A CONTINUOUS THREE BIT FEE MODEL TWNIC. Content THE GOAL THE ASSUMPTIONS THE THREE BIT CONTINUOUS MODEL INCREMENTAL ADDITIONS FROM NIRS AND UNION MEMBERS.

Slides:

Advertisements

Similar presentations

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC Member Meeting Taipei, 31 August 2001.

Advertisements

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E APNIC NIR Meeting What is an NIR? Paul Wilson, APNIC.

Policy SIG report 29 February 2008 APNIC 25, Taipei Toshiyuki Hosaka Randy Bush Jian Zhang.

NIR's situation on APNIC fee review Ching-Heng Ku, TWNIC NIR 22 th APNIC OPM, Kaohsiung, Taiwan September 7, 2006.

NIR SIG Update APNIC20 Fri, 9 th Sep Overview Attendance – Roughly 30 attendees – Attendees also from a few non-NIRs this time Presentation – 1.

APNIC Executive Council Report APNIC 27 Meeting Manila, Philippines 27 February 2009.

1 Overview of policy proposals Policy SIG Wednesday 26 August 2009 Beijing, China.

ARIN Policy Experience Report Leslie Nobile. Review existing policies – Ambiguous text/Inconsistencies/Gaps/Effectiveness Identify areas where new or.

Medium Term Financial Plan (MTFP) April MTFP The MTFP is a high-level forecasting model that enables the Council to assess the financial direction.

1 Axel Pawlik APNIC 22, 8 September 2006, Kaohsiung RIPE NCC Update APNIC 22.

APNIC Membership Fee — The History Che-Hoo CHENG APNIC 23 in Bali 1 Mar 2007.

Final Stages of IPv4 Distribution Guangliang Pan Resource Services Manager, APNIC.

Policy Documentation Adam Gosling APNIC 38 Policy SIG Meeting 18 September 2014.

African Network Information centre © AfriNIC AfriNIC Update Ray Plzak, for AfriNIC APNIC-25 Taipei, February 2008.

News from APNIC ARIN XXI April APNIC Areas APNIC structure ServicesCommunicationsBusinessChief Scientist DG.

CENTRAL NINE CAREER CENTER QUESTIONS FOR CONSIDERATION FEBRUARY 10, 2014 Educational Services Company 3535 E. 96 th Street, Suite 126 Indianapolis, IN.

Issue Date: Revision: Treasurer’s Report APNIC Member Meeting – March 2015 March

A proposal to lower the IPv4 minimum allocation size and initial criteria in the AP region prop-014-v001 Policy SIG APNIC17/APRICOT 2004 Feb

APNIC Budget APNIC budget planning process Expenses –APNIC Member Survey 2007 –Secretariat activity plans for 2008 –Historical financial data and.

APNIC Fee Structure Result of fee structure vote.

What is the Recovered IPv4 Address Pool ? APNIC Services Guangliang Pan 9 September 2015 Jakarta.

February, 2007 MH Billy Cheon / Review of APNIC Fee Structure v2.3.

1 APNIC Membership Fees APNIC September 2006.

Local Control Accountability Plan Forestville Union School District December 2013.

1 APNIC Membership Fees APNIC 21 – Annual Member Meeting Perth, Australia 3 March 2006.

APNIC Annual Members’ Meeting Singapore, 6 March 1999 Fee Structure Proposal.

February, 2007 MH Billy Cheon / Review of APNIC Fee Structure v2.3.

1 APNIC Update AP* Retreat Meeting 17 July Status Update Membership –1250 ISPs –6 NIRs (CN, ID, JP, KR, TW, VN) Staff –48 staff –15+ nationalities.

1 IP Address Space Transfer between Existing Taiwan LIRs Dr. Ching-Heng Ku, TWNIC Policy SIG, APNIC 20, Hanoi, Vietnam September 8, 2005.

A S I A P A C I F I C N E T W O R K I N F O R M A T I O N C E N T R E Budget Proposal APNIC Annual Member Meeting Seoul, 3 March 2000.

APNIC Executive Council Report APNIC22 Member Meeting Kaohsiung Sep 2006.

FIVE YEAR FINANCIAL FORECAST OCTOBER 2012 Cleveland Municipal School District The primary goal of the Cleveland Municipal School District is to become.

1 APNIC Membership Fees APNIC 23 February Fairness 1 Fairness for normal APNIC members in all categories –Effective annual cost per address –Distribution.

News from APNIC German Valdez Communications Area Manager RIPE October 2008.

Report of Open NIR Meeting at 12 th APNIC Open Policy Meeting in Taipei MAEMURA Akinori, Chair JPNIC IPwg Equant Japan.

Issues for Voting. Voting Procedure Revision of Confederation Fees Confederation fees based on number of members has proven difficult to implement Proposal:

Prop-073 Automatic allocation/assignment of IPv6 Terry Manderson Andy Linton.

NIR SIG Report Izumi Okutani, David Chen

Hyunjoon Kwon APNIC 23 - information Voting System in APNIC By-Laws.

BAC Meeting: Review of Planning Factor Formulas Arlington Public Schools November 14,

APNIC Executive Council Report APNIC 29 Meeting Kuala Lumpur 5 March 2010.

1 IANA global IPv6 allocation policy [prop-005-v002] Policy SIG 1 Sept 2004 APNIC18, Nadi, Fiji.

A proposal for changing IPv6 per address fee Izumi Okutani Japan Network Information Center NIR 18, Fiji 31 August – 3 September, 2004.

Copyright (c) 2005 Japan Network Information Center NIR Fee Revision ~ seeking for long term solution ~ Toshiyuki Hosaka Japan Network Information Center.

Addressing Declining Emissions in Title V Fee Program Design Connecticut’s Approach Anne Gobin NACAA Fall Membership Meeting October 5, 2011.

Policy SIG Report APNIC AGM Friday 29 August 2008 Christchurch, New Zealand 1.

Comprehensive Fees Colorado College’s comprehensive fee for will be $54,534, an increase of 5.95% from  13 of CC’s 17 peer institutions.

APNIC Fee Structure Report APNIC 28 Beijing. APNIC annual revenues and expenses analysis.

CHALLENGES OF THE PENSION SCHEME IN VIETNAM. 1. Social Insurance Law adopted in 2006 Compulsory SI schemes including: Sickness, Maternity, Employment.

1 APNIC Open Address Policy Meeting Special Interest Group Session March 2nd, Korea, Seoul.

Budget Overview February 3, 2017.

NIR SIG Report Report to APNIC Member Meeting APNIC18, Nadi, Fiji

NIR SIG 7 Sept 2005 APNIC20, Hanoi, Vietnam Paul Wilson

IPv6 Unique Local Addresses Update on IETF Activity

APNIC Executive Council Report

Requiring aggregation for IPv6 subsequent allocations

APNIC August 2008 Christchurch, New Zealand

News from APNIC ARIN XXII 16 October 2008.

Policy SIG Thursday 26 February Manila, Philippines

APNIC Executive Council Fee Study Report

Randy Bush & Philip Smith

Overview of policy proposals

Recovery of Unused Address Space prop-017-v001

Rules of Divisibility A number is said to be “divisible” by a number if you can divide it by that number and get no remainder.

APNIC 21 Perth, Australia March 1, 2006

Overview of policy proposals

Policy SIG Thursday 28 August Christchurch, New Zealand

APNIC Members Meeting, APNIC 22 8 September 2006

ACSDA 10th General Assembly

Presentation transcript:

A CONTINUOUS THREE BIT FEE MODEL TWNIC

Content THE GOAL THE ASSUMPTIONS THE THREE BIT CONTINUOUS MODEL INCREMENTAL ADDITIONS FROM NIRS AND UNION MEMBERS FEEDBACK TO LDC

THE GOAL TO INCREASE THE APNIC REVENUE WITHOUT SIGNIFICANTLY CHANGING THE CURRENT FEE STRUCTURE TO INCREASE THE STABILITY OF APNIC FEE STRUCTURE CARE FOR LDCS

ASSUMPTIONS ALL MEMBERS UNDER NIR ARE TREATED AS A UNITY TO APNIC NIR IS TREATED AS A LARGE LIR WITH SOME ADDITIONAL CONTRIBUTIONS

THE THREE BIT CONTINUOUS FEE MODEL THE THREE BIT CONTINUOUS FEE MODEL IS A MODIFICATION OF THE CURRENT STEPWISE MODEL TO A CONTINUOUS MODEL ACCORDING TO THE FOLLOWING FORMULA: PARAMETERS FOR IPv4 –Minimum prefix (MP = /21) –Minimum fee level (MF = 2500) –Prefix factor (PF = 3)

ADDITIONAL CONTRIBUTION FROM NIRS INSTEAD OF USING YEARLY INCREMENT OF ADDRESS PER YEARS AS A BASIS, ONE CALCULATES ALL THE ADDRESSES LOCATED TO MEMBERS OF NIRS SINCE THE FEE WILL BE CALCULATED ACCORDING TO THE AVERAGE OF THE TOTAL ADDRESS OVER THE NUMBER OF YEARS SINCE 2003 AND α VALUE.

COMPARE DIFFERENT MODELS

Prefix (/) IPv4 address Current Lump sum 3 bit Increase of Lump Sum 3 bit v2.3 Increase of v %204, % %102, % %51, % %25, % %12, % %6, % %3, % %1, % % % % % non 625

IMPACT – APNIC REGULAR MEMBERS Prefix(/)number Current Membership IPv4 address Average Prefix Currentv2.3 Lump Sum 3 bit 6140,00043,515, ,000164,91669, ,00011,272, ,00083,93544, ,0005,561, ,000176,864104, ,0002,252, ,00037,52325, ,0001,391, ,000176,941131, ,000733, ,000321,089266, ,000395, ,000251,432231, ,000181, ,000298,348312, ,00093, ,000274,990321, ,00051, ,000392,015505, ,00025, ,000236,328342, ,00012, ,000253,075412, ,5007, ,000479,052861, ,5003, ,000383,802772, ,5001, ,000227,942521, , ,25049,650125, , ,00033,37593, , ,00028,80090,000 non ,75017,00058,750 4,605,0003,887,0775,290,469

THE CALCULATION FROM THE THREE BITS MODEL THE CALCULATION FROM THREE BITS MODEL IS AS FOLLOWS: Current APNIC Proposal v2.3 Lump Sum 3Bit Model LIRs4,605,0003,887,0775,290,469 NIRs Membership fee (NIR’s version) 200, ,453 (NIR Pools) 304,963 NIRs Additional (NIR’s version) 489,680 1,290,712 (NIR Members) 512,381 (ex: α=1.3) Total5,294,6805,629,2426,107,813 Increase 6.32%15.36%

LDC ISSUES TO HAVE A DISCOUNT TO THE APNIC FEE MIGHT NOT BE RIGHT TO THE POINT AND SUFFICIENT IN ORDER TO BRIDGE THE DIGITAL DIVIDE, IT IS SUGGESTED THAT APNIC ALLOCATE X% OF ITS REVENUE TO PROJECTS INVOLVING LDC. APNIC SHOULD ENCOURAGE NIRS TO WORK WITH THEM IN THE LDC ISSUE

SCALABLE MECHANISM IF IT IS DETERMINED THAT APNIC HAVE A FUND SHORTAGE, A SCALABLE FACTOR TO ADJUST THE FEE IS POSSIBLE SUBJECT TO APPROVAL FROM ECS AND MEMBERS MEETING CALCULATE FROM SUM MODEL APPROVAL FROM APNIC BUDGET ß %