WP 09 Monitoring & Forecasting Thematic & Assemby Center for IBI MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Design Workshops – June 2014 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

List of PUs / Du MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

Products evolution in V4.1 Product Customer NameStatus IBI-ANALYSIS-FORECAST-PHYS bBaU IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002New IBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003New MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

Products evolution in V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 n IBI_ANALYSIS_FORECAST_PHYS_005_001 n dataset-ibi-analysis-forecast-phys hourly n dataset-ibi-analysis-forecast-phys daily n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys hourly-regulargrid n dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys daily-regulargrid n dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys monthly-regulargrid n dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys monthly-nativegrid n IBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003 n dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio monthly-regulargrid n dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio monthly-nativegrid BGC Vars: Chl,Fer,NH4,NO3,O2,PO4,Si,Phytoplanckton, primary production & euphotic zone depth PHY Vars: Tmp, Sal, U, V, SSH

Model: NEMO (v2.3) Resolution: 1/12º (  6Km)/75lev Atm. forcing: 3h - ERAinterim Ocean BC & IC: MyO GLO-Reanalysis Tidal forcing: 11 harmonic components (FES2004 & TPXO7.1) River discharges: flowrates for 33 rivers, using climatological data IBI-REA System 04/2011 Today… IBIop-PHY IBIre-BGQ 12/2011 IBIre-PHY 02/2002 n IBI-REA & IBI-OP Systems: Analogies & differences… Model: NEMO (v3.4) Resolution: 1/36º (  2Km)/50lev Atm. forcing: 3h ECMWF Model Ocean BC & IC: MyO GLO Forecast System Tidal forcing: 11 harmonic components (FES2004 & TPXO7.1) River discharges: flowrates for 33 rivers, using PREVIMER obs, SMHI E-HYPE model & clim data Data Assimilation component SAM2 (Mercator-Ocean; Lellouche et al., 2013), Reduced-order Kalman filter (SEEK or Singular Extended Evolutive Kalman filter). Observations: SST: AVHRR + HR Multi-Sat SLA: all sat data available In-situ OBS: CORA3.4 (including ARGO T&S obs) Products evolution in V4.1 IBI-OP Ocean Forecast System

Interfaces evolution in V4.1 n IBI Interface tests performed for V4.1 n Interfaces tested: DGF/SUBS/WMS n No MyO-FTP used for IBI product dissemination n Datasets tested: new V4.1 IBI REA products n IBI DU Interface tests done in a testing environment n DU testing environment independent from the Operational DU n (as in previous Vx Reviews). n Virtual machine used for testing, analogous (in terms of resources & communication facilities) to the operational one. n Adequate extrapolation of performance result from test environemnt to future operational ones. MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 DU OP Dissemination (V4 & future V4.1): While testing environment:

Technical tests on Interfaces for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 n IBI DU pass successfully the performance test n Both in terms of processing time, download rate and number of simultaneous connexions. Dataset and Volume/time per Data access service FTPDirect get file Subsetter DataSet Size Downloading timeProcessing timeDownloading timeTotal timeProcessing timeDownloading timeTotal time Tests 1.1.1N/A Tests :00: :00: :00: ,2MB Tests :00: :00: :00: ,1MB Tests 1.2.1N/A Tests :00: :00: :00: ,5MB Tests :00: :00: :00: ,6MB Tests 2.1.1N/A Tests :01: :00: :01: MB Tests :00: :00: :00: MB Tests 2.2.1N/A Tests :01: :00: :02: MB Tests :01: :00: :01: MB Tests 3.1.1N/A Tests :05: :00: :06: MB Tests :02: :01: :04:34.501GB Tests 3.2.1N/A Tests :06: :01: :06: MB Tests :04: ,3MB

Technical tests on Interfaces for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 n However, a last-minute “surprise” when testing!: n Problem to disseminate IBI-REA datasets in native grid through SUBS interface. n Problem seems related to have in the same file variables defined in different grids (native grid is a staggered ARAKAWA-C): netcdf IBIreV1r1_PHYNA_01mav_ _ _R _RE01 { dimensions: n depth = 75 ; n latitude = 504 ; n longitude = 296 ; n longitude_U = 297 ; n latitude_V = 503 ; n time = 1 ; Dimensional variables: n float time(time) ; n float depth(depth) ; n float latitude(latitude, longitude) ; n float latitude_U(latitude, longitude_U) ; n float latitude_V(latitude_V, longitude) ; n float longitude(latitude, longitude) ; n float longitude_U(latitude, longitude_U) ; n float longitude_V(latitude_V, longitude) ; Variables: n short temperature(time, depth, latitude, longitude) ; n short salinity(time, depth, latitude, longitude) ; n short ssh(time, latitude, longitude) ; n short u(time, depth, latitude, longitude_U) ; n short v(time, depth, latitude_V, longitude) ;

Technical tests on Interfaces for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 n Problem limited to MOTU SUBS. IBI-REA Nativegrid files OK with: n THREDDS (Catalog OK). n OpenDap / Subsetter services n WMS n IBI-REA Nativegrid datasets served through DGF without problems. n SUBS Issue scaled to CIS-Op Team. Waiting for advise, in the meantime, Natrivegrid datasets declared in the EPST as …. IBIWP9SUBS DGF WMSIBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys hourly-regulargrid IBIWP9SUBS DGF WMSIBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys daily-regulargrid IBIWP9SUBS DGF WMSIBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys monthly-regulargrid IBIWP9DGF WMSIBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys monthly-nativegrid IBIWP9SUBS DGF WMSIBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio monthly-regulargrid IBIWP9DGF WMSIBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio monthly-nativegrid

Product Content Verifications for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 Product specification & dataset/Dataset StatusCF CheckerNetCDF File TitleDate in the WMS ibi-analysis-forecast-phys Ok dataset-ibi-analysis-forecast-phys dailyOk dataset-ibi-analysis-forecast-phys hourlyOk dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys hourly-regulargrid Ok dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys daily-regulargrid Ok dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys monthly-regulargrid Ok dataset-ibi-reanalysis-phys monthly-nativegrid Ok dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio monthly-regulargrid KO*Ok dataset-ibi-reanalysis-bio monthly-nativegrid KO*Ok n CF Inconsistency in BIO datasets n 2 errors found in monthly BIO files n Variable name for Euphotic Zone Depth var n Units for the Primary Production variable  Consultation to CF-metadata mailing list  Evolving situation in CF convention for the 2 BGQ variables (name/unit).  currently, not rightly included in the Reference Table (v26). But should be OK in the following CF Table update (v27).

Scientific reporting for V4.1 n Product validated & Validation Tasks: n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n Validation focused on monthly data n MO PU (producer of the IBI-REA) n Validation focused on high-frequency data n PdE PC n IBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003 n Validation based on metrics computed from monthly data (MO PU) n Overview & Results on the IBI-REA Validation Activities in: n MYO2-ScVR-REA-IBI-v1.0 n MYO2-IBI-QUID-REA (PHY) n MYO2-IBI-QUID-REA (BGQ) MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

Scientific reporting for V4.1 n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 T-CLASS1-SST-MEAN IBI-REA Vs AVHRR ( ) T-CLASS1-SST-TREND This kind of IBI-REA metric will be included in the OSR

Scientific reporting for V4.1 n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 T-CLASS4-LAYER S-CLASS4-LAYER Regional IBI-REA improves significantly Climatology & provides some added value regarding global GLO REA

Scientific reporting for V4.1 n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 Estimated Accuracy Number computation: VariableMeanRMS error Temperature (°C) 0-5m Temperature (°C) 5-200m Temperature (°C) m Temperature (°C) m Temperature (°C) m Temperature (°C) m Salinity (psu) 0-5m Salinity (psu) 5-200m Salinity (psu) m Salinity (psu) m Salinity (psu) m Salinity (psu) m

Scientific reporting for V4.1 n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n Example of IBI-REA Validation on monthly basis MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 UV-CLASS1-15m_MEAN Information from a long list of metrics based on monthly data (> 20) available in the QUID….

Scientific reporting for V4.1 n High frequency IBI REA Val with in-situ data from moorings (PdE PC) n Remark: This validation exercise is performed with independent in-situ observational data (in the sense of non-assimilated in the IBI-REA system). n Quite valuable exercise to evaluate the skill of the IBI- REA system in coastal areas. n Metrics computed using high frequency (1-h) in-situ measured data over the 10-yr period across 14 moorings from the Puertos del Estado Network. MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n High frequency IBI REA Val with data from moorings SST-CLASS2-HF-MOORINGS Scientific reporting for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

SST BuoyYearNObsIBIreBiasRMSERSI Bares Bilbao Peñas n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n High frequency IBI REA Val with data from moorings SST-CLASS2-HF-MOORINGS SST BuoyYearNObsIBIreBiasRMSERSI Alborán Cádiz Gata Scientific reporting for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

Scientific reporting for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n Water masses (density) T/S Diagrams Silleiro, 2011 Tenerife, 2011 vv Cadiz, 2011 Valencia, 2011 Bilbao, 2011 Scientific reporting for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

UV-CLASS2-HF-MOORINGS Gran Canaria, 2011 IBI-REA OBS v Gran Canaria, DJF-2011 IBI-REA OBS IBI-REA OBS AUG-2011 SEP-2011 Progressive Vectors Scientific reporting for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

n IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002 n High frequency IBI REA Val with data from moorings Taylor Diagrams Silleiro, 2011 Tenerife, 2011 Cadiz, 2011 Valencia, 2011 Bilbao, 2011 Scientific reporting for V4.1 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

Transition Planning for V4.1 n Provide planning information regarding parallel availability from V4.1 launch : n Are you able to provide a double dissemination n If yes, which will be the period of double dissemination… n If not, which are the difficulties (to anticipate user communication) MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 Not Applied: new V4.1 IBI-REA Products Static

Documentation delivered Document Title (+ version)Version V4.1_EPST_External_Product_Spec_Table-1.114_IBIV1.114 V4.0_PDD_Product-Dependencies_1.21_IBIv4.1 V4.1 MYO2-WP9-DUs-TD_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-ES_V4.1V4.1 IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-ES-Tests results-Summary_V4.1V4.1 File1_V4.1_IBI-REANALISYS-PHYSV4.1 File1_V4.1_IBI-REANALISYS-BIOV4.1 MYO2-ScVR-REA-IBI-v1.0V1.0 MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 Product Specification Customer NameAssociated PUM Version Date Associated QUID Version Date IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002MYO2-IBI-PUM V0.1 04/14MYO2-IBI-QUID-REA V1.0 04/14 IBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003MYO2-IBI-PUM V0.1 04/14MYO2-IBI-QUID-REA V1.0 04/14

Main Architecture Elements reminder MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 Glo MFC: Provision of Initial and bdy data ECMWF Atm forcing NEMO Preprocess. Outputs Validation Products OBS SST TAC SL TAC INSITU TAC NEMO Preprocess. Outputs Validation Products OBS IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR DU IBI PdE PU: CESGA, Finisterrae IBI MO PU:Meteo France IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP DU BACK-UP Capability: exchange Of files in case of incident External inputs Internal inputs ftp ftp, Motu ftp MIS-GW (Subsetting, WMS, DGF) ftp log files MIS-GW (Subsetting, WMS, DGF) log files

List of implemented interfaces = SST-IFREMER-BREST-FR PortsInterface types Interface unique nameWill be provided?When ? Delivery / DownloadFTPEI_D_FTP_ FTPSEI_D_FTPS_ OPENDAPEI_D_OPENDAP_ SUBSETTEREI_D_SUBSETTER_ DirectGetFIleEI_D_DGF_ ViewingInteractive maps (Gridded products) EI_Vi_MAP_GRIDDED_ Interactive maps (InSitu and along-the-track products) EI_Vi_MAP_ALL_ Monitoring & Control(Basic) Push MonitoringII_C_BASIC_PUSH_MONITORING_ (Advanced) Push MonitoringII_C_ADV_PUSH_MONITORING_ Support ServicesITIL support processes (hooks)II_S_ITIL_SUPPORT_ Products Management support processes (hooks) II_S_ PRODUCTS_MNGT_ Components deploymentWill be deployed ?When ? THREDDS V4.1 OPENDAP (as THREDDS service) WMS 1.0 (as THREDDS service) MIS Gateway  highlight scheduled changes MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

List of implemented Interfaces : = IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP PortsInterface typesInterface unique name Will be provided?When ? Delivery / Download FTPEI_D_FTP_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP NO Cancelled, linked to V0 FTPSEI_D_FTPS_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP YesActive from V 2 OPENDAPEI_D_OPENDAP_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP yesActive from V1 SUBSETTEREI_D_SUBSETTER_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP yesActive from V2 ViewingInteractive maps (Gridded prd.)EI_Vi_MAP_GRIDDED_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP yesActive from V2 Interactive mapsEI_Vi_MAP_ALL_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP yesActive from V2 Monitoring & Control (Basic) Push MonitoringII_C_BASIC_PUSH_MONITORING_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP - (Advanced) Push MonitoringII_C_ADV_PUSH_MONITORING_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP yesActive from V2 Support Services ITIL support processes (hooks)II_S_ITIL_SUPPORT_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP YesActive from V1 Products Management support processes (hooks) II_S_ PRODUCTS_MNGT_IBI-PUERTOS-MADRID-SP YesActive from V1 Components deployment Will be deployed ?When ? THREDDS V4.1yesActive from V1 OPENDAP (as THREDDS service)yesActive from V1 WMS 1.0 (as THREDDS service)yesActive from V2 MIS GatewayyesActive from V2 MyOcean2 Design Workshop – Barcelona 6,7,8th June 2012

List of implemented Interfaces : =IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR PortsInterface typesInterface unique name Will be provided?When ? Delivery / Download FTPEI_D_FTP_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 FTPSEI_D_FTPS_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR NO OPENDAPEI_D_OPENDAP_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 SUBSETTEREI_D_SUBSETTER_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 ViewingInteractive maps (Gridded pr.)EI_Vi_MAP_GRIDDED_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 Interactive mapsEI_Vi_MAP_ALL_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR NO Monitoring & Control (Basic) Push MonitoringII_C_BASIC_PUSH_MONITORING_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR - (Advanced) Push MonitoringII_C_ADV_PUSH_MONITORING_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 Support Services ITIL support processes (hooks)II_S_ITIL_SUPPORT_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 Products Management support processes (hooks) II_S_ PRODUCTS_MNGT_IBI-CLS-TOULOUSE-FR YES2011 Components deployment Will be deployed ?When ? THREDDS V4.1 YES2011 OPENDAP (as THREDDS service) YES2011 WMS 1.0 (as THREDDS service) YES2011 MIS Gateway YES2011 MyOcean2 Design Workshop – Barcelona 6,7,8th June 2012

Products evolution foreseen for V5 Product Customer NameStatus IBI-ANALYSIS-FORECAST-PHYS bUpdated IBI_REANALYSIS_PHYS_005_002Keep Static IBI_REANALYSIS_BIO_005_003Keep Static MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

Interfaces and system evolution foreseen in V5 n Provide information on interfaces evolution foreseen in V5 n No changes expected on interfaces MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 n 2 types of system changes foreseen for V5 n Changes associated to potential upgrades in the IBI NEMO model application or updates of any required external inputs. n Changes required in the IBI operational suite to adapt it to any novelty (upgrade) of the computing environment existing at that time.

V5 Master schedule plan n Present here the main steps and planned dates of the developments for your WP in V5 n List issues, risks … (if any) MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

MyOcean2 Design Workshop – Barcelona 6,7,8th June 2012 Master Schedule (review of the 1st MyO-2 Master Plan) Model improvementDelivery Improvement of operational suite: decrease CPU time, increase robustness V3 and V4 River input improvement V3 Solving the BU issueV3 New stress parameterization taking waves into account V4 Possible new Heat flux formulationV4 Nudging for spin-upV4 Change of model version from 2.3 to 3.4V4 Vertical turbulence with input form wavesV4 Data assimilationECOMF… Still on the plan … Tested, but decided not to be applied at MyO2 stage Testing delayed to MyO2 end (Op impl. at V5; if demonstrated) Testing delayed to MyO2 end (Op impl. at V5; if demonstrated)

MyOcean2 Design Workshop – Barcelona 6,7,8th June 2012 Master Schedule Plan for MyO-FO and beyond (Copernicus….) Model improvementDelivery Possible new Heat flux formulationV5 (if demonstrated at the end MyO2) Nudging for spin-upV5 (if demonstrated at the end MyO2) Production and/or Dissemination of waves products Copernicus (if decided at Top Level) New stress parameterization taking waves into account Copernicus Vertical turbulence with input form wavesCopernicus Data assimilationCopernicus

V5 Master schedule plan n List issues, risks … (if any) n V5 fixed at the end of MyO-FO. (Acceptance in Dec-2014) n Jump from MyO-2 to MyO-FO and the short time extension of MyO-FO (6 months) introduce some risk of discontinuity in the Team (risk high at PdE PC). n Very likely we will have to face a temporary limitation in terms of human resources for the MyO-FO period. n Activities related to provide the committed Operational Service will be the priority (and will not be affected). n However, R&D activities, Tier-1 and system updates capabilities may be affected by the human resources gap. n This is main reason because some continuity between V4 and V5 is planned. n Leaving significant changes ahead for further Copernicus upgrades. MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014

V5 Change impact n Provide information on products updates likely impact (on external or internal users (TAC  MFC)) MyOcean2 V4.1 Acceptance & V5 Product Design Workshops – June 2014 n Provide information on impact mitigation (double dissemination timeframe, availability of samples, …)