanoid Robots December 8, 2009 Modeling and Control of Periodic.
Kinetic Rules Underlying Multi-Joint Reaching Movements. Daniel M Corcos†, James S. Thomas*, and Ziaul Hasan†. School of Physical Therapy*, Ohio University,
Results Table 1: Muscle force and relative difference to control Fig. 2: Muscle force during stance phase for a) m.tibialis posterior; b) m. tibialis anterior;
August 16, Dept. of Engineering, Computer Science, and Systems University of Bologna, Bologna, Italy Neurological Sciences Institute.
Dynamic Posturography
Control of Human Posture during Quiet Standing Motor Command of Proportional and Derivative (PD) Controller can Match Physiological Ankle Torque Modulation.
‘Initial state’ coordinations reproduce the instant flexibility for human walking By: Esmaeil Davoodi Dr. Fariba Bahrami In the name of GOD May, 2007 Reference:
Model Predictive Control for Humanoid Balance and Locomotion Benjamin Stephens Robotics Institute.
Musculoskeletal Modeling Colin Smith. A method for Studying Movement Things we can measure in movement: – Kinematics (using motion capture) – Output Forces.
CHANGES IN VERTICAL JUMP HEIGHT ACROSS EIGHT DAYS IN COUNTERMOVEMENT JUMPS PERFORMED BY NOVICE JUMPERS Michael E. Feltner, FACSM, Priscilla G. MacRae,
Andre Seyfarth Hartmut Geyer Fumiya Iida Leg design and control of locomotion Zurich, 25 May 2004 Locomotion Lab Jena.
Biomechanics of Human Movement
Perspectives on Walking in an Environment Işık Barış Fidaner BM 526 Project.
The influence of movement speed and handedness on the expenditure of potential and kinetic energy in full body reaching movements Nicole J. Vander Wiele,
Video Analysis of the Inverted Pendulum Model of Walking- A Classroom Activity by Justin Dunlap Angela Steichen Crystal Wright Ralf Widenhorn.
Comparison of Knee Kinematics during Anticipated and Unanticipated Landings Tony Moreno PhD CSCS School of Health Promotion and Human Performance Eastern.
POSTECH H uman S ystem D esign Lab oratory Ground reaction forces on stairs: effects of stair inclination and age Alex Stacoff et al. (2005, Switzerland)
BIPEDAL LOCOMOTION Prima Parte Antonio D'Angelo.
THE INFLUENCE OF CHRONIC LOW BACK PAIN ON THE SPINE AND HIP JOINT EXCURSIONS AND JOINT TORQUES DURING FORWARD BEND TASKS Stacey L. Moenter, Nikki J. Vander.
THE INFLUENCE OF CHRONICE LOW BACK PAIN ON THE SPINE AND HIP JOINT EXCURSIONS AND JOINT TORQUES DURING FORWARD BEND TASKS Stacey L Moenter, Nikki J Vander.
Kinetics of Hula Hooping: An Exploratory Analysis Tyler Cluff D. Gordon E. Robertson Ramesh Balasubramaniam School of Human Kinetics Faculty of Health.
Balance Wael Alasaq PT. Ph.D. PT Department Kuwait University.
COMPARISON OF KINETICS OF RAMP AND STAIR DESCENT Andrew Post, B.Sc. and D.G.E. Robertson, Ph.D., FCSB School of Human Kinetics, University of Ottawa, Ottawa,
Whitman and Atkeson.  Present a decoupled controller for a simulated three-dimensional biped.  Dynamics broke down into multiple subsystems that are.
3D Simulation of Human-like Walking and Stability Analysis for Bipedal Robot with Distributed Sole Force Sensors Authors : Chao SHI and Eric H. K. Fung.
R ESULTS : O BJECTIVE : Develop a phenomenological joint-space formulation of general human EE for various tasks that is validated by experimental gait.
Biomechanics Examines the internal and external forces acting on the human body and the effects produced by these forces Aids in technique analysis and.
The relationship between pain-related fear and lumbar flexion during natural recovery from low back pain. James S. Thomas 1 and Christopher R. France 2,
Effective leg stiffness increases with speed to maximize propulsion energy Dynamics & Energetics of Human Walking Seyoung Kim and Sukyung Park, “Leg stiffness.
Comparison of Loaded and Unloaded Ramp Descent Jordan Thornley, B.Sc. and D. Gordon E. Robertson, Ph.D., FCSB School of Human Kinetics, University of Ottawa,
Simulating Balance Recovery Responses to Trips Based on Biomechanical Principles Takaaki Shiratori 1,2 Rakié Cham 3 Brooke Coley 3 Jessica K. Hodgins 1,2.
Baseline parameters are treated as normally distributed, first POST parameters as uniformly distributed samples, with variance [2]: Variations in the kinematics.
KINEMATICS/KINETICS CORRELATIONS OF ARM MOTOR CONTROL DURING CORIOLIS PERTURBATIONS. A. Pierobon, S.B. Bortolami, J.R. Lackner*, P. DiZio. Ashton Graybiel.
Yoonsang Lee Sungeun Kim Jehee Lee Seoul National University Data-Driven Biped Control.
Introduction of PCA and energy flow pattern in lower limb Reporter: Yu-shin Chang Date: 99/02/05.
Balance control of humanoid robot for Hurosot
Benjamin Stephens Carnegie Mellon University Monday June 29, 2009 The Linear Biped Model and Application to Humanoid Estimation and Control.
Discussion Figure 3 shows data from the same subject’s lead leg during planned gait termination. The lead leg arrived first at the quiet stance position.
Introduction to Biped Walking
Three-dimensional analyses of gait initiation in a healthy, young population Drew Smith 1 and Del P. Wong 2 1 Motion Analysis Research Center (MARC), Samuel.
Progress Report Yoonsang Lee, Movement Research Lab., Seoul National University.
Heather Hodnett Dr. Michael Pavol, Department of Nutrition and Exercise Sciences Oregon State University Howard Hughes Medical Institute.
S TABILITY AND B ALANCE. C ENTER OF G RAVITY OR MASS The point at which the entire mass or weight of the body may be considered to be concentrated.
KINETIC ANALYSIS OF THE LOWER LIMBS DURING FORWARD AND BACKWARD STAIR DESCENT WITH AND WITHOUT A FRONT LOAD Olinda Habib Perez & D. Gordon E. Robertson.
MEGN 536 – Computational Biomechanics Prof. Anthony J. Petrella.
Introduction Results Browning, R.C., Baker, E. A., Herron, J.S., Kram, R. Effects of obesity and sex on the energetic cost and preferred speed of walking.
Chapter One What is Biomechanics? MET 235.
COMPARISON OF ANKLE, KNEE AND HIP MOMENT POWERS DURING STAIR DESCENT VERSUS LEVEL WALKING François G. D.Beaulieu, M.A.; Lucie Pelland, Ph.D. and Gordon.
Muscle function during running and walking Forward dynamical simulations Split-belt treadmill with embedded force plates.
Date of download: 7/8/2016 Copyright © ASME. All rights reserved. From: Stabilization of a Dynamic Walking Gait Simulation J. Comput. Nonlinear Dynam.
COMPARISON OF LOADED AND UNLOADED STAIR DESCENT Joe Lynch, B.Sc. and D.G.E. Robertson, Ph.D., FCSB School of Human Kinetics,University of Ottawa, Ottawa,
Date of download: 9/29/2017 Copyright © ASME. All rights reserved.
PO-0015 THE EFFECT OF BAREFOOT COBBLESTONE WALKING ON PATTERNS OF LIMB MOVEMENT Sport and Exercise Science Research Centre School of Applied Sciences Bruno.
Realization of Dynamic Walking of Biped Humanoid Robot
Figure 2. Change in saccade frequency (without vs with a visual cue)
Yoichiro Sato1), Hiroshi Nagasaki2), Norimasa Yamada3)
Evaluation of a Construction Block Lift-Assist Device
M. Williams1, S. Martelli1, N. Sancisi2, M. Conconi2, V
Segmental Power Analysis
The biomarker of interest: the “healthy” 1/f pattern in walking.
Visual Contributions to Balance Control During Gait
Temporal-Spatial Gait Characteristics in Youths with Hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos By: Nicole Vigon.
EFFECT OF THE USAGE OF HANDRAILS ON GAIT DYNAMICS
Presentation transcript:

1 Feedback gain scaling quantifies postural abnormality of Patients with Parkinson’s disease Seyoung Kim, Fay B. Horak, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta and Sukyung Park, “Postural Feedback Scaling Deficits in Parkinson’s disease”, Journal of Neurophysiology, Vol.102: , 2009 Human Balance Research Quantification of postural balance Seyoung Kim, PhD

Model based balance & gait analysis 1/3 of the elderly has a fall every year [ 2008]. The medical expenses for the aged people have been steadily increased [ 2005]. Research background 2 [ ] Scientific research into postural balance is required to provide solutions for fall prevention. CoP [ Termoz et al., Gait & posture (2008) ] RMS amplitude of Side by side / 45° Elderly: 0.48 / 0.41* PD: 0.45 / 0.34 CoP does not explain the abnormality of elderly or patients. Outcome measure is not enough to represent postural balance. e.g. Parkinson patients

Model based balance & gait analysis Systematic analysis with feedback control model 3 [ Park et al ] Can this model be a good measurement for postural balance ?

Model based balance & gait analysis 4 Objective : – We examined whether the “feedback gain and its scaling” may explain the deteriorated control adjustability of Parkinson patients. Hypothesis : – The deteriorated control adjustability of PD patients might be reflected in feedback gain scaling. Research Neurological Sciences Institute Perturbation Feedback gain K Ankle  Hip strategy Normal PD

Model based balance & gait analysis Experimental procedure Neurological Sciences Institute Subjects – Seven healthy elderly (63±7y) – Seven age-matched patients with PD (UPDRS: 23.8±10.2) Protocols – Backward perturbation (3-15cm in 275ms) X 5set SubjectAgeGender Height (cm) Weight (kg) Duration of PD (yrs) UPDRS Total Dyskinesia Score Side most affected H&Y Score ABC* Sub0153M R293 Sub0266M R291 Sub0365F R296 Sub0481M R395 Sub0567M R296 Sub0656M L1.599 Sub0765M18577N/A26.50R283 * Activities-specific Balance Confidence scale Measurement – Joint angle captured by Motion capture system (Santa Rosa, California)  200 Hz sampling rate  5 th Butterworth low-pass filter with cutoff frequency of 10 Hz – Moment & Ground reaction forces measured by a custom force plate  400 Hz sampling rate  5 th Butterworth low-pass filter with cutoff frequency of 30 Hz

Model based balance & gait Neurological Sciences Institute Backward perturbation profile: 7 conditions – (3-15cm in 275ms duration) X 5 times, in random order Instructed not to lift their heels off the ground while keeping balance 3.0cm : 0.12 m/s 4.5cm : 0.18 m/s 6.0cm : 0.24 m/s 7.5cm : 0.30 m/s 9.0cm : 0.36 m/s 12.0cm : 0.47 m/s 15.0cm : 0.59 m/s Experimental protocol 6

Model based balance & gait analysis Equipment & Measurement Motion capture system – Kinematics Joint angles – 8 IR cameras – 22 optical markers – Sampling frequency : 60Hz Custom made force plate – Ground reaction forces / moment Fx, Fy, Fz, Mx, My, Mz – Sampling frequency : 480Hz 7 [ Motion capture system, Santa Rosa ] [ Custom made dual force plate ] 7

Model based balance & gait analysis 2segment inverted pendulum model in sagittal plane Linearized Joint torques were calculated by inverse dynamics [ Kuo,1998 ]. Full-state feedback control model that represent CNS control Gain parameters calculated by optimization Biomechanical model for human postural control 8 K

Model based balance & gait analysis Calculation of feedback gains by model simulation [ Exp. data and Simulation ] Elderly : avg. 0.84±0.038 PD : avg. 0.80±

Model based balance & gait analysis 10 Postural response to support translation Postural feedback gain and its scaling Results and Discussion

Model based balance & gait analysis Postural response to support translation 11 Normal Neurological Sciences Institute [ S. Kim et al., Journal of Neurophysiology (2009) ] CoP does not explain the abnormality of elderly or patients. Can feedback gain diagnose the abnormality of postural balance ?

Model based balance & gait analysis Postural feedback gain scaling of elderly and PD 12 [ S. Kim et al., Journal of Neurophysiology (2009) ]

Model based balance & gait analysis Complex plane trajectories of closed loop eigenvalues for gain variation: Elderly & PD 13

Model based balance & gait analysis 14 Linear regression slopes (feedback gain scaling) quantify how flexibly subjects change their postural strategy from ankle to hip and a formation of intercepts (feedback gains) describes the postural system’s parameter set for postural control. Quantification of postural balance Slope and intercept of scaled k 11 k 12 k 13 k 14 Elderly / / / / PD / / / / 0.13 Slope and intercept of scaled k 21 k 22 k 23 k 24 Elderly0.002 / / / / PD0.03 / / / / Linear regression slope / intercept

Model based balance & gait analysis Postural adjustments in responses to increased perturbation magnitudes were quantified by the scaling of the feedback control gain. The PD patients showed significantly different gain and gain scaling behavior from the healthy elderly. – The PD subjects showed much smaller ankle gain with low ankle gain scaling and a larger hip gain with slightly greater hip gain scaling. – Subjects with PD have significantly larger hip feedback gains than age- matched control subjects, leading to stiffer hip joints so that overall postural sway resembles an inverted pendulum with significantly smaller hip joint motion. Conclusion 15

Model based balance & gait analysis Model limitations Current model does not exclude the possibility of the nervous system’s selection of preprogrammed responses. The violation of constraint followed by the initiation of step response was not explicitly modeled with current model. – Subjects were instructed to recover their upright posture without violating the flat-feet constraints. However, subjects would rather step when they encounter unexpected perturbation in real situation. The current model misses various nonlinear, temporal aspects of postural physiology. – Dynamics of muscle mechanics – Short-latency responses from reflexes – Long-latencies from long-loop feedback 16

17 Different postural response to support translation between the young and the elderly Seyoung Kim, Fay B. Horak, Patricia Carlson-Kuhta and Sukyung Park, “Postural Feedback Scaling Deficits in Parkinson’s disease”, Journal of Neurophysiology, Vol.102: , 2009 Human Balance Research Quantification of postural balance Seyoung Kim, PhD

Model based balance & gait analysis 18 Peak joint kinematics and kinetics [ S. Kim et al., Journal of Neurophysiology (2009) ]

Model based balance & gait analysis 19 Feedback gain scaling of young and elderly [ S. Kim et al., Journal of Neurophysiology (2009) ]

Model based balance & gait analysis Parameter study : Peak joint angle as a function of body inertia and feedback gain Avg. upper body mass Young : 39.84±7.70 kg Elderly : 63.42±15.84 kg 20 [ S. Kim et al., Journal of Neurophysiology (2009) ]

Model based balance & gait analysis 21 The differences in the measurements of joint motion and torques between the young and elderly groups may be attributed to altered system parameters such as feedback gains and body mass distributions and do not necessarily indicate changes in postural strategy. Smaller maximum allowable ankle joint torque in the elderly may be due to the tendency of initial forward leaning at their preferred upright posture. Conclusion

Model based balance & gait analysis Funds – Postural control study was supported by a Basic Research Fund of the Korea Institute of Machinery and Materials, the second stage of the Brain Korea 21 Project, and a National Institute on Aging. – Walking research was supported by the Basic Science Research Program through the National Research Foundation of Korea (NRF) funded by the Ministry of Education, Science and Technology (# ) and the Unmanned Technology Research Center (UTRC) at the Korea Advanced Institute of Science and Technology (KAIST), originally funded by DAPA, ADD. Collaborators – Fay B. Horak (Oregon Health & Science University) – Patricia Carlson-Kuhta (Oregon Health & Science University) – Chris G. Atkeson (Carnegie Mellon University) Acknowledgement 22

Model based balance & gait analysis 23 Special thanks to…

Model based balance & gait analysis 24